Every time we write about Persona 5 we worry that we're going to run out of superlatives. Frankly, the game's an absolute masterpiece. Not only is it one of the best titles on PlayStation 4 – and PlayStation 3, if you want to get technical about it – it's also one of the greatest Japanese role-playing games of modern times. It's almost a perfection of the series' formula, which combines regular, every day life with shadow-slaying dungeon crawls. Persona 5 is our Game of the Year for 2017.
An interesting detail: Persona 5 swept our internal Game of the Year staff vote like nothing we've ever seen. It got so many first place votes that it was out of sight before any other nominee barely left the starting line. Does that mean Push Square is now officially a haven for weebs? Possibly, but let's not try and deny that Persona 5 is an impactful experience.
Once the 80-or-so-hour journey is over, you can't help but reflect upon the memories that you've made with the game's ragtag gang of outcast teenagers. If you've got no mates in real life, chances are you'll walk away from Persona 5 feeling like you've genuinely made a connection with some of its well developed cast. The title promotes a poignant sense of belonging that very few other games manage to replicate.
And on top of all the social gatherings and awkward dates, there's a deep dungeon-crawling RPG. Somehow, Persona 5 balances its wildly varying tones incredibly well – a feat that's overlooked all too often. But without its ability to flit from having fun to being deadly serious in the blink of an eye, the game wouldn't feel so grounded. There's a realism to Persona 5 that shines through even when you're battling demonic entities inside a mind castle. It's an experience that, on paper, shouldn't work anywhere near as well as it does. It's a real storytelling achievement.
Boasting one of the slickest turn-based combat systems ever crafted, battles come close to looking like an action title at times. The tactical depth offered by the persona system adds an addictive Pokémon-esque flavour to proceedings as you welcome otherworldly beings into your soul, and the boss battles are electric.
It's difficult to fault Persona 5 – one of the reasons we awarded it a 10/10 – but there is one overarching element that's crucial to tying everything it does together. We are, of course, talking about its art direction, which is mind-blowing. From the in-game menus to the flashy combat effects, Persona 5 is utterly stunning. Graphically, it's clearly a cross-gen title, but its sheer style solidifies it as one of the most unique and memorable looking games out there. Oh, and then there's the insanely catchy soundtrack, which is easily one of the best of 2017.
In a year that's been amazing for top quality games, it's Persona 5 that has stolen our hearts.
Please note that some external links on this page are affiliate links, which means if you click them and make a purchase we may receive a small percentage of the sale. Please read our FTC Disclosure for more information.
And there you have it: Persona 5 is our Game of the Year for 2017. What did you make of the Phantom Thieves' adventure? Remove your mask in the comments section below.
Comments 42
Maybe push should do a PSN top 10 indie games
I will probably get this after I am done with Horizon Zero Dawn and Zelda Botw. Looks very good!
It looks good and I would be interested in trying it. However the length puts me off, it would take up so much time to beat and would mean I wouldn't be able to play anything else for weeks at the least.
Parp
Sammy's currently working on a time machine so he can travel back into the past and try to stop this from happening.
@ShogunRok Did he really not enjoy it, then? I noticed he recently finished it.
LOL, the trailer makes it look like a little kids game? I've never played it, but...really?
@Jake3103 He came incredibly close to quitting it at least once or twice but stuck around to see it through. From what I understand he thought bits of it were great but overall there was too much padding.
Can't win 'em all!
This game ate so much of my time this year. It was my goty for sure.
YES! I love Horizon and Zelda! But P5 is the game of the year!
Very bold to put at number 1! Good job guys!
Played this with my wife, she enjoyed it but wasn't too keen on part of the ending, obviously I don't want to spoil it but she though it was really over the top and somewhat unnecessary. I think she has a point. Overall it is a great game though.
I wasn't going to post but seeing as others have derailed for me. The problem with Persona 5, in my opinion, is that for a game where you spend at least 50 hours reading, the script is incredibly dry. I'm not sure whether this is the fault of the localisation or the original Japanese story, but there's very, very little character to any of the dialogue.
