Well would you look at that; actual reviews for The Last Guardian - an actual game that is actually releasing tomorrow. A few years ago, we were really struggling to believe that this day would come, but here we are, sitting staring at review scores for the long awaited spiritual successor to the masterpiece that is Shadow of the Colossus.
So, has it been worth the near-decade wait? Have critics formed an unshakeable bond with boy and beast? let's find out.
Push Square - Hands On
This is a game so creatively dense, so cleverly put-together that it will stand the test of time for years to come. It's taken a long time, but The Last Guardian has been more than worth the wait.
Eurogamer - Essential
Does The Last Guardian live up to its lineage? Does it do its forebears proud? It does so much more. It is bold enough to step away from their hints and their mysteries and explore its own kind of wonder.
GameSpot - 9/10
When the book closes on their story, it's hard not to open it up again and begin anew. The trials you overcome endear you to both characters, but the emotions Trico elicits make you want to give it another chance--to be the patient, effective partner it truly deserves.
Videogamer - 9/10
Almost a decade in the making, The Last Guardian has issues but will surely go down in history as one of the best love stories in video games.
Jimquisition - 6.5/10
I wish I could say I love the game, that its plagued by only minor setbacks, but I cannot honestly do that. I can't look back at how much time was spent not enjoying myself, at how much time was spent actively wrestling with the game to wring anything worthwhile from it, and say I played the masterpiece many are going to say it is.
Destructoid - 8.5/10
I'm confident in saying that although it isn't their best work, there really aren't too many directors out there like Fumito Ueda, and I hope for our sake, he continues making games.
Are you happy with these scores? Will you be buying The Last Guardian when it launches this week? Grab some fur and hang on in the comments section below.
Comments 44
I think it's interesting that, in general, UK media seems much more positive than US media. A cultural thing?
Just glanced at IGN review and they gave it a 7.
Game is a unique experience that some will love and other won't
@get2sammyb
I think that can be said for a majority of games released
It's the sort of game I would expect to divide opinion. Good to see some people are enjoying it a lot. Some will not be at all forgiving of any shortcomings. Which is fine, we can't all love the same things.
There's also Geek Culture that gave the game a 9.8 out of 10.
Drink it in MAAAN!
Greatness has finally arrived!
EDIT: The PushSquare hands on reads like a 9. Calling it.
@get2sammyb I wouldn't be surprised if there is a cultural difference. What I detect from the reviews is that those who embrace the Japanese culture are more likely to review the game higher than a western game had it had the same issues. It seems they are far more forgiving whilst those who prefer the more western style (including visual style) are more likely to be more critical.
When you look at what this offers, including any technical issues, regardless of its cultural origin, is it really as good, as well developed and as content rich as other '9' rated games? Of course its difficult to compare to a game from a different genre but certain aspects can be - like technical issues for example.
Xmas day for me it looks stunning all though Sammy your video did not do the game justice
@get2sammyb I often think US media (particularly the perceived "large" gaming sites) will give a game an exceptionally high or low score just to get the clicks. I know that's awfully cynical of me, but that's just the way I am!! Of the sites I trust for reviews, Hardcore Gamer gave it a 5 out of 5. The review is worth reading as they do state the issues the game has - they just don't feel these things detract from the game overall.
@Bad-MuthaAdebisi This is a title I can see a lot of people not enjoying. I know having had no interest in the other "Cinematic...games?" from this studio, I won't enjoy this. I expect more meat on something you know? And near a decade in the making too. If the line is waiting for tech to catch up...well that's fine.
@get2sammyb
I belong to a date and age where we did not have internet reviews. Regardleas of what reviews say The Last Guardian will have a place in our heart just like Ico and Shadow before it. I have been a Playstation owner from its inception here in Europe. These moments are far and few in between. These games are moments in history of gaming. This will be a classic no reviews can take away that. Games like these are meant to be played. And lets hope for our sake and for future generations that these type of games continue to be made for and to mark the history of gaming. I am very proud to be a gamer and live the experience.
