Sony's been plotting an Uncharted movie for as long as this website has consumed bandwidth, but the project seems closer to becoming a reality than it's ever been. That's all fine and dandy, but the problem is that Naughty Dog's denied having any involvement with the project. And to make matters worse, scriptwriter Joe Carnahan keeps insinuating the opposite.
As part of a wide-ranging interview, he told Collider the following: "I'm very happy with the script, and listen it was important that I got Amy Hennig's approval, her and Nolan North, and what I've heard is the Naughty Dog guys are really happy with it. But who knows? That could be like Donald Trump hearing something; that may not be true at all."
The problem is that writer Neil Druckmann says the developer knows absolutely nothing about the film. "Wish he'd stop implying that he has our support," the clearly agitated scribe wrote on Twitter. It's not the first time Carnahan has insinuated some kind of collaboration with Naughty Dog, and it's also not the first time that Druckmann has very publicly called him out.
The problem here is that this whole messy situation doesn't exactly portray the picture of unity that Sony's trying to paint. Look, we understand that the company wants to leverage its game brands to prop up its ailing movie division – that makes sense. But clearly it needs to get Naughty Dog involved in some capacity – this is its baby after all.
Now, in the defence of the Japanese giant, it may not have even approved Carnahan's script yet, and it may be looking to run it past the developer before it settles upon a final draft. But shouldn't the studio be involved in the creative process a little earlier than that? We'd argue that it should. Either way, none of this looks good.
[source collider.com]
Comments 26
He said it wrote the script as a Rated R movie. That doesnt fit the tone of Uncharted to me. ND NEEDS to be more involved if this is going to have a chance at being good. They should be doing the script then Carnahan adapting that script.
Considering how long the project has been in limbo, it's probably for the best. The back and forth certainly doesn't help matters.
I try to be optimistic about video game movies, but I just can't see it working out well for Uncharted.
@DerMeister I agree that getting Naughty Dog involved means that the movie's probably never going to happen, but I'm not sure having your creative director getting all tetchy on Twitter is particularly good news either.
Considering Amy Hennig hasn't been at ND for a LONG time now, Its possible she saw the original outline for a script before she left and was OK with it. Personally I preferred her 'vision' and more Indiana Jones feel to the story compared to the last, more 'Goonies' inspired plot.
Anyway, as I said before, many authors don't have any say on the film adaptations of their books. Some turned out as great movies. The games do have a lot insight into the characters and their backstory so its not as if the source material isn't there to write a good movie with or without ND. Whether that turns out as 'good PR' though or not (I'd say Not) and impacts the movie - time will tell. It could work to its advantage by lowering expectation...
@get2sammyb Yeah, and Druckmann sounds pretty peeved too. Might be calling it too soon, but this could possibly play a part in the film getting axed.
This movie is never coming out.
The guy said Amy Henning and Nolan North liked it, 2 people who do NOT work at Naughty Dog, so I don't see how he lied. Maybe he emailed them a copy and they replied, "Sure, great, whatever, have fun."
I don't see why ND has to be involved at all, they make video game graphics and user interfaces, none of that need be in a movie. And they make bullet sponges. It's OK if people die in a movie getting shot in the face only 4 times, it doesn't have to take 5 bullets to keep them down. And that rope swinging in U4 isn't even remotely believable. If that was in a movie people would laugh and walk out.
Makes a great game, but a game isn't a movie.
Frankly, to me it's more important the movie gets Amy Hennig's seal of approval than Naughty Dog's. It may be an ND property, it's her creation. Also think Nolan North's opinion on the matter carries more weight than ND's since he's the one who brought Nathan Drake to life.
Amy hennig version of uncharted 4 suck, I still remember the trailer, it seems sam drake is the bad guy in that game. Amy hennig make uncharted 3 while neil druckmann make the last of us and uncharted 4 (new), we all know which game is better compared to uncharted 3.
