Microsoft’s seemingly becoming more platform agnostic, with its software and services now exploring devices outside of the Xbox ecosystem. The thought of Halo coming to the PlayStation 4 is not as wild as it once was, then – although it does, at first blush, still seem pretty crazy. Speaking on a recent episode of the Sacred Symbols podcast, however, ex-IGN editor Colin Moriarty reckons that a port of the Master Chief Collection was, at one point, being considered for Sony’s system.
“I have it on good authority that Master Chief Collection was being talked about on PS4 years ago,” he said in a recent episode, which you can listen to through here. “Like, I have that on great authority.”
Halo’s franchise director Frank O’Connor has since weighed in on the rumour, stating that he’s “not aware of the details of conversations between the platforms at a corporate level but the distance between ‘plans’ and some ‘what if for instance’ conversations is a meaningful gulf”. He added: “We’ve had plenty of those over the years, but not one line of code was even glanced at.”
So it seems that if there’s any truth to the rumour, it never got much further than the consideration stage. Whether those discussions will go further in the future remains to be seen: Microsoft does seem determined to get its software and services in as many hands as possible, and that could result in unexpected partnerships. For now, though, we’re going to assume that any chance of Master Chief appearing on PlayStation is low – of course, there’s always Dreams.
Please note that some external links on this page are affiliate links, which means if you click them and make a purchase we may receive a small percentage of the sale. Please read our FTC Disclosure for more information.
[source podbay.fm, via twitter.com]
Comments 62
Sony needs to inject life into new IP genres for PS5. Resistance needs a reboot (doubtful i know. A new FPS would be fine) and a RPG franchise needs to happen. Like Sonys own Mass Effect or something. Their are already plenty of eastern rpgs exclusive to the platform that we dont need a Dragon Quest or Ni No Kuni style game. There is, imo, a gaping hole leftnin gaming with no sci fi operas to play
@Nyne11Tyme Er, Horizon: Zero Dawn?
At least the MCC is coming to PC. I never got around to installing it on my Xbox One, even though it came with the system.
To hell with Halo. I want Gears of War on my Playstation. That is the only Microsoft’s IP i care about.
@get2sammyb i mean kinda. Id call it more action/adventure with some rpg elements. I mean i wouldnt refer to Assassins Creed as a RPG...maybe im in the minority on that? I used AC as a comparison because of their similar structure. I do realise a lot of genres are blended together these days. I mean a true RPG with Western influences. Maybe Fable or KotOR would have been a better analogy than Mass Effect
@majklpetr used to be mine too. Judgement and 4 were kinda let downs for me
I'd love Alan Wake on PS4. I really liked that game.
I’d love to play through the Halo games on my PS4. I can easily believe they had this conversation, not that I expect it went much further than coming up in a few meetings.
@Nyne11Tyme no resistance don't need a reboot playa.give me resistance 4.word up son
I'm going to give it a shot when it comes to Game Pass PC. I played a bit of the first but that's it.
Game Pass is pretty good by the way. I have never owned an X-Box but now that it's on PC I have to admit it's a heck of a lot of bang for your buck.
I'm convinced Colin was right and it was talked about like the great authority said....
It s well worth a lot of articles all over the internet...
So all that was based on something some IGN ex-editor said? Seriously guys, there's rumors and then there's......nothing. It's like some ppl i've seen over Nintendo sites asking for MCC on Switch because MS ported Cuphead.
Halo is MS's killer up since the Xbox's conception. Handing it over to the competition doesn't seem like a smart move from a bussiness standpoint.
Now if Xbox Game Pass was to come to Sony's consoles that would be a different story. But we all know that this ain't happening anytime soon.
This was Wild talk from the get go. If MS was going to do that they would just do a Sega and stop making hardware. Giving Halo to their main competitors is conceding defeat.
