Where do you even start with Red Dead Redemption 2? The game's a modern masterpiece and developer Rockstar's best ever release. Mature storytelling combines with one of, if not the best open world in gaming, and the result is a phenomenal experience from start to finish.
Red Dead Redemption 2 may not be crowned our Game of the Year for 2018, but we reckon Arthur Morgan is the year's greatest character. Flawed and influenced by your in-game actions, Arthur is brilliantly worked throughout the 60 hour campaign. When we saw him in that first reveal trailer, looking rather plain and predictably angry, we would never have thought that he'd end up being such a superb lead.
But it's not just Arthur. Red Dead Redemption 2 arguably has the strongest cast of 2018, with each and every outlaw committing themselves to our memories long after the credits roll. The clashing personalities of the Van der Linde gang keep the tension perfectly poised throughout the entire game, and watching it all unfold makes for one of the best told stories in gaming.
And boy what a story it is. Admittedly things start out slow as Arthur and the group attempt to keep a low profile, but later on, when the sh*t really hits the fan, Red Dead Redemption 2 turns everything to 11 and never looks back. Gripping is an understatement.
Narrative gushing aside, the overall quality of Rockstar's latest alone is enough to put it above most games on the market. This is an open world title that somehow has the polish of a Naughty Dog game. Everything is immaculate, from the countless little animations that most players may never even see to the excellent presentation and direction. Without a doubt, Red Dead 2 is the most cinematic open world game ever made.
Take a step back from the serious stuff and there's still so much to love about Red Dead 2. You can spend hours upon hours just hunting and fishing, or roaming the game's absurdly detailed world. There are so many secrets and strange happenings to discover, and even now, players are still finding things mysteries that have so far gone unsolved.
Red Dead Redemption 2 raises the bar for what we expect from an open world title. Pretty much a perfect prequel, it's got all of the action, all of the drama, and all of the grit that you could want from a game set in late 1800s America. Red Dead Redemption 2 isn't just one of the best releases of 2018, it's one of the most memorable, masterfully crafted games ever made.
Please note that some external links on this page are affiliate links, which means if you click them and make a purchase we may receive a small percentage of the sale. Please read our FTC Disclosure for more information.
Is Red Dead Redemption 2 one of your favourite games of 2018? Stand unshaken in the comments section below.
Comments 43
Color me shocked that this wasn't your #1 on this site. All signs kept pointing to it being. Well congrats you guys got it right.
I have so many complaints about this game but the fact I poured almost 100 hours into one playthrough of the single player campaign says it all really.
Despite me being super critical of certain plot points, mission structures and the controls, the game is absolutely brilliant at so many things.
So Fallout 76 for number 1 then. Can't think of any other game that came out that came out this year that is in contention, no sir... can't think of a single one.
Don't rule The Quiet Man out just yet folks...
@AdamNovice
It may miss the top spot just because there's no cross play.
A fantastic game and one of the best open worlds in any game. I've said before that I've never spent so long in a game world doing so little but still enjoying it so much.
The story is a bit off in places and I wish we knew a bit more about Dutch than we got but Arthur really is a great (anti)hero.
EDIT: and what a great character Sadie is! If they do go for single player DLC (I wish), then focussing on her would be great.
Incredible game! So immersive, with a brilliant cast and an unrivalled open world.
Bought this, wanted to love it, but it just sucks the fun out of playing games, it's so slow to play., and when will rockstar sort out the control methods of their games.. sick of clicking x to run for gods sake... . traded it in only 30% complete. Couldn't stand another long horse ride, and when my horse fell and died and I had to walk, that was the end !!! Some say this game was immersive, i say it was just boring.. Got my money back and went back to assassins creed odyssey, which is actually fun to play. Thankfully you didn't make it number one
A truly, truly amazing game, in my opinion. Even though I finished it a while back, I still think of all the gang and Arthur Morgan is now one of my favourite ever protagonists. There's only a handful of games that have made me emotional as much as this one.
Thankyou, Rockstar Games.
