In case you missed the recent news, SEGA has cancelled Hyenas, its online multiplayer shooter that was in development at Creative Assembly. This was a surprising move, given the game had been in the works for a long time, and was very close to completion. It's also reported that layoffs will occur at the studio. Now, new details are beginning to emerge about the situation — including that the game was the publisher's most expensive it's ever produced.
A video from YouTuber Volound, who follows the Total War series, contains anonymous accounts from developers about the project. Their claims are corroborated by VGC's sources. Apparently, the game suffered from a laundry list of issues, as one source writes: "So what went wrong? Total lack of direction, many of the leadership asleep at the wheel but they never seem to lose their jobs. An engine change, part way through the process. Attempting to break into a saturated market, and not committing to do anything adventurous with the game."
Other revelations are outlined in the video and VGC's report, including that film director Neill Blomkamp helped with the game's lore and story, and that it had transitioned to a free-to-play model shortly before cancellation. It was previously intended to be a premium game.
Former developers claim Hyenas had SEGA's biggest ever budget for a game, and was one of the publisher's so-called "super games".
There are some more details to pore over on VGC, but the gist is that Hyenas was an extremely challenging project that struggled to find a direction. Its concept, a team-based shooter about stealing from the mega-rich, failed to really capture anyone's imagination, even if the game itself showed promise in our hands-on time. Unfortunately, it won't materialise now, despite the apparently large sums of money thrown at it.
[source youtube.com, via videogameschronicle.com]
Comments 40
Sega should have put that budget somewhere more reasonable, like Sonic, Yakuza...um...
Well, that was really stupid of them.
Hopefully Sony takes notice and does something about FairGame$.
There but for the grace of God goes Sony themselves
Absolutely ridiculous decisions all around, the Fortnite explosion broke these studios and we're all seeing it play out years later.
Can't even get access to older Sonic games aka their bread & butter on current gen consoles but they'll go all in on an unknown IP for a heavily cornered/declining market.
I hope all those failing GaaS-games lately finally will be a wake up call for all those publishers
@Lyedecker there is no need to do anything imo. And it is too late to save money on that. FairGame will launch and die in months like many other live-service games out there.
Oof. Hope Sony takes notice.
That’s the nature of this industry now. Everyone’s seeking destructive growth. At this point, there’s no developer or publisher I trust to break into the multiplayer space. It’s also insane that they barely have Sonic Frontiers any proper funding, but they pumped so many resources into this generic attempt at live service.
Well then, I guess it's a good thing they cancelled this mess. Imagine spending that much on something this poorly conceived. I guess somebody at Sega finally wised up.
@HotGoomba Thing is Sega has tons of great IP's that have been gathering dust for what is probably decades now. They have so many great things they could be doing with their money. Heck they could just release their old 90's arcade games, or go back to some of their Dreamcast era franchises they have abandoned, like JSR and Crazy Taxi.
@Lyedecker First impressions are everything and the impressions for FairGame$ (man that name 🤢) have been overwhelmingly negative, is already a laughing stock. Soapstars has a better chance at success and that too will ultimately fail
I feel no pity. Don't sink your money into that over saturated market. End of story.
Surely it would have been better to just stick it in the next Yakuza as a mini game
@Juanalf But no one has seen the game in action the only thing we got was a CGI trailer. It may give an idea of what the game is but we have no idea how it actually plays.
That’s too bad, but it’s definitely not a game I was looking forward to anyways. Give us Virtua Fighter 6, Sega.
I agree with a lot of the other comments here. Companies spending a lot of resources and money into trying to push their own games into a booming market usually don't end well, especially when it's overly saturated.
And since this is Sega we're talking about, they can put a lot of said resources into their own dormant IPs instead of trying to push out something that they hope can be a cash cow. Sony has been teetering on this line for the last few years with trying to push live service games.
Although it didn't appeal to me, I can't fathom why they wouldn't have tossed it out into the market to try and recoup at least SOME of its costs. Especially since it was so close to being done AND so expensive. How can scrapping the entire thing and making $0 off it be better than at least TRYING to make it successful, even if they only supported it for a year or 2 like some other doomed service titles?
Being F2P, it likely would have garnered at least SOME users who would have dropped some cash on it. As it stands, it seems bizarre they'd rather lose everything than try and mitigate the losses at least a tiny bit.