@Nyne11Tyme Guerrilla Games Could Turn the Killzone Franchise into Something like Mass Effect If they take what they've Learned From Horizon Zero dawn and apply it to killzone
@Syndrome to be honest the MC collection coming to PS4 could be a smart business decision. It doesn’t necessarily mean all future instalments would make it to PS4, too. But what it does mean is people like me get to try Halo out properly for the first time and if we enjoy it we may be inclined to get Xboxes for future instalments...
@Areus now thats a concept i could get behind
@Nyne11Tyme Have you ever Read the backstory of the killzone Universe cause it will show you That they have alot to work with lore wise https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=2ahUKEwjMvdme7OviAhUKd6wKHXz-CT0QFjAAegQICBAC&url=https%3A%2F%2Fkillzone.fandom.com%2Fwiki%2FTimeline&usg=AOvVaw3XTWa7pdKKfTbEfbcAwRy-
Bring over Gears and I'll be very happy.
@Areus nice. I will check that out. Ive enjoyed the franchise a lot. I think Shadow Fall was better than it got credit for. The MP was a blast too
@Nyne11Tyme this generation PlayStation has a decent number of new IP.
The Order 1886, Driveclub, Knack, Horizon Zero Dawn & Days Gone all out. Bloodborne was a new IP in an existing brand of games FromSoftware. Then there's Death Stranding & Ghost Of Tsushima to come that are new as well. That's 8 off the top of my head that are new IP right there.
Add to that Spiderman, God Of War (which felt like a totally new series for me), the Uncharted's, Killzone Shadow Fall, the Infamous', Persona 5 & Street Fighter V (both still console exclusive), Medievils return, Ratchet & Clank's reboot and The Last Of Us Part 2 I don't think Sony have had to bad a run at it.
Personally I'd like to see Syphon Filter come back with MGS seemingly dead now HK has departed Konami and Splinter Cell not looking likely right now there is a market for it imo.
Give me Forza and reboot the Fable series on PS4 and I'd be happy.
Microsoft now really don't care about the console wars they stopped caring when they released X1X mid way through. And with the push for game pass on pc and cloud based computing more and more talked about. I feel MS will continue to release consoles to the market because there is a fan abse there, but they also now realise that the pc gaming community is a big thing (considering it has been for 30 years). They tried it once with Games of Windows Live but failed because Steam dominated the online digital gaming market
Well, some of their IP's have come to Switch, with some more on the way, and many of Microsoft's IP's have disappeared from existence (Viva Piñata, Blinx, Voodoo Vince, Project Gotham, Amped, NFL Fever and more)...with the fact of how the XBOX one is being treated now, and if Microsoft has another console that does the same thing in terms of sales, I'm thinking they would start pulling a Sega after. Other than that, don't forget that Minecraft is on every console
@Syndrome Colin is a Moron. Always has been. I just find this rumour incredibly hard to believe. Cuphead on PS4? Sure, maybe. Halo? No way.
For anyone wanting Halo, just grab MCC on PC. That'll be an amazing, definitive experience. Plus gamepass is a good deal. Way better then PS+.
They should ask Phil Spencer that if the opportunity came up would consider bringing Game Pass onto Playstation, albeit with Xbox only games from X1 and 360 via streaming. I think it would be win win for both, Sony get a service that doesn't step on PS Now's toes and MS get another revenue stream. And Xbox can still offer native experiences through their consoles.
If sales trends continue into the next gen I wouldn't be surprised to see such games appear on Playstation within a couple of years of their launch. The console's are going to be very similar, so little work would need to be done and it's easy money
@thefirst That is happening with me right now with the first Gears of War. I never played any of them but thanks to Game Pass on PC I'm finally giving it a shot.
I don't hate it or anything but nothing special about it really. I haven't finished it but plays like a 7 out of 10 right now.
Colin is usually spot on.
@Syndrome never heard of Colin Moriarty? He's only of the only legit games journalists left. The rest are activists.
