It still seems crazy to think that the studio responsible for the Killzone series, a PlayStation mainstay for well over a decade, would make such a creative leap. From a dingy first-person shooter series of fluctuating quality to a vast, vibrant open world RPG, rarely do we see studios of Guerrilla’s size and reputation stray so far from their comfort zone. We’re very glad it did take a creative gamble, however, as Horizon: Zero Dawn is comfortably its best game, and can stand proud among this year’s most beloved titles.
Perhaps the biggest hurdle for Guerrilla to overcome was the story. The Killzone series has never been lauded for its narrative, but Aloy’s odyssey to uncover the mysteries of her world and her origins is a truly captivating tale. The history of the wonderful setting is fascinating, with every new development raising more questions until you’re finally treated to a phenomenal backstory that places everything into context. Okay, so it’s an exposition explosion, but it’s also a mind-blowing twist that you’ll be mulling over long after the credits roll.
It’s the world itself and its inhabitants that are the real winners, though. Aloy is a wonderful protagonist whom has already become synonymous with PlayStation, as have her robot dinosaur foes. All the characters in Horizon are well-designed, but these synthetic beasts are something else. From the raptor-like Watcher to the intimidating Thunderjaw, each creature is excellent, all with different behaviours and roles within the world.
Fighting them is even better, thanks to a dynamic combat system making battles one of the game’s best elements. The diversity of your arsenal and freedom in how you approach each encounter mean that you can be highly improvisational, or plot out your attack, scouting the area and laying traps in strategic places. When you also factor in weak spots, removable components, and elemental damage, combat becomes a complex yet intuitive part of Horizon, and is some of the best action to be had on PS4.
It helps that this all takes place in a breathtaking open environment. Surrounded by mountains, the landscape changes dramatically from snowy cliffs and takes you through grassy plains, woodlands, a desert, and even the ruins of a previous civilisation. It all looks marvellous, Guerrilla bringing its A-game on the technical side but also from an artistic point of view. This is a game that manages to always look good, no matter where you are or what you’re up to. It’s no wonder it comes with a fantastic Photo Mode so you can share the magnificent views.
In short, Horizon: Zero Dawn is a huge achievement for Guerrilla Games. It tackled an immensely ambitious game that forced the team to push its technical wizardry and bring its storytelling prowess up to speed, and it did so in great style. It feels like the start of a big new franchise for Sony, and we certainly can’t wait to see where the series goes next.
Was Horizon: Zero Dawn one of 2017's best games? Where would you like to see Guerrilla's franchise go next? Leave an audio log in the comments section below.
Comments 55
This is the Game of the Year for me. I really liked the setting, the story, the visuals and the sense of freedom. The pacing was not good sometimes and I ran to some glitches but no one is perfect. As the game went towards the climax I got it an "epic" feeling that haven't felt from a videogame for quite some time. I really liked how the game moved to the final battle.
Wow - number 3? I had it pegged as at least 2. A shame as I think it's appeal is broad enough to make it a top choice amongst hardcore and more casual gamers.
Still, I loved the game from start to finish. The best story I have played in an open world so far in my mind. GOTY!
I spent most of this year not seeing the hype for the game, I genuinely think the "zomg giant robotic dinosaurs" marketing put me right off it, but for whatever reason I I bought it in the Black Friday sales and ended up loving every single minute of it, was more than happy to be proven wrong!
3rd!!? How unexpected. I would guess NieR and Persona 5 for the next two spots then, but in which order?
AH! Not number one...I'm surprised!
At the same time like I said in the article I do think some aspects of the game are a tad overrated!
Still I loved the game and it's one of the best games this year for sure!
Not just GOTY but game of this gen for me.
Horizon Zero Dawn is just so impressive.
New IP.
Fantastic lead.
Incredible combat.
Best photo mode ever.
Rich vibrant open world.
Robo-freaking Dinosaurs.
Such an impressive first entry. I have no idea where Guerilla Games go from here, but I'm excited to find out.
Definitely my number 1. Not only did it look and play superb, the story was gripping right to the end, I thought. I couldn't wait to find out what exactly Elisabet Sobeck had done.
Not my PS4 GOTY, but I think considering all its positive elements and just in terms of general appeal this should be in the 1 spot.
Also there is no : in Horizon Zero Dawn so ner ner ne ner ner
Christ in heaven they're gonna put Nier over Horizon aren't they?
