These monkeys have a problem. Well, a succession of problems, really, but the main one is that they've been trapped inside giant spheres for no reason. And they're beloved, these monkeys: since the GameCube days, Super Monkey Ball has been (perhaps bafflingly) popular, with increasingly diminishing returns across the likes of Super Monkey Ball Adventure through to the recent Banana Blitz HD.
Here, though, you've got a functional remake of PS2 and Xbox's Super Monkey Ball Deluxe, itself a 2005 compilation of the original game and its sequel. Presentation has been overhauled, but the core ball-rolling simian action seems to have been left largely untouched. If you've never played Monkey Ball before, it's a bit like those old wooden marble mazes where you tilt the play area to roll the ball, except this time there's a little monkey fella.
The removal of any kind of stakes is an interesting choice, here; the lives system has been stripped out in favour of a more straightforward (and contemporary) reliance on repetition. Unfortunately, with no fail state or consistently skilled play necessary, the game starts to feel monotonous rather quickly. And that's not some "git gud" cretinousness: if there's nothing to strive for, we don't see that there's much point in persevering.
Thankfully there are copious unlockables, from secret characters (including Sonic, Tails, and, erm, Kazama Kiryu) to more skins and the usual mini-games. Unfortunately, the latter feel unpolished to the point of unfinished at times and we found ourselves wondering why they bothered.
Still, it all looks gorgeous, moves smoothly, and sounds exuberant as ever. We'd say that for Monkey Ball fanatics this is a bit of a must, but then said fanatics are the ones who will notice the cracks more than anyone else. So we're not sure, ultimately, who this is for. Newcomers may find themselves wondering what all the fuss is about.
Comments 28
“No live system means no stakes”
That’s a pro to me, limited lives are an archaic thing of the past that just create frustration and anger.
No Monkey Target is a real shame.
Infinite lives makes the game far easier and IMHO this isn't what Super Monkey Ball is about.
I still have the Gamecube games along with Deluxe so when I'm finished with this I'll stick with those.
For whatever reason, it always seems like Sega just misses something. Disappointing about the mini games but I’m not bummed about the lives. I’ll still end up getting this.
@darkswabber I never got frustrated with Super Monkey Ball at all.
Oh man! I just read the subheader!
Ricky Gervais Show FTW! I can't tell you how many times I've listened to every XFM, BBC Radio and podcast episodes. The 3 of them (Ricky, Steve, Karl) are absolutely hilarious.
Stuart you have instantly gone to the top of my fav reviewer chart 😊
I pre-ordered for the first time in years just because it was about half the price of a PS5 exclusive. It would be nice if they just included the original version through PS2 emulation for posterity’s purpose.
The Lives system was the big reason why I stopped playing the Vita game. Being expected to clear all those levels in one sitting with very limited lives just wasn't fun to me. Glad to hear this one doesn't use lives.
@shonenjump86 it's usually due to picking the wrong engine or studio to make the games. I think they used Unity for this game, which no one would pick for SMB unless they wanted to do this cheap, quick and have it work on everything.
..turns out, little monkey fella sat in a ball.
@roe PLAY A RECORD.
@Integrity glad im not the only karl pilkington fan here lol
@Danloaded head like a f***in' orange 😁
@Integrity Why is monkey target in the screen shots then?
@StuartGipp are there online leaderboards for the mini games?
Sale it is!
Kinda disappointing scores this week...Far Cry 6 better be good!
Pre-ordered this and it arrived on Saturday. The main game is fine, but Monkey Target is completely broken. Compared to the original GC version, it's a shambles
That subheading’s brilliant 😂 I’ve cried with laughter watching The Ricky Gervais show.
@Loftimus monkey target is in the game. I have it on switch and it’s there for sure. However, some reviewers have said that it doesn’t play quite as well as the original
@RavenWolfe81 I see, maybe Sega will get it right eventually.
Collection is reviewing pretty well but I have zero nostalgia to buy day one, will wait for a 50% off sale in a year or two.
I clicked for the Karl Pilkington reference.
Game seems alright.
I never played a Monkey Ball game so I'm hyped to play this collection.
It also has Kiryu which is a plus lol.
@Loftimus I didn't see it. Oops
I'll live with the memory of SMB on the brilliant GameCube.
Any differences between the PS4 and PS5 version? Haptic feedback or anything?
THIS GAME IS HARD AS IT IS! No lives doesn't reduce the stakes, especially for those who like to 100%.
The GameCube version will always be best purely because of the controller. The analogue stick ridges/segments made it amazing.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...