There was a time when a new Telltale title was an event, but given how prolific the publisher's been with its episodic output of late, its Batman series has been met by murmurs rather than fervour. That said, we love the studio's style of game, and a tale that promises to spotlight Bruce Wayne as much as the Caped Crusader sounds fascinating. But is Episode 1: Realm of Shadows actually any good?
GameSpot - 8/10
While many fixate on breaking the Batman, Telltale wants to bring down Bruce Wayne, and it demonstrates an understanding that people and relationships are the key to this. Episode one begins the process of unravelling him, and sets the stage to lay him bare. Impressively, by sticking to its strengths, Telltale also delivers on the experience of being Batman. Realm of Shadows establishes a compelling Bruce Wayne narrative and is an exciting start to the series.
IGN - 7.5/10
Telltale's Batman is an unpredictable, multi-faceted adventure told through Batman the brawler, Batman the detective, and Bruce Wayne the politician. The three almost entirely separate characters and play-styles keep the familiar Telltale formula feeling fresh and inviting. While some of the dialogue does feel overly expositional, it's hopefully only there to provide concrete padding for future episodes, and the gorgeous, high-action combat sequences and creative detective work provide the right amount of contrast.
Game Informer - 7/10
The hook at the end of this episode has me intrigued for what comes next, but be warned, this is the roughest (and slowest) start to a Telltale series yet.
Our review of Batman's inaugural episode will be live imminently. In the meantime, let us know if you intend to wear the cowl in the comments section below.
Comments 21
To my great shame I still haven't played a single Telltale series. Really need to set that right, and tempted to start with either this or the Wolf Among Us.
@SegaBlueSky I like The Walking Dead ones the best. The Wolf Among Us is good, though - I'd wait and see how this series shakes out before picking it as your first one.
@get2sammyb @SegaBlueSky This or Wolf Among Us?Surely it's better to start with Wolf as the whole series is out and you won't be left waiting for a year to see what happens next.But I agree with Sammy,The Walking Dead series are by far the best
@Wazeddie22 @get2sammyb Yeah, they were just the ones that immediately grabbed me the most, thematically. Not bothered about the whole series being available immediately or not. Might have to check out the Walking Dead instead though, appreciate the recommendation!
Waiting till the whole season comes out before dipping my toes in with this one, Telltale is like a rollercoaster of quality these days so hoping for the best.
I'm a massive Telltale fan, and will certainly be getting this one.
Never played a telltale game I have not liked. Wolf Among Us was a persoanl highlight along with Tales form the Borderlands. I would not start with the Wolf Among US simply because it probably the best they have made. The Walking Deads are a good starting point and you can pick them up chealpy in sales.
I love telltale releases but i just have to wait for a sale on this one. Had my fingers burnt one too many times now buying on day one before finding the season pass on sale for as much as 50% off before the full set of episodes have finished releasing. I will certainly get this in the future though
My concern for this one is the same I had with Arkham Knight from a narrative perspective - I feel like all Batman's stories have now basically been told. It was like on the Arkham a Knight box when it was all like " Who is the Arkham Knight?" And it turned out to be the first person you'd think of if you knew anything about Batman.
At least the plot twist one quarter of the way through the game was decent, though.
Just beat the episode! There are frame drops here and there but the narrative is interesting. The episode 1 focused on both Wayne and Batman.
I wanted to play this because Im a DC fan and an avid Batman reader.
Unfortunately it looks identical to every telltale game ever made, which is a huge negative for me.
I didnt enjoy the People Arguing and Sometimes Zombies Show Up, but Im not a fan of the show so I tried Wolf Among Us, but it seemed to play exactly the same as TWD.
The story sounded so good as well.
Ill probably just wait until theres a playthrough on youtube and watch it as a story.
@get2sammyb is the Wolf Among Us based on anything? Or is it an original Tell Tale concept?
@itshoggie ita based on a series of graphic novels called fables not read them, but telltale did a wonderful job at getting me interested. They got me into watching the walking dead aswell come to think about it
@itshoggie https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fables_(comics)
I think telltale borders on publishing non-games but I'm a big DC fan so I'll get my first taste of telltale's games when i buy this tomorrow!
The big question is how does it run on PS4
@Rob_230 thanks for the info man! It's the only TellTale game I never heard anything about before, hence the reason for asking.
Sounds rubbish, I'll pick it up when it's on sale as per.
@itshoggie probably the best along with TWD season 2, TWD 1 and Borderlands are also worthwhile, GoT and Back to the Future are trash.
@Bad-MuthaAdebisi I think I have season 2 of WD (if that was the one that was on Plus).
When you say "probably the best" you mean story right? I presume the gameplay is the same throughout all TellTale games.
@itshoggie yeah story wise and characters, I had a lot more fun playing as clementine
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...