There’s no need for catty remarks from yours truly anymore, as it’s time for Sonic Forces (and its fanbase) to put up or shut up where critics are concerned. Hopefully the game’s good, but we can tell you that SEGA has decided not to send us code until after launch – and it seems like we’re not the only outlet in that boat. Maybe it’s because we’ve been arses about the title in the past – or mayyybe… Let’s just wait and see, shall we?
Hobby Consolas - 5.7/10
Think of it as a Sonic game for the toddlers at home. Even so, it maintains some mistakes from which Sonic Team should have learned a long time ago.
Destructoid - 5.5/10
It's mostly just exceedingly average. Levels are short enough where I never once felt like they were a chore to complete, and there's enough variation in there in terms of setpieces where you can really start to see the framework of an expansive, epic Sonic. Hopping around Eggman's base in space while navigating moving platforms gives me flashbacks to the great pair of Sonic Adventure games -- a simpler time.
Polygon - 5/10
Sonic Forces creators' good intentions and interesting ideas don't amount to much in a game so clumsy and limited in design. It certainly doesn't help that Forces follows right on the heels of Sonic Mania, a game that not only demonstrated a more focused design sensibility but also did a far better job of realizing its creators' ambitions. Forces may have had a larger budget than Mania, but it feels like the poorer creation all around. Unless your dearest dream has always been to play a Sonic game as your own original fan art character, Sonic Forces doesn't have much to offer.
We’ll update this page with more Sonic Forces reviews as and when they become available. In the meantime, comfort yourself with your copy of Shadow the Hedgehog in the comments section below.
Comments 63
Never have been and never will be a Sonic fan. Pretty much the poor man's Splatoon.
@KirbyTheVampire Sonic's nothing like Splatoon?
im glad sega respected their flagship franchise enough not to send pushsquare a code, regardless of how good/bad the game is.
@get2sammyb I think that's a joke that's been going around.
I want to like this game, but I just wasn't feeling it with the demo on Switch. I feel like 3D Sonic kind of plays itself (speaking from my experience with Generations and the demo of this). I'm probably gonna save my money for DOOM on Switch.
Famitsu gave it 35 out of 40 https://mynintendonews.com/2017/10/31/famitsu-sonic-forces-received-a-review-score-of-3540/
@Arminillo If Sega didn't send a code to PushSquare towers because they're critical towards Sonic's past releases explains why they keep making 3D Sonic games that are subpar at best; they never learn from their mistakes and block out any type of criticism that would better themselves.
Besides, they said they're not the only one.
@Arminillo And yet I’d planned (and still plan, present tense) to assign the game to a Sonic fan who would have given it a very fair and honest review.
@get2sammyb
How many bad reviews did you give them? Haha. Haven't played a Sonic game since Sega Genesis, I have no clue what they are like now a days, just curious!
@KirbyTheVampire I can see that, but everyone knows that Splatoon is just the poor man's Knack 2. I mean c'mon there are even two of them!
What I want to know is whether it feels like a Generations 2 or not, I love Generations but hate every other Sonic 3D game
“Better than Bubsy”. Sounds like the perfect tagline.
Yeah, the review is confirming my worst fears. It'll only get worse as more reviews come out.
What a shameful showing after the delightful Sonic Mania. Disband Sonic Team and have the developers of Sonic Mania continue to pump out original 2D outings.
@KirbyTheVampire I feel like there's a joke here that I'm not privy to.
Is this the game that made everyone rage with sammy? If yes I'm glad it's average so these crybabies have their average meh mediocre game to play
grabs popcorn
@get2sammyb @BLP_Software @Ralizah It's a joke, but I think I'm pretty much the only one who finds it funny, haha. Check the comment sections in the De Blob and "What are your thoughts on Call of Duty as a whole?" articles if you care at all to understand it.
i knew the 35/40 = 8.75/10 famitsu gave was BS lol
The only 3D Sonic game I've played was the one that turned him into a werewolf or something. Obviously I wasn't impressed since I can't even remember the name!
"There’s no need for catty remarks from yours truly anymore"
No point holding back at this point, you've poked the defenders enough that at this point it's just humorous to see the responses
@NYJetsfan123
Try sonic mania, it's great and feels like a direct sequel to the genesis games.
If Sega didn't send out any review codes, how did Polygon end up with a review before everyone else?
Sonic is so fast he arrived on my doorstep early! Had it since Saturday. So far my thoughts on it is that it's not the best Sonic game (shocker shocker) but it's still quite enjoyable so I'm happy with it. Made it to stage 20 so far and a handful of those stages are good for fans of the classic Sonic. A nice mix up with both 3D and 2D. Don't want to spoil anything but there was a moment in a stage that reminded me of one/two in Mania.
@KirbyTheVampire you're not the only person who finds it funny.
Never understood the appeal of Sonic, especially the 3D entries. Poor man's Splatoon.
Its Polygon, they are dreadful. Im sure it wont be the OMG! greatest game ever made, but as long as its fun to play then who really cares
I'll stick with Splatoon.
LOL, why are you guys talking about Splatoon?
Looks like that Sonic Forces will not be a good game, i'm not surprised after Sonic Boom and Lost World, but i would never trust Polygon, tbh.
@Octane I still dont understand the comparison probably a terrible joke.
And Polygan yeah who trusts that crappy site.
Think deep down I knew this game wasn't going to be very good.
I just want Sonic Adventure 3.
...or just give me Sonic Adventure 2 on PS4...
Guess I'll pick up Sonic Mania next time it's on sale.
I'm not denying the score is likely spot on, just funny that there's only one review in this "review round up" and it's from one of the weaker sites.
Why would they send you a copy if your just going to trash the game? I ws watching a Twitch stream the other day and he had been given a copy of a game by the publisher all he did was talk about everything bad about the game and none of the positives.