@EVIL-C because he isn't a far left activist like the rest? Let me guess, did you find his twitter joke he left KF for offensive?
@oldschool1987 So far right is fine... Okay....🙄🤮 And IIRC the incident you're referring to, the "ah, peace and quiet for a day" or whatever, not at all. That was just some innocent humour.
Nice try, though.
@Frigate lmao fair enough
@oldschool1987 who said Colin is far right? You're the jerk calling me deranged and a communist. You brought politics into this, not me. Take a long, hard look at yourself first. Secondly, be careful who you're tossing labels and names around to in future.
@EVIL-C you're right, I misunderstood your comment, I thought you were saying he was far right. But you did make a stupid comment still, you think just because I criticised the far left, that means I think the far right is fine? How does that work? How did you come to that conclusion? Please, tell me. The extremes of anything are always stupid. Far left and far right is stupid. The reason I brought up far left is because the vast majority of games "journalists" are far left activists. Criticising that doesn't mean I support the other extreme... In future think before you make stupid generalisations.
@Frigate As per community rules
Do not use profanity; Use of unsavoury language including profanity and swearing is not acceptable, please remember that this website has users of all ages.
Also I suggest you reread the community rules. I have had to edit several of your.posts for derailing threads and such. I don't want to do it again. So please be mindful of the rules.
Thanks for understanding
@oldschool1987 I was making the same assumption as you. I agree the far extremes of anything are not good. What they are can be open for interpretation, but in principle I dislike extremism.
For my comment about Colin; as a journalist, I never liked his work. Going way back to his early days at IGN. Simply because I rarely could agree with most of his opinions and analysis of many games I thought were enjoyable. That's all. However, he never should have been fired for such an obvious tongue in cheek twitter remark.
Gimme a reboot for alpha protocol please
@EVIL-C honestly my dude, my bad, I wrongly assumed you didn't like him for his political views, which is the only reason I've heard people criticise him for. But it's fair you just didn't like his journalism, that's fair. I'm happy to admit I was wrong, and a git. Sorry, man.
Not only do I totally believe this, I still think it will actually happen.
I mean, it wouldn't actually be that crazy. I grew up in the NES and SNES days and back then you would have sounded insane if you suggested that in about 10 to 15 years Sonic would be on Nintendo consoles, let alone that he'd be in Nintendo exclusives like SSB.
@Neolit I'm sure he sold he shares to the remaining three members, I think I remember him saying so in one of his final KF appearances.
I like Colin, he has a lot of opinions I don't agree with but I genuinely believe he tries to be fair and honest. It was a shame seeing his "friends" at KF throw him under the bus and apologise on his behalf for one of the most harmless jokes I've ever seen. I have no idea why they would bend the knee the the faux outrage twitter mob.
You ever listened to his new PlayStation podcast, Sacred Symbols?
@EVIL-C
I agree about Colin (not for calling him names though)
When he left KF about the fuss over a joke is when I got the most respect for him.
Now apparently he s a new source for saying PS5 is more powerful (new articles incoming haha) whereas I m inclined to think he probably is just expanding on Reiner s. Internet news are very misleading. I remember when he said DC is back to the drawing board when actually that was a past event.
@AdamNovice Game Pass would step on PS Now's toes for me personally. Now is allowing you to download games now (albeit PS4 only right now) and if they can get it working for PS3 games on PS5 it's essentially the same thing but with streaming as well. Sony should do more work to use there back catalogue of games they should really have PS1 & PS2 games on Now for me (and not just the ones that have been ported to PS4 already) maybe even adding PSP & Vita to it as well.
@oldschool1987
I've just listened to Sacred Symbols about the xbox E3 conference
Haha
Colin is saying that Ms announced 8k at 120fps
Wth?,
🙃
@RedMan33 I agree that Sony need to do more with it's back catalogue but what I was suggestion that Game Pass on PS4 would just offer Xbox exclusives so it's giving people new games but at the same time it's not repeating those that are on PS NOW.
