Republished on Tuesday, 29th December 2015: We're bringing this article back from the archives as we look back at some of Push Square's features from 2015. The original text follows.
Originally published on Monday, 3rd August 2015: Sometimes I think that strategy guides are a little bit misunderstood. I understand that spoilers are a big problem these days – especially with titles that are heavy on story – and there's no denying that finding your own way through a game is, more often than not, the most rewarding way to play. But for me, the appeal of strategy guides has never been their intended purpose.
Back when I was a kid, I remember buying a pocket guide to Discworld on the PSone. The point and click adventure sailed straight over my head at the time, and the only way that I could possibly beat it was to use the aforementioned guide and go through the game step by step. But this is the only memory that I have of actually using some sort of walkthrough to reach the ending credits of a release.
For me, a strategy guide is like the encyclopaedia of a particular game. To an extent, it's almost like a physical record of a game – something that can be archived and dug out when you want to be reminded of its contents. Where most people have novels on their bookshelves, mine's stacked with strategy guides for some of my favourite titles.
I've spent hours upon hours just poring through the knowledge stored within these guides even when I'm not playing the related release. There's something satisfying about having all of this stuff at your fingertips, and while that's obviously also the case when it comes to using the Internet for guides of all different shapes and sizes, there's something compelling about the information being bound in a physical form. I guess it's the same reason why people went mad for Skyrim's limited edition cloth map.
Having said all that, it's not like strategy guides are particularly fun to read. Most just rattle off instructions on where to go and how to do things – but again, it's everything except the guide's intended purpose that makes it compelling. In many cases, it's the accompanying artwork and neat presentation that make strategy guides a pleasure to flick through – and if this article's pictures haven't given it away yet, Square Enix is usually the absolute best for this.
Take the brilliant Final Fantasy XII guide, for example. I managed to pick up the limited hardback edition when the game first launched on the PlayStation 2, and I still give it a read now and then. It's got everything that you could possibly want to know about the release, from a complete walkthrough to massive amounts of data on every enemy, character, weapon, and item, but it's the way that it's all presented that's masterful.
Detailed illustrations accompany perfectly laid out tables, maps, and charts, while a ridiculous amount of screenshots adorn nearly every page, which is great if you're up for a hit of nostalgia. It's a superb account of the game and all of its workings, to an extent where it almost feels like a celebration of the release.
In that respect, strategy guides prove to be great companions to the games themselves, and I think that it'd be a real shame if they were to ever disappear thanks to the digital age, much like a lot of other printed media. I think that there's always something to be said for works of quality, especially when it comes to gaming merchandise, and as far as I'm concerned, you just can't beat a good old strategy guide.
Are you a fan of strategy guides? How big's your collection? Tell us all about your favourites in the comments section below.
Do you enjoy strategy guides? (62 votes)
- Yes, I use them to complete games
- I do, but I just like to collect them
- No, I don't really see the appeal
Please login to vote in this poll.
Comments 48
I still have my Gta V guide from launch day, there's something satisfying about owning one
I love hard cover Zelda strategy guides. I also have the FF12 Limited Edition guide. My last one is for Super Mario RPG, to this day the only one I would use. Those invisible treasure chests are not always easy to find.
I like them, but due to limited budget for gaming related stuff other than games, I only own one: Final Fantasy XIII-2's. It's a great guide and it saved me from the chore of going through the Web after scattered info on how to get all the secrets.
Yep, love em as well....but only for RPGs, because I simply want to get everything possible out of those games.
I never have nor will I ever buy a strategy guide. My ex girlfriend got me a strategy guide for FFVII and I took it back to the store. I understand why people buy them but for me, I like to try and discover everything myself. Besides, if I ever get stuck trying to solve a puzzle or find a collectable, theirs always YouTube or Wikki. Its alot cheaper than spending £20-£30 on a guide.
I also understand that some people like to have them for there favourite games as collectables.
I use to get them all the time back in for NES, SNES and PS games but once the internet became mainstream I couldn't justify paying the price for something I can find for free on the internet. I think the last game I used a strategy guide for was Zelda Ocarina of Time on N64 back when I played it during the N64 era because at that time I didn't have internet.
I still have my first one the strategy guide for Super Mario 3 by Nintendo Power and all of the ones I bought, there's something about just reading the tidbits of info about the game that they include in strategy guides along with the walk throughs.