@Deoxyr1bose
That's a great point. Perhaps if Frontiers had gotten at least a bit of the money poured into this they might been able to do something about the bad pop-in that game suffers from.
Plus it's Sonic. Their mascot. Why did this get more funding than that? Hopefully they learned their lesson and give the next 3D Sonic a bit more budget because Frontiers was a solid game just rough around the edges.
@MFTWrecks I think the problem with that is how these online live service games cost a lot to put up and keep active. I think Sega simply decided it wasn't worth spending more time and money on.
This is what happens when you get greedy
@Mauzuri I'm sorry to burst your bubble dude, but Crash Team Rumble is unfortunately a thing lol
Ok now this cancellation is making much more sense. Like I think I was one of the few people interested in Hyenas, but this doesn't feel like it should be Sega's most expensive game ever. I would expect something like a new huge Sonic game or Like A Dragon Infinite Wealth to be their most costly titles, so I guess a cancellation here to avoid blowing even more money on it for super lacking returns makes sense
Sega, Sega, Sega, Sega, Sega, Sega 🤦
This is why Japanese developers should stick to what they do best and that's making great JRPG's. Making live service shooting games is maybe out of their comfort zone and too risky.
@UltimateOtaku91 The developer making it is from the United Kingdom. Creative Assembly were the people who made the excellent Alien Isolation. Sega was just funding the project.
this is what happens when a single player studio creative assembly is asked to make a multipayer game
Sony take note it doesnt end well, oh youve just discovered that with factions
Its always a shame when a game concept and lots of creative work fails to manifest into a good game. But its absolutely par for course in game development that not all projects make it. I spent 20 years making games and at least 50% of them got canned.
Its the cost you pay chasing that big hit.
@MFTWrecks
It’s possible this is a repeat of last year’s Batwoman fiasco where companies managed to save money and write it off as a tax expenditure of some sort to save money.
I hope they’re at least able to use some of the assets elsewhere
Another talented team syphoned off into the coop/gaas goldrush with little to show for it. It hurts, but tbh Arkane hurt a lot more. Nintendo are one of the few to come out unscathed, they stuck to their guns, gave gamers what they crave.. and are killing it. I hope they actually give their next console some juice and conquer the end of this gen.
I got a beta key for Hyenas and tbh when it was announced I was vaguely interested, but when it came time to install it I just couldn't muster any enthusiasm for anogher MP shooter.
I think it's wild they cut bait on it prior to release, but it's probably the wisest move - as mentioned they'd still have to invest in it once it went live.
I think my biggest concern is whether this was in fact one of their "super games". There had been rumors they were working on live service Crazy Taxi and/or Jet Set Radio games, and frankly I think both of those games could be interesting in that space, IF handled appropriately - certainly no given since Sega doesn't have a single studio with live service chops.
Why can't they keep the budget low? I don't need high quality graphics. Don't need ray tracing. I'm good with PS3 graphics, but with good performance.
@JayJ But you'd think they would have budgeted ahead to support the necessary online infrastructure for [checks notes] an always-online live service title.
@MFTWrecks I'm sure they did, but then some bean counters did the risk assessment and decided any further spending would be bad for business.
I still keep forgetting that this game was a thing lol
I never heard of this until it was canceled.
But it’s usual Sega crap.
Why can’t they give us a reboot of Phantasy Star Online? That’s the type of game that could succeed as GAAS. It’s a well known and beloved IP, it had a rich history on Dreamcast, GameCube, and Xbox, and it could be converted into Live Service quite easily. Come on Sega.
They could also start revisiting some of their dormant IPs. I’d love to see a new Golden Axe made by the guys who did SOR4. Hell even a new Altered Beast would be nice.
Live services eh? Always a sure hit into disaster. 🤣
@OrtadragoonX Isn't that what Phantasy star new genesis is? Not sure it did too well. I would much prefer a reboot of the original single player RPG's or even better, Shining force.
I am expecting a golden axe or SoR5 from dotemu. Fingers crossed.
It's shame cause the concept didn't sound THAT bad
But at least if anything hopefully SEGA will actually start putting their money where a certain blue hedgehog needs it, or maybe that golden axe remake from awhile back?
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...