Comments 222

Re: Xbox Sales Hit New Low in UK, Barely Competes with PS5 at This Point

Carnage

Xbox adopting the PC model of selling hardware for a profit doesn’t mean much to the PlayStation. There are lots and lots of things competing for people’s attention nowadays (the Nex Playground is an interesting competitor).

The big challenge IMHO is current gen hardware prices have going in the wrong direction for a lot of reasons (many outside the control of the industry). The PS1 started at $300 but eventually dropped to $100. The PS5 started at $500 and is now $550. Yes it’s a small increase compared to the massive one the Xbox has seen but the sorts of more casual and/or budget minded gamers who jump into consoles mid gen clearly aren’t being drawn in in the numbers they could be.

Re: Game of the Year: #5 - Dispatch

Carnage

Finished my first playthrough of Dispatch yesterday (I started playing it early Christmas morning). From the perspective of a longtime fan this is easily Telltale/Ad Hoc’s best game.

Anyway, dispatching superheroes is a pretty deep because there are multiple missions requiring different skill sets which often can benefit from more than one hero being involved, though that might mean you have the wrong people or even no one on hand to deal with subsequent events.

I have only played through the one time at the time of this post but I know (because the game told me at the end of each episode) how big choices I made in my character’s personal life shaped things and it’s also nice how you can upgrade heroes (they have ability points as well as short upgrade trees) and they get more comfortable with each other over time if they are dispatched together (some of them start off pretty comfortable).

The writing is strong, the characters are vibrant, the art direction is gorgeous and the music fits the game very well. I eager to play the next season of Dispatch (I am fine with waiting so long as the episodes are released in close proximity).

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 613

Carnage

Just finished Dispatch for the first time. Telltale is back (as Ad Hoc). I did fairly poorly on the minigames and dispatching but I avoided strategy guides and now that I understand everything better through bitter experience I aim to rise above the bottom 1% of dispatchers 😅! Also I can think
of several different choices/potential alternate paths I’d like to explore.

Re: Ex-PlayStation Boss Believes Exclusives Make Consoles 'Sing'

Carnage

Exclusivity means a lot to gamers making lists on the internet but in and of itself means nothing to the overwhelming majority of gamers.

If someone enjoys a game (whether it is an exclusive like Astrobot or a multiplatform game like Dispatch) they buy it and maybe recommend it to friends, if they don’t they ignore it.

I have enjoyed a lot of exclusives over the decades and I expect I will continue to do so but I don’t hold being multiplatform against a game.

Re: Game of the Year: #7 - Lumines Arise

Carnage

Luminees Arise is a spiritual sequel to Tetris Effect with even more gorgeous and trippy audiovisuals. The way some of the puzzle pieces and stages morph as things progress (my highlight is the vegetable stage) is really crazy.

Shrugs I don’t worry much about rankings or awards (it’s a very rare year when I’ve played every game in contention and I don’t like all genres equally) I’m just glad that like most other Enhance games Luminees seems to have found an audience.

Re: Embattled Divinity Dev to Host Q&A with Fans After Tough Week

Carnage

As I noted before Larian should have seen this coming since all of the excitement about the game is based on their promises (the trailer was very cool but contained no gameplay).

While there is a vocal group of online skeptics of AI use in game creation I doubt the average gamer cares. Clair Expedition 33 and Arc Raiders have/are experiencing some turbulence over their use of AI but clearly lots of gamers are squarely focused on the games rather than their creation. Another interesting point of comparison is the latest CoD, whose relatively cool reception is partly a result of AI being used in ways gamers felt lessened the stuff they care about.

I respect people who are skeptical of or even opposed to AI vs human made art but it’s cheap in a competitive industry struggling to both catch the attention of people in a world saturated with entertainment options and keep costs down. I believe kind of like CG FX vs practical stunts in movies the games industry is going to wind up encompassing them both depending on not just audience reaction but what individual creators are enthusiastic about.