@WARDIE I was of the same opinion until a few years ago. Nowadays, I haven't got nearly as much time to gaming, and my love for JRPGs makes me always want to do everything on them. However, adult life makes it hard for me to have 100+ hours to devote to one single game and try to discover everything on my own. Sometimes I got only one hour to play if I'm lucky, so wandering around on the game or searching the Web is not an option anymore. The guides are much more practical in this sense (not to mention collectables, as you said).
Haha I remember discworld the game and struggling with its obscure puzzles and fiendishly tricky chapters/acts.
As I had never read a terry pratchett novel at the time I thought that to stand a better chance at completing the game was to read a couple of his dis world novels to try and get into the mind of the author and stand a better chance at completing the puzzles in the game. Load of nonsense nowadays I know but at the ages of 10 I was willing to give anything a shot to complete that darn game.
Lol in the end I just paid 20 pounds to get the guide O.O
Completely agree. I actually have those DQVIII and FFXII ones, plus X-2. I don't have the Fallout 3 one but I do have the one for New Vegas. I've got quite a few more than that, even though I often didn't really intend to use them as guides. I did use the DQ and FF ones heavily. They're just nice to read for entertainment, like basically an absolutely enormous, in-depth magazine article on the game.
I'm not sure where people are getting the idea that they cost £20-30 from, though. Maybe that's what GAME charges, but they're usually not much more than £10 on Amazon. The hardcover Witcher 3 collector's edition guide, which also comes with a 96 page "grimoire", is just £13.59 at the moment. That'd basically get you 3 pints or a takeaway pizza, so I think it's great value for money.
I have that FFXII hardcover guide its my favorite.
Hmmm lets see.....Breath Of Fire 1 and 2, Phantasy Star 3 and 4, FF7, Oblivion, Skyrim, Fallout 3, Multiple Zelda ones, lol cant remember the rest. Honestly I get them for the artwork. My most prized artwork at the moment is the one I got for Dragons Crown. Bought the game at gamestop soon after its release and the guy behind the counter told me someone had preordered it but never picked it up. He let me have it for the normal price. Now that is one magnificent artbook. My son and I had quite the time looking at the....ermmm, umm, ladies in the artbook, lol.
preordered the special edition with artbook and I got that special edition for the price of the normal game is what I meant to say
Never been interested in one, the only game I'd buy one for is Shenmue and only would I ever read it after several play throughs. Maybe I'd get one for something amazing, perhaps Fallout 4.
To be honest, I don't think I've ever owned a strategy guide, but I have always appreciated them for the same reasons outlined in the article. I remember using a tips book that came with Official Nintendo Magazine for Ocarina of Time, as I couldn't get past the Water Temple when I was a wee nipper.
I own Skyrim, which helped me platinum the game! Also fallout 3, final fantasy X (also very stunning artwork) and the limited edition Final Fantasy XII which is just a beautiful guide!
Good read, and I fully agree with you. I love strategy guides for only rpgs and not to help me through the game, but to read about everything in the game and see what else is in the game. I think you said it best when you called it a encyclopedia for that game.
Not sure if you guys had this across the pond, but when I was in grade school we would have a book fair a few times per year. Basically a way for the school to make money by sending home a catalogue with all manner of books for children, and some for the parents. Of course my friends and I found that they were also selling strategy guides and "cheat code" books, a must for us at the time. I fondly remember getting the one for the original rygar as well as journey to silius, both under appreciated games at the time in our opinions lol.
As long as it's Prima or Piggyback. Not those terrible Brandy games guides.
I was lucky enough to win a Dragon's Dogma book from a Capcom stream, and after receiving it, understood the appeal of a tangible "thing" related to a much-enjoyed game. I went on to buy the Hyrule Historia book, and I suppose this trend will continue.
I never considered buying a strategy guide untill previous generation when just buying games wasn't as fulfilling as it once was. My fondest memories of buying games isn't just opening it and playing it straight away, it's the same night in bed that followed where I would sit under my blankets with my flashlight reading the big, chunky instruction manual. I would read up on how to actually play, see a bit of the backstory and get aquinted with the protagonists and enemies I'd face. I'd also write down my first notes of the earlier gamesession, smell the booklet one last time and close my eyes to start dreaming bout the wonderful things I would experience in game when I'd wake up.
