So here's the thing: we've never known a start to the year quite as strong as what 2017 is turning out to be. Last year was a fine year for games, but it was by-the-numbers – few games exceeded expectations and even fewer will live long in the memory. The past two and a bit months have been the opposite, though: exciting, fresh, and so much better than anyone could ever have expected.
Go back to January and few would have predicted that the likes of Nioh, NieR: Automata, and Horizon: Zero Dawn would be Game of the Year candidates; even less could have foreseen Yakuza 0's impact (and we include long-time series fans in that) or Resident Evil 7's sharp return to form. And as for The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild's current Metacritic rating… Well, you'd have been laughed out of the room.
Something special is happening here: the games that are releasing aren't just good, they're significantly better than anyone could have ever anticipated. Take a look at Gravity Rush 2 – it's fast becoming one of the forgotten gems of 2017 already, and yet it's more likeable than the abundance of blockbusters that launched the year prior. Hatsune Miku and Night in the Woods? Same thing.
And while it's possible things could fall apart over the coming months, the release schedule at the time of typing gives us hope. Mass Effect: Andromeda may have its pre-release critics, but so did Guerrilla Games' open world RPG – and look how that turned out. Elsewhere, Persona 5 just landed its first English language 10/10, while Crash Bandicoot: N. Sane Trilogy's looking like a fan's dream.
Looking elsewhere, the likes of Splatoon 2 and Super Mario Odyssey are still to come – but even if we focus on the PS4, there's stuff like Destiny 2 and Star Wars Battlefront 2 on the horizon. And then you've got Red Dead Redemption 2 – sure, it might get delayed, but if it makes it out and builds upon the critically acclaimed blueprint laid by its predecessor… Oh boy!
There are a few years in history that currently claim the greatest ever crown: 1998 with Half-Life, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, and Metal Gear Solid; 2007 with BioShock, Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare, and Super Mario Galaxy. Could 2017 top them? Maybe not – many of the aforementioned are iconic. But is this shaping up to be the best year in games for a long time? Y'know what, it's looking that way, isn't it?
Could 2017 be the greatest year for games ever? Are you shocked by how strongly this year has started? Wash away the cynicism and let yourself get over-excited in the comments section below.
Could 2017 be the greatest ever year for games? (144 votes)
- Yes, it's well on its way at this stage
- Hmm, too early to call
- No, previous years are far too strong
Please login to vote in this poll.
Comments 59
Ooo 1998 was indeed a vintage year! I'd have to say 2017 is probably shaping up to be better, though.
There are a lot of games I'm looking forward to playing this year. That's for sure.
1998 is tough to beat with the best Zelda (probably best game), best Resident Evil (2), Banjo and Metal Gear. I think this year may do it with an excellent Resident Evil, the second best Zelda Yakuza, a new Mario which looks great, Persona 5, the quite stunning Horizon, Nier, Banjo 3 sorry Yooka Laylee, plenty for VR, Red Dead Redemption........ yeah this is getting silly, 2017 is definitely taking that honour
It's pretty bloody special so far.
well it most certainly is! XD
It's weird I was thinking this just this morning. There have already been so many great games released and we're not even halfway through March. This generation has taken a long time to feel like it's getting going but we're finally at that point. Will it beat out 2007? Maybe, though I imagine things will slow down significantly in the second half of the year. Sony may surprise us all and release God of War in the Autumn, but there seems to be an increasing habit of them releasing tentpole releases in Q1.
I'm still not too fussed about Mass Effect (despite loving the original trilogy) but Persona 5 is something I'm enormously looking forward to. I doubt Yooka-Laylee or Dragon Quest Heroes II will be critical darlings but I'm really excited to play them as well.
I'm too old to remember years gone by and Horizon was released, so yes.
PlayStation's 2017 is incredible and Nintendo just unleashed an all-time great game...I hope they will keep the momentum with strong E3 reveals.
Yes this is the best year in gaming for me since I've been an adult. Horizon and Zelda are amazing games, and I'll be getting Yakuza 0 soon. Plus there's Mass Effect next month and Mario Kart 8 Deluxe and Persona 5 the month after.
If you own a PlayStation 4 or Switch, it's been great and will get better.
