The Sonic the Hedgehog movie finally hits theatres across the globe tomorrow, but it doesn't sound like the best way to spend an hour and 40 minutes of your time on Valentine's Day. The reviews are starting to flood in across the internet, and you might be better off watching paint dry alongside a date rather than spending your hard-earned cash on the video game adaptation. Some critics have taken a shine to it, but with a Metacritic rating of 45, it's certainly not the best film in the world. Here's a sampling of verdicts to whet your appetite.
IGN - 7/10
While this family-friendly action-comedy suffers from a simplistic story and leans too heavily on tired visual cliches, Sonic the Hedgehog is nevertheless boosted by solid performances from Ben Schwartz as Sonic and Jim Carrey as Dr. Robotnik. Their ongoing cat-and-mouse game is entertaining, and passionate fans of the Sega franchise should appreciate all the nods to Sonic’s history. Make no mistake, this frantically-paced film is made first and foremost for Sonic fans. If you’ve been there for the little blue fella these past 29 years, from his humble beginnings on the Sega Genesis to his current iteration, then Sonic the Hedgehog is the love letter you’re probably looking for. If not… maybe save your gold rings.
Total Film - 6/10
Ending with a pair of mid-credits scenes that don’t so much tease a sequel as outright confirm intentions to make one, it’s a film that should have die-hard fans doing loop-the-loops. Whether Sonic has the box-office mileage to make it that far remains to be seen, but on the basis of this better-than-expected first instalment, further fast times wouldn’t necessarily be a bad thing.
Screen Rant - 6/10
Altogether, Sonic the Hedgehog is a fairly middling family-friendly adventure movie, but a comparably good video game adaptation the belies a great deal of potential for a stronger, even more ambitious sequel. Hopefully Sonic the Hedgehog will get the chance to explore its world and take more risks in a followup.
Empire - 4/10
An on-form Jim Carrey can’t stop Sonic’s live-action debut from feeling like a missed opportunity. If the teased sequels do materialise, here’s hoping the storytelling levels up.
The New York Times - 3/10
Indeed, other than product placement, the movie’s primary goal seems to be delivering 1990s nostalgia. To that end, Jim Carrey gives his most spry, “Ace Ventura”-like performance in years as the know-it-all villain, Dr. Robotnik. Only his physical and verbal contortions (“I was spitting out formulas while you were spitting up formula”) make the film feel remotely animated.
The Irish Times - 2/10
The filmmakers seem to be harbouring a naïve belief that punters will pay money to watch a comedy about a friendly cop bonding with a wise-cracking forest creature while driving through uninteresting scenery. For most of its duration, Sonic could be working from the script to that Woody Woodpecker movie you prey will never happen.
The Verge - Unscored
Sonic the Hedgehog could have gone from a good to a great movie not by bringing Sonic into the human world, but by bringing audiences into his. Maybe we should just be thankful that the movie was watchable at all. Sonic’s success hinges on the character being likable, and the redesigned Sonic is easy to love.
Are you still going to give Sonic the Hedgehog a chance? Do you plan on seeing it tomorrow or over its opening weekend? Dash into the comments below.
Comments 51
Well duh. What did you think was going to happen?
Seems okay, and okay is.. okay.
The trailer looks good, maybe if my friends want to see it too, if not there's always netflix.
Edit: critic don't like it but reviews on youtube seems positive, most says it's a fun film, sonic is great and jim carrey is perfect cast for robotnik.
i don't take any notice of critics anyway, i'll watch it for myself and make my own mind up, like everyone should
Realistically this movie was never going to review well. But I'm sure it'll be fun.
Why did the new york times review this? Isnt that like a posh newspaper? Course they wouldnt like it. Its got a decent rotten tomatoes score overall and il still see it. All the work they put in revamping the cg earmed my ticket
I would be more interested if it was just set in Sonic's world. The green hill bit in the trailer looked great.
I'm sure it would be a fun watch. Video game movies usually don't review well with critics.