Last gen we saw the instruction manual making place for downloadcodes for pre-order bonus hats or boots that aren't any good and a small paper that had a website on it; needless to say I needed more from my games and that's when I started buying strategy guides. Fortunately gaming is cheaper than ever nowadays to a point where I often times wonder how it's possible they keep on selling new €69 RRP games for €44- €48 at my local electronic warehouse, so I don't mind spending an extra few bucks on a guide.
Those guides look pretty neat in my game room and I also like to buy art books of games I really like and I actually do put them on the coffee table for others to browse through. Because I don't just collect, but actually use my books I tend to go for the hardcover/ collector's editions of he guides whenever available and I can get just as excited by browsing through an art book or guide, as with playing the actual game itself.
@ShogunRok glad you didn't get the final fantasy 9 strategy guide - there was a massive uproar about it. And I mean massive. I bought it - it was boss, great to look through, but - there was something off with the guide. Do you know what it is?
Good piece, I like strategy guides, but I also like half decent manuals as well, something which should return. When the ff12 remake comes our you will have loads of fun copying and pastin erm I mean writing your guide
I lost my count in how many SG I've bought, on the other side one hand is enough to count how many I really had put to use...
There is a strange appeal that make me buy an book just to open it once...
I started collecting them relatively recently, after getting the Skyrim legendary hardcover and loving every page. Then came other BethSoft games and now I'm trying to get one for all my favorite titles from over the years, which is only getting tougher. I had fun slowly finding every Silent Hill title's guides in pretty good conditions. I've bought a few artbooks too, if said art warrants (Valkyria Chronicles' is astounding). Right now my library is in stacks, but my future house's man cave will have bookcases full of them next to their game cases.
Here's one of many stacks 😅:
I don't buy a lot strategy guides, only a few and they've all been for RPG games that require long hours to complete. Plus, strategy guides cost too much nowadays - some as much as $40 which is almost the cost of the full game itself.
@Arckadius I bought the Zelda treasure chest box set and love those guides. And they prove VERY valuable when playing a Zelda game and get stuck.
I just bought the Fire Emblem guide for the original FE on GBA. The IGN guide stops after Chapter 23 in Eliwood's story, and while there are other websites they are all bits and pieces. I wanted a complete walkthrough without having 4 different tabs open in my iPad browser- and, for the collectibility as well.
I do use guides from time to time after all- Zelda, Bayonetta 2, Wonderful 101, DKC Tropical Freeze, Dragon Age Inquisition, Hyrule Warriors... they come in handy.
I like the digital PRIMA guides though. So convenient,mso easy to use on an iPad.
Does anyone know a good and cheap internet shop where i could buy some? Here I only get German ones (and my German understanding sucks a lot). Tnx in advance
@get2sammyb even to this day whenever I play a Zelda game with a water temple I get cold shivers down my spine.nintendo are evil
Where is the option I want to collect/use them but haven't got the change for it yet?
@themcnoisy I assume you're referring to the fact that they left half of the useful information out of the guide, forcing people who had already bought the guide to then go online to find said info at specified web addresses. Total rip haha! The funny thing is that now those servers have been taken down, so it is an absolute nightmare trying to find copies of the missing info! Still a nice little guide though, although out of all of them I'd say it's the one that's been made most obsolete by the internet.
And @ShogunRok nobody will judge you for Discworld. I still refuse to accept that there is anybody who actually completed that game without any help whatsoever!
@themcnoisy You'll have to enlighten me about the Final Fantasy IX guide. And yes, easy pickings for those FFXII guides!
@SteveButler2210 I guess that's true - a lot of the puzzles are incredibly obscure, especially by today's standards.
sadness! time for a
?
@ShogunRok the best stuff was reserved for a website as @SteveButler2210 mentions. The book constantly said "goto this site to find out how!" Annoying.
I don't think I've ever bought a stratagy guide in my life kinda alway's thought they were for people that couldn't play without a guide, or just a cheap way to play and after patch's etc the guide's would actualy become dated and missleading.
Great article- never thought of them in that way! I wouldn't use one to guide me through a game, but as a memento of a brilliant game... That works!
