A new entry in The Gentlebros' all-ages action RPG series, Cat Quest 3 opts for a pirate-themed escapade, in which you play as a fearless seafaring feline. In search of a legendary treasure known only as the North Star, you'll explore an open map made up of ocean and islands, often aboard your trusty tub. As we've come to expect, this is a lighthearted tale full of fun characters and dumb puns — but overall, it feels like both a refinement and a small step backwards after 2019's impressive Cat Quest 2.
Indeed, Cat Quest 3 is a more streamlined release. Its map doesn't quite have the scope of its predecessor's sprawling world, and there's just less stuff to do in general. There are fewer locations, quests, dungeons, secrets, and storylines to follow, and while size certainly isn't everything, this third instalment can end up feeling surprisingly short-lived and slightly limited, even though its eight-hour runtime is pretty much on par with what's come before.
There's still a lot to like about this furry foray, though. For starters, the addition of ship-based exploration and combat brings some variety to the sequel's gameplay suite, and the adventure's punctuated by a bunch of fun boss fights, set across both land and sea.
Aside from being able to swap between melee and ranged weapons with the push of a button — which only adds to the game's enticingly chaotic clashes — on-foot combat remains largely untouched. Once again, you're expected to make clever use of dodge rolls and quick combo attacks, before building up to and unleashing powerful magic spells. It's enjoyably fast-paced and easy to grasp, although there are times when the sheer amount of on-screen effects — especially of the magical variety — can obscure the action to a frustrating degree.
Character builds are back as well, as you can deck your paw-tagonist out in weapons, armour, and accessories that boost specific styles of play. Finding an effective combination is satisfying, and key to conquering late-game challenges. The title does a good job of dishing out worthwhile rewards, whether you've just completed a quest or delved to the deepest depths of a dungeon.
Having said that, there isn't a whole lot of room for experimentation. Upgrading your arsenal requires hefty amounts of gold at later levels, and grinding enemies doesn't net you much currency. As a result, you'll probably find yourself sticking to a select few weapons or armour sets, depending on whether you've enhanced their stats already. It's a bit of a shame that the game isn't more liberal with resources, but there is New Game+, which brings some welcome replay value to the table.
And just quickly, you can play through the whole Cat Quest 3 in two-player local co-op. Your partner in pirating will take on the role of second mate, and they're afforded all of the same gameplay freedoms. However, you can only have one ship, which both of you control, meaning that you'll either have to divvy up duties, or decide who's taking charge on the high seas. An awkward caveat to an otherwise faultless co-op mode.
Conclusion
Cat Quest 3 doesn't quite live up to the expectations that were set by its purrfectly poised predecessor, but it's still a rock solid seafaring adventure. While it falls short of Cat Quest 2 in terms of size and overall scope, this is perhaps a more focused take on the series' action RPG formula, and the game's pirate theme gives it an undeniable charm.
Comments 21
If anyone's got any questions about the game or the review, let me know and I'll try to answer them.
@ShogunRok is the trophy list similar to the previous games? Simple and nothing missable?
A backwards step by the looks of it. Shame, I enjoyed the first 2 and was hoping they built on it rather than pared it back.
Even if it’s not purrfect, it might still be worth taking furr a spin.
@Americansamurai1 I haven't actually seen the Trophy list yet — doesn't seem to be public — but I did get a lot of Trophies throughout my entire playthrough. I'd be surprised if it's that much harder than what's come before.
@ShogunRok if you disable your internet you can then view your trophy list locally which should then show the full list.
@ShogunRok thanks
@Simon_Fitzgerald I know, just never thought of doing it while I was playing!
This seems inline with my expectations. Didn't see anything that elevated the bar up to Cat Quest 2 standards. Still excited and already preordered it.
Smaller and more streamlined is a welcome adjustment for me personally.
I just wish the co-op would also be online.
@ShogunRok " Co-op only allows for one ship "
I feel seen. Unhappy, not surprised, but seen.
"However, you can only have one ship, which both of you control, meaning that you'll either have to divvy up duties, or decide who's taking charge on the high seas."
My wife just pointed out that's how the menus and shops worked in the first game, one screen w/ both of us moving stuff about, so since we do only get 1 ship at least we can sort of take turns, which I suppose is better than only player 1 always controlling the ship while player 2 does nothing. I'll probably just let her do it, how much trouble can she get in in a ship?
You talk to the person who gave it a 9 out of 10 on sister site Nintendo Life? I never heard of them before but their profile says they work for you guys as well as NL. Not that a 7 and 9 are all that different, but they are different.
https://www.nintendolife.com/reviews/switch-eshop/cat-quest-iii
Sorry, I don't have any questions about this game as I've already pre-ordered it. I have about a million about Stellar Blade but that seems a bit off topic. 😂
Is there a list of best pirate games on PlayStation platforms?
My youngest son and I are going to play this co-op. Can’t wait!
@rjejr Hahaha, hopefully you find the right place to ask them!
And yeah, Echo's a freelancer. Obviously this review's my take and the NL review is theirs — I'll be interested in seeing how well Cat Quest 3 reviews elsewhere too.
For me, the second game is still the best, but I can kind of see why some people might prefer this third one. It does feel well made and very polished.
@ShogunRok My wife and I will probably play CQ3 next week*, we just finished 2 so it's fresh, and she's a harsher critic than I am so I'll get an honest "better or worse" opinion out of her. We stopped about level 120, couldn't do the 150 caves. If this is much shorter though, 2 took us about 10 or 12 hours, than we won't be happy. your 2nd review paragraph made me sad. 😥
*Unless the library let's me renew Stellar Blade again, I read it was only a 20 hour game but I'm at 30 hours and only 43%, just got into the great desert, not even doing the side missions. 🤷♂️
https://howlongtobeat.com/game/97758
Still playing the minute it drops, it could've got a 3 and I'd still be there.
I’ve never played these but I picked up all three for about $20 on Steam. I’m looking forward to finally giving them a try.
I got the paw-latinum trophy for both 1 and 2, will definitely being playing this fur sure.
This game is everything I hoped it would be and more! The Cat Quest Trilogy is one of the best gaming trilogies out there.
Looks really good I need to buy the first two games they somehow looked really fun to play.
Going to play it this weekend. Looking forward to it!
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...