The inability of PlayStation Network users to change their online names is undoubtedly one of the most philosophically important dilemmas of the modern age. It feels like a strange and slightly archaic policy, whichever way you slice it. Thankfully, in a recent interview, SCEA president Shawn 'E3 Yawn' Layden explained the reasoning behind the system.
Speaking to IGN, the gaffer stated that the decision was informed by issues of online harassment. "We don't want to make it so that you can go in, grief a bunch of people in Far Cry, change your avatar, change your username, go into Call of Duty and grief everybody over there. We want to stop that," he said. "And yeah, it’s terrible that you have to make decisions on a service sometimes by optimizing around the bad actor. I hate that we have to do that. "
While this is definitely a valid line of reasoning, we can think of a few simple workarounds. Namely, we reckon a system similar to the one used by PC gaming platform Steam – in which you have two separate names; an ID which is permanent, and a screen name which is changeable – would be a workable solution. However, that would probably require fairly significant and fundamental changes to the core of the PSN service.
At any rate, the gaffer certainly seems cognizant of the issue, stating that he's always looking for ways to "give you more control across your experience", and that changeable account names are definitely one of those ways. Is this an issue that affects you, or are happy with your PSN name? Shout, shout, let it all out in the comments section below.
[source au.ign.com]
Comments 47
Oh god, I would love the ability to change my PSN Name.
I meant to make a new one when i got my PS3 back in 2012 & it completely slipped my mind until i had gotten a lot of games purchased from the Playstation Store.
Oh well. lol
I wish I could change mine..I made mine back when I was 14 so of course I want a new name now lol Unfortunately, I can't bare to make a new account due to all the trophies and PS+/digital games I've accumulated over the years :/ Even one chance to change our names would be good enough Sony :/
Had my psn name since day 1. Made different names a few times, but always went back to the original. Doesnt bother me in the slightest
I know a lot of people wish they could change their PSN names but I'm ok with mine. I picked mine in 9th grade and I still like it. I was smart enough not to use something offensive.. I wonder how many people would break into a cold sweat if they went to a job interview and was asked to show their PSN name...
Changed mine April 4 2013 getting ready for the PS4. I had 0 Platinum trophies All I had to do was earn one trophy that I didn't have in every game!
That brought back the full list of earn trophies I had earned in each game one at a time. I was mostly a PC gamer any only had abut 30 games on PS3.
I'm pretty much content with mine, but I would like to change it to match it up with my Nintendo and Microsoft profiles, as I like that one better than my PSN name...
Though Sony has a real name system in place, your ID is tied to that, no? It seems if someone was being harassed, they could always just track the username to the original account... Or maybe I'm understanding how their system works wrong.
Gahh, I want to change mine. Couldn't you make once every 2 years or something, or only once, or maybe even you have to contact support? Just something to change it. I don't have a terrible one, but I didn't choose it because my dad set the PSN account years ago. I good username for everything else that the same thing, but not PSN.
Come on Sony you can do better than this, this is like a claiming that my dog ate my homework.
It would only be matter of setting an ID number of just limit the number of changes to 1 every 3 months or something like that, they just don't have the system setted up for this and don't want to invest in the resources to do so. -_-
I don't have anything to complain regarding my PSN Username but still pretty sad for those that do want to change it.
Very Happy with mine,
Really? Though their explanation makes sense, I always thought it had something to do with the way they set up they databases. If they use your psn name as the primary key of the account in the database, you simply cannot change it because there has to be a unique identifier for your account. Now, if this is the case they can change the schema of the database and make it so that the primary key is not the psn name, but that could cost a lot of money I guess, and time....
The very least they could of let people changer theirs that wanted to when the PS4 came out, I know a bunch of people that made their user name years ago when it meant something to them but now not so much.
As for mine I like mine.
They could just let you pay $10 to change it like Microsoft does. That way it's not something you'll just do willy-nilly, but it IS an option if you REALLY hate your old name.
As for me, I'm just fine. Suffgamer1 is my online identity almost everywhere, and I have no intention of changing that now.
I definitely would like to change my ID on PSN.