@AdamNovice if it was only Xbox games it would make sense for Microsoft, I imagine it's more likely on Switch at the moment
@RedMan33 Most probably, I just feel that if MS just see Xbox as a brand now to sell through services then it's almost pointless to ignore the PlayStation install base now.
@oldschool1987
It's fine, don't worry about it. I'm sorry as well.
@Neolit @JJ2 True, although as I'm sure we've all referred to other people in conversation with unflattering names, I'm not name-calling anyone I'm talking with here from the site.
When one is a public figure, trash talk just comes with the job. Hell, I'm a part time YouTuber who stutters. Long story, but I used to get crapped on all the time for that when I first attempted it.
And that's right, Colin left voluntarily. KF was more worried about their own image than colleague. That doesn't make them look very good.
Maybe a takeaway from this is, no matter your beliefs or whatnot, be quiet on social media? Maybe just don't even use it? 🤔
@EVIL-C
Twitter is very useful to follow gaming news from all sites. Even sources I don't like (for instance Kotaku to know what rubbish they go on about Haha.
I don't follow Colin though and I never tweet.
I still think he maybe cool as a person but that's it.
@JJ2 Kotaku is awful.
@RedMan33 oh not saying they have. Love my ps4 and VR. Waaay better than what Xbox has put out this gen imo. Id just like to see them recommit to a FPS IP and go full Fable on something lol. I enjoyed just about every title you listed
@JJ2 didn't they? I didn't watch the Xbox conference, so I'm not sure
@oldschool1987
No. It s 8k 'capability' in the same way Sony put it.
Up to 120fps not related to 8k
@JJ2 I honestly can't remember how he worded it tbh, I'm not sure if he said it'll be both at the same time, or capable of one or the other. Did he get it wrong? Probably wasn't intentional
@oldschool1987
40.15
https://youtu.be/O8ddCGsid18
I don't care much about Halo. But if you told me Gears of War was coming to PS4 I would be very happy.
@JJ2 yeah, you're right. I don't think he was misleading, just seems like a mistake. He will correct himself if told, he often does.
@oldschool1987 I listen to Sacred Symbols (although I’m a couple weeks behind atm) and yes, you’re right — he corrects himself in subsequent weeks, and he eats crow and is apologetic when he reports something wrong. He is often right about a lot of things, though (obviously not about the 120 fps, 8K issue) and has multiple sources in the industry. He also frequently admits that although he knows video games and the industry, he is not good at the technological aspects like hardware specs, programming, etc. He’s very clear about that and unapologetic about the fact his business, like video gaming, is primarily concerned with entertainment.
I’m actually impressed with how well he keeps politics out of Sacred Symbols, only delving into it when it makes sense in the setting of a story. I also never sense overt malice when on a rare occasion he references his days at IGN or KF, or mentions he doesn’t have a review copy of something from Ubisoft because they have blacklisted him. He will buy a copy himself and often still give them a very favorable review (Far Cry 5 and The Division come to mind). Seems to take the high road even when some of the industry continues to act like so silly and childish toward him.
Also he references Push Square almost weekly as a source. I’m sure he’s read this article. Hi Colin 👋🏼.
@Th3solution worded better than I ever could.
@Nyne11Tyme I totally agree. Well at least not an 3rd person action adventure game. We have a few of those already: uncharted, horizon, God of war, the order, days gone etc. I would like to see some variety in their new ips.
If Halo ever headed to a Sony plataform, MS would kill any change they could have that I'd buy an Xbox ever again. And that would make me a happy camper
@Splat
Agreed. The BuzzFeed/TMZ of gaming, and that's probably being too kind.
@JJ2
I still have some social media. It's not like I don't have any whatsoever (I even opened a page for my YouTube work) but I don't tweet nor generally post anything personal much at all. Call me a dinosaur, but I visit individual websites for most info, as my shelves of physical discs tower over me. 😋
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...