I’ll probably still end up watching it when it comes out on video or so. Not surprised by the reviews.
@JoeBlogs and yes they can but they shouldn't be the only thing you use to judge something like a film because at the end of the day a critics review is just their point of view, just because they didn't like something that doesn't mean you wont like it as well
that's where things like rentals, streaming and DVD comes in, because they allow you to check it out in your own time but i don't think any piece of film should be dismissed simply because a critic said they didn't like it, if i did that i would have missed out on some of my favorite ever films
@JoeBlogs oh that's true too some can be very interesting and some even entertaining
Idk it’s sitting at 70 percent on RT right now so it’s not like it’s some disaster really that’s rather good. Most reviews are saying that it’s either good or at least watchable with the chance that sequels will take it to the next level
I am not particularly interested, but my kids really want to see it. So......see you all at the movies this weekend! 👍
What a BS article. The movie currently sits at 70% Fresh on RT.
Cherry picking certain reviews to make the movie look worse than it is.
@jFug And the grand rating of 45 on Metacritic. What do you have to say for that?
https://www.metacritic.com/movie/sonic-the-hedgehog/critic-reviews
These scores and reviews are actually much better than I was expecting.
Jim Carrey turned me off of this instantly, I don't like him and think he was a horrible choice for Dr. Robotnik, and then the early ugly graphics. I don't think I'd even watch this streaming, it just looks that bad, I don't even see the point of it.
I'm not opposed to video game movies or CGI characters, "Detective Pikachu" was so good I've watched it twice, once w/ the director commentary, and I'd watch it again before this. I just don't get this.
Though I also really enjoyed Venom this week after saying I'd never watch it b/c of the awful trailers so who knows, maybe someday.
@LiamCroft Considering the RT score is based on twice the amount of reviews that the Metacritic score is, I'd say RT provides a better picture of what the general consensus is thus far.
Not to mention, movies topically score much lower on Metacritic than on RT.
Wonder Woman: 93 on RT, 76 on Metacritic
Shazam: 90 on RT, 71 on Metacritic
1917: 89 on RT, 78 on Metacritic
Rocketman: 89 on RT, 69 on Metacritic
Jojo Rabbit: 80 on RT, 58 on Metacritic
etc, etc...
It's a video game movie. It was never going to review well.
And, frankly, the previews don't give me a ton of hope for it. But it looks like it might be dumb fun, and at least the blue blur looks better now.
I watched a movie last night called "the man who killed hitler and then the bigfoot", and it was pretty good. If a movie with that title can be decent ill give anything a try!
Well you know...reviews....🙃
Still I hope it's not too bad since I'll have to watch it with my daughter.
@LiamCroft Metacritic is an awful way to judge films hence why everyone uses RT for films and not MC, most reviewers use a 1-5 rating for films what doesn't translate well to MC. Joker for instance got 59% on MC what is clearly not right especially when the film was up for 11 Oscars and has won more awards then any other comic book film. RT ain't perfect far from it but its currently the best way to judge a film and unlike Metacritc RT actually includes most reviews.
I gotta say I think the trailers look terrible.Love Sonic and glad they changed his look after all that commotion.But why they always have to insist on having real live actors in these kind of films is beyond me.Id much rather a Sonic movie in his own world with Tails and Knuckles.Computer animated without any silly humans tainting the franchise.
Rotten Tomatoes aggregates it at 70% currently, which is interesting.
Seems like a passable family movie which, to be honest, is clearly where they are pitching it. I was expecting a disaster and it looks like a competent film with likable characters.
I might take my daughter but for me, I probably wont make time to see at cinema.
@jFug That Jojo Rabbit difference is crazy. 58 is absurdly low for that film.
Critics are just p*ssed that they "bowed to the fans" and made Sonic look like Sonic, rather than the blue stuff of nightmares he was originally. They were bound to slate it from the second it was delayed for the redesign - they've whined about it since it happened.
