Alongside the usual top 10 countdown that culminates in the crowning of Push Square's game of the year, we've decided to expand our deliberations this year. On a select couple of days we will be celebrating different types of games, from smaller indie titles to those that push the boundaries of virtual reality. Today, we're celebrating narrative. These are the games that we believe told the best stories in 2018.
Bronze Trophy: The Missing: J.J. Macfield and the Island of Memories
For those that strive for the LGBTQA community to share equality with people that consider themselves straight, The Missing: J.J. Macfield and the Island of Memories' story is perhaps the most important of 2018. A love letter to transgenderism, Swery65's latest is about figuring out who you really are as a person. What starts out as a simple search and rescue quickly develops into so much more, and it's the text conversations uncovered through gameplay that hide the biggest discoveries.
One such chat log is between J.J. and her mother, a woman who is piling pressure onto her daughter thanks to a religious mentality that is pumping suspicion into the relationships J.J. holds with other people. For our lead character, this leads to depression, self-harm, and an eventual suicide attempt. The game respectfully provides commentary on such topics, but it's the ending that really knocked our socks off. One small detail subverts the entire plot, and that's gender. The Missing is a story interwoven with beauty, as well as a celebration of what it means to be human.
Silver Trophy: Detroit: Become Human
Despite the amount of vitriol thrown at David Cage every time one of his projects comes to fruition, there's no doubting how fascinating the stories he crafts are. Alongside the likes of Fahrenheit, Heavy Rain, and Beyond: Two Souls, Detroit: Become Human is another major success for narrative-focused developer Quantic Dream with a plot that centres on the uprising of androids as they ditch their living and breathing mentors in an effort for equal rights.
As characters Kara, Connor, and Markus, your choices will shape the success or failure of the protests: former housekeeper Kara aids in the protection of a little girl named Alice before eventually joining the revolution; Connor actively attempts to stop the demonstrations as sidekick to police officer Hank Anderson, and; Markus is the leader of it all. The three characters cross paths with one another repeatedly, but they're not always on the same side. It's a fascinating sequence of events to witness when you escape police detection as Kara, to then be searching for the andoid as Connor minutes later. Detroit: Become Human doesn't tell the perfect story, but what it attempts is ambitious, largely successful, and most of all, captivating.
Gold Trophy: Red Dead Redemption 2
Red Dead Redemption 2 is more than just a story, it's a theme. The Van der Linde gang wants nothing more than to just keep on surviving as the decline of the Wild West brings with it more and more hardships for the group of outlaws, and with government officials on their tail, confrontation is all but impossible to avoid. As lead character Arthur Morgan, you'll do anything and everything to keep your people safe and serve gang leader Dutch, but there comes a point where you also need to start looking out for yourself.
Red Dead Redemption 2 is a story about failure. It's about the unravelling of a gang so consumed by greed that it will go to any lengths to survive, in spite of the America that's evolving around them in an attempt to kill their kind off. But most importantly, it's an utterly phenomenal narrative. What starts off slow eventually concludes with plot points and moments that live long in the memory, while twists along the way kept us guessing at every turn. It's an incredible achievement, but we think there's one tale better.
Platinum Trophy: God of War
Winning the vote by a single point is God of War. Kratos and Atreus' journey to the highest peak of the nine realms to spread the ashes of a wife and mother is a truly magical and wondrous experience from start to finish. From the moment you pick up the controller, it's clear that love, heartbreak, and family are more of a burden for the Greek god than a blessing. He resents his son Atreus, routinely barking orders at the boy while also keeping a secret from him.
It's this father and son dynamic that drives the plot forward, resulting in an arc that many people have been able to relate to while also aiding in the creation of a fantastic unfolding of events. The trip across Midgard and a whole bunch of realms is simply unforgettable thanks to supporting character Mimir's humour, the ruthless pursuit of antagonist Baldur and his nephews, and the brotherly conflict between Brok and Sindri. Culminating in a mesmerising final battle that leads to eventual revelations about identity and the true nature of those we thought we knew inside out, God of War wears its narrative crown with utter pride.
Do you agree with our choices? Is there a different story within 2018 that had you gripped much more? Turn a page and reveal all in the comments below.
Comments 45
yeap, god of war story is amazing
God of the year 2018.kratos the 👑 king.word up son
@Krest_arisen RDR2 can be summarized by saying "sluggish controls and wild west stuff" as well
Red Dead 2 for me. Aside from Yakuza 6 and Dragon Quest XI, no game came close to giving me the emotional ride that Red Dead 2 did. Story is absolutely superb, especially near the end, and Arthur Morgan is one of the most complete characters ever to appear in a video game.
God of War easily had the best story of the year. Red Dead 2 comes in a very close second for me.
Also, where's the love for A Way Out? Not even a mention in the poll, but Tacoma, Transference, and Forgotten Anne are options? That's cold.
@ShogunRok Curious, did you even play God of War? I know you're primarily an RPG guy, just wanted to know if you tried it, and what your thoughts were if you have?
