data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7b2b8/7b2b8542da8304319bf6425bffe326525b8bc634" alt="Sony Issues DMCA Takedown Against Bloodborne 60FPS Mod, Four Years After Release 1"
Update []: Modder Lance McDonald has clarified some detail about Sony's DMCA takedown relating to his Bloodborne mod, which allows the game to run at 60 frames-per-second.
In a post on Discord, McDonald says Sony's issue was with the use of the trademarked word Bloodborne, rather than the patch itself.
"The DMCA was not against the patch," he wrote. "They used DMCA to take down the page because the page used the word "Bloodborne" which they own the trademark of. They can't legally DMCA the patch because it's 100% code and the patch doesn't actually even say what game it's for in it. However I'm not stupid enough to try to work around their copyright to re-post it."
So, it's perhaps not as mean-spirited of Sony as it first appeared, with the issue being a matter of copyright on the game's title.
Still, the timing remains unusual, given that the patch has been around for years with the Bloodborne name, so the fan theory that this takedown is indicative of an impending announcement can still fly.
Original Story: Almost four years down the line, Sony has issued a DMCA takedown request against an unofficial Bloodborne patch that allows it to run at 60 frames-per-second.
The news comes via the mod's creator, Lance McDonald, on social media:
McDonald has said in the past that Bloodborne is just two lines of code away from hitting the performance target. His unofficial update proves that it's possible, but now the mod is unavailable thanks to Sony taking action against it.
While this shouldn't be surprising news, the timing is quite interesting. Why has the DMCA takedown taken such a long time to happen?
Some are positing that the takedown request has occurred now because the action RPG's 10th anniversary is in March of this year, which would be an ideal time for Sony to make any Bloodborne-related announcements.
After all, if people can play Bloodborne at 60 frames-per-second now, why would they bother buying, say, a remaster?
It's all just speculation of course (and likely a generous dose of hopium), but there's definitely some logic to what fans are saying here. Either Sony is very slow to discover the mod, or its sudden action suggests something else is bubbling away.
What do you think? Does this DMCA takedown mean anything more, or are Sony's lawyers just playing catchup? Discuss in the comments section below.
[source x.com, via resetera.com]
Comments 72
HOPEFULLY this means they are doing something with bloodborne (inhales copium)
It is COMING. Late but it is finally happening.
Oh my gosh. Screw Sony. In one generation, I went from loving Sony to hating basically everything they make and do. Except Astro Bot. That was their one saving grace this generation.
*Huffs Copium
Get ready folks!
Probably cause they still own it and can't be letting people play it for free
Besides I find it rather funny that they've practically ported all their western games under the sun to pc. But have managed to keep all their Japanese ones so close to their chests for whatever reason lol
Sony next level trolling
It would be funny if they did something with the game (remaster, update or whatever) but didn't announce anything about a possible PC version.
Allright, time to open the valves of my Bloodbornium tank
"But why" because it's copy right maybe?
They're going to release Days Gone Remastered on the 10th anniversary of Bloodborne.
While terrible by Sony to act like Nintendo I do hope it means they're getting ready to show Bloodborne remaster (lol no chance).
This is just prep work to kill the emulated version on PC that people have been working on... There will be no actual improvements to Bloodborne.
Maybe they know something we don’t 🙏 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🫣
I think I sucked at Bloodborne when it was 30fps, and I'd suck at Bloodborne if it's 60fps, so no difference to me!
Doesn't matter. When something like this is uploaded, it spreads all over the web. Good luck taking down every link out there. Shut one down, and 10 more shows up. Plenty of backups available 😁
That's ridiculous
@ED_209 it would be funnier is they announced it for pc and ps5 though..
They GOTTA be planning something. No reason to be be this petty this late.
The Bloodborne is real! The borne will be Blood but re-released!
Jokes aside, it sucks to see mods taken down but I do wonder if it'll result in an actual official, well, anything.
Thaf sucks, you hate to see it. Sony is pulling “the blizzard” with classic wow.
DMCA is not how you do it, you make your official version and make it better. Denying fans what they want is just bad rep.
Big L for sony in my opinion.