@SkanetWasTaken I second everything you said! 😄
Also: Will buy it on disc but later on - its just too much right now...
I'm happy with the score, eurogamer, gamespot, destructoid and of course push square seems to like it, I'll take my preorder tomorrow
@lixei32 Before the internet I mostly play the game from the gameshop before buying it or trust my guts instinct from the cover, and in the ps1 era, review from egm
@SkanetWasTaken Yeah, I mostly agree on his opinion piece on game industry but his review sometimes really miss the mark.
@PlaytendoGuy Yeah I just read their review but it's typical ign theses days, at the same time they gave Dead Rising 4 an 8 and people wonder why we get the same games over and over again.
@SkanetWasTaken He also gave Mad Max a 4 which i was ridiculous when you think about it.
It seems that bug bear some have is trying to get Trico to stuff, though that is the whole point. He's meant to be a living breathing creature with his own independence, so he isn't always going to be obedient.
PlayStationLifestyle gave this a 10 as well
Why does Europe have to wait till the 9th....
@wiiware
Back in the days i bought magazines as well. But what a feeling when i played ff7 for the first time and discovering bit by bit the classic that it was. And after vagrant story. I still have a copy of croc the first need for speed and many others. Almost 21 of playstation goodness
@Bad-MuthaAdebisi Exactly. My response is to usually see how much people are raving about it and hold off, because the hype kills a game for me. Crash 1, SM64, Journey, etc. Don't build it up as the best thing ever because I will find it unenjoyable. Dunno why but it happens. Overselling I believe.
Ill hold off on this. Just like The Last of Us before it.
Pre-order back on. I will be picking up a physical copy tomorrow on release day. So good to hear that it is as great as many hoped it would be as a finished product.
Well I'll listen more to Jim as at least he gives his honest opinion and isn't reliant upon sponsors ad etc. like the rest. I don't always agree with him but there is always truth in what he says.
im turning off all reviews all videos of this game come friday as cant play it till 27th december due to working xmas day and boxing day
In an industry where every developer packs in as many new features, as many modes, options, and configurations, The Last Guardian has no upgrades, no leveling, no add-on map packs, no RPG elements – it is an almost solitary experience, between nothing more than a boy, a beast, and the big world around them, yet it outshines nearly everything else. Video games as a market might demand the Call of Duty’s of the world to move units and put a spotlight on the industry through hype and marketing buzz, but video games as a medium deserves The Last Guardian.
Beautiful. In every way.
That was what i was talking about in my previous comment. These moments are far and few in between. Enjoy the classic. Happy Gaming
What is "Jimquisition" FFS?
Its very much a niche game so I think that will be reflected in the review scores. I trust IGN as much as I trust dodgy dave who lives at the end of the street.
IGN gave a 7, but it's hard to take IGN seriously now days. I miss so much of their old staff, like Audrey, Greg and even Colin. Now I think that only the Nintendo guys still doing their job, specially Jose Otero.
That said, I'll keep my word and wait someone spoil the end for me, if the dogbirdcat lives I'll play, if not I'll skip.
@Frank90 I totally agree about IGN. They can give great FPSs that are the same every year an 8-9 but an equally great game that is weird or different gets a 6-7. I feel like the score can vary 2 points depending on who reviews the game. This is definitely a cultural thing as well. Some people I know can't stand anything that seems Japanese.
I can't wait to play this but it's the only thing I asked for for Christmas so I'll have ot wait.
@NESguy94 Yeah and this is sad because until 2011~2012 IGN was great, now they're a mere shadow.
Liked Ico and SotC but i've got too much on my plate as it is, so i can wait a year or so and pick this one up at a discount.
@GBMatthew I don't like him he thinks he is great. To many strange scores from his site.
@get2sammyb
Maybe the IQ has something to do with it...
@hadlee73 To be fair, Jim absolutely detests ICO, too. It's not surprise he's not a fan of this.
Redemption...
