I never tentatively tore the corners of my Christmas presents in order to get a sneaky first look inside. I had friends who claimed to know the contents of all of the gifts nestling beneath their fake fir trees, but I always preferred to wait. In fact, as I got older I tended to recommend that we held off opening our gifts until after dinner; with birthdays, I'd never touch anything until all of my family was home. I think, deep down, I just wanted to prolong that sense of not knowing – after all, the excitement of secrets always withers the second that they're revealed.
Now don't get me wrong, as a child I was always appreciative of every single gift that I received – but there's an unavoidable low that follows the unwrapping of presents; something that was a mystery is now laid bare in front of your eyes. And I feel like a similar thing's happened in the games industry of late, as E3 2015 lurks tantalisingly on the horizon – but Fallout 4, Ratchet & Clank, Mirror's Edge Catalyst, and many others are already in the public eye. "Why wasn't that saved for the show?" I've read dozens of times – and I'm here to tell you why.
The thing about E3 is that it's almost too good. There are 52 weeks in the year with which new games can be announced, but many of them are condensed into a couple of days. The annual Los Angeles convention may not be the biggest gaming expo in terms of pure attendance anymore, but it is undeniably the most important event in the gaming calendar; Gamescom and the Tokyo Game Show are both busy, but not on the same scale. This, of course, leads to lots of noise, where organisations battle with each other in order to get their message heard – and it doesn't always work.
Everyone's shouting at the same time, but no one's really getting heard
Imagine you're in a football stadium, screaming for your star striker to pick up the pace. No one's going to hear your cries when the person behind you is booing the opposition and the person in front of you is talking on the phone; all that the television microphones will pick up is a blast of rumbling sound. And, as someone that covers it, I find E3 to be a bit like that: everyone's shouting at the same time, but no one's really getting heard. Massive announcements melt into the overall narrative, and press conferences are judged on the quantity of their reveals – rather than their quality.
I've never worked in public relations or marketing, but for those departments, I suspect that the idea of being ignored is a frightening prospect. No one wants their carefully planned product reveal and expensive CG trailer to be overlooked; they want it to be trending on Twitter, being liked on Facebook, and shooting up the YouTube charts. Only a number of brands can do that during E3, though – and even they have to settle for being a part of the conversation rather than the focus of it when all's said done.
So, would Fallout 4 have made an impact at E3 2015 if it debuted during Bethesda's press conference? Absolutely – it's big news. But by revealing it early, the publisher utterly dominated the industry for a couple of days – its debut trailer has already been viewed almost five million times. And that sets it up nicely for its big show; with pre-orders placed and the first footage picked apart, many will be tuning in to the aforementioned media briefing in order to see the title's first slice of gameplay in full.
The surprise may have been "spoiled", then – but does it matter all that much? The answer, of course, is no. I preferred to wait to open my Christmas presents, but the contents inside never changed. And the same is true at E3. Yes, the mysterious allure surrounding some of this year's bigger games may have been sapped, but you're still ultimately seeing the same things that the publishers planned – albeit ever-so-slightly prematurely. The silver lining in that is that you actually have time to digest some of these titles now, because you definitely won't next week.
Do you prefer your E3 reveals to be condensed into a very short space, or do you appreciate it when they're given a little more room to breathe? Blow your load early in the comments section below.
Have all of the early announcements spoiled your E3? (89 votes)
- Yes, I doubt there will be any surprises left
- Maybe, I'll have to see what’s announced
- No, all I care is that cool games are revealed
Please login to vote in this poll.
Comments 21
Actually it matters a lot, Sony wouldn't be in this position if it didn't "drop the mic" 2 years ago.
But your right the speculation is more fun than the game at times, and for me early leaks spoil the experience. The best of times at e3 is seeing an unexpected game show up, and show up in style. As a marketing manager (although a different scale) I like trade shows but prefer on the street boss business practice and sharing the message with customers and keeping them in the know.