I have been waiting to change my psn name for years now, sony's excuse seems kind of daft to me because like others have said (and this is certainly true in the days before ps+ was a necessity for online gaming on ps4) people could make multiple profiles for free so that makes sony's excuse completely void.
If they charged people to do it then maybe it would only be the people that really want to change their psn ID doing it, or trolls with money to burn.
I'd love to change mine ive had it since 2009 and I'm not the same person now I was then...and my username sucks a lot more than I used to think it did. I'd certainly be willing to pay a reasonable fee to be able to change it...as others have said, a fee being in place would possibly handle trolls changing their ID reguarly. There could also maybe be a limit of only being able to alter the username once a month, or every six months...maybe even having to stick with the new name for a year after it changes.
I'm not too bothered about changing my PSN ID.
I think they should look at allowing sub account users to upgrade to an adult account.
There is currently no way of doing it, and limits the functionality of the ps4 services to gamers who come of age.
The only way round this is to create a new account.
Have a look at this Sony please??!
I think it should be a so many changes policy and then after say 3-5 changes you'll have to start paying for such, shouldn't get the griefers he's so concerned about.
Surely they could implement a solution like Microsoft?, wouldn't mind paying to bring my PSN profile in line with my other profiles
Meh, I never really gave it much thought to be honest, but I usually pick a username I'm content to stick with anyway. There should be some way to get a change though if you really want one.
Please SONY....Let me change my user name!
I was, I am and I will be Belmont forever! I don't need to change my psn ID.
@Cowboysfan-22 - "I wonder how many people would break into a cold sweat if they went to a job interview and was asked to show their PSN name"
And what, pray tell, is wrong with calling yourself 'ChunkyLover53'?
@smell_andersen haha I just happened to be listening to Violator while reading this article
@SuperCat
Everything...
I never want to change mine either, however I think this is a cop out. It's a brilliantly thought out response, but the issue is clearly PSN-based - I strongly doubt it has anything to do with griefing.
If a user acts like an idiot and gets reported, it shouldn't matter what their username or avatar is - as they'll be defined by their email address, so Sony will still be able to ban them.
Some people's names they don't deserve to be able to change them(i.e the silly racist/sexist etc etc ones) :-/
@SuperCat obviously nothing if there's 53 names like that. Haha
It is inexcusable and nothing else. A policy which bring strong walls in front of the costumer is no good. There are, like everyone said tons of different work arounds to the harassment problem other than this. There lots people as mentioned who wants to change their names with no goal of harassment but personal taste. There is saying in Turkish "Burning the dry wood along with the newly-cut wood" similar meaning to "Throw out the baby with the bath water" Why? Why "hurt" honest people while trying to get rid of bad people?
I've thought about changing mine a few times, but I eventually just stopped caring. HeartBreakJake95 may sound a little...odd, but it's grown on me. Plus it's based on my favorite wrestler ("Heartbreak Kid" Shawn Michaels) so I'm cool with it. The only reason I ever felt like changing it is because my uncle made my account for me an picked the name.
@Stuffgamer1 That sounds like a really bad idea, no offense. The thought of charging money for a name change that involves literally no effort on their side would be a rip off.
Makes sense, but they could limit the amount of times you can change you psn name.
I always use some variation of Gnollish or Gnoll for my username. Even if it really meant something for me just twenty years ago, when I was a gamemaster in a D&D campaign, I've grown accustomed to it so I always think of myself as "Gnollish" when I'm online.
So yes, I'm still happy with my PSN ID.
@Bad-MuthaAdebis Downside to creating a new PSN ID is that you can't transfer save data and trophies from your old ID.
I appreciate they are trying to prevent spammers but they could still allow us to change the PSN name say once every year. That would give us what we want and also prevent spamming.
Get to it Sony...
@wittypixel: None taken, I assure you...until I read this article and thought about it, I also thought it was a rip-off that MS operated that way. But it DOES seem like an interesting middleground approach to me now that I HAVE thought of it. I mean sure, Steam's approach would be BETTER in a way...but worse in another. I don't really like the fact that my friends can just up and change their displayed name whenever they feel like it all willy-nilly on Steam. It makes keeping track of the friends list inconvenient, IMO. So I think making it possible, but limited is a good idea. Yes, a time-based system would be fine too...just SOMETHING, I guess.