I laughed maybe a dozen times and enjoyed a handful of scenes, but if you compare to Yakuza 0, there's more drama, goofiness/humour, and personality in its opening 90 minutes than the entirety of Persona 5. Not directly comparable games, of course, but it really sticks out when you play them back-to-back.
But there we go. It's our Game of the Year, and it won fair and square. Just my two cents!
@get2sammyb seeing the mini-review in this article, all the comments, and the overwhelming support for the game from your co-workers, I doubt you're gonna get much agreement or sympathy on that point.
Being Italian I should play Persona 5 and Yakuza, both Japan-centric, in English, still a foreign language for me. I doubt I could enjoy them as intented...
Persona 5 was easily the best game I played this year, and it was a great year. It's just an absolute delight. Roll on Persona 5 Golden so I platinum it all over again.
@get2sammyb I saw your comments on twitter about the game. At first I really loved the game, but it went on too long. FWIW, after about 115 hours, the story does pick up. :/
Can’t believe this won with you guys! After playing Horizon, I really didn’t expect anything to top it until I played Persona 5. Amazing music, amazing style, one of the best turn based battle systems I’ve ever played. I felt like the story line was something totally different and unique from anything I’ve ever played (granted, it was my first persona game). I wasn’t sure what I was getting into when I loaded it up, but it truly was my GOTY.
It was a great game but I preferred the cast of characters from P4. I loved Makoto, though. Also, I've got to agree with @get2sammyb about Yakuza 0 having much sharper writing than P5.
Deserved
Where did Nioh finish out of Interest? Top 15 ? 20?
@ShogunRok He had a vision that the site was going to get renamed Push Sqweeb, didn't he?
This is why i love PushSquare! Honest opinions and not much hint of corporate sponsorship. Please don't change, PS!!
Side note, unless of course Atlus and P Studio already bought Shogun Rock and Sammy is the foil we all need.
Oh dear.
Well deserved. But I still rank P4G above P5 personally. But I thoroughly enjoyed it, although I wished if it was a bit shorter. Persona 5 is my favourite PS4 game, hands down.
Congratulations Persona 5, it's my second favorite game this year, but it really deserves to be goty as well.
First time that I played a Persona game and it was an unforgettable experience, I was feeling empty when I finished the huge journey.
Persona 5 is the best home console JRPG I've played since the PS2 era. It's complex, funny, full of character and narrative... and that's not to mention all of the mechanical improvements to the experience, reintroducing demon negotiation, the fun, structured dungeons, the dazzling, stylish U.I., etc.
It's a wonderful game. Not quite my GOTY, but definitely my favorite game on the PS4 overall.
Also, while the game isn't absolutely filled with goofiness, there's still a ton of wonderful character humor, and the dialogue really gives you a sense of everyone's personality. I don't understand how anyone could think this script is dry. Bloated? Absolutely. These people love to talk. But I always felt these characters had so much personality and charm to them.
If I hadn't of played Horizon this would of been my Number One too.Such a fantastic game.
I spent 117 hours on my first play through and unlike some of the guys on here I never felt it was padded or drawn out.I never wanted it to end!
I love RPGs and all but unfortunately I kinda went and ruined the Persona series for myself by playing 3 and 4 back to back, I was so tired of that style of gameplay by the end of it that I don't think I could ever play one of these games again.
@get2sammyb Yakuza 0>Persona 5 easy...in that we agree
I've got a lot of love for Crisis Core & Persona 3, but Persona 5 is the best JRPG I've ever played.
Also PushSquare top 3:
Persona 5
Uncharted TLL
Horizon Zero Dawn
This is why exclusives matter.
Not my type of game. Congratulations though.
I'm honestly surprised. I thought Horizon would get the nod hands down. It's my favorite game this year, but I thought it wouldn't win. Points for doing something different, I suppose.
