Straight to the point: Genshin Impact has pretty much ripped our expectations to shreds. The game that many have been calling a Breath of the Wild clone is actually really, really good — and it doesn't have to cost you a penny.
Genshin Impact is a free-to-play, open world action RPG. It has a story, interesting characters, quests, exploration, combat, and puzzles. We've played a good 12 hours of it, and honestly, you could tell people that this is a full price release and they'd probably believe you. The quality on display is not what we've typically come to expect of free-to-play titles — Genshin Impact really does go above and beyond.
So what's the catch? This is a question that we've been asking ourselves throughout our entire time with the game, struggling to come to terms with the fact that this colourful and polished open world adventure is indeed free. Well, it'll come as no surprise to learn that Genshin Impact does have microtransactions. You can spend real money on crystals, which can then be used to unlock random characters or items.
In essence, this is a 'gatcha' mechanic — you're spending money to be in with a chance of obtaining rare playable characters or equipment that'll make you stronger. What's more, the big prizes — like the rare characters — are on rotation, meaning that you've only got a limited amount of time to capitalise on certain deals.
It all seems a bit insidious when you really start to examine the system as a whole, but again, Genshin Impact is free. As mentioned, we've been playing it for over 12 hours and we haven't felt the need to spend a penny. Whether pulling for rare characters and equipment becomes an ugly necessity later on, we don't know — but you could argue that we've already gotten more than enough enjoyment out of what's on offer for the sweet, sweet price of nothing but 10GB of our PS4's hard drive.
And you don't have to spend money on this gatcha business, by the way. You can earn crystals by playing the game, exchanging them for gems that you can collect throughout. Gems can be found in treasure chests, or they can be given to you as quest or challenge rewards. It can be a bit of a grind — especially since gems are also tied to daily activities in an attempt to keep you coming back — but Genshin Impact doesn't appear to be overly stingy. This is a big open world, after all, and we haven't yet run out of things to do.
So what about the game itself? Well, Genshin Impact does take cues from the aforementioned Breath of the Wild — there's just no getting away from that comparison. But to call it an outright clone would be disingenuous. Genshin Impact leans a lot harder into RPG territory, with character stats and equipment levels determining your progress. Different parts of the map are effectively level gated, featuring monsters that'll kick you to bits if your party isn't up to snuff.
As such, there's a definite grind to Genshin Impact. You're encouraged to go exploring in order to enhance your abilities, but because there's so much to see and do, the inescapable grind doesn't necessarily feel like a chore. Little secrets are scattered all across the world, with Zelda-esque environmental puzzles leading to hidden treasure chests. It's very easy to get side tracked as you make your way to the next objective marker.
When you're not jogging, sprinting, climbing, and gliding across the countryside, you're probably following the main story, which is surprisingly cinematic. It's got fully voiced cutscenes and really cool looking dragons. It's all very anime, but there's a undeniable charm to the adventure, as your clueless hero learns more about ancient gods and the raw elemental powers that they once commanded.
Speaking of the elements, they also play a major role in both exploration and combat. Within its first few hours, the game gives you four different characters to work with, each with their own elemental attack, and you can switch between them at will. Amber, for example, can shoot flaming arrows that burn away organic obstacles, while Kaeya can freeze bodies of water to create pathways. These abilities give exploration a satisfying level of interactivity, as you're always looking for ways to utilise your current party members.
And then there's the combat. Enemies in Genshin Impact tend to have elemental weaknesses, so you'll find yourself switching to different heroes in order to efficiently conquer the battlefield. But things get all the more interesting when you realise that elements can be chained together with often explosive results. For instance, you can set a foe alight with Amber's projectiles before switching to your wind-wielding hero, who can then fan the flames to deal huge damage. Likewise, icy enemies can be melted on the spot, while Lisa's electrical spells make short work of monsters that take to water. Finding new ways to exploit both your foes and the environment around you is always fun, and we imagine that the process only becomes more and more rewarding as the game goes on.
Moving on, performance was a big point of concern following the game's frankly woeful PS4 beta. Thankfully, the finished product is a dramatic improvement. The input lag that plagued the aforementioned beta test is gone, and the frame rate manages to stick to a solid 30 more often than not. There are still some noticeable dips during busy combat encounters, which is a shame considering how flashy it all looks, but hopefully they can be ironed out in the near future.