I was worried the game wouldn't be good. I'm so glad to see all this positive feedback. Shadow of the Colossus is by far my favorite PS2 game ever made, and I will definitely be slotting this in for New Years after I beat Final Fantasy XV (and before Jan 20th when Dragon Quest VIII releases)
@get2sammyb It surely can be something cultural. The JP and UE covers for Ico were clearly inspired by Giorgio De Chirico paintings, but in US they must have thought: "F*** art, give the guy a mace!"
@get2sammyb
I don't know if it's a cultural thing. I would say it seems like a lot of North American outlets score Japanese lower in general these days (except for Nintendo games) but they are reviewing this better than the Western-created Dead Rising 4 so, the mixed reaction is probably simply down to this is very much a love it or hate it style of game. I know a good number of people who like ICO and Shadow of the Colossus, but I never really cared for them and know several others who don't see the big deal either.
Having read IGN's review on both this and Dead Rising 4, I can totally understand why DR4 has a higher score.
A game that has flaky controls and camera issues, as well as big drops in frame rate (unless you play in 1080p on the Pro) lasts around 12hours with no reason to replay or a game that offers a lot more hours, more progression, crafting, new game +, MP etc.
Just look at it objectively! If this was a 3rd party multi-platform game, would this be acceptable? What about if it wasn't 'Japanese' but had a more western Artsyle? Personally I think 'niche' (at least to us in the west) often get bonus marks for being Niche rather than being objectively reviewed.
You can criticise sites like ign for reviewing yet another FPS game higher but these often offer a 'lot' more. Maybe the Campaign is a little generic but at least its technically proficient and offer some replayability in most cases. Then there is the MP and maybe even a co-op mode too. Its not ign (or other sites) reviews that determine the direction developers take with projects but the gaming public. Games like CoD, BF etc sell very well and developers/publishers want some of that money.
Historically, Japanese games (and culture) have a 'cult' following in the west. These are generally very popular within those sectors but outside of that, can be very hit or miss.
@BAMozzy Yes, because this game has more "heart" and "personality" than practically any other I've played. But that's just my opinion... Everyone else is entitle to theirs.
@get2sammyb Heart and Personality are purely subjective qualities and impossible to quantify. Technical proficiency and quantity of content (inc campaign length, potential replayability value etc) are much easier to define. Of course that doesn't mean that you wouldn't want to play something like TLG again in the same way that you may want to watch a film again for example because of the way it makes you feel.
Stories have the potential to have a much bigger impact than everything the game offers but technical issues can impact on the way that story is felt too - bringing you out of the moment - a great game story can be ruined by technical issues affecting playability. Stories also impact on people differently so what someone has emotional connection to another feels very disconnected from. Its difficult to be objective but appreciate that reviewers can only write how it made them feel. As a result, I tend to dismiss this aspect and focus more on the things that can be quantifyable unless I know the reviewer has had similar connections to games that I have had.
@BAMozzy Perhaps, but I'd still argue this game achieves more artistically than perhaps any I've played in recent memory. To me, it wouldn't matter if it was 60 minutes long if it invoked the same emotions.
DF's PS4 vs PS4 Pro comparison:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g48ZELS0tyw
This is bad news for me, since I'm not planning to buy a PS4 Pro until maybe sometime next year.
It's also a shame that the game suffers from camera issues and cumbersome controls otherwise it would've scored a lot higher I feel.
@WanderingBullet
I'm not making excuses for the devs but the fact this game is here at all is shocking. Some of the problems I'm reading about don't surprise me considering what we know about the development cycle for the game. It's unfortunate.
@Gamer83 Yeah, but its great for Team Ico even with its problems that its currently scoring 83/100 on Metacritic which is a very good score by today standards, imo. I had a feeling that TLG might score higher than FFXV, right now its just 2 points shy of overtaking it.
@WanderingBullet
Oh I agree. Just getting the game out was a big deal for the developers, the fact it's scoring great is even better. Not my kind of game but I hope those who are playing it are enjoying it.
Really looking forward to getting my collector's edition on Friday. If it's as good as Ico and SotC then I'll be very happy.
@get2sammyb
No more of a cultural thing than the US getting this game earlier than the UK...
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...