Update: Ubisoft has responded to this situation with a statement to The Verge. "We have been made aware that some players encountered pop-up ads while playing certain Assassin’s Creed titles yesterday," it says. "This was the result of a technical error that we addressed as soon as we learned of the issue."
We suppose that's that, then.
Original Story: Well, this is potentially concerning. Video footage is circulating on social media of what appears to be an advertising test in Assassin’s Creed Odyssey, the 2018 Greek adventure from Ubisoft. The gameplay clip clearly shows the player opening their map, before being greeted by a banner for latest title Assassin’s Creed Mirage’s Black Friday sale. When cancelled, the map loads as normal.
It’s unclear whether this test expands beyond Odyssey just yet, and indeed whether the French publisher intends to use this technology in more titles moving forward, but it potentially sets a worrying precedent if it proves successful. Obviously, the idea of in-game advertising isn’t exactly new, but this feels pretty immersion breaking for a narrative-heavy experience.
We’ll contact Ubisoft in an attempt to understand the exact intention of this experiment, and how many titles it’s trialling it in. For now, though, let us know your thoughts about in-game advertising like this in the comments section below.
[source reddit.com, via resetera.com]
Comments 71
Grim. Wrinkle my nose when they advertise DLC in games with banner ads and such but it’s even worse being added to an older game like this.
Well, that's sh**ty...
Oh god no..its bad enough with adverts on sky every 2 secs and youtube vids etc..now adverts in video games. There has to be a line.
Disgussting. While EA is in the incline in my eyes, Ubisoft took over trophy for the worst videogame company. At least in my eyes. It's pitty since i really liked them.
So Xbox's full screen ads have already led to this. 🤮🖕🏻
@pushsquare correct me if I am wrong, but isn’t Assassin’s Creed Odyssey set in Greece, not Egypt?
@anoyonmus
To be fair Origins and Odyssey are so similar on the surface that you really can't blame anybody for mixing them up.
@anoyonmus You're right, my bad. I'll correct that!
Like almost everything else that’s bad in gaming, we’ll complain for a while, but they’ll persevere, knowing that we’ll get tired and then the new generation will eventually just see it as normal, as they’ve grown up with it, and it will be accepted.
Oh god: I can see it now. ‘Full game at £60 but get a staggering £3 off for the full game plus ads’ 😂
I'd understand if it was a free to play game and the ads were the loading screens, but not in a single player game in the middle of gameplay that's just messed up. I won't be supporting any title that has ads like that.
It's what Activision has been doing for a while now and at first it's not really annoying but it does get on your nerves after the second time, at least to me.
I fear this will be popping up in other games soon.
I'm more concerned about the fact that the guy has gold exclamation points over every section of the HUD...I mean seriously, get better at housekeeping 🙄😄
I really like this idea. I get so bored playing Assassin's Creed that it'll be nice to be able to take a break from the same gameplay they've been shovelling out since 2007.
Oh God I'm trying to escape ads and subscription prices just be going up god 😩
@
Unacceptable.
Ubisoft keep finding ways to make the player experience worse. It's almost impressive.
Imagine ads being in every loading screen for Starfield.
This is unforgivably bad. I've never touched an Assassin's Creed game, or any of these other huge franchises such as CoD, but what can't happen is for those giants to normalise this practice. We need less advertising in society, not more. Hopefully JRPGs are niche enough to be protected from this kind of thing, but I suspect that's wishful thinking.
Now that’s unacceptable, wtf Ubisoft.
Congratulations Xbox, this is your fault.
This is how it starts. In 2006, Oblivion releases the first DLC. It was considered odd. Its now almost shocking to not have a game with DLC.
This is the direction gaming is going sadly.
Good old Ubisoft, making themselves more unlikeable with every passing day and hopefully this doesn't become more prevalent
Nothing new. COD has been doing that for a while. I’m currently playing COD:Advanced Warfare and whenever I click over to zombies I get an ad for COD: WW II. Same thing w/ Infinite Warfare. And Black Ops II for that matter. Ads for different games come up depending on which game you’re playing, but ads none the less. As a matter of fact I think COD does it on ALL of their titles…..