All in all, then, Genshin Impact is well worth a download. Based on our time with the release, this could easily be one of the PS4's best free-to-play titles. Yes, there are a lot of characters and items locked behind the game's gatcha system, but what's here for free is undeniably impressive.
Comments 66
Gotta agree. I've only played it for about 5 hours, but it's mighty impressive. It feels like a proper JRPG and it's one of the most charming games I've ever played.
The f2p model hasn't been an issue so far. Glad I gave it a chance.
Edit: The enemies are way too weak at first, but as soon I moved to some other areas, they got much stronger and fun to beat. Some of them gave me a real challenge. It kind of reminds me of Nino Kuni 2.
I hope it does well, because it feels like a proper game and nothing like any other f2p game I've ever played.
Setting to download now ! You've definitely piqued my interest guys
I was a bit lukewarm on it initially but it's pretty substantial for being free. Haven't hit a "wall" yet which is good. Pretty fun to play, the anime-ness of it isn't really my thing but overall a nice experience thus far. Waiting for my kids to level up so we can try some MP action!
Agree with the review and above comments. I've sunk around 8 hours in and will easily spend many more. Also with the gems I've earned from this play time I've unlocked a good set of characters to swap in/out of my party.
I forgot this was F2P. Going to download it later on.
I downloaded it yesterday, and I'm looking forward to giving it a go.
Despite being F2P you don't feel the pressure or the need to spend money on microtransactions...
You and Nintendolife seem to have very differing opinions. Perhaps they know many Nintendo fans don't want to hear that it's good? XD
Stupid question @ShogunRok Have you played BotW? I don't recall seeing you mention that anywhere.
Not much time for this right now, I'm 30+ hours into The Witcher 3. Heading to Novigrad next after finishing up all of the Baron and Bog and Pellar storylines. I may have my wife play this if she can handle the switching character combat. Downloaded it yesterday.
It's lovely! If I ever have to spend microtransactions it should be on this game. They deserve every cent! I'm playing and I feel like "why's this even free...". This is by far the best F2P ever, makes a change from the oversaturated Battle Royales. The menus, everything's so stylised like P5. The combat is so enjoyable. The characters with their unique special abilities required in unique situations....oh it's superb. I'll definitely have to spend on this game.
I'm about 15 hrs in and enjoying every minute. Manged to get 3 new characters from the gacha system using all the free currency they throw at you and I'm a couple of adventurer levels away from being able to play the event to get the Xiangling character for free.
If you just want to play through the story and move on there's no reason to spend a thing on it. I'll definitely drop 20 quid into the MTX pot as a thanks to the devs though. It's a top quality game.
@Jayofmaya "Perhaps they know many Nintendo fans"
Or, perhaps they know nearly every Nintendo fan has already played BotW but a lot of Sony fans, not owning a Wii U or Switch, haven't played it, so this would be an entirely new experience for them. The cel-shaded graphics in particular, we're used to The Witcher 3, HZD, TLOU, etc. I could see a lot more Sony fans picking this up than Ninty Zelda fanbois mad about the copying. Not much to be mad about from Playstation fans.
@rjejr Maybe. It is free at the end of the day, so there's no real reason not to try it for yourself, eve if you don't plan on getting too far into. I'm playing Warframe and Dragon Age Inquisition GOTY so will only be lightly playing it, myself.
Loving it!!!. It was 2AM last night and just had to force myself to stop 😅
I have 6 characters just playing the Story and with the free currency they give you every day and doing events.
I did buy the $4.99 30 day blessing thing. I love the world, art and music so much, I felt guilty not paying something. But the 300 it gave is sitting there, not found a use for it.
Jumping between this and 13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim... great gaming right now. But I am a zombie on my 8AM work calls 🤣
I am in love with the look of this game. It is one of the best looking games I've played. I'm also surprised by the amount of well done voice acting in the game. Exploring the world is fun and I even enjoy talking to NPC's because they all have well written dialogue. Once I'm done with Kingdoms of Amalur: Re-Reckoning, I'll definitely sink a lot more time into this.