Of course it's the greatest year in my book, considering the advent of a console I've needed for years. XD
Otherwise, I don't assign greatness to years that much. But "iconic" is hardly an intimidating perception for future "contenders" - I mean, if 1998 and 2007 are considered "iconic" by some, then obviously the former's status didn't really prevent the latter's in their eyes, did it? 2017 ia shaping up to be a very rich year in video gaming, and that's what matters. Including the birdflip at the perrenial sentiment about the industry - "Nintendoomed" is hardly the sole representative of it; I mean, I see "PS4 has no games" jabs to this day, so what was the point of nearly 60 million purchases is apparently anyone's best guess. We're fans, doomsaying and complaining is pretty much all we exist for - but the fact our lot continues to be spawned in people's minds and relationships with fiction is also a sort of testament to video games' actual vitality in the end.
It is looking like a great year indeed, but greatest ever is pushing it too soon. Especially since we're only 3 months in. Give a couple years to see how every game holds up, before we really decide.
Based solely on BotW... Yes.
Let's not forget Hellblade: Senua's sacrifice which is shaping up to be special, both in terms of technology (real time mocap/green screen) and content (deep dive into mental illness)....
And Nioh
This year is great so far, but can Sony sustain it? They seem to have heavily loaded the first half of the year
A new Persona. New Gravity Rush. Multiple interesting PS4 exclusives. A decent Resident Evil. Possibly the greatest Zelda ever made. New exploratory 3D Mario. New Splatoon. A home console I can take with me anywhere.
Yeah, this year is perfect so far.
This year has too many great games and not enough time. It may not have titles that beat the 1998 classics but overall this year is shaping up to be something special.
Yep, for the PS4 it is And maybe the Switch if not all future Switch games will be like the God awful 1, 2 Switch(or whatever it's called) And the Xbox ONE has...er erm...
Yes and we don't even need more games! But we will have more games and it will be even better! Persona 5 can't come soon enough
Maybe but ya have to also take into consideration how games have evolved into account... The early eighties with my Commodore 64 were breathtaking.. At the time...
Yes especially for ps4 owners, for nintendo switch owners too if mario launch on fall, definitely not on xbox land however.
Whoa, Hatsune Miku got a mention! You guys linked to Diva X and not to Future Tone, but I will overlook that
Indeed a lot of heavy hitters, and most of them on Sony's side. I wonder how ARMS on Switch will fare, since it looks quite interesting.
Yeah, I haven't known a year be this good in quite some time. It's getting to the point where one will be able to take a bath in all the game cases, Scrooge McDuck style.
For me it's looking to be the best. Haven't even played games like nier or hollow knight yet. If sony releases god of war or last of us this year, holy good god overload.
Potentially great, but how can the last few months compare to 1997 let alone 1998? Its like comparing Theo Walcott to Zinadine Zidane at this stage. But Theo can grow into Maradonna by the end of the year.
The games mentioned in MGS, Half life and Ocarina of time are a pinch of what 1998 brought to us - but those 3 games alone were so revolutionary I've yet to see that in the last 2 months.
As someone has already pointed out how big 2013 was, what about 2009 - Uncharted 2, Infamous, Killzone 2, Assassins Creed 2, Batman: Arkham Asylum, Modern Warfare 2, Left 4 Dead 2, R&C: A crack in Time, Bayonetta, Halo 3ST, Forza 3, Halo Wars, Street Fighter 4, Minecraft, Dragon Age: Origins....
This year is pretty crazy for gaming. This is definitely one of Sony's all-time best years for the PS4 if not every system. Nintendo is looking to have a great year as well with a great lineup of Switch games for the holiday season. Microsoft... well there isn't a lot to look forward to there, sadly. I don't think there is a single XBOX One exclusive I plan on getting this year as of now. I'm pretty sure that will change after E3 or the Scorpio reveal.
And that's not even considering third party games.
@BAMozzy Both were definitely incredible years. It's weird how the odd number years are always the standouts.
release God of war this year and it will definitely be the best
That Nier score should be higher but some moron gave it a 5/10. Really. Even if you don't like the style or genre u have to admit it's atleast a 7 or an 8.