@ApostateMage Same here. When the story involves a big family, you care for everyone. Like the family in Dishonored 1 made you care about everyone, something which was missing in 2. You look back and feel sorry for those who couldn't make it, and the ones that did gets you wondering where'd they go, what happened to them... I'm near RDR2'S end, after I'll concentrate fully on God of War and make my judgement. And oh, the soundtrack of RDR2 is terrific, deserves that award.
I knew it, the Shenmue 1&2 remaster will finally claim the top spot of 2018!
«Red Dead Redemption 2 isn't just one of the best releases of 2018, it's one of the most memorable, masterfully crafted games ever made.» NO! it’s simply overhyped.
This is just a few gameplay quirks and some stupid decisions away from being the best game ever and to me it's the second best game of the year FOR SURE!
That's not bad AT ALL considering the great games we had this year (the best ever possibly)!
But I'm surprised you guys put it at second place at the same time I'm happy! You madlads!
Sorry for double posting.
@AlekseyVolkov why is it overhyped? It's one of the best games ever, no arguing in that!
I love this game!! So immersive and detailed, thanks to Rockstar. For me, truly sets the bar about story telling and immersion in an open world action game. Still not finished it yet and while I normally sell games after I finish playing with them and never replay games, I know this will be a keeper and will get a second play through. If God of war is better than this, I can't wait to play it!!
I see we're well into the "universally praised blockbuster is actually complete trash and one of the worst games ever" part of the cycle when it comes to Red Dead 2.
I guess when you sell 17 million copies in three days the sample size for opinions becomes so huge that it's only natural.
I fear for open world games releasing next year, because they're really going to struggle to live up to Red Dead 2.
@get2sammyb Yeah. Poor Days Gone. I fear it will struggle.
I can’t help but feeling an overstatuation of instant gratification has made some people not like this game. Not all who don’t like it, but I think it’s slower pace and more methodical controls are good for the industry and set an example of how everything doesn’t need to be snappy and instant. Not every character you play as should be an acrobat who can roll his way up a mountain while getting shot at.
I still think its the best game this year if not this generation. I know that the controls are somewhat sluggish, HDR isn't well implemented and its 'slow' to start but the game is technically on another level in so many areas - even more so than Uncharted which was linear. NPC's that all react to you and your actions and a world that 'evolves' with you. Little details like a bullet-hole remaining in your hat for example is astounding. Its raised the bar not only for open world games but also linear games too. If a linear game doesn't have the interaction, the attention to detail etc that this has, it could well be criticised because an open world game can do it...
In some ways, the attention to detail etc is its downfall too - spending 20mins just looting dead bodies, seeing the animation of turning people over (if face down), searching through pockets etc for loot is 'slow' compared to just sprinting around and miraculously picking up everything nearby. Can be annoying to have to pick your loadout from your horse and not carry 'every' weapon in a weapon wheel to just switch between on the fly. Can be annoying to have to go looking for your hat after its been knocked/shot off and then have the animation of bending down, examining the hat before putting it on etc but its on another level compared to any other game.
I know GoW wasn't as slow, combat was more fun and the HDR was better implemented but from a technical perspective, the game is quite old-school - well polished but still not pushing gaming forward. Maybe that helped with the moment to moment game-play as it's a much 'simpler' game in a LOT of areas. Being much more linear too may help the story pacing as well but it was a much simpler game technically too. You can see where they built in 'hidden' loading areas that loaded up the 'next' zone as you progressed on the path - at least they often filled this with 'dialogue' to alleviate the 'trudge' - those long, empty cave boat rides for example loading in the next zone and made less boring by some dialogue whilst you travelled. Not saying its 'bad' but its hardly revolutionary.
This is why I have to give it to RDR2. The fact that it also runs on multiple platforms, not built around just one and 'tailored' for that hardware, with very little 'difference' other than resolution is also testament to the developers. I know that some here won't care because its Xbox or that the Pro version doesn't implement CB rendering as well as GoW, but its still a remarkable achievement...
