Persona 3 remains a groundbreaking RPG but we were slightly worried if Persona 3 Reload would live up to its legacy. It's been 16 years since the original game first appeared, introducing life simulation mechanics and a considerably darker storyline than its successors. As the game that reshaped Atlus' popular series, expectations are unsurprisingly high for this full-fledged remake and after going hands-on, we've come away impressed.
Playing a 30-minute demo at Gamescom 2023, Atlus split this into two segments. 'New Moon' showcased the remade Tartarus and its procedurally generated levels from floors 2-6. That includes the first mini-boss battle and at that stage, only Yukari and Junpei are available as active teammates. There's also 'Full Moon', which pits you against Persona 3's first major boss in the monorail segment.
If you never played Persona 3, Tartarus is comparable to Persona 5's Mementos, a hefty dungeon that gradually unlocks upon advancing through the main story. Exploration remains familiar and Reload faithfully recreates this warped version of Gekoukkan High β perhaps a little too closely. Mini-boss floor aside, each area only featured several enemies and the odd treasure chest, lacking that same variety Mementos holds. That said, we might actually prefer the shorter length given how vast the original Tartarus was.
Unlike the original game, you also won't get tired when exploring or potentially become sick the next day, as Atlus previously confirmed the Condition system's removal. This means characters who've been battling for ages won't see stat reductions like decreased accuracy and defence, removing the regular need to swap out characters upon ascending Tartarus. It's a welcome change that simplifies exploration and removes combat limitations.
Combat benefits from Reload's modernisation while remaining familiar. Though not identical in style, Reload uses a straightforward one-button combat menu like Persona 5 that improves combat pacing. Thankfully, the entire party is controllable instead of just the protagonist β something Portable allowed but not the original or FES. Great news for anyone who remembers Mitsuru spamming Marin Karin and other annoying AI decisions. Like Persona 4 Golden, Shuffle Time lets you directly pick a reward card following combat, offering bonuses like increased EXP.
Finally, upon exploiting an enemy's weakness, you can follow up with a bonus attack, pressing the advantage with the same character or 'Shifting' to someone else. It's a useful improvement that's functionally identical to Persona 5's Baton Pass command, adding to combat's tactical gameplay nicely. When all enemies are Downed, finishing off entire groups with a single All-out Attack remains highly enjoyable.
We're really impressed with how clean Reload's art style looks, too. Character models look sharp, performance is smooth, and the art style successfully captures the original's look, recreating the Dark Hour's oppressive atmosphere incredibly well. The iconic soundtrack complements the action nicely, and hearing Mass Destruction when a battle begins provided some nostalgic joy. In another nod to Persona 5, Reload's menus receive a matching overhaul, replacing the red and black colours for a pleasing softer blue palette.
The demo nicely illustrates these improvements but unfortunately, there's not much else we could judge from this. We couldn't explore the Iwatodai dorms, witness any social links, try out school life, or basically anything else. For such a vast game, a demo focused on Tartarus and the first boss fight only scratches this RPG's surface.
Indeed, we're still unsure about the wider decisions guiding Reload's direction. Atlus' focus on the original Persona 3 alone while excluding Portable and FES' major additions is both incredibly disappointing and a huge missed opportunity to create a 'definitive' version, though minor FES changes are present. Of course, The Answer and the female protagonist could be added through DLC or expanded versions like Golden and Royal; Atlus certainly has form here, after all. That would be in poor taste given how long fans have wanted something like Reload, but we're getting ahead of ourselves.
As much as we'd love to see those additions implemented, their exclusion doesn't significantly dampen our enthusiasm for Persona 3 Reload. We're still incredibly happy to see Atlus give this classic RPG a much-needed remake. What we've seen in this short demo looks highly promising, and we can't wait to explore this world once again.
Persona 3 Reload is slated to release for PS5 and PS4 on 2nd February, 2024. How are you feeling about this remake? Try to avoid the Dark Hour in the comments section below.
Comments 43
Tartarus still sounding kind of bland in terms of exploration is unfortunate. I didn't expect them to hand design every floor since there are so many but I was hoping for a bit more there.
Still, the rest of the game looks fantastic overall so I'm still very excited for this one!
The answer would probably be dlc as will bonus personas.
