It’s been a big year for PlayStation – many would argue a vintage year, in fact. While the selection of first-party software from Sony has been a little on the light side, third-parties have more than picked up the slack, producing bangers like Baldur’s Gate 3, Alan Wake 2, and so, so, so much more. As has become something of a Push Square tradition, we’ll be spending the Christmas months recapping our favourites, from today right through to New Year’s Day. (And honestly a little bit beyond that, too.)
We pride ourselves on producing a festive Game of the Year fiesta to keep you occupied while you’re chomping down on leftover turkey, and that’s no different this year. In addition to our esteemed team’s personal picks, we’ve also got a cavalcade of individual categories, as well as our overall top ten – voted for by our editors and the community alike. We’ve always wanted to keep you, the readers, included in our top ten – and that remains true this year as well. Hopefully you enjoy reading through the results.
In the meantime, our video editor Aaron has produced a brilliant video recapping all the best PlayStation games from 2023, and we’ve embedded that above to whet your appetite for the main course. Which game do you reckon has got Game of the Year in the bag? Pick a winner in the comments section below.
Comments 45
Toss up between Alan Wake 2 and Lies of P for me
There can be only one! (And it’s Zelda)
Armoured Core is probably the best game I've played on the ps5 this year. I borrowed Spiderman 2 from a mate and started it yesterday. It's fun, but nothing special, more of the same really. Sony should be pretty embarrassed about their output this year, as should Microsoft. Nintendo has wiped the floor with both of them. The sheer amount of quality games on the switch has be staggering.
The switch has had:
Fire Emblem Engage
Metroid Prime Remastered
Pikmin 4
Bayonetta Origins: Cereza Bayo Spin off
Advance Wars 1&2 remake
Warioware: Move it
A load of new Mario Kart dlc
Xenoblade 3 dlc
Zelda Tears of the Kingdom
Mario Wonder
Mario RPG remake
I'm probably missing a few others too. It makes you wonder what the others are doing. How can they mismanage their studios so badly while another can release so many good games in one year? The decision to close Japan Studio by Sony was so unbelievably short sighted. A couple of games like Puppeteer or Gravity Rush would have gone a long way.
It really is all about what you actually played. For me it's FF16 as I've never played BG3 or half of the other contenders.
I didn’t play many 2023 games this year. I’m a pretty new gamer so I’ve mostly stuck to older games in the ps plus catalog. Having said that I loved Tchia and surprised it’s not really mentioned in people’s favorite games this year. I thought the story was nice, the music was great and was just a real fun time.
Perfect opportunity to give Starfield PlayStation game of the year for the giggles.
@Old-Red for one thing, a realistic looking game takes longer to make than most of the games you mentioned. Pretty sure Sony is far from embarrassed considering that it's dominating the market.
"A couple of games like Puppeteer or Gravity Rush would have gone a long way."
Both brilliant games that hardly anyone played. Not sure what "would have gone a long way" refers to. At the end of day, other than a few hardcore gamers, everyone else couldn't care less about them (unfortunately).
@naruball "Pretty sure Sony is far from embarrassed considering that it's dominating the market."
This is precisely my point, they should be. The fact that they feel like they're doing it right whilst laying off so many people across their studios is upsetting.
"Both brilliant games that hardly anyone played. Not sure what "would have gone a long way" refers to. At the end of day, other than a few hardcore gamers, everyone else couldn't care less about them (unfortunately)."
They would have gone a long way to actually adding something back to the industry whilst creating more jobs and raising their reputation for experimenting with some low risk new ideas. It's not all about realistic looking retreads of the same tired blockbusters.
@Old-Red Remakes and Remasters don’t count as real games, everyone who hates PlayStation knows that. Nor do games made by third party developers. You also randomly included games from 2022 like Bayonetta 3 and Mario + Rabbids.
Additionally you included a bunch of DLC, but DLC is bad because it just means the developers shipped an incomplete game and it’s not worth playing until the complete edition comes out(has to be a physical edition with 100% of content on the disc too, or it’s a rubbish cash grab).
You also listed WarioWare 😅
@Old-Red
Retreads and tired blockbusters from the dude celebrating Zelda 26 and Mario 39 and about half a dozen remasters.
My top 3:
1- Final Fantasy 16
2 - Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom
3 - Quake 2
It’s been a fantastic year though overall.
Well this is a tough one for me because I've enjoyed all 4 games equally and all for different reasons so here goes in no particular order:-
1) hogwarts legacy
2)diabolo 4
3)lies of p
4)lords of the fallen
These 4 games have taken up almost the entire time I've spent gaming this year and I've loved every minute spent.
This is a PlayStation GoY so I won't list other platforms but It has been a great year, I haven't played everything yet but from what I have my top 3 would probably be SM2, RE4 (1st time paying) & Robocop. BG3 and AW2 are in the back log and no doubt BG will win.
