Sony switched up its annual pre-Tokyo Game Show press conference format this year, hosting a PlayStation LineUp Tour livestream that was surprisingly good. The hour-long event did have a live stage element, but there was only one public speaker: SEGA’s Toshihiro Nagoshi, who was awarded the opportunity to unveil Yakuza Studio’s new detective title Judge Eyes in person. And while there was a small audience huddled around a huge television screen, if it wasn't for a short interlude in which giant inflatable golf balls were batted around by uncomfortable attendees, we didn’t really know they were there.
This was, for all intents and purposes, a Nintendo Direct; it was a barrage of trailers, gameplay demos, and smaller announcements, uninterrupted. And it was, as we mentioned earlier, surprisingly good. The platform holder, perhaps recognising that it doesn’t have a personality like Shigeru Miyamoto or Eiji Aonuma, opted to pace the presentation with a space exploration theme. The idea, cheesy as it may seem on paper, was that a DualShock 4 was flying through the galaxy, discovering new star clusters filled with games. It worked well and kept the content flowing at a rapid pace.
In contrast, there’s no question that Sony’s conference at E3 2018 this year didn’t work, but if you take away the agonising interlude as attendees were bizarrely expected to walk to a different room, the format wasn’t massively dissimilar; once The Last of Us: Part II was out of the way, the Japanese giant played a string of trailers, one after the other, without any chatter or talking heads. After years and years of being criticised for poorly paced pressers, it seems that this is the direction that the organisation is heading now – but should it continue to do so?
You definitely do lose some of the magic when you switch to a pre-recorded livestream; the Jack Tretton smackdown of 2013 or the Holy Trifecta of 2015 simply wouldn’t have the same impact without an audience losing its mind. But while no company will say no to free viral marketing, these press conferences can be fickle beasts; The Last of Us: Part II looked outstanding at E3 2018, and so did Ghost of Tsushima – but there’s no doubt that Sid Shuman’s babble between both games sucked virtually all of the enthusiasm out of the show.
To be fair, a more traditional presentation could have saved Sony here, but these conferences aren’t cheap to put on – and who really benefits from strobe lighting and cinema screens? Only a select few actually attend the briefings in person, and while they can be considered chest beating from the platform holders in front of their corporate partners, all the majority of us want and need is a good quality feed of the games on display. The orchestra at PlayStation’s brilliant E3 2016 event was a neat trick, but it can’t be repeated now; E3 2018 is what happens when you try to take an already elaborate concept one step further.
We’re not saying scrap stage presence entirely; no one would say no to Hideo Kojima introducing Death Stranding or Neil Druckmann playing The Last of Us: Part II on stage – but do we need Shawn Layden to anchor things now? Can’t all of the information that we need be presented more clearly and concisely in a pre-recorded video that’s been thought-out, planned, and expertly edited? Look, we’ll always have a soft-spot for the stage shows of yore, but they’re beginning to look expensive, unwieldy, and honestly redundant in this Internet age. Maybe, just maybe, it’s time to change tact.
Do you think Sony should adopt pre-recorded press conferences moving forward, or do you think the live stage shows still have a place? What did you think of the PlayStation LineUp Tour livestream, and is that a format the platform holder should consider adopting worldwide? Whoop and holler in the comments section below.
Should Sony adopt pre-recorded pressers moving forwards? (86 votes)
- Yes, I just want to see games without theatrics
- Meh, I don't really care either way
- No, the live aspect makes these briefings fun
Please login to vote in this poll.
Comments 36
Strange timing for this article seeing as how the last ND was delayed for an earthquake and probably 80% of it is already known so we'll all be disappointed watching it now.
Youtube and twitter exists, companies can do what they want whenever they want.
Yes. Please. Anything but what happened at E3.
@Jriibz A little bit, but that was more about them appearing in interviews and stuff. You can still hear from the execs and have press conferences that are pre-recorded.
I liked the E3 2017 - brief human touch, life audience atmosphere but wham and bam view of games.
If they did that then we wouldn't have amazing moments like E3 2015/2016.
I think E3 could have been saved if you just took out that really weird interlude after last of us. Surely someone from marketing could have looked at that and been like, nope. It’s not gonna work.
Keep it live but cut the live music out just a little and be more succinct. The orchestra before the God of War reveal was amazing.
I choose live stage compared to direct approach, but it need to be good, I don't understand why sony doesn't copy e3 2016, that's shows is perfect. Microsoft already copy sony e3 2016 shows to great success on e3 2018 and will surely do it again on e3 2019.
I feel in 2015, 2016, 2017 it was great. Lots of trailers and once a n a while short breaks with SLayden coming up with Crash shadow or Kojima saying he's back. That's great stuff they need to keep. Also add more live demos which I think is the best of the best.
No let them be their own thing, the less they look like nintendo the better.
@wiiware
Ms copied Sony E3 2016?
Didn't see the live orchestra or was it that drum roll and soprano chanting 'exclusive' every so often?
Nah the live element makes it so fun.
I'll never forget the God of War 2018 reveal with the live orchestra playing and Kratos stepping out of the shadows.
The Lost Legacy reveal was great too.
I don't even watch the Directs. Just catch the news when the sites report them. More often than not, they're just a bunch of ports anyways .
As someone who’s been predominantly Nintendo only for the last few years, I’ve always liked the Nintendo Directs, because they’re just condensed announcements about games and hardware. Of course, they’ll only ever be as good as their content, but all live shows seem to be good for these days are memes.