Will the outfits and personas from fes and portable be in this one though?
Wouldn't be surprised if they did Persona 3 Reload FES in the future to add the missing features back from P/FES back in
I didn't realise this is lacking content. I am sure Atlas will release a definitive version later for full price. They are so damn greedy.
I get annoyed with atlus I didn't buy the remaster because they skipped the FES version they could have combined both but didn't. Now with the remake they cut even more content and if they add it later it will be infuriating.
I do like the improvements as I was hoping they cut out characters getting sick and they did so combat I am happy with as they combined all the best elements from previous titles.
I feel like I can wait for this one. Felt a bit burned by Persona 5 Royal, especially when there was no option to upgrade from the original and you had to buy it again for PS5
This game will be an exception to my βno day oneβ game list, alongside Like a Dragon Infinite Wealth.
@Korgon
I really didn't enjoy the Mementos section of Persona 5, so my enthusiasm for P3R has definitely decreased.
Also, I agree with everyone saying that Atlust will probably add in the P3P and P3FES features at a later stage, by selling it as another version of P3R.
I think I'll wait until P6 arrives for my Persona fix.
This one is on GP right?
I like the persona games, but damn I find Atlus so greedy with them, so if itβs on GP Iβll play it there
Regardless of some missing features, this might be of my most anticipated games ever. Persona 3 is probably my favourite game of all time and as corny as it sounds definitely taught me some important life lessonsπ .
The only thing I'm a bit iffy on is Akihiko's voiceπ. The new cast honestly sound fantastic from what I've heard, aside from Akihiko. His voice isn't bad per se but it's just soooo off? π€. Not throwing shade on the voice actor by the way, I'll wait until the full game to pass judgement, but Akihiko's voice is really hmmmmmmmmmmmmm.
Fuuka on the other hand went from 0-100. No further comment. Just wow.
Oh, and the new battle drip that every member has? Even better.
I WISH I COULD FAST FORWARD TO 2024πππ
I'll wait until they release Persona 3 FES remake in a year at full price.
Never played Persona 3, so I wonβt miss any removed content. Really looking forward to this. Persona 5 is one of my favourite games and I really enjoyed 4.
Too bad its missing some features and the bland main dungeon is still bland, Pass from me.
Sounds promising, with at least a few improvements on the original.
But Iβm waiting a few years before buying it. Like the article suggests, and others here have said, Atlus will probably release Persona 3 Reload Royal later and charge full price for it, with no upgrade path. When they port it to PlayStation 6, theyβll again charge full price for it, with no upgrade path.
They make good games, but they have really scummy business practices.
Even if they had included FES/Portable content, it wouldn't have made this game any better. It's fundamentally the worst Persona game out of 3, 4 and 5. Tartarus is awful, social links with your party members are lacking and there are barely any story events throughout the game like in P4G and P5R (camping trips, school trips etc.). It's such an underwhelming and forgettable experience. The focus should be on improving these aspects, not adding post-game content or a female protagonist. The fact that this is a remake makes me hopeful that, despite Tartarus being seemingly unchanged, they will improve upon the game's other shortcomings.
I learned my lesson with Atlus from previous games, so I'll wait for the 'full' release with all of their games going forward.
Like many others here, I won't be giving Atlus my money considering how they treat their fans
atlus has shot itself in the foot with its business model. after re-releasing the "complete edition" of p5 as a seperate game with no upgrade path and no free ps5 update for ps4 owners (presumably they will follow the same pattern with smt v down the road), many fans have been conditioned to wait it out for the re-release ("complete edition") before purchasing. nobody wants to get burned and be "forced" to double dip, afterall, other than the most hardcore fans who don't mind being exploited time and time again. better off taking a wait and see approach here bofore supporting atlus' devious practices.
as excited as i am for studio zero's new game, metaphor, i can't help but wonder what they are planning down the line as well and if it would be better to wait a few years for the "complete" edition.
@Kanji-Tatsumi Don't forget at full price.
While it would be nice to have them, the missing contents are nothing that really changes anything in any major way. I am ok with it not being there and the focus being on the canonical character and his story.
As long as they focus on making that the best it can be, i am fine with it.
