Set in 16th-century Bavaria, Pentiment tells the tale of the small Alpine town of Tassing and the simple people that dwell there. We play as a Nurembergian artist named Andreas Maler who is living in Tassing while he completes work on a piece for the local monastery, and through him we meet the residents of the town and share in their struggles during a period of political and religious upheaval.
It's a cruel time and a hard life, made harder still when a visiting Baron is murdered in the town and the abbot fingers Andreas' friend for the crime. From here, Andreas launches a private investigation into the matter, which involves talking to the local peasantry and clergy, unearthing clues as to who might have had a motive for offing the Baron, and pulling at threads that hint at a more sinister plot lurking beneath the surface of the town.
The storytelling is at times glacial in its pacing. It's trite to say that a game isn't for everyone in a review since that could broadly be said about any video game, but it's worth mentioning that if you're not a fan of slow-burning fiction, or excessive reading, or spending time chatting with sullen-faced peasants about which one of their kids didn't survive the winter then perhaps this isn't a game for you.
While Pentiment lives and dies by how the story grabs you, worth mentioning also is the wonderful animation work and the delightful art style of the game. It's like a painting brought to life, each location in the game beautifully realised in severe black outlines and colours that pop off the screen. There's no voice acting in the game, so you'll spend most of it hearing little but the chirping of birds and the shuffling of feet, but a sparse employment of music is used to poignant effect.
We were largely enthralled during our dozen or so hours with Pentiment. The mystery at the heart of the narrative remains compelling throughout, but it was the smaller moments that warmed our hearts; breaking bread with friends, sharing in their joy and heartbreak, watching lives play out, and generations pass, in a world on the cusp of dramatic change.
Comments 57
At last, I can stop monologuing in the mirror when I feel the urge to spend time chatting with sullen-faced peasants. Team Green’s sudden realization that they’re the world’s largest software company is already bearing fruit!
Every game, or any form of media, is not for everyone. Why is that a negative point for this game?
@bpomber Agreed. They dont stamp this on Yakuza reviews, but I very much know I don't enjoy the beat em up gameplay
@LordAinsley @bpomber This is noted in the review text.
Doesn't particular look or sound very appealing to me, what makes it even worse is the lack of voice acting, even indies with games that cost less include voice acting.
I played quite a bit of this on gamepass when it released but fell off in the 2nd act. Very unique experience and I do plan on playing (and hopefully sticking with it) this after Rebirth at some point.
Tried on a free month of gamepass in the past. It is a very niche title that many will simply not enjoy as i did not. Not to say its bad, just not massively appealing
"not for everyone" should now be put in the negative for every review you do it applies to all games
Having played this on Gamepass last year, I fully agree with this review
"Not for everyone"
Could be said about every game
@UltimateOtaku91 FYI it would be hard to execute with voice acting as the way the text animates in, and out, is part of the game at times.
Yeah Pentiment will either click in the first hour or not at all. I loved the game and generally think it is the best xbox game this decade (maybe one of three or four that I actually consider good in that ecosystem)
I love the way the ending connects all the stories but I also acknowledge its abrupt nature. Music is brilliant though and the mind palace scene at the end made me cry.
@mariomaster96 @trev666 @LordAinsley @bpomber You’re all partly right, every game is “not for everyone”. But I think it’s fair to say this is far MORE niche than most and will actively put more people off with its eccentricities. Perhaps it could be better worded, and the actual review does better than that bullet point, but I think it’s fair to include that reservation in the review.
Tried it on Game Pass and it was not for me. I guess a certain type of gamer likes this type of niche game. It does however have a 4.8 rating in the PS Store.
This is one of my personal favorite games. Since it launched it started a whole new interested in the Middle Ages for me that's still going strong (currently reading a history of the crusades by Steven Runciman)
Baldurs Gate 3 10/10*
Elden Ring 10/10*
😁
@TwoDents it would have already been in development when they bought Bethesda I think, there's a PS5 build of Starfield that was worked on until they were told to stop after the acquisition.
@get2sammyb I saw that, it says it's worth mentioning. I'm questioning why it's worth mentioning for this game and not others.
Loved it on Game Pass, would happily play it again.
@get2sammyb Based on the comments, you probably only need a number and bullet points and can use lorem ipsum for the body text in future reviews. Might be some cost savings there.
@Amnesiac no no.
Everybody’s point is this has as a negative ‘may not be for everyone’ because it’s a slow burner.
Gt7 doesn’t have a negative saying ‘not for everyone’ because you may not like track sim.
Or GoW doesn’t say not for everyone because you may not like over the shoulder 3rd person.
It has happened on an Xbox release game.
If you are going to put it on one game you HAVE to apply the same standard to all reviews.
@PsBoxSwitchOwner @Ravix @mariomaster96 @trev666 @LordAinsley @bpomber
From the review you are all commenting on:
The lack of voice acting is explained by the fact it is set in Southern Germany and the text you read is often translated in front of your eyes as you do so. Having an English voiceover wouldn't work at all.
@Impossibilium
Like I said above, you can apply that logic to any game. (And the review does)
So why single out this one game for it? Simple answer is because it’s an Xbox studios game. No other reason for it.