I wish I made a new one when I got my PS4...I don't like mine.
I have often advocated for Sony to adopt Steam's ID system. It is both user friendly and doesn't allow griefers or cheaters to just disappear into anonymity. I think if we keep up the pressure and stay vocal about it they will eventually buckle.
@Stuffgamer1: Yeah it can be a tad bit annoying to log in and not recognize a persons ID because they just changed it but it is a simple matter of checking their previous IDs to figure out who they are/were. It is a small inconvenience in favor of a much bigger convenience.
@Stuffgamer1 Charging money won't fix the problem though. They are kids/griefers/whoever that would gladly pay the 10$ everytime lol, so the payment system would only stop a certain type of griefer.
And I don't think people should be able to change their name easily. people would just switch whenever they felt and take up a name an actual NEW player wanted to use.
I think people gotta pick a name and stick with it! a name isn't an easy thing to pick.
@wittypixel they absolutely should charge and it should be on the order of $50 or more (or increase by $10 for every change). It's not about what it costs them, it's a way to deter griefers so they don't be a jerk and then change their name. $10 is nothing, that's a visit to McDonald's, or the cost of a theater ticket, definitely not costly enough to prevent abuse.
It may not be a popular stance but I hope they never let people change names, you (the general you) should have been smarter when you created your account.
please watch the language -Tasuki-
@wittypixel if the cost increases by $10 with each change...it might put a stop to it after a few changes.
@-CraZed- steams system is a terrible system though. The whole point of changing your name is that you picked something stupid (that you may have liked when you were ten) and don't want to be associated by that anymore. Steam keeps a list and you can always see every name a person has had. That pretty much defeats the point of changing your name in the first place.
It's not like it is right out front, glaring at you when you view a person's profile. It's behind a very small tab next to your name. It's a great system and allows you to change your name at any time even if another user has already taken the name. It is a brilliant system especially when compared to both Sony and MS in which one charges you and the other doesn't even allow it!
@thedevilsjester I read both your post and the system they have in place now is good enough to prevent griefers and the switching of accounts, and it's also free.
Like you mentioned towards the end. people just have to be more thoughtful with the first name they create.
@wittypixel @-CraZed-
Steams solution is not a name change system (its an alias system with an easy to view history), so not only does it not solve the core issues that arguably most of the people that want a name change on the PSN want (such as not being associated in any way, shape, or form with XxOneDirectionFanxX) but it also creates a logistical nightmare for their friends. I can't count the number of friends I have pulled off my Steam friends list because they changed their names so often that I no longer knew who was who. Now Sonys "Real Name Request" helps alleviate this a little, for a select few friends, but not nearly enough to be useful.
A real name change is the only real solution, but it has to be behind some heavy limitations/restrictions to prevent abuse. I don't think Sony is willing to put those restrictions in place (such as an ever increasing cost to change your name, or once every five years, etc...) so unless they are going to make it very hard for people to abuse it (and $10 is not much more than a coffee and a cookie at Starbucks, so anyone that really wants to abuse it, and has a decent paying job, can do so very cheaply).
Since Sony is not likely to put in place good enough restrictions, I would rather no name change system at all (a half assed Steam solution is worse than no solution). Really if you made a terrible choice as a kid, and you want to make a better choice now, pay the price of losing your profile. The only one you have to blame is yourself (the general you/yourself, not specifically referring to anyone) as Sony didnt make you choose poorly.
Why not just charge a buck to make the change? Griefers can make as many psn accounts as they want also...
I can't stand my gametag given as a nickname in a gaming clan so long ago. If Sony charged £10 for the service I'd do it straight away! Plus if Sony was smart they'd realise this will help remedy their financial woes a little. Come on Sony believe in your message 'this is for the players!' Help us to help you!
@ShockeyRai same here i would love that as well most people still like playing xbox one knowing they can do that.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...