@RedMageLanakyn I did indeed play God of War, bought it day one, thought it was really, really great. I've always liked the series a lot, but it's never quite clicked with me 100%.
Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't argue against God of War PS4 getting a 10/10 score and I think it's a masterfully crafted experience, but purely on a personal level, I played a bunch of games that I enjoyed more in 2018.
Do I think God of War is maybe a tiiiiiny bit overrated? Yeah, probably, but again, I'm totally fine with it being hailed as a masterpiece. Just not quite up there at the very top for me.
@ShogunRok Fair enough, I just didn't see it in your top 5 of the year either, so I was curious. I'm the same way with RDR2, got through it, but it really didn't click with me as it appears to with others, and I'm ok with all the praise it receives.
@playstation1995 God of Awards wins again, word up son.
Yeah...I’m starting to think this site is PlayStation biased. Nearly everywhere else I go I see people say Red Dead Redemption 2 had the better story. God of War is fun to play for the gameplay, but the story itself wasn’t very memorable and was actually dull. I think Arthur Morgan is a way better character.
@RedMageLanakyn I guess learning and world building is too much for some people.
@OmegaYato I guess understanding that other people's opinions might differ from your own is too much for some people as well.
I can understand why some people would give GOW GOTY, it's indeed a masterpiece just like RDR2. The art and design on the whole is soooo beautiful. I think though, the fantasy mythology thing gives it the freedom to get more creative than a realistic game like RDR2. This is why what R* have managed to craft with a limited Western theme is such a big deal.
The story in Red Dead Redemption 2 was very well told, very well acted and will be very much remembered. It's a shame that a lot of people never had the patience for the pace of the game and dismissed the brilliance of it because they never finished it.
@Krest_arisen yeah and rdr 2 can be summarized as “gang goes on the run and some regret their life decisions”. Breaking down the story so simply for both games does a disservice to both of their stories
@OmegaYato really I see it evenly split and I visit quite a few different gaming sites
The year end articles on Push Square have been great, and I really like the choice to break it all up into smaller categories. Thank you Push Square writers!
I was really glad to see Detroit on this list. QD gets a lot of criticism (often deserved), and the story in DBH has its flaws. But the ambitious scope of branching narrative in this game is pretty great. And, I could not put down the controller until I found out what happened, the mark of a compelling story.
The father son dynamic in GOW was told quite beautifully. I am really glad that game exists.
@PS_Nation 👑 kratos strikes again.word up son
I think Red Dead Redemption 2 is Game of the Year but I actually do think God of War has the better story. It's a real accomplishment that leverages an established character and builds him into something else entirely.
That said, RDR2 is also impeccable, and I couldn't argue against either winning this category.
For me it's Red Dead Redemption 2. Arthur's story really hit me and in the end he became one of my favorite game characters of all time. I played gow and it's great, but not on Red Dead Redemption 2 level.
OK sorry for the unpopular opinion but I disagree.
While I think GOW story telling was fantastic in the way the story unfolded through the gameplay. Because that's basically what the story is about. It's the journey. The plot, well what of it? You know from the first chapter what the purpose and ending is going to be. 'journey to the highest peak of the nine realms to spread the ashes' that's the basic story. The villain? You fight him at the beginning and you know he's the final boss. Talk about twists.
OK I get there's the setting and all but the story is quite unremarkable.
The way it's told is great though that's for sure
@OmegaYato I better not find out that Push Square is biased towards Playstation... recently discovered Nintendo Life favoured the Switch - totally ruined it for me 🤨
@RedMageLanakyn
I mean.. He just expressed His opinion. It's what comments are for?
The World Wide Web Serpent biting its tail....
I like DQXI story too but yeah God of War was masterful and the stories of mimir were always entertaining
@Deljo It’s called NintendoLife, so I hope you weren’t surprised. Any gaming site aimed at a specific brand is biased, that’s why you shouldn’t listen to them for reviews either.
@dark_knightmare2 A lot of people don’t have the attention span for a game like RDR2 and they weren’t able to finish the game. Everyone I know who finished the game said it has the best story.
@RedMageLanakyn Why are you offended. I’m just speaking facts.
No other game hit me emotionally like RDR2. It was a sad story of failure, one which you couldn't prevent, but then ended with a story of redemption and even more sadness as the credits rolled, knowing what the future held for certain characters. GOW had a cool story, but to me had no ups and downs as RDR2 had. It had its moments but it never hit me emotionally. I just felt it was a story of a disappointed father and revenge. As others have also said, GOW is a tad overrated to me.
Which nagging writer of PS wrote this: Winning the vote by a single point is God of War“? Thats democracy;) it seems most people of the staff cant handle it (see sammies and ramsey comments).
OT: i cant understand the appreciation for Rockstar games. The stories are good but the gameplay is always so bad.. GTA V and this both have tanky controls but its the hype train i guess
My game of the year: Smash brothers Ultimate : most fun i had in years. No tank controls
@OmegaYato I recommend you expand where you look then. God of War has been winning best Story from many, many outlets.
