In case you missed it, Microsoft made an industry-shaking acquisition at the tail end of last year, buying up Activision Blizzard King for an eye-watering $69 billion. It took a long time to close, though, because of intense scrutiny from a handful of different sources — one of those being the USA's Federal Trade Commission (FTC). Now, in the wake of Microsoft cutting thousands of jobs, the FTC is back on the company's case, accusing it of contradicting statements made in court about how the business would operate post-acquisition.
The aforementioned layoffs have affected teams within Activision Blizzard and Bethesda as well as Microsoft, with about 1,900 employees made redundant. Microsoft stated that these cuts were being made to address "areas of overlap" between the companies. This, according to the FTC, goes against what the Redmond corporation assured in court before the deal closed. An official complaint has been issued to the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals. In it, the FTC says Microsoft's job cuts are "inconsistent with Microsoft’s suggestion to this Court that the two companies will operate independently post-merger".
Additionally, it argues that the action from Microsoft "undermines the FTC’s ability to order effective relief should the pending administrative proceeding result in a determination that Microsoft’s acquisition of Activision violated Section 7 of the Clayton Act". In other words, if the acquisition is deemed illegal — which is still possible, as the FTC is appealing against it — the layoffs prevent the FTC from helping those affected.
Since this complaint was filed, Microsoft's legal team has put out a statement on the matter. Shared by journalist Stephen Totilo, Microsoft essentially says Activision was already planning a round of layoffs before they were acquired. "Activision was already planning on eliminating a significant number of jobs while still operating as an independent company," the letter reads.
We're not out of the woods yet, then. What do you make of all this? Discuss in the comments section below.
[source bnnbloomberg.ca, via videogameschronicle.com, x.com]
Comments 54
I love how Pete Hines saw the writing on the wall and retired before the you know what hit the fan. Smart guy.
Microsoft lied to get their way? I am shocked!!! Who could have ever foreseen a company with a history of saying one thing and doing another would do just that after getting the acquisition approved by a Microsoft judge??
Hopefully, the ABK disaster can be unwound.
It would be crazy if this blocked the merger. Absolutely crazy.
I thought that Microsoft buying Activision would’ve been bad for the industry, but i never could’ve predicted how exactly it would be bad. Not even a year after the acquisitions and I’m pretty sure in retrospect it was a mistake. The Xbox division spent $69 billion dollars on this acquisition, and the suits at Microsoft are now demanding a return on investment, which is why they’re doing job cuts, going multiplatform, doing all digital, and maybe even other things (they might begin increasing Gamepass prices, or putting ads on Gamepass). The Xbox model is incredibly unsustainable, and the Activision acquisition only made it worse. They already had a good enough studio lineup + Bethesda, I don’t see why they needed Activision.
Xbox are turning into a complete laughing stock
long may it continue
"Shocked Pikachu face". This is what companies do. I worked in corporate for 10 years and this comes as no surprise. I think after this merger the FTC really needs to step in. I mean look at the Embracer group and how they are destroying studios cause of their hunger for investments.
Its crazy that ever xbox podcast still is all in on acquiring stuff but also demanding that microsoft not demand a profit from xbox
Flag on the play!
4th down.
2 seconds on the clock.
Why would you want it to stop? These articles are among the most popular on this site!
There’s no way Microsoft can feed that many mouths if they are going to leave PlayStation out to dry on Bethesda games.
Man it would be hilarious if Microsoft become the first ever company to have its acquisition unwound.
Microsoft Lawyers: Curse your trickery calling out our mass sackings as fibs instead of alternative facts will you FTC?
Bring out the "It'd been Far Worse if BOBBY KOTICK was still there,so nyerr!
Ultimate Chewbacca defence!🙄😂
"Wait, which lie are we supposed to be telling?" - Microsoft PR
"NOT THAT ONE!" - Microsoft Lawyers
Like the price is right.come on down.Bring on the Bethesda games and other games to PlayStation. Let see what lies of p aka phil spencer word up son
The heads of Microsoft and Embracer should be fired with no severance and put on a government blacklist where they can never register a business under their names again. Then they would have to be part of the working community that they have treated like expendable components.
US law treating corporations as people but actual people as disposable property as always.
FTC will wring their hands and talk tough, pretending to care, but we all knew what side they were on when they let the merger happen.
I have a feeling Phil's time with MS is nearing its end. MS are clearly taking more control from him and well let's face it what has he done for Xbox? Gamepass that's it and even that is starting to backfire on Xbox. Fanboys forget Phil is a Don Mattrick lackey and was all in on what Don had planned.
The FTC seem to be ignoring the thousands of other layoffs from nearly all publishers in the gaming industry. Every single one of those layoff cases falls right in line with the 8% of the workforce that microsoft laid off. The FTC continues to show they don't know anything about the industries they are trying to regulate.
What is the end goal here for the FTC? Unravel the deal and leave ABK in shambles as their leadership is gone and are in the midst of a major restructure? I'm sure that would be a positive in their eyes as they only care about hurting big companies. It would be horrible for the Industry and consumers but the FTC hasn't shown any concern for them yet.
@Jacko11 just in time for a quick commercial break?
@BacklogBrad they arent ignoring them. Its just that all those other companies werent part of a massive merger in which it was clearly stated this wouldn't happen in a court of law.
The fact they said it happened due to 'overlap' basically confirms its because of the merger.
