Our individual Game of the Year articles allow our lovely team of writers to share their own personal PS5 and PS4 picks for 2023. Today, it's the turn of reviewer Jamie O'Neill.
5. Cannon Dancer - Osman
I've waxed lyrical many times about how Capcom's 1989 Strider is one of my personal favourite games ever, so the long awaited console release of Mitchell's previously unconverted 1996 coin-op title, Cannon Dancer, was genuinely one of my most anticipated games of 2023. Strider led me to be fascinated by Kouichi Yotsui as a Japanese game designer, so I also spent many more hours than most gamers playing PS3 Moon Diver. Cannon Dancer's acrobatically animated sprites and detailed, ethereal 2D backgrounds have aged magnificently, so hats off to artists like Kiyoshi Utata, and Mitchell's arcade team for creating a worthy spiritual successor to Strider.
4. Dead Space
Of course, it's the tense, tread carefully gameplay, and the swanky, spit-shined PS5 remake's graphics, but with Motive Studios' 2023 Dead Space I especially enjoyed the way its story, setting and lore sucked me into a blissful black hole of sci-fi media, and interstellar horror appreciation. I sandwiched returning to the USG Ishimura in-between repeated views of both the animated Dead Space: Downfall prequel, and the Dead Space: Aftermath films. My outer spooky space nostalgia for the 2008 PS3 game was expanded, so even though it's a tenuous link, revisiting Dead Space brought back fond memories of an interview I carried out with Firesprite about The Persistence back in 2018. Dead Space's sci-fi horror vibe also convinced me to re-watch Event Horizon, too.
3. Vengeful Guardian: Moonrider
Take into account that Blazing Chrome featured in my top five PS4 games of 2019, and combine this with how editor Sammy Barker had me sold in the introduction of his Mini Review of Vengeful Guardian: Moonrider by describing it as "a white-knuckle mix of Shinobi III: Return of the Ninja Master on SEGA Genesis and Mega Man X on the Super Nintendo." I blatantly adore retro arcade games, and in an interview with Nintendo Life, JoyMasher's lead developer Danilo Dias explained that, "The idea is to try to simulate the arcade experience that older games used to present." Fair play to this talented Brazilian studio, because it's nailed the arcade presentation and flow of the 16-bit era.
2. Marvel's Spider-Man 2
I've chosen an Insomniac Games title in my Push Square Game of the Year list four times out of the last six years, so the studio has easily cemented itself as my favourite modern video game developer. This admiration not only includes 2021's Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart, but also the first 2018 Marvel's Spider-Man and 2020's Miles Morales, so Insomniac's Spider-Man series now ranks as highly as Rocksteady's Batman: Arkham franchise in my eyes, which is strong praise indeed. The very best thing about Marvel's Spider-Man 2, though, was bonding with my 81 year old stepdad as we compared our progress, and I watched him advantageously use his PlayStation Portal to slingshot launch past me in completing the game.
1. Blasphemous II
I love 2D art styles, so including Vengeful Guardian: Moonrider above, I made myself a list of fun but sometimes forgotten 2023 pixel art games like Bat Boy, Double Dragon Gaiden: Rise of the Dragons, Full Void, Lunark and Revita. Yet, it's Blasphemous II that's the graphical pinnacle of this year's pixel art with its sumptuous visuals. Obviously, Blasphemous II's difficult, but if you can't stand the heat, get out of The Game Kitchen. In a similar way to how I mentioned Strider earlier as one of my most fondly remembered games, Blasphemous II reminded me of another of my personal all-time favourites, and it's a huge compliment that I speak about it in the same revered tones as PS1 Castlevania: Symphony of the Night.
What do you think of Jamie's personal Game of the Year picks? Feel free to agree wholeheartedly, or berate relentlessly in the comments section below.
Comments 30
One fun 2023 honourable mention I want to note as an addition to my Game of the Year list was the Dead Cells: Return to Castlevania DLC.
Furthermore, as an extra bit of Push Square reading to complement my GOTY choices, Marvel's Spider-Man 2 deservedly received the Platinum Trophy as the Best Open World Game of 2023, and Simon Fitzgerald also chose Blashpemous II as his personal number one GOTY pick.
Finally, I discuss forgotten 2023 pixel art games in my GOTY list, and Max Freeman-Mills recently wrote a Push Square Soapbox examining if PS5 Dead Space Is This Year's (Almost) Forgotten Horror Delight.
It's only three days until the New Year, so thank you to anyone who reads my Top 5 here, and all the best for 2024 everyone!
I picked up Canon Dancer - Osman and Vengeful Guardian: Moonrider in one sale or another over the last few months. Wasn’t planning on playing them any time soon but this list has piqued my interest in both for sure!
@JamieO Great shoutout to the Dead Cells DLC. One of the most finely crafted DLCs I’ve had the pleasure to play.