I have never really been a fan of Sonic, and have played exactly one game, on the Game Gear. But I could see why the fans weren't happy with the original design. And I have to say that from the clips I've seen, even I as a non-fan want to see the movie... it looks like a bit of fun. Okay, I won't see it at the cinema, I'll wait for it to hit Netflix - but I will watch it.
I'll rent it when it shows up at the local Blockbuster.
Looks like the curse of movies based off of games lives on.
Mmm... Empire is usually a good baro
Wow, they're really going big on the 1990s nostalgia for this one. Not only is it about Sonic the Hedgehog - it sounds like Jim Carrey is actually funny.
Wildly different review scores there...
I don’t know why Hollywood keeps insisting that video games make for good films.
Street Fighter with Raul Julia and Van Damme remains an entertaining pile of mess, and the first Mortal Kombat is similar.
But the vast majority are just dull garbage.
@FullbringIchigo I agree with you. I don’t read about games, films, music etc until after I’ve seen them.
Most adults have a fair idea about what they are gonna like or dislike before going in.
@Salmonella Hahahahahaha
i went to see it and it was fun 90 minute romp. But i saw it in german lol. was funny seeing jim carey speaking german. but a fun popcorn flick. or pizza and beer at home.
I'll wait for this to come to Sky and I will watch it, I went to see Bad Boys 3 the other night and I was expecting a lot of explosions like 2 but it didn't have many and I enjoyed it a lot.
Disappointing but I'll probably still see it in theaters, need to start using my Regal Unlimited membership more.
@FullbringIchigo So everyone should watch every film?
@Folderoll NO but perhaps read some of the other posts in the comments section before commenting, i'm not explaining everything again
I’m still taking my kids to see it this weekend, my youngest is Sonic obsessed atm, so even if we don’t rate it at least my youngest will enjoy it regardless. I thought it looked alright from the trailer.
Funny, cause the audience seems to have loved the movie. Oh well.
I guess you can call this the Detective Pikachu of 2020. Not amazing or anything but for a kids movie based on a kids game, it's okay.
@LiamCroft that nobody ever references metacritic for movies lol besides when they want to make a point. You never see oh this movie has a so and so on metacritic it’s always RT
@3MonthBeef what does that have to do with anything. The R rating hurt it according to publications but it doesn’t really matter since the movie only cost 85 million so it’s going to make a profit and then some
I don’t listen to movie critics unless ALL of the reviews are poor. Mortal Kombat & Shark Tale got mixed reviews, but they’re both my favorite films of all time.
To be fair, reviews have no bearing on a releases success (or lack of). I will applaud the Verge's approach to not giving a number to a review, though. If you have to slap an arbitrary number on a review then you need to be better with your review content. I still think this will be just silly fun.
Just saw it. Wasn't bad at all and some parts were genuinely enjoyable. Though there were definitely a few roll your eyes/groan moments, overall we had fun with it!
Move over 2001 a space odyssey and shawshank redemption, theres a new movie in town!
But really, did anyone actually expect this to be anything but a run of the mill generic holywood trope filled video game movie?!?!
You have seen movies before right?......
Either way it looks fun for die hard sonic fans and kids so i guess chalk it up to a win?
This movie was actually pretty good. I had a lot of fun watching it with my GF for Valentine's Day, but there was ONE thing I'm absolutely disappointed in...
I won't spoil, but any fan of Sonic Adventure 2 will know it when they see it.
Missed opportunity!
Looks like another movie the critics hate while the public on the whole are enjoying it
The most pretentious group of all 'critics' hating a video game movie? I'm in shock...
Obviously this movie was never going to score well but I don't care. The studio listened to the fans an changed Sonic's design which tells me they care to some degree. I'm going to pay for a ticket to watch and hope it's halfway decent. I went to all the live-action RE movies and a few of the Transformers. This certainly can't be worse than the latter.
A missed opportunity to shine a light on the horrible hedgehog situation.
Let's all be real. The movie was excellent.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...