I remember when 2K pulled something very similar (though admittedly worse than this) with their NBA games a couple years back. Still absolutely ghoulish what Ubisoft trying to do here though and I pray that they backpedal this ASAP.
@UltimateOtaku91 I can't they already ram it full of macro/micro transactions what's next that it's better to play a mobile phone game....
Immersion isnt such a big issue where they already add a seperate tab for micro/macro transactions.
Ubisoft they are the worst adding DLC prerelease, broken games, always online now its even easier to skip Ubisoft games.
@Northern_munkey Especially when it's something someone has paid $60 for.
🤦 no body wants this , I hate advertisements, I like a fictional advertisment you'd hear or see and later in the game stumble across the guy that makes the product , do a mission or two and have the option to burn their empire to the ground 🤦🤣
No no no! Don't go down this path Ubi! The way you've been doing it is fine keeping it in the main menu on the side but once the game starts that's it, no ads. Don't be dumb!
I would never buy a game with ads … but as we have seen repeatedly with review copies, mtx (or in this case, ads) can just be patched in later. Terrible prospect. But, we never really got to see Ubi's NFT BS, so here's hoping it will never happen.
I can just about accept a small banner on the main menu of say F1 22, offering an upgrade or discount for F1 23. But anything in-game?... no thanks, I'm out.
AC: Mirage has adverts on the righthand screen of the opening menu. Whilst I tut at that, it's kinda acceptable there. Within the game, having adverts for real-world items is just not acceptable and for me, this will be an insta-avoid for any PS game that does this.
It tells me that the publishers believe that paying customers are nothing more than exploitable bags of cash and they should be unequivocally targeted at every opportunity. Which in all reasonableness, has been the attitude for a couple of decades at least in the gaming world.
There used to be the balance between consumer and provider, with the consumer getting an item for a fair price. This balance has long since gone, with consumers totally exploitable and nothing more than percentages on a spreadsheet for shareholders to solely reap the benefits.
But that's capitalism for ya!
I played AC Valhalla for more than 2 hours yesterday on PS5 and nothing like this happened. I hope it's only a bug...
We're always so fast to jump to conclusions. Let's wait for the response first. But just to be clear: I don't want that either.
Nothing makes me want a game less than seeing an advert for it in another game, and the actual conversion rate from ad to sales from this will be absolutely zero difference to if they just don't waste time doing it.
People playing Assassin's Creed know there is another Assassin's Creed game that is not the issue, it is just that they are waiting to buy it when it's £8 in a sale, you know this Ubi! Your sales won't improve with ads, so stop being dumb.
Whereas let Coca Cola or Mcdonalds pay you for the space, and people will be shovelling that sh** in their mouths before you can say "Free NFT with every 100th order" 😁😁😁
Cancelled my Prince of Persia preorder now.
They’re the gift that keeps on giving
It would be something you could shrug off if it was during a loading screen or something like that, but the fact that you actually have to close the pop-up ad in order to look at the map is ridiculous. It's also possible it goes away once the Black Friday sale is over, but still, they could do it better.
I guess once I finish the DLC trophies from AC3 I won't be playing any of the games I haven't started from Unity onwards. It's a shame, I was looking forward to trying the RPG aspects of the later games
Anarchy Online did this to go FTP. Although it was mostly just limited to monitors in game, it also blended in enough to be safely ignored.
This updated version would be better served as a banner or a splash page at title (DL2 does this).
"It’s unclear whether this test expands beyond Odyssey just yet" It's also in Origins. I recently started my first playthrough, and a few days ago the ad for Mirage popped up when opening the map for the first time. I said out loud "seriously, dude?" not just cause it's ridiculous, but the same ad popped up (and had to be dismissed to continue) after the title screen.
AD's are fine if it's on the main menu or the in-game shop but it should never be during the game.
So…a “technical error” in this case apparently means “we didn’t mean to invoke this YET, we built it in for down the road when other developers embrace this kind of crap. We want to be ahead of the horrible curve.”
So they accidentally invented an intrusive ad? Of course they didn’t. They may have accidentally put it into the wrong game at best, but that doesn’t make it any better, and just shows how integrated this rubbish is into their platform if so.