I touch upon how I focussed on playing a lot of smaller, less known pixel art games this year (above), so here's a bit more information about five forgotten pixel art games that released in 2023:
@JamieO Really good list mate. As a Dead Space fanboy myself, I too found the remake to be superb and it shines on PS5. I discovered Full Void on the Evercade, what a treat! Back on PS5 as a pixel art fan I enjoyed Prodeus too and now it is coming to plus in January everyone will get to sample it.
All the best Jamie, keep up the great work!!
Thats a cool top 5.yes blasphemous 2 is excellent just like the first blasphemous.and yes 🕷 spiderman 2 is amazing.and dead space remake is one of the best games ever made.word up son
Thank you very much for people's comments, so far.
Cheers, @somnambulance, I really liked the way Dead Cells: Return to Castlevania opens by having to find Richter Belmont in the Prisoners Quarters' of the main game, and then after first confronting Death you have to explore through to the core game's Clock Tower to be able to continue, so it weaves the DLC into the biomes from the main content. As a consequence, I love that I've earned playing Return to Castlevania as a separate, linear Castlevania game on my PS4/PS5 now, too.
Nice one, @Mostik, PS5 Dead Space has become one of my favourite modern remakes, and that's high praise, since there's a lot of competition on that front. Good call on Evercade Full Void, as well. I meant to buy the Evercade version, so I've just sneakily added it to our shopping list for when I'm next in town to see if GAME has a physical copy.
Thanks, @playstation1995, it's kind of you to describe my list as "cool", and it's nice to hear that we've enjoyed similar games in 2023.
Have a fantastic 2024 all of you!
Great list, Jamie. Love your picks! Happy New Year to you!
Revita, Blasphemous 2, and Vengeful Guardian are all on the backlog. Currently working on The Last Faith and it’s giving me Castlevania Bloodborne Vibes.
@get2sammyb Happy New Year right back at you too, Sammy!
Wishing the best for you, your family and everyone at Push Square to have a very most excellent 2024!
@JamieO Great list and extremely well written, as always.
An important extra thought for me is that my GOTY article gives me the chance to give a nod to my 81 year old stepdad, who has been the biggest gamer I know in 2023.
He went from buying a PS4 for additional entertainment during the 2020 UK lockdown — where he initially struggled to navigate so many DualShock 4 button presses in Assassin's Creed Syndicate — to completing multiple, massive games in 2023.
Starting with Assassin's Creed Valhalla in 2020/2021, we both play the same game at the same time, and discuss our progress together in what we call 'Jamie/Jeff Bonding Games'.
We're currently doing this with side missions in Marvel's Spider-Man 2, and then in early next year we're going to focus on Final Fantasy VII Remake in time for Final Fantasy VII Rebirth's 29th February, 2024 release.
We've also talked about playing Grand Theft Auto V before the much anticipated sixth GTA arrives in 2025, although Jeff preferred completing Red Dead Redemption II — one of his favourite games, so far — over beating L.A. Noire, because he doesn't like controlling a car in an open world game as much.
Below is my stepdad Jeff’s Top 5 games of 2023 list (he said his first and second picks are nearly interchangeable, but he felt that for him there was a bit more variety in Final Fantasy XVI):
@JamieO Great to see Blasphemous 2 get some deserved love!
This was my #4 GOTY (1. Baldurs, 2. Lies of P, 3. TOTK, 4. Blasphemous 2, 5. Hi-Fi Rush)
Eviterno, the penultimate boss, had me on my knees though... that second phase is obscene!!
@SoulChimera Thank you very much for your kind words. All the best to you!
@CJD87 Cheers, I was actually prewarned about Eviterno, because I bought Blasphemous II late, and I read about his encounter as a difficulty spike in the comments of a video. Like you mentioned, I was blindsided by naively thinking his first phase was okay, before he started whizzing about in the second phase — although I'm not ashamed to admit that I learnt his attack patterns the best I could, by watching YouTube videos when I wasn't playing the game.
@JamieO love this comment about your stepdad. I hope I’m gaming so well at 81!
What did you think of Event Horizon? I watched it for the first time last year, thought it was truly awful. Enjoyed Dead Space though.
@MB81 Good on you for your comment about my stepdad, mate, I'll pass on what you said to him.
I also hope I'm gaming at that level when I'm 81, although in truth he outshines my gaming progress now, anyway! It's genuinely amazing how quickly his skill level has progressed over three years.
I couldn't help but love rewatching Event Horizon, because I have such nostalgia for seeing it with my mates as a student in 1997-ish. I must admit that it hasn't aged well, though. My memories of it were better than the actual quality of the film.
@CJD87 you warned me about it and just got to that boss fight last night. I can go through that first phase without any damage, that second phase is too much though!! @JamieO I'm clearly going to have to hit youtube as well, even with 6 bile flasks I've not got past a 3rd of that 2nd phase healthbar :/
My favourite top 5 I've seen so far this year on the various websites, cheers!
