Thread is broken since Mario Galaxy is already out.
For the record though, I had played both games.
I'm only joshing. Galaxy and it's sequel though, for me, are completely untouchable. Nothing has come close before or since. SOtC is an amazing game, easily in my top ten, but (again, for me) it's no contest compared to SMG.
Oh, and I think you mean Persona 4, not 5 @themcnoisy unless we're doing unreleased games now, in which case Half-Life 3 v Shenmue 3 ;P
Sorry, yeah I still have 5s trailer in my head. Any takers for this battle and back to the cup. Rogue galaxy vs Persona 4 golden.
Forum Best Game of All Time Awards
PS3 Megathread 2019: The Last of Us
Multiplat 2018: Horizon Zero Dawn
Nintendo 2017: Super Mario Bros 3
Playstation 2016: Uncharted 2
Multiplat 2015: Final Fantasy 7
Thread is broken since Mario Galaxy is already out.
For the record though, I had played both games.
I'm only joshing. Galaxy and it's sequel though, for me, are completely untouchable. Nothing has come close before or since. SOtC is an amazing game, easily in my top ten, but (again, for me) it's no contest compared to SMG.
Oh, and I think you mean Persona 4, not 5 @themcnoisy unless we're doing unreleased games now, in which case Half-Life 3 v Shenmue 3 ;P
Fetching stars is overrated. Games like Zelda TP and RE4 are better IMO.
Fetching stars is overrated. Games like Zelda TP and RE4 are better IMO.
Fair enough, personally I found the searching for heart pieces, Skulltulas or whatever more boring than earning stars by completing more levels. Each to their own though.
"Oh smeg. What the smegging smegs he smegging done? He's smegging killed me."
Fetching stars is overrated. Games like Zelda TP and RE4 are better IMO.
Fair enough, personally I found the searching for heart pieces, Skulltulas or whatever more boring than earning stars by completing more levels. Each to their own though.
I also found SMG 2 a disappointment after SMG. It needed something like Rosalina's storybook to keep me going. Collecting stars for the sake of opening new levels is a little one-note IMO, though the gameplay is stellar of course.
Fetching stars is overrated. Games like Zelda TP and RE4 are better IMO.
Fair enough, personally I found the searching for heart pieces, Skulltulas or whatever more boring than earning stars by completing more levels. Each to their own though.
I also found SMG 2 a disappointment after SMG. It needed something like Rosalina's storybook to keep me going. Collecting stars for the sake of opening new levels is a little one-note IMO, though the gameplay is stellar of course.
I would just about favour SMG2 to 1. The inclusion of Yoshi adds something else and makes it even more fun. Personally I found the lack of story (and storybook) and the old style map opening as you did more better than today's typical structure.
I'm sorry to hijack this thread (I'll be gone in a second!) but I'm here to ask something relative. If Push Square was to host a tournament to decide, say, the best ever PlayStation 3 game, what would you think?
Say we'd have 32 games, and once a week, we'd have a vote to decide which of two games goes on. It would take a long time to get to the final, but does it sound like something you might like? Any feedback is appreciated.
Right here we go next person on we have 3 unanswered battles. Rogue galaxy vs persona 4,., resident evil 4 vs Zelda twilight princess,., Mario galaxy 2 vs Mario bros 3. Remember to answer the battles then put two of your favourite games against each other for the next person to answer. If your unsure how it works refer back to my opening comment.
Forum Best Game of All Time Awards
PS3 Megathread 2019: The Last of Us
Multiplat 2018: Horizon Zero Dawn
Nintendo 2017: Super Mario Bros 3
Playstation 2016: Uncharted 2
Multiplat 2015: Final Fantasy 7
I'm sorry to hijack this thread (I'll be gone in a second!) but I'm here to ask something relative. If Push Square was to host a tournament to decide, say, the best ever PlayStation 3 game, what would you think?