Maybe I'll download it. It looks good. I just HATE the monetization model of the game. It's going to become a problem somewhere. That's how these companies make their money: by compromising the game design to push mtx.
@rjejr Aside from pretty much stealing some UI elements from BotW, Genshin Impact seems like an extremely different beast. If anything, the upcoming Gods and Monsters (I know the title changed, but the new title sucks) is closer to being a third-party equivalent of BotW, considering its focus on physics manipulation and environmental puzzle solving.
@Jayofmaya something like that yeah... Nintendo Fanboys are worse than PS and XB combine...
It is a good rpg game but there are certainly room for improvement.
@rjejr Yeah I've played quite a lot of it. Genshin Impact definitely takes some inspiration from BotW but people calling it a clone or a rip-off clearly haven't given it a go.
@Agramonte 😅 not another advocating 13 Sentinels. I really want to rest my poor wallet, but i fear the draw will be too much to resist. 😁
@TheArt my thoughts exactly. I'm happy to pay for a few characters or something, just to reward the developers for making such a great game.
OK fine, you win, I'll try it!
Yeah put in a few hours and its pretty fun.
The Japanese voice acting surprised me. It's really impressive. But overall the game is so much fun and experimenting with the elemental attacks adds more depth to the basic combat system
I've been hooked on this game all week. I'm really impressed by just how generous it is for a gatcha game. I've already unlocked one of the best characters with just the stuff I've been given from the start.
Looks great but honestly the F2P thing makes me feel physically sick so I won't bother
the pop in is unbearable
I played for a couple of hours today. I like it. Lovely graphics
Im playing it now and this game reminds me of tales games more than zelda.its a beautiful game and the gameplay graphics.story is really cool.i like the voice?acting also.probably the best free to play on ps4 next to destiny 2.word up son
I played this for a couple hours yesterday and was actually enjoying it, but I'm concerned about investing too much time into it without a payoff.
I have a couple questions I can't seem to find answers to about this game if anyone can help:
1. Is this a game that can be beaten?/What are the requirements to roll credits?
2. Has anyone actually run into a microtransaction wall?
Don't play these Chinese games! They are total rip-offs and steal your personal data! The CCP is the most evil government on Earth!
Can this be played offline or is it always connected only?
Glad this site is more positive about it. Nintendo life was super salty.
This released already? I forgot lol.
I'll have to give it a go.
@everynowandben The game has a main story that CAN be beaten, like Destiny
However also like Destiny, you can continue to do grind activities after the main story if beaten. Because it is f2p it will also get frequent story updates as well, so you can come back every few months to play the new stuff.
I've been playing this since the beta, it's really good
The voice acting is suprisingly great, the music is also great, the story is quite good, the graphics (especially on phone & pc) is good too. Playing this 60 fps on ipad and iphone is quite an experience, I really hope there's 4K & 60 fps ps5 version with cross-save with iphone and ipad.
@johncalmc What have you got to loose by playing it? 🤔
Does it have a main story campaign to follow? Any idea about the length?
Glad it's shaped up to be good on its own, though I will not touch this with a barge pole, simply because I freaking hate F2P games.
A game like Rocket League I get why has gone down the F2P model, it makes perfect sense for that game, but a single-player, story-driven open world RPG is the worst fit possible for that pricing model.
Even if implemented well, it causes all sorts of ripple effects like the level gating, and that's not something I wanna advocate with my time and/or money.
A shame, really.
@Bentleyma- I can't speak for him, but I for one don't want to encourage a pricing model that can only be detrimental to a game, rather than an advantage.
That's the reason I've barely tried out any F2P games in my life.
@ShogunRok Thanks. Figured you probably had just couldn't recall you mentioning it before. I'm assuming people who had played BotW or not are going to have a different reaction to this. Seeing screenshots is 1 thing, playing a game is another.
I think it's best to wait and see how the F2P model develops. At the moment it is scaled down by the sound of it, to get good reviews perhaps. What happens after that is anyone's guess and when you are hooked several hours in it is kinda too late to drop out.
@Mafia_Man19 lol
I love this game. It completely surprised me, and I'd even go as far to say this should be the new standard for F2P games. So much content, a great combat system, a huge and diverse open world with an emphasis on exploration that is rewarded more often than not, and really cool characters.