@OmegaYato The part where it won be one vote is very biased towards PlayStation yes.
@PSfan4Life22 That’s among critics. I’m talking about users and their opinions hold more weight than those of (paid) critics. I’m not saying they were paid for God of War, but some can be paid off.
@OmegaYato I'm not offended, and you're speaking your opinion, which is not fact, except in your head.
@JJ2 He made a snide comment, so I returned with one. I never called him out on anything he said. He's clearly very full of himself if you look at what he is saying.
Rdr2 and GoW were probably equally as good as each other. Very different games, i loved both of them. Really hard for me to pick one over the other.
@OmegaYato yeah I finished it and liked it well enough but it had too many pacing issues and a horrible chapter 5 that felt like a completely different game for me to say it had the best story
@OmegaYato
To be fair. Every review is subjective. Its the nature of the beast. Review scores even more so. I'm not sure we could ever imagine something more subjective than a score.
There are very few, very few sites that are not biased. It obviously depends on the writers too within the site. I think actually sometimes PushSquare is being harsh with PS games, possibly because they like PlayStation too much?
Anyway I do think GOW has this widespread appeal that is not entirely due to the quality of the game. Its an appealing enterprise from a charismatic director which made a lot of people happy on many levels. When you think of it. Reviews are not about reviewing games nowadays. They are about expressing peoples subjective feelings. That's all.
@JJ2 I totally agree with you. Although I loved God of War as a game, and although its way of telling a very simplistic story was perfect, that doesn't make the story good.
I think game sites are still too much influenced by the way we look at movies when evaluating storytelling, but it should be closer to what we do with books. When you watch a 2 hour movie, having a complex story told in a simple and understandable way is a positive. When playing a 30+ hour long game, having a simple and easily remembered story told in an engaging and complex way is a positive. So no, God of War's story is not good, it's simplistic and cliché, but it's exactly what this game needed.
As we are expressing controversial ideas, I loved GOW as a new fantasy game, but I hated it as a God of War game... replaying GOW3 after it was a blast... Turning Kratos into a mooshy sentimental father was not a good direction for the series, even though the game is incredible (and I would have enjoyed it a lot more if it hadn't be a GOW game...)
@Olmaz
You put nicely into words what I was feeling:
'God of War's story is not good, it's simplistic and cliché, but it's exactly what this game needed.'
I agree (though I wish it was more twisted and unpredictable)
I don't really get what you said after that though. Sounds a bit contradictory. The franchise needed a more intimate and uncomplicated story like you said. It's indeed a very simple story told in an intimate and careful approach. It's a different approach from the previous games.
@JJ2 Thanks for reacting, always appreciated!
As for my view of GOW not being a good GOW game, but an excellent game in general... well, I have the feeling that I can find deep characters going through life-changing events and having very intimate and realistic relationship to other character in many games (say, The Last of Us, Horizon, Detroit, Hellblade to name a few). That is not what I want from a God of War game. Kratos, in his very one dimensional way, is a character that we don't see a lot anymore in modern AAA games, and, it may be weird, but it feels good sometimes to have a character that doesn't react based on a complex moralistic view.
To make it simple, God of War is a spectacle : simple story, simple characters, full on cinematic set-pieces with a very good appreciation of the mythology it's based on (even with the liberties taken). How many games these last year would fit in that description? So then, why change the formula? And if they wanted to tell a deep character based story in the Norse mythology, why choose the God of War series? I enjoyed Hellblade a lot more than God of War because I wasn't attached to a Senua that wasn't the one I was seeing on screen. I would have been a lot more attached to this Kratos/Teal'c character if it hadn't been Kratos.
Some people say that it's the series finally getting more mature... For me, I see only a way to sell an already incredibly good game by artificially tying it to an existing franchise. As I see it, in this new game, everything that was related to the previous games could have been omitted/slightly modified and the game would only have been better for it.
@Olmaz
I actually see what your saying. I personally loved the game for its gameplay, not for the story or characterisation. I found the previous game stories a bit complicated tbh. I do like unexpected twists in any game though which are missing here.
@JJ2 Really? I thought there were a few unexpected twists. Like Baldur being Freya’s son And Kratos getting his blades back. I thought “oh yeah I’m going old school on you mother rubbers” I can’t express how many good twists there are because swearing isn’t allowed. But yeah there are definitely twists in there bro
@OmegaYato
Not really. I mean I said elsewhere you meet the first boss and it's also the final boss. You get the purpose at beginning and it's the same ending you get achieving that goal. If you think a minute at the beginning you already guess who Atreus is. Etc it's all kinda predictable
Blades are awesome but it's not really impacting the story. I mean story is not change d for that. Don't get me wrong I loved it but that's not story like twist giving you a new purpose, a new direction etc if you see what I mean
@JJ2 You right, you right. I don’t know much about Norse mythology so I had no clue who Atreus was
@OmegaYato
Your right Freya is a nice twist but not a twist changing any of the main character, main enemy, main purpose etc of the story. Most type of twists there r are only about background story.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...