Atlus has published the results for its annual player survey, and they make for a reasonably interesting read if you're a fan of the Persona series. We suppose that it doesn't come as huge surprise, but PS2 (and later PSP) classic Persona 3 tops the list when it comes to most wanted remakes. It is, after all, the game that put the franchise on the map for a lot of people — a seminal JRPG not just for Persona as a property, but for the genre as a whole.
Persona 3 wasn't the out-and-out winner, though. It's joined at the summit by the lesser-known Persona 2: Innocent Sin, and direct sequel Persona 2: Eternal Punishment. It's fair to say that both of these PS1 titles — which have certainly aged — could benefit from being remade.
Persona 4 isn't that far behind in the rankings either. It's in fourth place, only just behind the original Revelations: Persona. Over 70 percent of fans who took part in the survey want remakes for all of these titles.
Would Atlus actually remake them, though? The Japanese company can be difficult to figure out at the best of times, but the fact that these survey results are so focused on the possibility of remakes does suggest that it's not an impossible scenario.
At this point it's worth reiterating that Atlus is re-releasing Persona 3 Portable and Persona 4 Golden for PS4, although as far as we know, they're just going to be straightforward ports.
Which Persona games would you like to see get the remake treatment? Feel free to say "all of them" in the comments section below.
[source gematsu.com]
Comments 27
Will they also expect people to pay for them at full price three times like Persona 5. Only with barely any improvements.
All that this money grabbing does is ensure that they have less sales for Persona 6. Everyone will be waiting on the third version before buying.
Persona 3. No doubt.
But if Atlus is handling it? Not sure I wanna see it. Already have a horrible feeling about the Persona 3 Port releasing next year. The SMT Remaster was so ridiculous lazy (and crazy overpriced, shocking!), and afraid that is going same route. So a remake from them? Probably not.
I've only played Persona 5 and I love it!
It would be nice to have all of the other Persona games released on modern systems. I'm looking forward to playing Persona 3 & 4 Golden on Series X for GamePass later this year. And hopefully pick up physical copies (if available) of them for Switch.
A remake of 3 but combining the elements of Persona 3 Portable and FES would be the best P3 experience imo.
Honestly disgusted with how low Digital Devil Saga was, but I know I shouldn’t expect much from modern ‘ATLUS’ (Persona only) fans.
I've wanted remakes of the older games for years. It's a no brainer!
Persona 1 and 2 make the most sense but number 3 just needs a HD version and it will do fine
Not surprising Persona is topping this survey but also kind of disappointing. ATLUS has a bunch of interesting games stuck on older consoles and people are asking for a Persona 4 remake above all of them? Persona 3 doesn't even seem like it needs a remake, just a complete edition.
Not surprising results for sure. P3 could use it just so we don't have to pick between FES and Portable. P2 has an interesting cast and story from what I've played (got sidetracked sadly but I still intend to get back to it some day) so that and it's sequel is a good choice.
P4 is pretty damn close to perfection not sure there's much they could do with that one. P1...I don't know it wasn't great in what I played of it. I didn't like the characters or the story really. Remaking that would require pretty much a complete overhaul.
I'd most just want them to keep making new Persona games though personally.
I don't need a remake of 2, I just want a re-release with some quality of life stuff. Maybe decrease the encounter rate and boost Exp, possibly add save anywhere or some sort of checkpoint system. I haven't played it in a long time and I bet it's really hard to play today - it was HARD then - but the bones of a great game are still there.
Persona 3 deserves a remake. Has the best story and music.
Bleh.
SMT I and II remain top of my own personal pile. 3D remakes with press-turn combat would be a dream come true.
Persona 2 is also up there. The narrative elements are interesting, but the utterly ancient feel of the combat and dungeon crawling ruined IS for me.
P3 was near the top of my list, but, at this point, it's clear Atlus has no interest in creating a DE of it, and I'm tired of waiting for one.
@Geezer Why? I've gotten 100+ hours of enjoyment out of each version of P5 I've purchased to date. As long as I own the hardware it's releasing on, Persona 6 will be a day one purchase for me. And I imagine that'll be true across the board, given how big the fandom for the series will be by then.
Innocent Sin was great but mostly for the story. A remake with proper gameplay would be nice. Still waiting for Eternal Punishment PSP’s fan translation too. I do wonder about these results though, Atlus have attracted an utterly insufferable fanbase of people who’ve never actually played their games but frequent the Persona subreddit. Like Persona 2 is good but I didn’t play the PSP version and then immediately think it warranted a remake. It’s just one of those games with decent word of mouth.
Persona 1 and 2 are tops for me. I played Persona 1 on PSP but didn't get to finish, plus it was tough ayy eff. I didn't get to play P2. I did play P3FES but wouldn't mind getting to experience it again since it's been so long. All 3 games deserve the remake treatment.
...but c'mon, while those would be great, what we really want is whatever Persona 6 is gonna be. that'd be the show stopper for sure.
I can't remember if they've ever shown off the results before so hopefully them doing so now actually means something
If they ever remake smt iv I hope they somehow make the version the creator originally intended with the full script in cause the story had so much potential but it just turned out bad
@nessisonett A fan translation of the PSP version literally went live within the last 24 hours.
I wonder how much the survey results would've changed if it was done in July. That survey was done in May which was before the P5R, P4G and P3P announcements.
I just wish I could get Etrian Odyssey 3. A dual pack of P2 and better P3 would be nice, I suppose. Digital Devil Saga is a bit of a hassle to play on PS3, though.
@Grumblevolcano considering the ranking was for most wanted remakes and those are just ports with nothing new added. I doubt it would change much at all
Persona 2: Eternal Punishment was never sold over here in Europe, so I'd love for them to make it accessible on modern hardware. Similarly, a remake of Persona 3 with the gameplay improvements and extra protagonist of P3P along with the extra story of P3 FES would be great.
Nice to see some Etrian Odyssey representation, with it in 10th place. I do wonder how they could make it for current consoles though. The Nintendo DS and 3DS were perfect for its manual map drawing features due to that bottom touch screen.
@Ralizah Dear god, the day has finally come! Been waiting bloody forever for it, cheers!
I'm a massive fan of the Persona 2 games and it's so sad Eternal Punishment (one of my favorites) never got a release in Europe. I'd be fine with them just porting the games to modern platforms but wouldn't mind them getting remakes.
it is worth noting that persona 2: eternal punishment psp remaster recently got an english fan translation. this was one of the most requested localizations of all time. the psp port has many quality of life improvements and is the best way to play persona 2: eternal punishment these days.
Persona 3 and persona 4 golden because persona 3 portable is a bad idea but it needs a remake and persona 4 golden will have a remake if persona new fighting game like persona 4 arena ultimax on ps4 persona will have crossover with persona 3,4 and 5
They should just do P3 & P4 HD bundle and P2 remake with Devil Summoner HD Remaster.
New Persona fans wouldn't like Devil Summoner or P2 to be frank. They have gotten spolied by P5 and royal style.
I know alot of friends that would love a Persona 3 remake combing both Persona 3 Portable and FES.
Might as well throw in Persona 1 & 2 remakes as well to please everyone...then they can fully focus on Persona 6.
P3 had one of the best stories in the series 🙏🏽
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...