@ChrisDeku you make some valid points, but it doesn't change that fact that I feel like I've got so much more from a console on its last legs than one that should be at its peak and in full flow.
I'm not a Sony hater, I'm just disappointed with how complacent they've become whilst chasing the live service trend that no one asked for. Both Zelda and Mario have so many new ideas and such creativity that dismissing then as retreads isn't really fair.
As for Warioware, it's not a game I'm personally interested in, but I'm glad it exists and they still release something different from the rest of the market. I'm sure I'll pick it up for cheap one day and get a few hours of fun out of it with a few mates and some beers down the line.
I was just being flippant, I absolutely value those games. Super Mario World is probably my favourite game of all time, but at the end of the day the resources required to make a 9 hour 2d platformer are small compared to some vast AAA cinematic game. I completely admit that Tears of the Kingdoms production is a vast undertaking in line with big AAA games.
@ChrisDeku I suppose I didn't want to let Sony and Microsoft off the hook for generally doing more damage than good for the industry in what has been one of the most amazing years for games ever. A lot of people have lost their jobs in 2023 due to greed and mismanagement.
In the spirit of the actual topic I'd say my top PlayStation games this year have been:
1: Armoured Core 6
2: Resident Evil 4 Remake
3: Spiderman 2
4: Final Fantasy 16
5: Jedi Star Wars: survivor
I haven't got round to Baldur's Gate 3 or Alan Wake 2 as I'm waiting for the physical releases next year and finding the time to actually play them.
@Old-Red If I like all kind of games also remasters my favorite was Demon Souls it brought back so many fantastic memories. My all time favorite brought back with new enhancements, running rocksolid and looking fantastic.
We all talk about gives developers time to do their best and bring their best games. Isn't it quite weird to say you need to bring the most beautiful games on a yearly base.
Sony released games when they are done and in the start they announced them early and people got mad. Now they make games and start to tell us when they are nearly done or if they worked on it for a long enough time to make a announcement and people get mad.
Third party releases that get funded by Sony are also there because of Sony people tend to forget that. And one other thing people want 100 million plus games that need to look brilliant, long playtime no monetization and no we don't want to pay €10 more. You need to sell 14,3 million games to make you that back with €70 and thats without the advertising.
Smaller games are useless and if a game is a 7 it's not worth my time. People get mad about the Japanese studio from Sony that gets shutdown the don't make enough money because they don't sell enough are expensive to get made a language barriers make it more difficult.
I wish I would see some smaller games that don't have a 100 million budget so they can take some changes.
I'm really sad that a smaller studio like PixelOpus is gone I would not be surprised if they could not cope with the pressure the need to make a big game. We need more small games without a massive budget to fill the time. It's insane to think they can make games with a 100 million budget for every year.
I can only dream about something like a Dark Cloud I don't need state of the art graphics to have fun just a nice looking game that is fun to play.
@Old-Red I agree with you that Nintnedo has had an amazing year, so many great games and all pure fun to play. But I also realise that this is the case every year, Nintendo always release double what Sony and Microsoft release. And that's down to production costs and the design of the games, one Sony game probably costs the same as 5-6 Nintendo games and take twice as long to develop due to more voice acting, realistic visual design and motion capture etc. Even Microsoft with low having over 30 studios are aiming for 3-4 releases per year which is still not as much as Nintendo. Nintendo aim for cartoony visuals that run off mobile hardware and have short development cycles and also employ a lot of second party studios to make games like Pokémon, Fire Emblem and Kirby, so take second party devs away then they would have less games per year, Nintendo own a lot of great IP's but not the studios that make them. Also the more powerful Nintendo's hardware gets every gen the more development time games will take, I mean between main Zelda games your now looking at 6-7 years and main mario games is the same.
My top playstation games this year have been,
1, Final Fantasy 16
2, Fate Samurai/Remnant
3, Hogwarts Legacy
4, Monochrome Mobius
5, The Legend of Nayuta
And to be honest I only see two of these getting top 10 on this site.
@Old-Red
'It's not all about realistic looking retreads of the same tired blockbusters.'
I cant believe you wrote that line whilst spamming out a list of ninty titles with not a single new Ip and some tired dlc.
I suspect the irony of your statements will go straight over your head.
Like what you like, but at least maintain a cogent argument...
My personal picks this year:
Sea of Stars.
Zelda TOK
BG3
FF16
The Crew Motorfest
Most disappointed in:
Forza Motorsport
Starfield. Put plenty of hours into both, but had little fun.
Its been a fantastic year for games.
A fantastic year for gaming indead, definitely more Smeagol than Gollum.
Love GotY ! It's a push square tradition !