@Mintie well it’s too late lol…people have already beaten the game on it, that’s how far it’s come.
When Nintendo stripped Gary's Mod of all its long-standing Nintendo content, it must've been because they were planning something, right?
Nah. Companies can abruptly change their mind on what they will or won't allow. Or just suddenly prioritize something they've been aware of but neglected for a while. Or sometimes, they actually don't know about these fanmade things until years after the fact.
All of which seem more likely to me than Sony felt threatened by this old mod with maybe a few thousand downloads, and thought an upcoming remake/PC port/PS5 Pro update would be diminished by its existence. Remember, From is allegedly too busy and Bluepoint wasted some amount of time on GaaS nonsense; who would even be making a remake?
Hermen sitting in his office and thinking „They want me to resign, so I don’t give them what they crave for“.
Disappointing but tbh, it's expected. Though quite unsure why it took this long for Sony to issue the DMCA
If it really is as simple as two lines of code, then maybe Bluepoint is doing this quick and they'll release a PS5 port this year. But, that won't happen.
This is baffling to me. It’s a patch meaning there’s absolutely no way to do anything with it without a copy of the game files. He doesn’t provide any of that. This is Sony trying to kill something that makes them look inferior rather than any indication of a remake.
Can someone explain all of this to me b/c between the article and the comments I’m confused.
Is this mod to let people run a PS disc version of the game at 60fps on PC or a PC version on PC or a PS version on PS?
Just trying to figure out what it was exactly the guy did wrong that was taken down by Sony? 🤷🏻♂️
@rjejr I believe it’s a mod you can run with the game on a jailbroken ps4, or, an emulated version on a pc
Full blown remake, like DS, possibly for PS6, possibly sooner with big Pro enhancements, really sounds like the only sensible reason here.
How dare they defend their IP!
Well, that's pointless. I just checked and the patch is still easily accessible and downloadable.
@ZeroSum
You'd be surprised at how much easier games are when running at 60fps with consistent frame pacing.
Hopefully they patch it.
Believing Sony will touch Bloodbourne again is like believing Ubisoft release finished game or Square Enix is satisfied with game sales...
Putting Bluepoint on Bloodborne remake? PS6 launch title ALA Demon's Souls? Big if true
Eliminating the competition now that Bluepoint is free? Maybe...
I wonder how long it will take them to go after the PS4 emulator and Bloodborne's "PC version" too...
Could we also hope that Sony will manage to get Miyazaki for an exclusive sequel on the PS6? Because that would single-handedly tip the balance for me to buy that console...
Oh here we go, more speculating, are we all that starved of stuff to play ??
I'd love for this to be a hint that something, anything Bloodborne related is coming... but I'm not holding my breath sadly. Would love to be wrong though!
Same thought. Clearly is going to make a remaster announcement any time soon
Bloodborne at 40 fps!!
@Grumblevolcano I’m going to one up you and say it’s gonna be the last of us 2 remastered remake.
Xbox Series port of Bloodborne incoming.
Removed - trolling/baiting
@Artois2 Uh oh, fanboy war ahead! Zzzzz
Arrrrr, nothing leaves the sea. Shiver me timbers, Sony. It's already done.
@3Above Or it could be that now we’re back to a Japanese business man CEO in charge of SIE… They’re probably not gonna tolerate stuff like this. 🤷
Kinda weird to see Sony put a DMCA over fans mod and after 4 years too. I mean, they didn't bother to do it with Bloodborne PS1 demake and the kart racing.
I feel this is the effect of new higher ups. Japanese are so tight up when comes to fans mod and emulator. Just look at Nintendo who keeps sending C&D over fans mod and emulator.
@Mintie there's no "emulated version". There's the dump and an emulator. Emulators aren't ilegal.
Used it for 4 years to build hype about the desire for an enhanced version. Now they shut it down so no one can get their fix before the upcoming release. Hopefully it's as good as the Demon Soul's remake
Genuine question to any diehard Bloodborne fans - am I missing something? I own it on PS4 and played it about 6 months ago for 10 hours or so and found it to be quite dull.