Rather than making this movie and dragging uncharted name down if the movie bomb, sony should just just cancel it.
We never got to play Amy Hennig's Uncharted 4, can't say if it would've sucked or not.
This will be awful, waste of time & money.
Either way they better get on with it otherwise the film will be released and people will be saying "Uncharted, really? My grandchildren used to play that on those old 2D non-immersive boxes."
Joe Carnahan is not a bad film maker all told, Narc and the Grey are pretty good films and I liked Smoking Aces. However, he is a bit of a contentious personality and he has had a few problems getting his films made and falling out with studio. He also, apparently, has the script for this film, the script for X-Force (new Xmen film) and is also remaking The Raid as writer/Director.
Sony's film division are pushing for this as they want new franchises. I expect he has delivered to the Studio and they have assured him that ND and everyone are happy with it as they want it made.
I would be very surprise if his script is filmed personally. He is talking it up to get it made.
@3Above Although he goes about it in a fairly light hearted way, Drake is pretty much a mass murderer so R rated isn't too far off the mark haha
@wiiware We really don't know what Amy Hennigs vision was for Uncharted 4 and what (if anything) actually remained. Sam was alluded to but not necessarily as a 'brother'. The first trailer just had a voice-over - “you left me in that hell hole” and “I lost 15 years of my life” which maybe wasn't a 'brother' but a 'friend/partner' that Druckman and co changed to be Nates brother to fit the outline of the Plot. Would Nate have gone on the Mission for an 'old' friend he hasn't seen for 15yrs, leaving behind his wife? People assume that the original trailer was alluding to Sam because of the final game but whether or not that was who Amy had in mind, we don't actually know. She left (possibly due to unconfirmed 'creative differences') soon after Druckman came in and they said they scrapped 8months of work to rewrite the game.
Personally, I think the Story is very different to the previous 3, the characters are different too in a few ways as well. Visually its stunning and it certainly plays well but I can't help feel the Story wasn't as 'fantastic' as the previous 3, that it was more 'Goonies' than the previous 3 which were more Indiana Jones. The Last of Us influence was clear and it feels like Druckman wanted to close down Uncharted to push his own 'projects'. Of course the game is still good - it still lives up to the standards ND have set but I do feel its missing something that the others had.
Unless Amy Hennig actually comes out and says what her vision was and whether or not she wanted Drake to continue beyond the 4th game, we won't know.
There's very few movies based on video games that are any good. So far, I'm not optimistic about this one.
@BAMozzy Story wise, uncharted 3 is a disappoinment, the bad guy (the old woman, katherine marlowe) scold charlie cutter (her henchman but actually nate friends) because he shoot nate, but in the next couple of scene nate shoot a lot of katherine henchman, katherine is a better man/woman than nate
The story also repeat victor sullivan getting shot like uncharted 1, and it really weird seeing nate & elena separate again, after getting all comfy in the end of uncharted 1 and 2. It's cheapen the ending of those 2 games.
Uncharted 1 is a fun game but have too many shooting gallery, uncharted 2 pacing is perfect, but when playing uncharted 3 I just want it to end. It's a good game, but it's a 8 game compared to uncharted 2 & 4 perfect 10. Uncharted series from the one I like most is uncharted 2, 4, 1 and the last one is 3.
Imho.
@Gamer83 Maybe suck is too strong a word, just a good game compared to excellent uncharted 2 & 4 is more apt.
@kreativekontroll R rated is more consistent with The Last of Us than Uncharted. No matter how many ppl die the games are Rated Teen but TLoU is not. So i hope he knows what hes doing IF this movie does happen.
like i said before, if you want a Uncharted movie let Naughty Dog do a CG one so it looks and sounds how the games do, it could even fit into the games chronology then
not everything has to be adapted to live action you know
I think the Sony Pictures hack showed us all we needed to know about Sony Pictures. It has a very different mindset from SIE.