Looking up other releases from 2007, you've got: Halo 3, Assassin's Creed, Mass Effect, Uncharted, Crackdown, Portal. 😮
Great article! And I would have to say 2017 is the best year for the gaming culture ever. It seems like every new game i get there is another great one right around the corner. Well... I mean for ps4 and switch, not for xbone sadly
@wiggleronacid 2008 had some great games - GTA4, Fallout 3, Dead Space, Gears of War 2, Burnout Paradise, Metal Gear Solid 4, Battlefield: Bad Company, World at War, Little Big Planet, Fable 2, Resistance 2, Mirrors Edge, Saints Row 2, Far Cry 2, Race Driver: Grid, R&C: Quest for the Booty, Star Wars: Force Unleashed, Lego Batman, Spiderman: Web of Shadows, Motorstorm: Pacific Rift, Tomb Raider: Underworld, Prince of Persia, Super Smash Bros: Brawl, Braid...
@Carl-G @walrusballs The Xbox One has Halo Wars 2, Cuphead, Sea of Thieves, Crackdown 3, State of Decay 2, Voodoo Vince Remastered, Phantom Dust, No doubt a new Forza Motorsport and Phil Spencer promised more exclusives than last year. MS usually announce a lot of games at E3 and the majority release within the next 'year' after - unlike Sony who announce games and most don't release before the next E3.
@BAMozzy Um... cool, those games are not terrible but I would never play them. And that was 10 years ago... what does xbone have this year that's exclusive and GOTY worthy? And if MS has some exclusives coming out this year good for them, Sony and Nintendo already beat them to it. No hate tho, I still play my 360 every now and then 😘
It's a good year so far, but way too early to even start considering it for the best year ever. I don't think games release at the rate they used to to compete with some of those earlier years, there was much more room for bad games to be released and still have a lot of amazing titles come out. Lower budgets also meant companies were much more likely to risk releasing new ideas in their games which, when it worked, led to some gems. Still, if good games continue to be released at this rate i'll be a happy gamer.
I would suggest there is something great for everyone this year. Definitely something to celebrate.
apart from HZD and mass effect andromeda, nothing much else so far really appeals to me that's either out already or confirmed to be coming in 2017. i guess we'll have to see what else gets announced for the rest of the year, but at the minute, the answer is a no for me.
@walrusballs What was 10 years ago? All the games I listed for Xbox are all Exclusives that are due out this year. Whether or not they win Game of the Year or not, who knows. Crackdown or Sea of Thieves may win MP game of the year for all you know, Cuphead could win best independent game but I do agree that from what I have seen so far, they are unlikely to win the 'main' game of the year title.
Just because they may ot be 'games' you want, doesn't mean that Xbox owners are not getting any exclusives. Personally, the one I was most excited for was cancelled (Scalebound) but I am looking forward to Crackdown far more than any of the 'Japanese' games that we have seen a glut of recently on PS4.
MS also has the Scorpio due out at the end of the year and with 9months left, they and fans of Xbox could still have a very good year. Its not all 'doom and gloom' with nothing to look forward too as you insinuated! The Switch doesn't have that many 'exclusives' coming out this year either - at least not that many announced so far.
I saw the headline & immediately thought "nah, not even close. '98 will never be topped" sure enough, '98 is the one everybody refers to.
2006 was also a vintage for me, my favourite game ever came out, Oblivion 😍
The latest Zelda is great but it doesn't come close to Elder Scrolls IV imo I'm afraid.
I have to say I've enjoyed 2017 a whole lot so far with Ghost Recon Wildlands and Sniper Elite 4. I will probably look into Horizon Zero Dawn too at some point, and I can't wait to get a Switch and play Zelda and FAST RMX.
@BAMozzy O whoops i thought those games were already out... lol mer n u are completely different gamers if you like those kinds of games... so I can't really relate or discuss with you about them cuz they are nert my fervorites types of games. But I do heart MS, I hope the Scorpio is also something I can get for my 4k tv and that their exclerserves aer werth gertting a skerpio, becuerze, the games you mention do not look that interesting to me serry. I hope MS learns from nintendo and does a handheld too with halo on it. That would be serkkkkk(sick)
If there's a new main Pokemon game released it will certainly be one of the greatest years.
Well every year the PS4 has been released has not been good. Zelda and Mario will be the only thing nintendo has, and Xbox has Grad Theft Auto 4. 2017 will be barely better than 2016.