@JamieO It’s fantastic game design, isn’t it? I can’t believe all these years later how much Dead Cells continues to be relevant and engaging years later. There’s not many games I replay on yearly basis these days, but I can’t seem to escape Dead Cells… or Castlevania… so combining the two of them was already dream, but the way that they melded the two experiences together was nothing short of a masterpiece. While Dead Cells has plenty of wonderful DLC packs, the Castlevania one is the highlight so far, and I’m hoping there’s yet more crossovers to come.
Also, what a great choice for your stepdad in Final Fantasy 16!
@JamieO Thanks for the response, and glad I wasn't the only one to hit a wall with Eviterno ha! Enjoyed your top 5, a nice mix of 'expected' titles alongside lesser-known, great job.
@R1spam - he is horrendous right? Like 70-ish tries I think it took me, and for first 10 tries not sure I even stayed alive long enough to see his full moveset... let alone learn it! But that's why we play these games hey...! Good luck pentient one
@JamieO When I got into AC Valhalla I thought I might be 81 before I finished it so who knows how your stepdad felt! Great list, great nod to him. Get him on the Souls-like route
@JamieO Great list Jamie! I can’t argue with your top pick, it’s an excellent game. It’s also good to see you’re enjoying some other smaller titles like Revita, it was definitely overlooked.
@JamieO Great list as ever. I always enjoying reading it, and your passion for gaming always shows in your writing.
However with all that said, I think Jeff's list might be even more impressive, because it's an absolute beast for a man of 81. He's not messing around. I'd be interested to know the combined hours he put in on those five, if you can sneak a look at his stats.
@JamieO man, you're the absolute best! You're the positivity that's lacking online.
@Marquez You made my stepdad Jeff laugh with your comment, he had a look at his PS5 profile's time log, and he's accumulated 203 hours on Assassin's Creed Valhalla so far! He said that Valhalla's his favourite Assassin's Creed game, although he appreciates that some fans don't regard its gameplay as an authentic Assassin's Creed experience.
Jeff and I both completed Assassin's Creed Valhalla at the same time together, as well as finishing Wrath of the Druids and The Siege of Paris simultaneously too, but Jeff took it a step further by beating the Dawn of Ragnarok DLC expansion separately.
We also discussed fantasy Soulslike design traits as a subgenre this morning, as Marquez mentioned, and Jeff said that the thing is he has so much choice of games at the moment, as he's currently juggling his two Christmas presents: Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora and PS5 Resident Evil 4. This month and next month he says he has an avalanche of games he wants to play, but he's half thinking of checking out Elden Ring next year, though. Elden Ring's one he'll go for during a quieter time, and he was talking about trying Baldur's Gate 3 at some point, too.
@Gremio108 Jeff has played 240 games since he first bought a PS4 in 2020. Below are his Top 5's 2023 game time stats:
Assassin's Creed Mirage = 24 hours (not yet finished, 3/4 complete).
Final Fantasy XVI = 37 hours (not yet finished, 3/4 complete).
Hogwarts Legacy = 38 hours (main game completed).
Marvel's Spider-Man 2 = 25 hours (main game completed, playing side missions).
Star Wars Jedi: Survivor = 22 hours (not yet finished).
As a thank you for your comments — and for showing an interest in his gaming year — if you have access to BBC Four, Jeff recommends watching the 2023 Royal Institution Christmas Lectures' episode called 'My AI Life'. He said it has a discussion about the AI in Gran Turismo, which could appeal to a Sony fan.
@JamieO Elden Ring is an excellent place to start, he can play at his own pace and in whatever style he likes. And hats off for the Valhalla dlc completion, I got the main game platinum and was too exhausted!
@ShaiHulud I really appreciate you saying that my Top 5 is your favourite so far. It's especially good to hear since some of my retro based picks are so niche.
@Simon_Fitzgerald Great minds think alike with our number one pick, Simon, plus it was cool to see Sea of Stars in your Top 5 GOTY list. I haven't played Sea of Stars yet, but its stunning 2D graphics must be competition for Blasphemous II for the 'Best Pixel Art of 2023' award. It was by reading your Push Square Mini Review that I was introduced to Revita, by the way, so cheers to you for showcasing a quality indie game to me.
@naruball You're super kind, no two ways about it, and your comment has completely made my day!
@JamieO Nice stats. You need to get on to @get2sammyb, there's an article in this for sure, maybe even a regular feature of some sort. Jeff sounds like a modern-day legend.
@JamieO Great minds and all that! You've got the same number of games from my top 5 as the whole of Eurogamer reader's top 50 😅 Still have to check out Bat Boy and Full Void myself.
@JamieO yes back in the day I thought it was brilliant yet since acre watch some films don't age well. The idea though would be excellent for a rework or make 😁👍
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...