1 hit, 2 miss. The rule continue. Sega almost tricked us with Mania.
I find it interesting that they claim this review was written using a Switch copy purchased by Polygon...two days before launch. Is it really a good idea to openly admit to weaseling around street dates like that?
@BLP_Software "I don't think its a fault of Forces that SEGA put it after Mania."
I kind of feel that way about Mario coming after Zelda. Mario is still a 10, but it's big open world fetch quest game play feels like the Mario devs were playing too much Zelda. So as good as Mario is, I feel like had I played it before Zelda it would be even better. Zelda still would have been great after Mario b/c it's so much more open.
But this Sonic, yeah, it's gonna suffer mightily after Mania, no getting around that. Fortunately my kid hasn't played Mania yet, which I guess will be to his advantage. To his disadvantage apparently, his Switch version arrives tomorrow. Whatever you've read, I'm nto telling him, he'll figure it out. Heck, he likes Sonic '06, so it's gonna take a lot.
I haven't decided how much effort I'm putting into it, probably play the first 2 or 3 levels to see what it's like then stop as I have a 3 try limit on any level in any game before quitting. I'm up to about 10 levels now in Mario that will never get done.
@RedMageLanakyn Sonic Unleashed. Which I only remember b/c it came out the same time as Godzilla Unleashed on the Wii. And the Sonic half of the game wasn't that bad, problem was they made half the game w/ the werewolf, which nobody liked. If this game is as good as the Sonic half of Unleashed it won't be horrible. $34.76 delivered tomorrow by Amazon, I've probably spent more money on worse. And it comes w/ stickers.
@Fight_Teza_Fight
Sonic Mania is an awesome game. You could not go wrong with that one.
COME ON SONIC, PROVE EM WRONG SON
I still think it's too early to judge the game based on One review and one that doesn't include the day one patch that seems to add a little to the length of the game.
But coming on the heels of Sonic Mania and Odyssey, the difference in quality surely would influence some reviewers into giving what would normally by a 6 or 7 with a lower score...
Still as said by many, it will surely be better than Bubsy. That game was GOTY material... not.
I'm expecting average scores. I can't wait to give it a shot tomorrow though.
PERSONALLY, as much as I loved Mania, it's still a 2D Sonic game. I really want another good 3D Sonic game like Adventures 1 and 2.
As for the comparisons to Odyssey, my #1 complaint with the game is movement... I hate the movement system so much. I'm certainly a little biased since I've never really liked a Mario game much and this one seems to bank a lot on nostalgia.
Did you had to remind me of owning Shadow the Hedgehog?!
I Played Sonic Heroes i beat it liked it.
Fight Me.
I'm genuinely still optimistic for this game. I won't judge until I've played it and tbh I trust famitsu more than polygon so here's hoping the sonic levels are good and the crap fan art levels are inoffensive. At the very least I'll make a hideous looking character and laugh my way through the game. I really love the sonic levels in Unleashed and it's a shame how bad the werehog levels were. And speaking of shadow the hedgehog lol I still own my copy on ps2 with a £5 Morrisons sticker on it. It's probably not even worth that much.
How did we get fifty comments after one bad review from Polygon?
Sonic rarely reviews well, in fact I'm expecting GI to have it at the back of my next issue with a 5.5 slapped on it. I'll try it myself sometime after release, hopefully it's alright.
Regardless of reviews there is not a Sonic game that my sister hasn't bought and she told me she wanted this for Christmas, so tomorrow I'll swing by Gamestop and pick it up for her.
TSSZNews, which is a Sanic fansite, gave it a 2/5. The other Sonic fansites beside the reddit community (much wailing and gnashing of teeth) seem ebullient about it coming out of the blocks all banjaxed.
Hey @get2sammyb, just review Just Dance 2018. Much more pleasant than playing through yet another poor attempt at a modern Sonic game.
@JoeBlogs Sexyplatoon?
Woah... is this Nintendolife?
I clicked on a link in a Sonic forces article...
Everything is blue...
I already have an account...
What is this?
@twenty90seven Yeah but they gave Sonic 2006 a 30/40, which is regarded by just about everyone else as one of the worst 3D platformers ever.
I bought it on Switch, first impressions are that the gameplay is like Generations but the music, voices and cut scenes are much better. Enjoying it in small bursts on the Switch.
I just beat it, and personally, I enjoyed it a lot. It has its issues, certainly. A few moments of slippery control, particularly as the Avatar stand out. But overall, it is a much more polished version of the groundwork they laid out with Generations, but prettier and with more focus, fewer glitches, and more to do. The soundtrack is also great. Definitely a standout for me.
@KirbyTheVampire keep it up dude, you’re gathering a small but growing group of supporters
To be fair I find your recurring gag way more fun than everyone saying “word up son” twice a comment lol
Updated with some new reviews.
@vegeta11 that’s awesome, hope she enjoys it!
@clvr word up son
@KirbyTheVampire "Poor man's Splatoon" is a great meme. Keep it going!
The PC version used to crash after Level 2 but they pathced it so now you are condemned to play all the levels.
Word up sonic!
Welp
COME ON SONIC YOU CAN DO IT!!
@vegeta11 This comment got a lot cuter when I imagined it coming from Vegeta talking about his little sister that he doesn't tell anyone about because he doesn't want anyone to know he's a big softy.
Pass
Edit: for now. I'll wait till it's down to at least €10 in a few months
Are you guys really surprised after Lost World and Sonic Boom?
This is definitely the poor man's Splatoon.
@KirbyTheVampire I f**king love this joke!!!!
Honesty and fairness are great and everything, but is anyone else actually quite keen to read the @get2sammyb review?
You need to update your aticle or are you just showing the bad review scores to emphsise your dislike of the game?
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...