Other: I used to collect strategy guides for games I owned, but stopped after I realized I could use that extra money to buy more games.
i put "I do, but I just like to collect them" as my answer but my real answer is that i play through a game and do as much as i can and once i completed it THEN i look in a strategy guide to see what i missed
The Witcher 3 was the first strategy guide I bought in about 12 years.
During the N64 era, me and my brother would probably pick up 2 or 3 a year.....I remember the Goldeneye 007, Ocarina of Time, and Perfect Dark guides rather well.
As a kid, I loved both gaming magazines and strategy guides (mainly for RPGs). I would collect them and stuffed them in my closet until I had to get rid of them before moving out for college. Strategy guides were a big help for me, especially when I didn't have friends who played video games nor have gaming friends who would play the same games as I did...
Nowadays, I like the sense of discovery and don't use strategy guides. The last one I picked was for Hyrule Warriors for Wii U but only because of the artwork. However, if I do need assistance with a game I'll consult the Interwebs.
The only strategy guides I have owned was the 'Perfect Dark' one on the N64 but that came with the game when I bought it - some promotion or something in the store.
I have used 'cheat books' that used to come free with gaming magazines but nowadays if I want to look up something, I just use the internet and therefore don't have to spend money. At most, I use these for finding hidden collectibles but that's not often. I am normally one of those that look in every room/corner etc before moving forward. Its those really well hidden in obscure and bizarre places though that I usually end up looking up.
Loved this article! Nice one for showing it again one of my favourites this year.
I remember finishing ff7 first time without having Vincent join the group, missing various things (breeding gold chocobos, knights of round) along the way which would have been impossible without a guide at the time.
I'll buy a strategy guide for a game I'm really looking forward to because a lot of times they have some interviews and provide some backstory into the characters and prior games. I try never to use them to complete games though, unless there's a sidequest I'm just completely stuck on. But as far as the main campaigns I don't use strategy guides.
I used to buy a guide for my second play through of a game (or to get all the things I missed once I beat the game), but would never, ever, use the guide as I played the first time. If all you are going to do is be an input device from an instruction guide to the game, you might as well just watch a video of the games cutscenes, or watch a friend play, and be done with it.
I stopped getting physical guides after the terrible FFIX guide, where half of it was online anyway, and started just using free online guides to find collectables or get 100% second play throughs.
Anymore, I dont really see the point. You can get (better) artwork for the game online (wallpapers, avatars, etc...), and you can almost always find more detailed strategy guides posted by other players within a couple weeks of a games launch (giving you enough time to enjoy your first, unspoiled, playthrough).
I think "official game guides" are a relic that I would not mind seeing disappear.
Got the Xenoblade Chronicles X Collector's Guide simply to have a complete collection of the game's collector edition, official Japanese soundtrack and the guide. Completely worth it.
I love strategy guides. Especially the older Nintendo Power ones! Some of those were great reads. I remember reading the Banjo-Kazooie strategy guide and just laughing my butt off when I was a kid. I've picked up a lot of older guides and look through them from time. Probably my favorite is the Earthbound guide, which I still have the scratch and sniff stickers in. And for Christmas I got the Conker's Bad Fur Day guide!
When I was a kid I bought strategy guides for every game I played because I loved reading them and I still have most of them, but I was looking through one of the Pokemon Red and Blue guides I had the other day (I bought like three or four) and it was inaccurate! What a ripoff, haha. They knew we didn't have any other choice back in the day but today's kids can use the internet. Which is what I mostly use when I need actual help in a game these days. Better and more efficient than a dead tree, but so much less character.
I want to add that strategy guides were probably a great way, back in the 90s at least, in their heyday, to get so-called "reluctant readers" reading. That was also the era before "young adult" literature and the booming kid's books market that we have today. Strategy guides, Goosebumps, and Animorphs books were pretty much all that were aimed at kids in the 90s. Also Baby-sitter's Club if you were a girl. It was pre-Harry Potter, even.
Physical strategy guides have become a novelty, but I do believe there is still a place for them. Especially since they come with a free digital version you can load up on your iPad while you play.
Many times games that aren't super high profile don't get complete Internet walkthroughs for months, if at all. This is where a guide comes in handy, especially if you preorder.
Thing is, PRIMA is pumping out quantity to stay in business, and the quality is suffering as a result. At least in some guides. I bought the Xenoblade Chronicles X guide and that thing is worthless. I mean REALLY worthless.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...