The more of an ad infected mess Xbox is, the more likely other publishers will join in with intrusive ads on console because Microsoft made it "acceptable". Rockstar or WB will probably be next.
Of course it was , try and do this you'll hear about it, this company reminds me of the bad guy in ready player one, how many ads can we put on the screen and get away with , eh zero hate ads I stopped watching terrestrial TV years ago or had VHS player record with out the ads , I'd prefer to sit in silence than to see an ad
Good. I was right, a bug.
I can't say I necessarily buy that it was just a "technical error" but at least it's gone now. Fair enough.
A "Stop playing this old game and buy the new game" error.
@dskatter sounds exactly right. It's been in development and someone accidentally launched it in the live system and not in test. Then had to quickly remove.
It wouldn't surprise me if this wasn't included in the next set of AC games, especially as they now know it works as intended!*
*Intended behaviours from annoyed consumers excepted, of course.
Bleh, pop-up ads in games you pay for. I don't like that one bit, even if this was an error on Ubi's part.
@Suur ig
Its not an error if its been coded to facilitate such ads is it?
Adds in games are coming - in a few years it will be common place in some eco systems..
@Titntin they could have used the stage version of the game as a test platform and accidentally sent it to the live version. Doesn't mean it's intended for AC games but probably for freemium games.
@Terra_Custodes What did I say again^^
@Maddie47 it could have been ment for the menus , which is normal for ac games. I mean why wouldn’t they advertise their own game that is on sale in the menus? It would be worse if it was something completely unrelated like dominos pizza or subway sandwich advertising in the game
"Technical error"....right...
If this is the future, I don't expect to be paying £60!
'Sorry guys, we just accidentally dropped these ads-whose-UI-is-themed-around-the-game-that-they're-being-shown-off-in in here, sorry about that'
'Anyways, did you know that Assassin's Creed Mirage is currently 20% off?'
Lmfao. A technical error inserted ads into old titles? Gtfo. no one believes this bs.
Sound like they got too much backslash and backing up for now. It's not a coincidence, how come they have this ability to push ads like that in the middle of the game in the first place? Clearly there was garden prepared for it.... I call it bs and they definitely testing waters.
Technical error my ass! They’re probably testing success rates, click through etc for some advertising plan in the future. Maybe free-to-play games or something. Either that or I’m too cynical!
This was not a error they were testing what response they would get. The industry lies way to much to be trusted.
@Pikki Adblock needed on your console I hope I never get to see that happen.
What a pathetic excuse! They got caught and are now spouting BS!
Yah, I 0% buy that. Ubisoft got a terrible response and decided to backtrack. Probably had that excuse already set in case they got the public bashing that just happened. Pretty lame IMO
Never trust Ubisoft, and never again will play Ubisoft game. Tried so much of their games, oh my every time I regret my decision. Even for free I will not play game made by Ubisoft.
And that's not because of this news, it is because the quality of the games.
@Suur As every each other game of Ubisoft, copy and past, just different name and new skin
@riceNpea Yeah nobody advertised before Xbox. Have you also seen the Sony patent that requires you to say the name of the product in the advert out loud or the advert never stops? That seems like it'll be fun!
Just one more reason to stop buying Ubisoft games. The fact that this code even exists in a game as old as AC Odyssey should tell you something about the company. You are not someone they are selling their vision too. You are someone they want to exploit dollars out of to the point of wringing a stone for blood. This is not a good company. They want to monatize you. If they are sneaking this into their games what else are they doing with your information. What else are they planning.
No one knows that Ubisoft, before the current generation of consoles was announced and revealed to them, that the company was looking to turn load screens into an opportunity to load streamed videos and commericals while you waited to load. The load screen was the advertisement. It wouldn't just be ubisoft products. They wanted to add advertisements from other companies both gaming and non gaming alike. Only reason they didn't carry that plan out was the push to move us away from load screens. If SSD's ever get to a point where they can't load a world fast enough, that code is still their waiting to be turned on. I'll bet you anything they are still considering it for prematch loading in multiplayer games.
Removed - disrespecting others
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...