@Weebleman best of luck to them in another unwinnable case. It won't be the public spectacle that their last lost was but it would be fun to watch them argue that Microsoft and ABK are not allowed to adapt to the industry constraints every company is facing.
Meanwhile they don't bat an eye at deals with national security concerns like US Steel being sold to foreign companies. But God forbid a videogame company bought a struggling videogame company in a deal that was already ruled to not disrupt the industry.
@BacklogBrad why u defending a trillion dollar company that does not care for u one bit.
Yes, because Microsoft are the only studio cutting jobs in the video games industry right now. Oh, and Activision blizzard always put employee welfare first when Bobby kotick was CEO. Get a grip people. Pretty much every company is cost cutting right now. Sony have done it too, cuts were made across its studios last year in October including 20% of staff at media molecule. The games industry is not in a great place right now in terms of job security and that is reflected across all studios, not just Microsoft.
@Slayer25c I'm criticizing the government that cares even less about us.
At least microsoft, sony, nintendo, etc. work for my money. This money the govt wastes on crap like this I worked for.
"They were gonna be fired anyway" is such a pathetic excuse.
Any doubt about why Microsoft is aka micro$haft?
You can stop writing about it at any time. In all seriousness, doubt this will change anything.
@Splat Shinji Mikami and the co-founder/studio director of Playground games, Gavin Raeburn also bailed.
@BacklogBrad not sure why you have your pants in a twist about a multi billion dollar company if im honest. I also wouldnt describe ABK as struggling.
Big oof on Microsoft's part, lying through their teeth
Microsoft lied? OMG What a surprising turn of events! Is this the same company who tried to mislead the customers into thinking Persona 3 Relod, a game most of their customers have absolutely no interest in, was a Xbox exclusive?
I don't think MS really cares what happens to ATVI or BLIZZ. I could see the FTC actually winning, as it would force MS to abandon two bad apples from the outset. Hell this was probably the plan all along. Then MS gets the pie it wanted, King. MS has what it wants. Guess we'll see how much value the two has for GamePass and them becoming a 3rd party in the end.
Whelp, this is a MS problem now, can't lay the blame on ABK anymore. When MS bought ABK, they also bought all of ABK's problems. Too bad, MS. This is what you wanted.
When can we stop writing about this Thats simple when you dont write about it. Especially since it not even PS news
@Deoxyr1bose @Deoxyr1bose people forget microsoft has a strong inclusion rule in hiring mist people fired are white males.
@personauser93 I get that people are mad at Microsoft, but what you are calling for are draconian measures that illegally restrict the rights of individuals.
You can’t just blacklist people. This isn’t China/Russia/Iran etc.
@WizzNL yeah they initially said it was overlap, and now claim activision would've done it anyway 😬
@Balosi @WizzNL I think it’s all PR spin.
The PR spin for the public was “it’s just overlapping jobs”. I had someone tell me in Microsoft’s defence that “every company would do that” which I did it buy for a second.
The court defense is these were “pre planned dismissals”.
One part is a lie. It’s just working out which one… or both?
@Weebleman @Slayer25c Because he’s a fanboy 🤗
So the US government doesn’t realize that when companies merge or buy out that there will be layoffs due to overlap and redundancy? At this point I feel like our government clocks in from their cell phones while on a beach in the Caribbean.
I’ve been saying this on Reddit for weeks and getting downvoted because “it’s just how mergers work.” Glad someone finally called Microsoft out.
So on one hand they are saying they are consolidating ‘overlap’ in the business and then also saying Activision was going to let people go anyway. 🤨
@TheCollector316 “Microsoft judge” 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Either the layoffs were already planned by Activision, or they are done because of areas of overlap.
You can't have both.
@AhmadSumadi This particular complaint is due to Microsoft giving assurances that ABK would still operate independently of MS after the acquisition, which would mean that those jobs would still be required. Effectively meaning they either lied in their assurances to the regulators, or are lying now when they say the layoffs are due to overlap. I'm fairly sure they were also trying to paint a picture where MS taking them over would be good for ABK as it would mean they wouldn't have to lay off staff under their leadership.
So many hot takes in this thread. Lina Khan and the FTC do not care about the layoffs. The FTC run by Khan is the biggest sham of an organization at the present moment. They just want to try and block the merger at all costs as Khan hates big tech in general. They are using this to continue their fabricated social justice crusade.
@CharlieChooChoo Limp Blizzkit
@cburg says “so many hot takes in this thread” then proceeds to make the hottest of all the takes 🤣
"eliminating" that could have been put better.
@AhmadSumadi Not a hot take though. Live in the US and you will understand.
@cburg have lived here in the US for 36 of my 42 years. The whining about social justice warriors is just as obnoxious and overblown as the social justice warriors themselves.
@BacklogBrad A struggling game company are you talking about ABK? Let's hope this won't be the same as all the big lies with Ticketmaster. In the end the want the stuff that makes money and cut out everything else. Still asking €30/$30 for a color of a portal this is going to be a bloodbath in the industry with all these buyouts.
@Flaming_Kaiser ABK at the time was rocked by the allegations and lawsuits. Their stock was in the toilet. Their future was pretty bleak enough where they were actively trying to sell themselves. I would categorize that as struggling.
@AhmadSumadi You don't understand if you make a deal with certain agreements you have to keep you to your part of the deal the US already destroyed the music industry with Ticketmaster.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...