That's some Konami ***** by Sony right there, putting effort in stopping anyone else making something good whilst they actively put zero effort in to do the same...
Hopefully a pc release
But why? Because they made it, it's their property. Every game makes it clear altering and stealing all or some content is a crime. I don't agree with that if a game has been abandoned but that's the way it is.
@SMJ it is so dull and boring. Most gamers with rise tinted glasses won't admit it but they find it dull to, they just want a remake hoping it'll be improved, most of us with a ps5 want something to play on it that has the ps5 logo on the game box and we don't care if it's remasters of remasters or non stop remakes lol
Surprised it took so long and I would be more upset at them doing something Nintendo does. But Lance McDonald was so ***** annoying online with his holier than thou shtick over this mod acting like it was a crime against humanity that Sony didn't patch it in.
@PorkChopExpress TBF Bloodborne's sales are not very good considering how much of it is from when the game cost 10 bucks.
Also, regarding the Zero Dawn remaster, my theory is they wanted Nixxes to get comfortable with Decima Engine to put them in an even bigger support role.
@PorkChopExpress Yeah I feel with Spider-Man 2 PC they dropped the ball. Maybe overworked with too many projects.
Also, I do see Bloodborne remake happening (if Demon's Souls is apparently not going to PC then I assume the same of BB remake being a PS6 exclusive).
People should calm down about Bloodborne. It's great, I played the hell out of it, including the dlc, but the internet has made it a neverending obsession. From software is mostly making the same type of game with only slightly different settings. Beyond that there's no lack of great soulsborne games from other studios. I for one since then had more enjoyment with wukong, lies of p and the likes.
And it's not like the PS4 version is unplayable or inaccessible. Move on and be patient.
I'd much rather this site did not reference or post links driving people to X, a bubbling cess pit of hate and mis information.
Particularly when the same post was made on sites without the baggage, such as Blue sky , which is where I read this post yesterday.
One would suspect if they have only just done this that they may have some plans of their own, maybe for a quick official 60fps patch.
Why abuse a DMCA? To kill what?
@AverageGamer True. I wonder if they will pursue the Tencent Horizon lookalike game?
@3Above That depends on if they can build a case against it. That could end up being a pal world vs Nintendo situation
I WANT TO BELIEVE
At a glance that dudes pic in the article looked like Andrew Tate had patched Bloodborne 🤣 the true Alpha Male haha.
Reminds me of when MP3 sharing sites appears in the late 90's. All the record companies were trying to shut them down, rather than pulling their fingers out and giving consumers what they wanted.
If you don't sell it, someone else will say "ta very much" and take that cash.
Sony/From have had ample time to do it themselves.
Why weren't Blue Point doing a remaster after they'd finished their excellent Demon Souls port?
Oh yes, because some clown completely wasted their time by putting them on a now cancelled GAAS, as RoomwithaMoose pointed out.
Damn... and here i thought they were pulling it for preparation to announce an ACTUAL Bloodborne Remaster in 60fps... guess not.
Queue the sad trombone for everyone that thought this was anything but that
"McDonald has said in the past that Bloodborne is just two lines of code away from hitting the performance target."
I got hopium going up one nostril and copium going up the other.
C'mon Sony, It's only 2 lines!
Good, then rerelease the patch as Bludborn and it’s all set
What's the difference in the end? If he posts it again even under a different name, Sony's lawyers will find a way to spin it in their favor...
Now that this information is public, I am sure someone else will take the mod he created and post them under a different name (since he seems unwilling to post again).
@Cornpop76 You have some nice stuff in your home i could use some extra cash if its not yours its not yours.
game titles are not the realm of copyright, but of trademarks. you can't copyright a title of something, that would be disastrous. trademarks are specifically for brands (logos, company names, titles of projects); copyrights are for the ideas contained within the project—its world, characters, prose, etc..
if Sony's lawyers actually said it was for violating their copyright, they need to go back to law 101 because the distinction is simple even for a layperson. (though I assume the taxonomical mistake is on Lance's end.)
regardless, surely the patch has mirrors elsewhere and it's simply a matter of finding one that isn't dead and won't give you a virus.
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...