I'm genuinely excited to see where this goes, and if Honkai Impact is anything to go by (Mihoyo's last game) it's going to have a lot of support, and the need for purchasing things won't really increase until you really want to draw for some 5 star characters... Because honestly, the drop rate for them is incredibly low at .6 percent or 1 percent in a banner.
It’s all fun and games until you’re playing the prequel, Breath of the Wild.
How are the trophies? Any trophies locked behind getting lucky with the microtransactions?
@Rob_230 That is why it is a rental... wallet exploded back at PS5 pre-orders 😅
@Turbodream - The trophies are mainly for opening x amount of chests in each area, a few story related and a few for leveling chars/weapons.
As far as I can tell all the upgrade materials either drop from enemies or can be bought from a shop with a currency that you earn in-game, not a premium/paid one. If it's an enemy drop only material then clicking on that material in the upgrade menu will tell you which enemy it drops from.
I fully expect that some high level materials will require some enemy grinding to get the drops but I'm certain they're not paywalled in any way. Just your standard RNG.
@Constable_What Yah there will be future support, they said they will make a city and region for each element,thus the map will get larger,so we have like 5 more to go
@Bentleyma- Time. I don't really want to sink time into a game and then have the rug pulled out from under me when I'm twenty hours in and suddenly I either need to wait a week or buy Genshin Bucks to complete a quest.
@johncalmc - I understand your concern but I'm 20+ hrs in and haven't been held back in any way whatsoever. Everything I have in terms of weapons and characters have either been part of the game or got with the free currency you earn. It definitely follows the Warframe fair F2P model rather than a predatory one.
@Shigurui yeah but what's up with that no platinum?
I might give it a try when I've worked through my backlog.
LOL
@johncalmc - What's up with those full price Hitman games not having a platinum? Very few F2P's have one.
@johncalmc no plat trophy probably the weirdest reason to not try a f2p game lol
@Mafia_Man19
Exactly why I dont download things like this. I couldnt care less about the microtransactions. The point is my privacy.
@Powerpellet This is on playstaion network,you should not worry about a company getting your data,and if they do,it is on sony.
@rachetmarvel
Then Im tempted but the only freegame I ever downloaded required I agree to terms of service first so I deleted it and assumed they all did. I wonder if this one has that.
@johncalmc If they do that, they will probably do it after several months/a year to justify the increase in difficulty.
Case in point, I was a 1st month player of Pokemon Shuffle (a match 3 game with pokemon as powerups) and initially they added new stuff quickly but at a sustainable pace.
Many months in, probably to squeeze out at once all the remaining cash they could before quitting updating the game, they cranked the difficulty to 11. The game was then really hard but still doable for veterans, but it probably weeded out all the casuals and noobs.
@Powerpellet - Every publisher has you sign a ToS these days, Sony, EA, Activision, 2K, Ubisoft etc etc. They all do it. Every single game you play is mining your data whether you like it or not.
Unlike most games this one gives you explicit details on how to close the account and wipe your data from their servers if you choose to without having to jump through a million hoops to do so.
Downloaded for android and the first cutscene had volume but then nothing after that so can't really play it
I'm looking forward to trying this out in a few years when it's been fully patched and has more story content, including an endgame.
@Shigurui
Im sure thats right unfortunately. But its reason I dont buy those. I play indies because when I see a terms of service I never accept.
@Powerpellet - That may be so but you did sign a ToS with Sony to access PSN and in doing so you agreed to your data being shared with third parties. You may not sign individual ones for your Indie games but rest assured they are getting your data.
@Shigurui
I'm sure. But that's also why I try to limit what data they get .
@Powerpellet - Well, you do you man. Just a shame that you feel compelled to skip games for something that's happening anyway.
Downloaded it as soon as possible and it's my very first such mmorpg, although it's actually pretty much single player focused and coop falls behind in features (you can't open chests in friends world etc., or progress your character). So yeah, played around 10 hrs in 2 days, love it. It's super fun and amazing looking game. The characters are cute and the paywall is really not that existent, if any. I already have unlocked 9 characters,
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...