(sub title reminded me of that Whitesnake song - so thanks for that . "CLASSIC !" )
@Titntin I was talking more about the actual content of the games themselves. Yes they are sequels, but they have all brought in new ideas, mechanics and creativity. Spiderman 2 is the exact same game I've played twice already and that's all Sony had offered this year. My issue isn't with sequels, it's with creativity and I don't see Sony making any genuine GOTYs any time soon with their current strategy.
Don't get me wrong, I'm enjoying Spiderman 2 (mostly cause i didn't pay for it), but if it costs that much time, money and effort to make something so similar to the last two they're focusing on on the wrong elements in my opinion.
Phantom Liberty for me.
I agree with those that said Nintendo wiped the floor with the competition… yet again. Switch has had the best line-up nearly every year though, so it’s no surprise. Publisher of the year, easily.
However, Sony was the platform I played my top two though (across all platforms my top 5):
1. Alan Wake 2
2. FF16
3. Mario Wonder
4. TotK
5. Pikmin 4
Sony only:
1. Alan Wake 2
2. FF16
3. RE4
4. Cocoon
5. Hogwarts/Forspoken (too hard to pick between the two for me)
What an incredible year… and honestly… I still feel like my top 5 keeps changing. It’s hard to keep it still, outside the top 2.
My top games I’ve played this year are:
1) Lies of P
2) Alan Wake 2
3) Baldur’s Gate 3
4) RE4 Remake
5) Octopath Traveler 2
Honorable mentions include Cyberpunk 2077; Metroid Prime Remastered; Dead Space Remake; The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom; Red Dead Redemption Remastered; Final Fantasy 16; Spider-Man 2; and lastly, Sea of Stars.
Does Push Square only consider games released on the PlayStation for the awards article?
Sorting out a top 10 has been a challenge for me let alone a top 5. At the end of it all, Final Fantasy XVI made the biggest impression on me. What a great year for gaming. Great video!
@Callmegil Aslong as its on playstation consoles then it will be considered. So games like Zelda and Starfield are not included.
@UltimateOtaku91 Understood. I was thinking more in lines of released on PC or released on mobile and then lately released on PS (i.e. Honkai Star Rail)
1 Baldurs Gate 3
2 Hogwarts Legacy
3 Final Fantasy 16
I’ve spent a long time playing Starfield which I like, but bad writing (and questionable game design choices) drag it down to a 75/100.
Easily Final Fantasy 16 for me
BLUEY is my GOTY 2023.
Street fighter 6 and it's not even close
I should be hitting the 200 hr mark later today on BG3. Just a stunning video game experience. To the extent that if I don't see it on a GOTY list, I assume the list maker hasn't played it. Tho of course this could also reflect genre preferences. Truly a stunning achievement worthy of the mountains of praise.
Other favorite games released in 2023 I think of in terms of polish and enjoyment, but weren't quite as revelatory or revolutionary for me. So that would be Hogwarts and Spiderman 2. Both fun engaging experiences with a dash of gameplay magic (webslinging thru NYC for example) thrown in and both are superb extensions of the overall franchise.
As for new to me favorites from past years, really enjoyed both Horizon Zero Down and Persona 5 Royal.
Alan wake 2 for me. Followed by spidey 2 and hogwarts.
Then every other game released this year comes before zelda. I hate breathe of the wild that much I cant bring myself to play Tears of the kingdom, but the hate has bled over to it so much its in last place.
1.baldur's gate 3.2. 🕷spiderman 2.3.dead space remake.4.octopath traveler 2.5.alan wake 2.6.final fantasy 16.7.lies of p.8.remnant from the ashes.9.star wars jedi survivor.10.resident evil 4 remake.word up son
@naruball yeah but it's not 'dominating'.. atm SM2 sits in 4th best-selling, behind:
1.Hogwarts Legacy.
2.Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3.
3.The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom.
4.Spiderman 2
Resi evil 4 Psvr2
Texas chainsaw massacre
Hogwarts Legacy
@Old-Red "This is precisely my point, they should be. The fact that they feel like they're doing it right whilst laying off so many people across their studios is upsetting."
Couldn't agree more. Been saying it for a while. When you continuous make record profits, laying people off seems even worse. Like you said, they could instead make smaller games, but hardly anyone cares either for them or for such games. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. So, they're unlikely to do anything about it. Though overall I'm happy with Sony's output, I do miss the more experimental games they were making and the attitude they had that out of our 10 games, 6 won't be profitable, but the rest will more than make up the difference.
@jedinite Actually it is. Not only is it selling far better than the competition in terms of hardware, but 3/4 of those games are available on ps5 and sell best on p5.
@ChrisDeku "Retreads and tired blockbusters from the dude celebrating Zelda 26 and Mario 39 and about half a dozen remasters."
Gotta agree with this. Used to love Nintendo, but after Mario after Mario and Pokemon after Pokemon game, I had enough.
I vote for Days Gone.
Yeah, it released in 2019, but it's still better than anything released this year. 🤷🏻♂️
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...