Marvel's Midnight Suns is one of this week's biggest PS5, PS4 releases along with The Callisto Protocol and Need for Speed Unbound, and outlets are beginning to post their reviews of the strategy title. To be very clear: these verdicts are based on the PC version. Review code for PS5 hasn't been made available yet, so you'll need to wait a while before we can deliver our own thoughts here on Push Square.
Still, we can take a look at what other websites are saying and get a good handle on whether the game's any good or not. The first round of PC reviews suggests it absolutely is, with many positive verdicts posted online. Currently sitting on a Metacritic rating of 83, it's judged to be one of the best Marvel games out there.
VGC - 5/5
Marvel’s Midnight Suns combines addictive, deep strategy gameplay with a cast of characters that make the moments outside of the action just as rich and enjoyable as those in it. A lengthy campaign packed with missions to go on and relationships to form with Earth's Mightiest Heroes make Marvel's Midnights Suns a modern strategy classic and one of 2022's biggest surprises.
TheSixthAxis - 9/10
Marvel’s Midnight Suns exceeded my expectations to be one of my favourite games of the year. With a good Marvel story and the ability to make friends on top of excellent turn-based tactical combat systems, Marvel’s Midnight Suns is a super experience.
GameSpot - 8/10
There's a lot to love about Marvel's Midnight Suns. The combat offers a rewardingly tactical experience, with a deckbuilding card system ensuring that randomness challenges the player, not frustrates them. Plus, the mission variety and cast of diverse playable characters keep combat fresh across dozens of hours. But I most enjoyed the role-playing elements and giving The Hunter a chance to connect with the members of the Midnight Suns and Avengers, forging friendships that resulted in powerful abilities I could take back to the combat side of the game.
IGN - 8/10
With Marvel’s Midnight Suns, Firaxis has put itself in the league of RPG developers like BioWare, Obsidian, Bethesda, and Larian. Its innovative turn-based hero combat system takes a bit of time to get going, but once it does it makes excellent use of card game mechanics to keep battles fresh, evolving, and unpredictable over the course of an epic-length campaign – bashing enemies into things for increased damage is endlessly entertaining. The supernatural apocalypse story is given emotional weight by the family relationship between the hero and villain at the heart of it. Building intense friendships with famed Marvel superheroes we’ve seen in comics, movies, and games for decades does tend to feel forced and weird, but learning all their backstories and conflicts with teammates can be intriguing, and the fact that nearly everything you do outside of combat makes you more powerful in the next fight means it all tends to be worth doing.
RPG Site - 8/10
Marvel’s Midnight Suns is an awesome tactical RPG experience. There are some aspects that have dampened my experience here and there, yet its most important element kept me enthralled throughout my entire playthrough. This is a game that shouldn’t be missed by strategy game fans, though I admit that the appeal of Midnight Suns depends on if your palate is open to card-based games. There is no denying that a significant chunk of Midnight Suns revolves around unpacking, upgrading, and unleashing cards to wreak havoc on foes and if that’s something that doesn’t make you turn away immediately, then this is certainly worth your time.
Do these PC reviews convince you to pick up Marvel's Midnight Suns on PS5? Let us know in the comments below.
Comments 36
That’s pretty cool, I bloody hate cards but they have proven themselves with XCOM so it could be worth a shot. I love the fact there’s Nico Minoru and Magik too, I just wish they hadn’t focused so much on the obvious heroes in the trailers. Plus the created character thing puts me off a bit.
Firaxis never misses. (Although I am still concerned about console performance!)
I'm only concerned with the relationship building stuff. I feel like it'll make me delete the game.
So uhh wheres the PushSquare and Nintendolife reviews at.
@Happymoogle It helps if you read the opening paragraph.
@Happymoogle Review code was only made available on PC I'm afraid. We'll either buy it on launch day or hopefully get code then. So it's going to take a little while longer.
Not gonna lie, this is a surprize - all the trailers didn't exactly make it look this good.
As far as I'm aware though, Firaxis has some history with less-than-great console ports at launch - really hoping it's not the case this time.
So basically they didn't send in Console review codes because they know the performances on them is unacceptable is what I'm guessing.
I'm looking forward to this game but from all the preview footage I've seen I'm pretty shocked at how glowing the reviews have been today. That dialogue outside of battle is not good at all and that the majority of the game takes place in the Abbey doing activities that seem out of character for some of the heroes is kind of odd to me (like Blade starting a book club, come on).
No thanks. It hard card mechanics.
Oh man. I haven't been following the hype cycle for games lately and so the whole time I thought this was superhero XCOM and I was really looking forward to it and now I just found out it's a card game.
aw man this is a strategy game ?!? damn! 😡
@johncalmc it’s a card game ?! that’s even worse ! no wonder it’s got high ratings , how much can you actually critique from a card game …smh
So it only looks f*ing ugly with all the gold an stuff, and the original characters are very uninspired but it's a fun tactical rpg? I can live with that lol
Shocks me that reviewers are giving it these scores. If you've seen any of the character interactions, they are awful, on a level of bad ive not seen for a long time. As there's 40 hours of this type of interaction thats a huge fail, and this game more than any other shows why you cant trust reviewers.