It's on pace to be the best year since 2007, but I can't see it topping that year in the end.
Don't forget Arms,too many are dismissing that but I think it's going to take a lot of people by surprise,just like Splatoon did.
@waluigifan "Zelda and Mario will be the only thing nintendo has"
and Arms,Splatoon 2,Xenoblade 2,Mario Kart 8 Deluxe and whatever they will reveal at E3.That is a stellar line up of 1st party games,perhaps Nintendo's strongest first year line up for any console they've put out.
Too early to say but I would say is that the classic years mentioned, such as 1998 and 2007 were years of innovation that produced titles that changed the gaming landscape in some way. To be honest, I'm not sure that this year has shown real innovation rather than excellent quality and variety. Possibly the only massive innovation has been Resi 7's VR mode.
That doesn't mean I am belittling what an excellent year it has been so far. I think we have come a long way from everyone declaring console gaming dead at the start of the gen to producing some of the best titles seen and selling them and hardware at huge levels.
I'm pretty certain this is an observation / question posed by someone else in the comments a few days ago - not sure who but Sammy will know, credit where credits due, eh?
The short answer is that we don't yet know if this will be the best year for gaming; will Mario Kart, Tekken 7(?), RDR2 etc fully deliver? I think Horizon has defied expectations so feels like an unearthed gem, Zelda on Switch is a sore point for me; whilst I loved SNES / Game Boy / N64 with the likes of Ocarina of Time, right now the Nintendo fan-bot 'critics' who lambasted Vita for not competing with PS3/XBox are the same fools who are lauding Switch and pretending the Vita didn't do it all better and first.
Maybe a more original question would be is the best TIME in gaming, rather than Year?
Think about GTA Online on PS4, Zelda, Horizon, Destiny, even Pro Evo 2017; or the games that have been out a few years - think about how phenomenal Persona 4: Golden is on Vita.......so surely it's the best time in gaming in general rather than querying if it's the best Year in gaming only two and a half months in....
I don't ever remember the beginning of the year like this for quality game releases.
It's more like the run-up to Christmas!
Am loving Horizon right now but have Zelda, Nioh, Neir, Gravity Rush 2, Yakuza all still to add to my swelling backlog! Crazy.
Not a bad year up to now, not many game's i'm excited for have been released yet, i'm sure Horizon is great and i'll play it when it come's down in price I never pay full wack for SP game's FFXV was the last straw. Not great but not a bad start to the year. I've only actualy bought one game this year and I have no plan's to pick anything up on release day as it all just look's average to me. RDR2 may well make this a great year for me though, Andromeda looked ok but it only has coop, maybe the lack of MP game's atm is the reason console/gaming sale's are so poor atm. Anyway I just plod's along through my old game's that some call backlog keep's me happy enough. I would LOVE to play Zelda but i'm not buying a console for one game, I will play it though, I will.
It's a damn good year so far, it must be said.
For Nintendo and Sony fans, it's looking to be one of the best years...Still pretty sad for XBox owners though...hopefully Microsoft can deliver at E3
The first half of the year has been and will continue to be undeniably awesome. Not entirely sure if that will carry over to the second half.
As of today there are more games that I want to buy then I usually do in a full year, with lots more I'm excited for. I won't say it is the best year yet since it is only March, but between the PS4 games and the great launch of the Switch (particularly Zelda) I voted yes...definitely looking that way.
I said last year, 2017 is gonna be a blast, but I could never imagined how good would be.
Nope, there's no Bethesda RPG. Destiny 2 and Shenmue 3 should make up for it, as well as South Park.
Considering there's still some very good games still to come out, yeah I think so.
1998 wasn't just my favorite year of gaming cause of crash 3 but also my favorite power rangers season was showing during that time
Just came here to point out that the original Starcraft also released on 1998. That was one mighty year.
That being said, I do agree 2017 is shaping up to be the best game ever. I have already a list of games I'll be picking up all the way up till August, and that's not counting anything that's coming up after Persona. GOTY is gonna be real intense.
The Wii launch year of 2006 with all the Wii games and everything else is very hard to beat, but 2017 is certainly shaping up to be a great year. PS4 is doing great with tons of games, 2DS is still getting interesting games like Fire Emblem Echoes, and even Wii U got Zelda.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...