It does mean you don’t get the awesome spectacles like when Nintendo revealed Twilight Princess, but these are few and far between.
As final point, Directs are definitely more accessible too. This year, despite me being more interested in the Sony side of things, I still watched the Nintendo Direct but didn’t watch Sony’s conference, because I have no interest in watching all that fluff. I just read the articles and trailers as they popped up on here. Nintendo’s E3 Direct was pants of course, but that goes back to them only being as good as their content. The format is far superior in my opinion.
I like the live conferences......and on that note Sony hurry up and announce psx so I can book my hotel lol
After Sony’s E3 2018... I wouldn’t mind the Direct style... not because it’s completely superior although some do believe it should be the standard... it leads to less waiting and more onslaught of games like seriously imagine we say get Horizon 2 then next on the list oh boy it’s Dad of War 2 back to back and oh look Bloodborne 2 and oh look PlayStation All Stars 2 it’s like that hype meter goes up high w/o any pace breakers like something cringey or distracting...
@JJ2 I mean the "executive talk - games - executive talk - games" format. Sony e3 2016 pacing is perfect, sony e3 2017 is too many trailer, too little talk, while sony e3 2018 is too many talk.
Whatever makes it go by faster with as little time wastage as possible.
What would be most important to me is not the format, but to skip the usual hype rituals. Here is a teaser for a game coming out Q3 2019, and here is another trailer and another... and later we realize those early teasers had nothing to do with how the game actually looks and plays...
I really liked the way Nintendo handled the Switch release of Into The Breach. They kept quiet and said: Oh, and its out this evening.
I enjoy both approaches. The Nintendo approach is straight to the point (usually) trailer, info, release date/window and on to the next. Not a lot of fluff. I do enjoy the live shows as well though as long as they're well produced. Sony has really nailed it in the past, not so much this year, so they know what to do. Would be cool to see a Playstation Direct just out of the blue like Nintendo does though!
I absolutely would love Sony (and Microsoft) to adopt the Nintendo Direct approach throughout the year, but not for E3, i like the live conferences for E3, they have a level of excitement that cannot be replicated with a pre-recorded show.
I'd like Nintendo to go back to live conferences for E3 with Directs throughout the year, we'd get the best out of both worlds then.
I'm not sure what it is about live shows, but there's something special about them and I'd like them to continue.
@wiiware
Yes if your only considering the pacing then it was similar. I m not really bothered about 'pacing' tbh. It's overrated so too speak haha. What matters to me is the content. Unless you see the advertising approach of the whole thing where form > content. Or the entertaining side of it like a show. Live is allowing to show content you wouldn't see otherwise though so that's more that just the form. Again I don't get why people are so focused on pacing while it's not what matters.
I don't care how expensive it is for Sony, I'm not the one paying, I want to see Shawn uncomfortably giving his speech.
The live press conferences can’t be beat. A direct isn’t the direction to go after the last travesty at E3. When the PS4 was announced to play used game, nothing a but a live press conference could have the slew impact. Sony just needs to go back to the glory days when the PS4 was new or unborn.
I dont think it would suit Sony, with Nintendo Direct even indie games seem like massive announcements. Its like magic.
Sony just shows artsy gameplay videos and closes with Coming TBC. Its very "direct", but its all it needs because you know what you're going to get. Unless its Death Stranding.
A Direct format wouldn't work for me, Sony like to show their games with a sense of theatre (which considering how well made they are you can't blame them) it's the balance they have to get right. E3 this year didn't work and they could have done with a handful of the 3rd party games to beef it up a bit. But E3 2016 was perfect that they repeated in 2017 yet people still didn't seem happy. When big games like TLOU2 and Spider-Man were announced it would lose it's impact without the audience reacting to it.
No no and no.
The live aspect gives us that juicy cringe! Besides there's something special about seeing something live, if it's a video I can watch it tomorrow, or later or later or later...
The problem with pre-recorded is that you lose the opportunity for such classics as the “Official PlayStation Used Game Instructional Video” and Uncharted 4’s “Stage Fright” trophy. Plus, hearing/seeing grown adults squealing at the announcements of Final Fantasy VII Remake, Shenmue 3 and The Last Guardian must be experienced live.
I enjoy both approaches. The PlayStation Blog is kinda like Nintendo direct except in written form. Maybe expand on PlayStation Underground a little and make it a place to announce smaller titles along with the game play from bigger games.
I think they should start doing something like Pulse again where it was weekly and showed the highlights of the week. Since they've been shoving asset flips on the store I think it's needed more than ever.
The live shows can stay I looooove cringe.
@Spanky
Bring back Qore!
E3 2016 was the year Sony nailed their conference in terms of pacing and balance of games. Everything since then has been really wonky.
I like the Sony conferences, they're always trying different things, sometimes it doesn't work out (like E3 this year) but I like to be surprised like that.. Gamers are weird man! If it's just game trailers you want then just watch YouTube later
Been saying this for the past year.
I like the live element and feel it makes it more of an event. Otherwise, it's just watching trailers on the internet and that's not much of an event at all.
I like it live better. More exciting.
@lacerz That would be cool but unfortunately I didn't get my PS3 untill Qore died a few weeks after so I never got to check it out. But I always wanted it on my PSP.
There was nothing wrong with the old style of E3 press conference! I guess they didn't have enough games available to show off this year as a lot of studios are preparing for next gen.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...