Nier Automata while still being good is the most overrated game of the gen for me. It's a 7/10 game propelled by an ending sequence and "muh deep story"
@PhenomenalOne Nier is GOTY for me but given it's hardly showed up in the staffs GOTY lists I'm going to assume it's not on this list at all. Hopefully they redeem themselves and I am wrong
@Kidfried I'd bet money it's not
Amazing game. I’m still shocked by how much Guerrilla exceeded my expectations.
@Kidfried We can do themes for different franchises, it’s just I don’t use the feature much.
@Kidfried Why is Uncharted the Lost Legacy half a game and no one cries and everyone says it's the best...but then some game (I don't remember what game was recently but I guess other games serve just as well) announces it will "ONLY" have 10-15 hours of gameplay and gets all the rage? LuL
@AFCC I, for one, wish more games were 10-15 hour solid titles with immense polish that sold for $40 instead of $60. We actually need more of those.
And regarding Horizon... HZD is very deserving of GOTY, but I had it in the same place on my list — #3. (Behind Uncharted LL and Nier)
@AFCC How is it half a game?
There is a start, middle & end.
Plenty of 'shorter' games have gotten recognition this year. Resident Evil 7 is 9-10 hours, Hellblade is 7 hours,...
Also Uncharted TLL launched at a budget price, but that's certainly not indicative of its quality.
You can't take these lists that serious. This site once ranked Rocket League better than Witcher 3 after all. #NeverForget
P.S. RL is a fine game it's just no W3.
@Kidfried I took the colour from her hair! 😅
I still haven't gotten very far in this. I found this game really boring...maybe it's just because Zelda came out about the same time. I should try to get back to it sometime, but I have too much else to play now.
@Fight_Teza_Fight I'm not complaining about Uncharted, I have I like it...it's still DLC so I guess it's ok for being short! But damn I wish I remember what game it was that people got mad for having short length
@Th3solution I'm seeing myself wanting shorter experiences more and more!
@Giygas_95 funny cause Zelda got boring for me at like the second beam or wtv you turn on! Didn't play more ever since
No way, it should be number one.
Anyway, Horizon Zero Dawn is also my game of the generation: a brand new ip, amazing narrative, the gameplay is epic and Aloy.
The Frozen Wilds is a solid expansion too.
@Kidfried I believe they will include Persona 5, for sure. My bet would be Nier too (even if I don't agree), but you are right about the editors list, Nier is not there.
@AFCC €30 versus €60.
@Splat The best games of this year are: Halo Wars 2, Mass Effect Andromeda, Lawbreakers, Agents of Mayhem, PUBG, Battlefront 2, Wildlands, For Honor and Sonic Forces.
@AFCC I ended up putting 350 hours into BOTW. I think I appreciated how open ended it is as well as the quiet, lonely atmosphere of it. In Horizon, it felt like I was in an open world being funneled through a very linear narrative. That's not a bad thing by nature, but it's something that doesn't really click with me. I'd still like to finish it though...someday when I don't have a deluge of games to play.
@Flaming_Kaiser not if you wait for sales (guy pointing at head meme)
@Giygas_95 I get your feelings and I admit that Zelda has more freedom! I guess I like more constricted and well written stories
Number 3? No doubt this will be contentious.
I thought this would for sure be number 1 considering the hard-on this site has for it, glad it isn't though. I think playing it after BOTW may have greatly reduced my enjoyment of it.
@Kidfried when we think about it top lists are always ALWAYS debatable! To me Yakuza 0 was the best game this year...to other it might be a game I hate..
This is without a doubt game of the year for me And second best of this gen behind the witcher 3
@PS_Nation Haha nice one 10/10. I particular loved MEA lololololololol.
Horizon is amazing. If it wasnt for the behemoth Yakuza Zero it would be my goty.
@Splat Tbf both RL and W3 are blockbusters of the gaming kind. Both are awesome!
Good game but a bit overrated. I think it's about #10 or 11 on my list of best PS4 exclusives. Solid B to B+.
I think many people often conflate "impressive" with "fun" when it comes to their subjective experience of games. I appreciate how much work went into the game, but it's not as fun as it is impressive — and I play games for fun.
Excellent game. Loved every minute of it. The DLC got a bit redundant for me but it was still good. Not my GOTY but close.