@ZurapiiYohane Thats what i was going to say, when i first saw Logan i said forget a Uncharted move. Get Hugh Jackman the way he looks in Logan because that's 100% Joel, this is This Last Of Us film with music as well.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbug3zTm3Ws
@wiiware
Uncharted 2 is the best in the series, and that was Amy Hennig's game. I'd agree with you 3 had certain aspects of it that I didn't like, but one area it did shine well above 4 was the villains. Imo, 4 has the two absolute worst villains in the franchise. Rafe served no purpose other than to be a foil. He was poorly developed and as cliche as it gets (the jealous, ex-business partner). Nadine may be my least favorite character in the series, because Neil Druckmann wanted to throw in a feminist wet dream so whatever. I know people won't like that statement but it's the truth (he's very outspoken about his philosophies and I actually have no problem with that because at least he isn't two-faced about it or trying to hide anything). Only villain in the series who never got her comeuppance and couldn't be touched at all, eventhough Nate had no problem taking down everybody else.
This isn't to trash Uncharted 4 though, it's a great game and my second favorite in the series, and has some of my favorite Uncharted moments of ever (The Brothers Drake chapter is fantastic) and the gameplay is the most refined. Still, the story, setting, set pieces, villains, everything but the gameplay (which is still very good) in 2 stands head and shoulders above 4. In some ways I also prefer 1's story over 4's so I stand by that I prefer Hennig's work on the series over Druckmann.
@Gamer83 The best villain is in the uncharted 2 (war criminal so it's okay to shoot them) and uncharted 1 (pirate that take no prisoner so it's okay to shoot them too). Uncharted 4 villain is not that bad of a person, one man jealous of nate accomplishment (rafe), and the other one (nadine) just doing their job at the mercenary gig. I disagree uc 3 villain is better than uc 4 villain though, uc 3 villain is just forgettable.
Also at least the enemy in uc 1,2 are clearly criminal and the enemy in uc 4 is mercenary (getting shoot is part of the job), the regular enemy in uc3 is just normal people.
Neil druckman is a game designer of uncharted 2. Still, after seeing the last of us and uncharted 4, given the choice of amy or neil, I take neil
I like uc 4 story better because the thing that you search for (the pirate treasure/colony) has a back story too and not just a mcguffin to advance the story like in uc 1, 2, and 3. I genuinely want to know what really happened on the pirate colony.
Personally, if this film ever sees the light of day but the Naughty Dog guys aren't behind it, I'm probably not gonna watch it. Just seems wrong if the creators aren't happy with the project and I'd rather not support that.
Uncharted 3 copies too many of U2's story beats, but I actually preferred it as a game. Both games had great setpieces, but I really enjoyed the looks into Nathan Drake's youth in 3, the villain was more interesting (2 has the most boring, generic villain in the entire series, imo), and, aside from the ending with the djinns, it lacked any annoying chapters (U2 had the chapter where you're trying to destroy the tank, which was miserable, the yeti chapter, which seemed like the point where the game jumped the shark, and another terrible ending chapter where you end up fighting lame Kratos-esque monsters).
Uncharted 4 is, far and away, the best game in the series, though. While the long lost brother angle is kind of hokey, the game's narrative is excellent, as it both provides an exciting action-adventure romp AND deconstructs the psychology of Nathan Drake's adventurer persona. Combat is really, really good, with stealth and the rope adding huge amounts of dynamism to fights, making the game feel like much less of a cover shooter than previous entries. The game has a superb climax, which finally makes VERY limited use of supernatural influences, instead of mobbing you with generic video game monster enemies. Also, actual exploration and substantive character development. It was great.
Only flaw in the game is Nadine, who doesn't feel properly integrated into the narrative. Her only function appears to be to provide unwinnable boss fights. She has no real narrative arc and nothing really changes when she disappears at the end of the game.
@ZurapiiYohane Just add an additional gameplay mode to Uncharted 1-4 that automatically plays Drake for you in the "between cutscenes" portions. Uncharted movie complete.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...