I agree. But I also think the type of person who keeps up to date with the goings on at E3 would probably be considered the "Core Gamer" if you will. I think we're pretty good at picking out the information we need from E3, so I'm not really sure the likes of Fallout 4 would be any less of a big deal in the long run (I'm talking ultimately in sales generated) had it been revealed along with everything else at E3. It's certainly been the focus of attention by announcing sooner but whether that'll actually generate any more sales, I'm not so sure. In terms of the more casual gamer they'd more likely make decisions nearer the time based on reviews/online & real world advertising, launch trailers and so on.
It makes sense because the majority of the gaming industry loves doing everything way too early now. We could already pre-order Fallout4, and at a discount no less if it's on PC. The thing is, doing things early in this industry doesnt always mean they'll catch the worm.
Nintendo has been mostly quiet about their plans and PlatinumGames has been teasing images from their entire library to keep everyone guessing. I like that, because the reveal will be fun to watch during the E3 craze. When the enthusiasts see that same R&C demo that we already saw, it wont have as much shine to it.
It's a good thing for bloggers, sure. Because then they dont have to go crazy making multiple articles during the height of E3. That doesnt mean these games are getting more attention because of early reveals though.
@BLPs I think Sony's actually been one of the quieter publishers, too... It's only really announced Ratchet & Clank, and we already knew about that! It's been more third-parties revealing stuff early this year.
Sony has done it in the past, though, so you're quite right.
@get2sammyb E3 is like the football transfer window, they had 3 months to make their deals but leave it till the last 12 hours.
When you talk about not opening christmas presents beforehand,this is why as a PlayStation gamer it's exciting because we don't know what the majority of their studios are doing, right now they could be making anything, mystery is fun.
I had been waiting so long to hear confirmation that Fallout 4 existed. All I cared about was that it got announced. Seeing some dude on a stage announce it while flashy lights rain down on him wouldn't have made it any better.
I agree with this. It makes sense from a business standpoint, and the gamers still have something to look forward to because, while the game did get shown early, that doesn't mean we got everything. There's still an element of surprise.
Besides, it beats hoping vaporware will show up.
Probably we will see a lot of surprises yet. From Nintendo really new stuff, from Sony maybe changes on gameplay that are really cool or a new footage on a game already revealed but with almost no info (look at Persona 5), and for Microsoft...I really don't care.
So all in all, E3 still awesome! And I can't wait for 15/06 (sony) and 16/06 (Nintendo)!!!
I just love the time leading up to e3 and e3 itself. The showmanship, the reveals, the non reveals. I love it all. The biggest tease of all last year was a woman walking on stage to the god of war music, and not showing us anything, and the mass effect reveal non reveal. This year, if i get a 1 minute clip of the new mass effect, a release date for the witness/no mans sky, some doom 4 eye candy, im happy. My pie in the sky is an es announcement, but i know thats not happening. But its like playing the lottery, its ok to dream once in a while.
"I never tentatively tore the corners of my Christmas presents in order to get a sneaky first look inside. I had friends who claimed to know the contents of all of the gifts nestling beneath their fake fir trees, but I always preferred to wait. In fact, as I got older I tended to recommend that we held off opening our gifts until after dinner; with birthdays, I'd never touch anything until all of my family was home. I think, deep down, I just wanted to prolong that sense of not knowing – after all, the excitement of secrets always withers the second that they're revealed.
Now don't get me wrong, as a child I was always appreciative of every single gift that I received – but there's an unavoidable low that follows the unwrapping of presents; something that was a mystery is now laid bare in front of your eyes."
Dude i never could figure out why i loved christmas gifts so much, but now i think i know. Thank you.
Since I, as a kid, always opened my gifts earlier I really like these premature announcements.
I got all my E3 coverage on the internet, so it's good to be able to see something a bit sooner. And, as @get2sammyb pointed out, there is more time now to digest all the news.
Having said that, this must be the 3rd article that I read today regarding these early leaks, so I guess that a lot of people must be really bothered about it.