@PSfan4Life22 yeah I’ve been saying the same thing so I’ll admit I was wrong and I’ve never been happier to be wrong lol because I think gow is easily the goty
A great game without a doubt, with a really great campaign, cast, soundtrack and missions. Arthur is awesome, impressive how Rockstar created another unforgettable main character.
I prefer the stranger missions of the first game and didn’t like the side-quests that much, but let’s focus in the positive aspects.
Red Dead Redemption 2 is my third favorite game this year.
@Jaz007 but he sure can roll down a mountain while getting shot at lol. Ive took many a tumble.
@PSfan4Life22 I would be shocked if GoW wasn't number 1 on this site considering its playstation centric site. Fan meltdown would be too heavy for them. From the get go I expected rdr2 to be number 2 and gow number 1.
@get2sammyb cyberpunk 2077 says hi but it most likely won't come out 2019 lol
@MonkeyDLuffy19 Yeah, Cyberpunk 2077 currently looks like the only game that could realistically top it.
@get2sammyb
You mean you fear for their review scores I suppose?
RDR or not, the other games still will be great for gamers. Not everyone wants to compare the incomparable.
@Th3solution
I feel Days Gone is perfect open world game to play after RDR2. It's gameplay is faster with better combats. It doesn't have to be the same living world. Heck it's more like a dying world
Also the dynamics weather might be even more meaningful. Wait and see
@AlekseyVolkov
Did you mean overrated? Sound more like the typical criticism people who don't enjoy a game that others did.
Ultimately, hype is a very personal thing. When you get hyped it's your own doing
Game of The Year contender? More like Snore of The Year contender.
Roasting aside I hope those of you who bought the game are enjoying your time with it.
@R1spam
I agree but people have a funny approach to comparing games. GOW isn't better and RDR2 isn't better. They are just very, very different games.
@JJ2 I just think it's going to be hard to top, and the comparisons will be unavoidable.
@get2sammyb I enjoyed the game but red dead did feel like a slog at times I was going to play red dead online but thought clear space so mixing kingdom hearts whatever game lol with xenoblade 2.
@get2sammyb
Ha OK.
I set RDR2 as the game of the gen long ago so I'm sorted and I'm not really expecting it to be topped. Looking forwards to being surprised with no fear at all. Days Gone Is the game Ive been looking forwards the most but not asking it to 'top' anything if it makes sense.
Edit
I do get it for a franchise though. A new entry has the pressure to top the previous game....
@LN78 Happy New Year! Good to see you’ve been playing Red Dead Redemption 2!
I didnt even finish this game.Lifes to busy i can only manage 1hr/2hr of gaming and this game requires you to really dig deeper and spend more time unlocking what it has to offer i cant do that in 1hr blocks its too slow and is essentially go from point A to point B and it just burned me out. Good game but not game of the year.
@ShogunRok Call of Duty do i need to say more.
I can't really argue with this even if for me personally it's not a game I really enjoyed due to its many niggling issues. There can be no doubt that on a technical level this is beyond anything I've played this generation, it's just a shame that it often gets in the way of the gameplay. The story, graphics and sound design are all fantastic, however one thing I can't agree is that it creates a new standard for open worlds as the mission structure is far too rigid and controlling and for all the smoke and mirrors you have no influence on the game at all. If we're talking open worlds than The Witcher 3 is still king for story telling whilst Breath of the Wild is miles ahead of this in terms of interaction with its world
Overall a game which I respect but cannot love, maybe I'll return to it in the new year with a fresh perspective to give it another chance
Superb game. Bit on the long side for me, but an incredible achievement however you slice it.
@roe nothing wrong with the game
@Mistameena your're joking right?
@AFCC gameplay quirks? What?
Amazing game, great story, superior voice acting. Terrible controls on foot especially in buildings. Missions are sometimes too closed leading to premature fails as you haven't done it the railroaded Rockstar way. I miss the old GTA3 engine days where it would say "go here and assassinate this guy" and you could choose to do so by landing a helicopter on top of him if you could time it right and chose to fly there in one.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...