While I have my critiques as I do with any game (Unsubtle story, two painful dungeon crawls, everything about Morgana outside of combat), it was worth that long wait. I had to refrain from replaying it for a month before caving in. I already said this on Ramsey's list, but it was everything I like in an RPG. Slick combat, honest dungeons, persona fusion was fun, challenging but still accessible, a good cast, and while I critique it's subtlety, the plot was still good enough to enjoy.
My personal game of the year. And apparently Push Square's too.
Think i might have to get persona 5 then it will be my first persona
So happy to see this as it's my personal GotY. Such a phenomenal game and one of the best experiences I've ever had from the medium.
To each their own I guess.
I can appreciate all the positives with this game but I fell off it twice, I am at around the 90 hour mark now and just cannot seem to force myself to finish it.
For all the things it does right, I just feel like it is so bloated and drawn out.
My game of the year, mementos got pretty oppressive at the end but hey it convinced me to try to be more than I am. Want another crack at it soon actually.
I'm a bit conflicted with P5. While I agree it's fantastic, I'm not sure I agree that it's GOTY material. That's not a mark against it though, this year has been full of excellent releases! Part of my problem with it is that the game goes on rails far too often, with many events simply making the player a by-stander as you wade through text boxes. I thought P4 was bad about this but P5 is much worse, with Morgana constantly telling you to go to bed and many scenes simply dropping you off at home. I felt P3 was much better paced in this regard. Factor in cheap difficulty (this game really loves aoe criticals and instadeath spells) and the fact dungeon design gets progressively worse as you go, and it becomes a tiring game. Like others, I was ready for this game to end around the 70-80 hour mark but it just...keeps...going. The last 3 dungeons are total wastes of time. Oh and the final boss and ending are predictable as well. Definitely didn't feel as moving as Persona 3's ending. Not even sure it even compares to 4's ending. I found many characters downright unlikeable as well among the playable cast, but the supporting cast (Sae aside) I liked quite a bit. Most of the playable cast are the same archetypes from the last 2 games and I definitely agree the translation felt a bit dry. I only liked Futaba and Fox out of the main cast, and certain aspects of the main plot came off as a bit silly. (Basically, they always meet in crowded places and Ryuji always screams about being a Phantom Thief.)
I do however adore the fact this game mixes SMT with Persona, the music is top notch, and the UI is as stylish as I would expect from a Persona game. It's definitely a great game, but I can't help but think "Eh, it's another Persona game." Can't really say it's any better than 3 or 4. This one was probably the boldest entry so far though and I liked some of the social issues that were tackled.
Honestly can't fault Sammy for not liking it. It's not going to be for everyone, and I've had hardcore SMT/Persona fans come right out and admit the game goes on way too much, has too much padding, etc.
EDIT: Oh and I share the sentiment about Yakuza 0. That game's wit was off the charts, and I'm dying to see what they do with Fist of the North Star!
Watched this and didn’t fancy it at all. Also didn’t realise it was part of the Shin Megami Tensei franchise.
Reviews seem to look so will definitely pick up the Switch port that will inevitably be released not long after Shin Megami Tensei V. Not a slight on my PS4, will just get played more on my Switch and 80 hours is a lot o’ hours!!!
@get2sammyb I appreciate your honesty about P5. It's easily my GOTY and in my top 5 of all time, and I loved everything about it, but I can't bring myself to agree with your opinion of it.
On a different note, I've never been interested in the Yakuza series before, and seeing your comment about its writing makes it seem like a game I would absolutely love. So, thanks in advance for that! I'll pick it up ASAP.
My GOTY as well. Absolutely worth the 9 years wait.
Meh. Not my type of game, but I do appreciate the style. Maybe this game attracts a younger gamer, dunno. I just couldn't get into it.
@XurAgentofthe9 even weirder, it's M rated. Whatever the case, P5 is the only 2017 game which left me satisfied after finishing it.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...