@kyleforrester87 I agree with your points. What irritates me is how most of these games like fallout 4 and others that only had a trailer and barely told you a damn thing about the content of the game want you to preorder. I like the fact rachet and clank which wasn't on my radar is very highly on it now. Rachet and clank did it right by giving you a demonstration videos of the game along with a trailer and some content info. I also like that it's $40 and seem to beredone almost from the bottom up with new boss fights, new flight sequences. Type of jet pack and all new cutscenes etc.
I want games to stop asking me to preorder until we get substantial information to make a good consumer decision. I am not the one to just preorder based on some well crafted trailer but it still irritates me.
As much as I love UC series. The trailer was one of the worse with the collection trilogy not even showing the game. How do I know if the 3 games look like a major over haul in graphics, textures etc prior to preordering ? I'm not preordering nothing until I see a ton of videos and info on Nathan drake collection. I know E3 will show plenty on Monday so I can be patient.
Some people would preorder or just buy games without research based on a developers rep like naughty dog. I am not the one although I trust naughty will have good to great games I still need to see what I am buying unlike if it woman's a Xmas gift then I wouldn't care.
@Alpha Yeah, I think the mystery is most of the fun. Obviously, gifts are also a huge token that people care about you and want you to be happy as well - but it's dat wrapping I tell you; it's not knowing what's inside!
@get2sammyb Maybe Push Square should be doing a feature: 'what games will be spoiled' alongside the feature of those, which will be 'announced'?
Spoiling obviously makes sense on many levels until it becomes an established practice; when someone will come up with a different way to advertise and set themselves apart that others will follow. That's the story of marketing, in a nutshell, but it does mean we have good few years of heavy spoiling ahead of us. The only good thing about it for me is finding out that something I'm looking forward to is in the works. The bad? The time you have to wait for the game to come out. The ugly? Sometimes things get spoiled early with best of intentions and then get cancelled.
It's the age we live in. Growing up in the 90s and remembering what E3 was like back then I kind of do miss the days when pretty much everything was a surprise. That said, just because a trailer or an announcement of a game leaks early doesn't necessarily negate its impact. At least not imo. Usually these leaks just say 'such and such game is on the way.' A cool stage demo at E3, especially if it's an exclusive game, can still be a big deal.
The only company really good at keeping 'shock' announcements these days is Nintendo, and as much as I respect the company, the fact is unless you're a hardcore Nintendo fan, these surprises don't mean much and for those of us who aren't enamored with Nintendo anymore it takes more than 'here's F-Zero' or 'here's Star Fox' to get us back.
I don't like a surprise to be ruined.
No games are accidentally, leaked, they are done so to start the hype, even if it's taken off of a website mere hours later. Balls gotta start to roll sometime, or there would be no hype
Yeah, it somewhat spoils it, but if you really want to get hyped, just stay away from the console pages, and never look at them until the day of E3. Other than that, with the internet, it's going to happen, but how much on the internet is actually true...barely any. It's better to wait until you see it listed at E3 before getting hyped, plus...most of the games that get mentioned are usually not coming out until close to the holidays or beyond...at least it seems to happen with many nintendo games. Still looking forward to reading the stories about E3.
@BLPs
There is a reason why I took off work Tuesday instead of Monday. Nintendo's conference is full of games, jokes, gameplay clips and devs explaining their labours of love. Not a suit talking numbers or a PR guy demoing a game they did not make.
On the same token, having Nintendo Directs regularly relieves them from trying to cram every new game in 90 min., which leads to lulls or rushing thru titles.
And you are right. " For the bankers" is more like it IMO.
@BLPs
I guess the fact the press always belittled Nintendo during E3 had a lot to do with it, right down to the "Direct" name. Also their kiddie, playful image help them to remind us we are here to have fun, not to be serious and "mature" about everything.
Well also remember how awful Nintendo were at E3. That unbelievably embarrassing thing with everyone pretending to play music for some Wii game that disappeared without a trace, them playing NSMB 4-player and one of them dying to the first goomba. Then sliding clunkily into 20 minutes of graphs and bar charts for the investors.
I don't really think you can say Nintendo are doing a better job of it when the point of this is to sell more games and consoles and Nintendo are doing dismally at that.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...