Not really missing anything by not including Portable's female MC, that's why they ported that version to modern platforms. Pretty much everything from FES that isn't The Answer is included, plus the confirmation of brand new events unique to this version.
The Answer is divisive for it's dull gameplay and questionable story choices, and they even avoided adapting it for the series of Persona 3 animated movies. But we may get a new epilogue as DLC.
I can understand this not having everything from every version of P3 plus new stuff on top, because it's a remake of a near 20 year old game with a runtime of 80 hours for it's base version, let alone Answer's extra 30 and the entire second campaign from Portable. You'd be looking at a doubling of development resources for an already large project. Focus on the core that people like the most, then maybe add more later.
I'll wait it's digital only and im certain there will be several editions In the worst case I'll have to wait a little longer and Ill get it cheaper.
Wait for the inevitable complete/royal/gold/final/FU edition if you must give this terrible company money.
I really don't like that they're making it easier and avoiding the challenge for ppl to get better. That was my problem with P5. It is a easy game to strategize for like no brainer stuff.
It's to be expected as it gets mainstream.
@Flaming_Kaiser
Digital only?
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0CGFBJ4T2/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
I'm in the "No Femc no purchase" camp. Already put about 200 hours into Portable, not planning to buy this inferior version with less content. It doesn't even have its own original content that sets it apart from the other versions like a new playable party member, social links, story content etc. What a lazy 70$ cash grab. Good for people who've never played P3 before I guess.
After persona 4 / persona 4 golden and persona 5 / persona 5 royal I think I'll wait for the updated persona 3 royal version rather than playing this one π
What are the major additions from portable and fes that are missing here?
@CutchuSlow
1. From Persona 3 portable -Femc and her social link.
2. From Persona 3 FES-The answer,which was a new epilogue.
Everything else that is actually important is included (The journey from FES, and controllable party members, walking the dog,and Aigis social link from Portable).
1.The femc route is not much of a loss, since she technically isn't even canon,and the remake will allow you to have events with the Male party members anyway.So nothing really lost.
Hell,people don't realise how much pointless work would go into making the female route,since she isn't just a reskin of the male route. They need to make whole new events,animation, anime cuts scenes, dialogue, and music.
People don't realise that she was only done in Persona 3 Portable,because it was basically a visual novel.
2.The answer was hated both gameplaywise and storywise by everyone. Now suddenly everyone one wants it back,lol. Anyway , there is still a chance that the anwser might be replaced by a new epilogue,that hopefully it is done better this time.
The discourse around this remake has been pretty disingenuous as you can see. I am just dissapionted that push square has been one of the ring leaders spewing the negativity.
As is: I'm playing this free on release via gamepass. But if they add in the missing content, then I will definitely buy.
Will stop wait for Persona 3 RRR (Reload Royal Redux⦠or somesuch) in a few years time with all features
@rachetmarvel oh ok thanks. I will still get the game, as I've never played the previous versions.
I feel kinda betrayed by Atlus for the scammy practices like asking full price for the 60 fps upgrade on PS5. Also Persona is a series that people associate with Playstation. I'm happy that xbox users can play it too but being in bed with Microsoft and putting it in Game Pass while loyal fans have to pay $70 feels kinda unfair. I will still play it ofc.
@dimi Isn't it a full remake? that doesn't seem like a scam to me its not like they are just porting it and adding better framerate
@AsterZero
You know well that Atlus is going to charge $60 for the other editions with few improvements with each iteration. Makes me not want to buy the game. It better be 60fps, I dont want to see no bs about keeping the integrity of the style.
i played the portable version 2 years ago. never played the other versions.
a really charming rpg, im eager to see how it will be with their new game engine.
@Moonvalley_PS I heard digital only here?
@Flaming_Kaiser
Well i want that sweet Aigis figurine.
@Logonogo yeah it's a full remake, it worth full price. I was talking about what they did with PS5R upgrade.
@dimi my bad, I thought when you said PS5 you were talking about Playstation 5
@Moonvalley_PS It was already sold out so nothing for me I'll just go for the disc then. π’
@Flaming_Kaiser
Should be back in stock on amazon. It says temporarily out of stock. Who knows π€
@Moonvalley_PS But I think it's only in the US the I'll have to ask a friend to order it I don't have a credit card. π
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...