The combat is a hard sell, but apparently its the bit of the game that works.
it strikes me as another case like what happened with deathloop of we must give a developer some extra credit because we like there previuos games over the years
@trev666 deathloop was a lot of fun, this game looks terrible to me haha
@Logonogo deathloop was ok but in no way was it a 10/10
I'm not a complex man : I look at ACG and I see his criticism. It seems valid and therefore I put the game on the wait for PS+ list.
I have heard the story and writing are terrible. Some of the worst renditions of marvels characters ever created. For me that makes this a hard pass. To only have nailed combat, and very little enemy variety in that combat, but pair it with a garbage story if you are over the age (or maturity level) of a 15-year-old is a bummer.
This and the new gameplay video showing the same for NFS Unbound, just tanks both titles for me. Catering to such a small demographic, and the most generic/simple, identity copycat follower members of the human family...... works for them and I am happy for them. Doesn't work for me.
@get2sammyb does this raise any red flags to you about the performance on ps5? Has a slight Cyberpunk 2077 on previous gen consoles feel about it to me....
If Cyberpunk taught us anything, it's to never preorder a console version if the developers won't release the console versions for review. Expect trash.
Personally, I see "card-based" and I'm out. That's just not my thing. Maybe if I get a free trial or it hits a flavor of Plus for free I might be convinced to give it a try, but...that's assuming the rule-of-thumb from my first paragraph proves unfounded in this case. No way I'm betting on that.
For those who like this type of thing - good luck, hope this works for you. Cancel your console preorder, though, and make them prove it's what you want.
@northaldinho Maybe, but it's not massively uncommon for reviews to lead on another platform. I'll do some kind of article on Friday once I've had a chance to play the game.
SkillUp's preview contained serious concerns about the interminable relationship building while highly praising the combat and given his review thumbnail says he recommends 'half of Marvel's Midnight Suns' I'm guessing that hasn't changed! Looking forward to seeing what PushSquare thinks.
@Titntin ...maybe they've given it these scores because, ya know, they've played the game ? And enjoyed it, deeming it worthy of the scores? ..just guessing
@Marquez Yeah SkillUp's review was incredibly fair and somewhat concerning. Flat battlefields, textures, performance, writing, characterization all look like varying degrees of red flags.
@KingPev lol. Yeah, I guess your right. I was just a little shocked at how unconvincing the characters were in the story side of things from all the footage I had seen. I hadn't considered that people would actually be drawn into those relationships.. But Im clearly wrong from some of the opinions expressed..
Clearly, as you rightly point out, you would need to have played the game to have a valid opinion. 😁
@Titntin ..🙂 sorry I didn't mean to come across as a bit of a tool - it's just that I've read a lot of the reviews today as I'm quite keen on buying it. The reviews say the same - it's a great surprise, combat is great, the card system works brilliantly as does the relationship building. Polygon and Gamesradar even say its it's a Game Of The Year contender. So I'm as shocked as you are ! Lol.. let's hope it performs well on console !
I’m going to need a review of this cos frankly I keep looking at this game waiting to be told what is actually is. Even when I went onto the Game website, the official marketing information still doesn’t really tell me. Is this just me?
Looks pretty cool to me, though I do love turn based games.
@bozz @Marquez Agreed. SkillUps review was hilarious. Those hangout conversations sound woeful. If anyones wondering what we’re talking about just watch a couple of minutes of this
https://youtu.be/zd3-qR0jKKY?t=1022
Wow, I distinctly remember most people being very negative about this game when it was revealed...how the turntables!
@themightyant
I'm glad skillup writes about it so well, and some others agree.
Having thought 'surely no one would excuse such poor characters' I was more than bemused to find people actually praising this element of the game. At least I'm not the only one looking at this dialogue and raising an eyebrow...
@Titntin that’s what I always respect about SkillUp. I don’t always agree with him but when he’s critical, or praising, he almost always goes into specific detail about WHY he felt that way. He justifies his reasons and leaves it for us to decide if those things will bother us. Plus he writes so well.
I agree it’s bonkers to me that others are praising this area of the game, but then they’re not going into any detail to justify why. It sounds atrocious.
To be fair while he’s hyper-critical of this aspect of the game he ultimately recommends (half of) Midnight Sons because the rest of the game is great.
£64.99...
I hope no one buys this on ps5. It looks like £10's worth, if that 👀 I thought it was a fighting game like injustice, and I had little interest in it, and now I've seen the gameplay I just can't believe my eyes that this is a full priced PS5 game. 2K sports quality, it is not 😬
I'm going to remain doubtful of the game's quality until Push Square has a chance to beat the story and publish their review.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...