We just want consistency across reviews.
so every game is for everyone apart from this one
This game is definitely not for me that's for sure. Hifi Rush maybe but not this.
I heavily dislike the type of murder mystery structure Pentiment uses, similar to LA Noire, where you spend most of the game 'solving' crimes knowing that the real perpetrator has got away.
The real perpetrator was guessable by the start of act two but the games makes you play on for hours before letting you do anything about it.
@Impossibilium again, I saw that. I'm questioning why it's worth mentioning for this game and not any other?
For example, in the NHL 24 review why not say:
"It's trite to say that a game isn't for everyone in a review since that could broadly be said about any video game, but it's worth mentioning that if you're not a fan of hockey then perhaps this isn't a game for you."
It seems also, that reading the actual review is not for everyone. Going by the comments.
Very nice meme potential, after IGN's "Too much water", we now have Push Square's "Not for everyone".
@Impossibilium It's still trite to say it. Just because he explained it doesn't make it less trite. Instead of writing that in the negative points he could've put "slow burning and excessive reading".
I understand his argument, but people who look at the bullet points will be dissatisfied.
It's similar to the IGN Pokemon review with "too much water". Even though the writer went in detail about why the excess of water routes in a Pokémon game bogs it down, everyone thought that saying "too much water" was overly simplistic.
@bpomber I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that the reviewer found it worth mentioning because a 2D murder mystery role playing game set in a 16th century Bavarian town is slightly more niche than hockey.
@bpomber To be fair, separate from this conversation that’s taking place, a fair number of commenters have pointed out that they tried the game and couldn’t get into it. So, I suppose that’s the point here.
For the record, I added the negative bullet point to John’s review during editing, and he obviously made his point much more eloquently in the text.
That falls on me, so your feedback is noted, although I still think you’re being a bit pedantic.
I’ve now edited to “an acquired taste” which perhaps better captures the point being made here.
I hope this clears up any confusion. Thanks for the feedback!
„An acquired taste“ is a con?!
You guys complaining about that bullet point are definitely being pedantic. The reason for it was fully explained. Just stop.
@get2sammyb You're absolutely right that I'm being pedantic. I'm being this way because I think minor details and rules for reviews should be consistent across the board.
I do understand your reasoning a bit more now though, so thanks for the response.
@LordAinsley Yep they should stamp that on Yakuza too.
@PsBoxSwitchOwner The Pure XBox review also had “Starts off slowly, absolutely takes it time in conversations and may not be for everyone” in its ‘Cons’ summary too. So I don’t think this was a PlayStation site specific comment.
https://www.purexbox.com/reviews/xbox-series-x/pentiment
@get2sammyb Or you remove it entirely, which would be the best move from my perspective, because this rebranding doesn’t address the issue MANY here have that it is not a negative, just a characteristic. But such a bold and brave move would require to swallow the own pride.
It is niche. I’m the only one of my Xbox friends who played it. But if you think you might like it, then you probably will.
@Max_the_German @bpomber @Pat_trick The Pure XBox review which has been up for over a year doesn’t have a single comment complaining that “may not be for everyone” is a bullet point on the negative side. I suspect the outcry here is overcompensating to try to seem like we aren’t picking on an XBox studios game on a PS site. But in reality, the XBox review says the same thing.
@Th3solution I'm not registered on Pure Xbox and I couldn't care less about the console wars.
I actually said the he explained his point well in the review while the bullet point is way too vague to be understood, that's all.
@Th3solution I didn‘t know, but I had the exact same feeling as all the others here. I find it just a poor level of journalism, no matter where it appeared first.
@bpomber I do see your point, and think you've expressed it very well. I suppose, maybe with other "genre" games, like GT, or NHL etc. People already know going in, whether they like racing, or sports... but a murder mystery set in the medieval times might sound like a gripping premise, that actually puts someone off because they thought it'd play like Kingdom Come, rather than similar to Disco Elysium... (not saying it is like DE, but as an example of a walkabout, slow burn, mystery).
It’s a Josh Sawyer game, so will definitely be playing it.
Some of these comments are not for everyone. Or an an acquired taste.
@TwoDents oh I bet anything Indiana Jones is coming to ps5
@PsBoxSwitchOwner Jesus who cares people are coming off as butthurt fanboys and it’s not like the game didn’t get a good score
@Th3solution that’s exactly what it is. It’s Xbox fanboys up in their feelings and it’s so transparent
@bpomber Xbox tax
Removed - flaming/arguing
@Pat_trick it's an IGN "too much water" issue. It is a poorly written bullet point that's actually very well explained in the article itself.
@TwoDents I think Indy being an FPS is what makes it interesting though. Uncharted already did third person run and gun action. Tomb Raider did third person stealth action. Indy being first person will make it unique and play to MGs strength. The whip mechanic looked a little janky though and I hope they fix it.
The only game I was really hoping would show up on PlayStation, and here we are. Sounds right up my alley.
This seems like more of a steam deck game for me, I just wish there was an easier way to play gamepass games on steam deck. Any chance we'll see a deal with Microsoft and Valve to get gamepass integrated into the steam deck?
Funny seeing people whining about the review of an old niche game that probably most won't buy, even less at $20. This game should have been $10.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...