What are all trick or treat answers and how do you solve the Decorative Box puzzle in Silent Hill 2? This puzzle has two sections to it: the trick-or-treat quiz you get in the Elevator of Brookhaven Hospital and then the Decorative Box that requires you give the correct answers to those questions. In this Silent Hill 2 guide, we're going to reveal all trick or treat answers and how to solve the Decorative Box puzzle.

What Are All Trick or Treat Answers and How Do You Solve the Decorative Box Puzzle in Silent Hill 2?

Silent Hill 2: All Trick or Treat Answers and How to Solve the Decorative Box Puzzle Guide
Image: Push Square

The Decorative Box is found in the Pharmacy of floor 1F in the Otherworld version of Brookhaven Hospital. On its top, it requires 3 inputs to open, which as the Q1, Q2, and Q3 on the left-hand side would suggest, relate to questions. You've actually already heard them: in the Elevator from the radio announcer. If you're checking this guide, there's a strong chance you've either completely forgotten about that or you're missing some answers.

In the Elevator, you're asked the number of victims from the Silent Hill plague in the past, what street you'd use to reach the Graveyard in the area, and who Billy Locane's sister was. The answers are as follows, with the number in brackets relating to the button you need to press on the Decorative Box:

  • 67 Victims (answer no. 2)
  • Wiltse Road (answer no.3)
  • Miriam Locane (answer no.1)

So, from top to bottom, use the code 231 on the Decorative Box to open it. Your reward is 2 boxes of Shotgun Shells and 2 Syringes.


Did you find our guide covering all trick or treat answers and how to solve the Decorative Box puzzle in Silent Hill 2 useful? Let us know in the comments below and check out our Silent Hill 2 guide for more help and information.