The big gameplay hook for Lost Ember is the ability to swap from one animal to another. Doing so allows you to view the game's big environments from different perspectives, but more importantly, allows you to utilise each beast's unique abilities in order to advance. It's a novel idea, but the game built around it feels underdeveloped.
You'll play as a wolf for the majority, but you can swap to any other creature you can find with a press of square. Wombats can squeeze through small tunnels, various birds can obviously fly, and fish can swiftly traverse through bodies of water. Finding and possessing each animal will likely lead to new areas and perhaps some hidden spots containing collectibles. Alongside a sombre story unfolded by your glowing companion, that's about all the game has to offer.
You'll often pass through huge, open ended areas, but other than looking for collectable bits and pieces, there's very little reason to stick around. You may as well book it from one memory to the next to progress the story, as that's the game's most interesting aspect. It's a shame more isn't done with the various animal forms; as it is, the shape-shifting only serves to get you from one point to another. It's all a bit lifeless.
Add to this the various bugs we encountered during play, and Lost Ember becomes a fairly hard sell. We got stuck on geometry a couple of times, and had to reset the game more than once. At one point, some animals failed to spawn, which meant we couldn't progress without reloading the checkpoint. These rough edges don't help a game that's already a little threadbare. Unless you're curious about the narrative, we'd beware of the dog in this case.
Comments 6
Great review, Stephen.
The game seems to have beautiful visuals and a neat animal shifting idea, but needed more time in the oven for performance and to fill the world.
Have you played Spirit of the North? I wonder if you'll review that.
I bought this and Spirit of the North. Both share similar bugginess but enjoying them with my kids. Haven't played enough of both to form a proper opinion but not regretting my purchases yet!
What an unfortunate review Stephen, this is absolutely one of the best games of this year. Usually your reviews are on point but you surprisingly really dropped the ball with this one.
To give this indie game a 4/10 you either had a bad day or something personal against the game. Objectively there is no way.
Edit: I guess I was right. Just checked Metacritic and it seems you are the only critic out there from a wide array of journalist going under the 6. Your review and grade is insulting to other journalists and the devs that poured their soul into this. Even if you hated the game you ought to have the decency to give it a 5.
Cant wait too see this hit Limited Run Games with patches on disc. 😃 👍
@sensodyne3333 Hey, if you’ve played it and think it’s one of the year’s best games, more power to you. We’ll have to agree to disagree on this one! Thanks for reading
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...