Say we'd have 32 games, and once a week, we'd have a vote to decide which of two games goes on. It would take a long time to get to the final, but does it sound like something you might like? Any feedback is appreciated.
Again, sorry to derail the thread - carry on!
yup that's a great idea, I've created a monster here - shogun you answer those 3 battles on my previous entree if you like. But defo up for that.
Forum Best Game of All Time Awards
PS3 Megathread 2019: The Last of Us
Multiplat 2018: Horizon Zero Dawn
Nintendo 2017: Super Mario Bros 3
Playstation 2016: Uncharted 2
Multiplat 2015: Final Fantasy 7
Persona 4
Resident Evil 4
... SMB 3 (God that's actually a really tough one)
I'll throw in...
The Last of Us vs. Pokemon Crystal
Not sure where we got Resi 4 v Twilight or even SMB3 v SMG to be honest. The first was someone saying they preferred the way those games have their collectibles and the other one never happened. Oh well.
Pokémon Crystal.
Ikaruga v Radiant Silvergun
To save making another post, the best PS3 game idea sounds a good one. Sadly Last Of Us will win but be nice to see what games miss out on say the top five or ten. I say go for it.
I'm sorry to hijack this thread (I'll be gone in a second!) but I'm here to ask something relative. If Push Square was to host a tournament to decide, say, the best ever PlayStation 3 game, what would you think?
Say we'd have 32 games, and once a week, we'd have a vote to decide which of two games goes on. It would take a long time to get to the final, but does it sound like something you might like? Any feedback is appreciated.
Again, sorry to derail the thread - carry on!
I think it would be interesting to do that, and hold something else where you just have someone write what they think is the best game without showing the results (at least until you've written yours) and see how both compare to each other.
Persona 4
Resident Evil 4
... SMB 3 (God that's actually a really tough one)
I'll throw in...
The Last of Us vs. Pokemon Crystal
Not sure where we got Resi 4 v Twilight or even SMB3 v SMG to be honest. The first was someone saying they preferred the way those games have their collectibles and the other one never happened. Oh well.
Pokémon Crystal.
Ikaruga v Radiant Silvergun
To save making another post, the best PS3 game idea sounds a good one. Sadly Last Of Us will win but be nice to see what games miss out on say the top five or ten. I say go for it.
yeah wesker wrote two games and considering the thread I thought why not? Also the way you are banging on about Mario galaxy I thought.... Well the best Mario game is bros3 so thought I would throw that in (to wind you up) Anyway..... Ikaruga and mega man 2 are through to the last 32. There's a bit of a mix with rastamadeus and tasuki as to the timing of the posts so next person on to put us out of our misery is it.... Pokemon crystal vs the last of us?
PS3 Megathread 2019: The Last of Us
Multiplat 2018: Horizon Zero Dawn
Nintendo 2017: Super Mario Bros 3
Playstation 2016: Uncharted 2
Multiplat 2015: Final Fantasy 7
I'm sorry to hijack this thread (I'll be gone in a second!) but I'm here to ask something relative. If Push Square was to host a tournament to decide, say, the best ever PlayStation 3 game, what would you think?
Say we'd have 32 games, and once a week, we'd have a vote to decide which of two games goes on. It would take a long time to get to the final, but does it sound like something you might like? Any feedback is appreciated.
Again, sorry to derail the thread - carry on!
This is a great idea. I love these kinds of debates.
i only played Onimusha, but i Loved and i meen LOVED Dino Crisis 2. It was one i started off playing thinking hmmm?! a res evil knockoff with dinos?! S.T.A.R.S and T.R.A.T?!?! But even a short way in i could see it was a much faster paced different game style and level after level i just enjoyed more. I lost count over how many times i replayed just to try and get those perfect max combo sections! I loved the ending too, and i really wish they had made a sequel more in that period of time
Tenchu 2: Birth of the Stealth Assassins vs Driver
Forums
Topic: Best game of all time cup
Posts 21 to 40 of 68
This topic has been archived, no further posts can be added.