@doctommaso "not as fun as it is impressive"
I agree 👍
@Kidfried Some of my best memories of the game are stumbling into a new machine and having to figure out how to fight them on the spot.
The combat is pure fun.
@Kidfried Fair enough! It was still fun, just not enough to be GOTY to me.
@Kidfried Well, my point was that I read a lot of comments like "Aloy is a great character", "the open world is amazing", "the dinosaurs are so well designed", "the game looks incredible", etc. That doesn't mean the game is fun, and I think those things do blind some people. But if you had a lot of fun with the game, then great! I had enough to get through it but had no interest in the DLC.
Has Horizon reached the tipping point of popularity where people are reductive about its achievements as a "game" purely because it happens to be strong in other departments, too?
This happens with Naughty Dog games, too. "Yeah, well, the graphics are good and the story's really good and the animation's amazing but... Is it fun?"
The answer is almost always "yes". In my opinion, Horizon's strongest asset is its combat, which is pure gameplay. It's an open world RPG that plays like a pure action game.
I am currently about 35 hours into HZD. But playing it after putting 200+ hours into Zelda, I have found myself being a little disappointed in it. Despite it being a good game. Parts of it feel very limiting and suffers from what most other "open world" games have at fault... Invisible walls blocking exploration. Not to mention for me, not being able to climb anything I want while exploring is disappointing (one of the first things that I noticed when I started playing. Guess I got spoiled in BOTW).
To me, it is basically a more sci-fi version of the Far Cry series with dino-bots, which is not necessarily a bad thing. It does feel a bit over hyped and has a few issues to deal with. But I still welcome the new IP and will keep an eye out on what they do with it.
Horizon absolutely floored me, easily PS4 game of the year to me.
Horizon and Breath of the Wild were such a great combo and together they consumed ~70% of my gaming time this year.
Can't wait to play this. Will be getting the complete edition once I complete my current backlog.
@themcnoisy eurogamer made that list.
@get2sammyb Every battle in Horizon is epic, the gameplay is top notch. It's even cool to go after the collectibles, exploring the entire map, one of the few games that i really wanted to collect everything. I just can't wait for the sequel.
This is a surprise. I figured Horizon would win GOTY here for sure. That said, while it is an awesome game and easily the best new IP this gen, I wouldn't put it at the top of my list either. Yakuza Zero and Uncharted: The Lost Legacy may not provide the huge open world Horizon does but I had more fun with the core gameplay elements in those games. Don't want to down play Horizon though, for a new IP, which has sadly become a rarity, it delivered in spades and introduced one of my new favorite protagonists. Guerrilla's best since the outstanding Killzone 2. The studio may not be held in the same regard as Nintendo or Naughty Dog but when it gets something right it is capable of top of the genre quality.
Persona 5 will be GOTY at pushsquare(even tho it is a bit niche...)
I'm not sure I could single out one game that stands above the others as its been such a good year overall..(I haven't played BOTW and I've pretty much avoided videos and stuff connected with it as I intend to buy a second hand Wii u just to play it but I guess that would definitely be up there for me)
@Kidfried Combat is better in Horizon, but also unavoidable due to the leveling system. Zelda offers complete freedom in almost every aspect of its gameplay, and a genuinely interactive world. Horizon is great but its size and openness completely conflicts with how linear it actually is.
Wow so neir is really good huh? I was under the impression it was just some niche bullet hell devilmaycry-ish action game. Everyone talking about it being GOTY got me thinking i missed something ?!?
Wow #3 huh? Well the obvious top 2 are Persona 5 and Life of Black Tiger
@Gmork___ Nier has one of the best stories I've seen in a video game, and it completely takes advantage of video games as a medium to create one of the most thrilling and engaging experiences of this generation, in my opinion. If you ever get a chance to play it, do NOT stop playing after the first playthrough — there's way, way more to the story after "finishing" it the first time.
My favourite game this year. Story telling, graphics and a stunningly crafted world to wander in. It's one of the few games that made me sweat with excitement as I ran in fear, screamed like a child as I took down a massive bot and felt sad as twists and turns in plot line. Probably my fave game on PS4.
@PS_Nation Nice to see a shout out for Agents of Mayhem. Loved it 👌
The combat system alone is worth GOTY, imo. On NG+ UH, it's as intense as Bloodborne but more fun. Planning out the different strategies for the different machines makes this game exceptional in the combat area.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...