Shrugs Based on my experience with Divinity 2 and BG3 I am very enthused about Larian’s next game and that feeling won’t change unless the gameplay they show of the next Divinity is sloppy.

Re: 'Sony's Never Experienced This Phenomenon Before': PS5 Smash Hit Gran Turismo 7 Getting Stronger Over Time

Carnage

Well deserved. Polyphony Digital has always been a quirky team who often finds themselves on the right side of things.

I remember an old preview of the original GT which questioned the economics of Gran Turismo (which included 200 or so cars when the genre average was a small fraction of that) and its focus on driving (a separate but related thing from racing) all sorts of cars including sedans and minivans ordinary people use in their everyday lives rather than just racing with supercars built to win competitions snd look real cool doing it.

Last but not least as a PSVR2/Pro owner I appreciate Polyphony’s continued willingness to support new tech which offers enthusiasts a deeper way to engage with their games (their use of the haptics of the dual sense is also exemplary). I never saw it first hand but years ago I watched videos of GT5’s multi monitor mode and thought ‘Yamauchi must not hear ‘no’ a lot’ 😋.

Gran Turismo 7 is great fun and the oldest game in my regular rotation and I don’t see that changing until GT8 sometime in the distant future.

Re: Nov 2025 USA Sales: Black Ops 7 Is the Month's Bestseller, But Struggles to Meet Call of Duty Standards

Carnage

The hardware numbers make sense. Consoles going up in price rather than down (the PS1 launched at $300 but eventually fell to $100) is clearly keeping a big chunk of people out of the market.

If I were a hardware maker intent on releasing new hardware I’d wait for overall inflation/ram prices/tariffs to fall (not sure when that’s going to happen, probably no time soon).

https://bsky.app/profile/matpiscatella.bsky.social/post/3ma6vnwvjmk2h

The average price paid for a new unit of video game hardware in the US during November 2019 was $235. In November 2025 it was $439.

3.9 million units of video game hardware sold in the US in November 2019. In November 2025 it was 1.6 million.

Re: Divinity Dev's Comments on Generative AI Trigger a Total Social Media Sh*tstorm

Carnage

I think the reaction to the AI talk (Larian says they are using AI but it’s not that helpful and no AI generated stuff will be in the final game) is excessive but Larian knows it is an enviable position where CG trailers and words can excite a big chunk of gamers so their surprise and irritation over the strong negative reaction to their latest batch of words is bizarre.

I personally don’t get excited by CG nor do I focus on stuff real far out (‘We are working on something too early to show, but get hyped now!’) but based on my experience with the original Divinity 2 and BG3 I’m sure whenever Larian’s next game comes out it will be phenomenal if they maintain their old standards.

Re: PS5 Will Be the Only Console You Can Play Phantom Blade Zero for at Least 12 Months

Carnage

Shrugs Windows of exclusivity are still a thing for a variety of reasons (one of which is moneyhatting another of which is the benefit of developers being able to focus since platform optimization is time consuming). I’m fine with the practice so long as developers are upfront about their plans.

To go on a somewhat related rant, Disgaea 7 is an example of the sort of exclusivity that bothers me. I splashed out the money for the ‘Complete’ PS5 version of Disgaea 7 at launch but NiS subsequently sold some dlc exclusively to Nintendo of America for an undisclosed period of time. That will give me and other PS5 or PC gamers pause the next time NiS comes around asking us to pay for not just the base game, but future content.

Re: 'If I Don't Belong in the Games Industry, I'll Have to Look Elsewhere': Keita Takashashi Moves Back to Japan After To a T Flopped

Carnage

To a T is a very weird, sweet game about a disabled boy who wanders around doing and learning stuff with the aid of his dog, his loving mother and a growing circle of friends. The gameplay consists of a handful of simple minigames/challenges the boy faces as he navigates through life but despite visual similarities it’s a very different design than that of his breakout hit Katamari Damancy.

I really enjoyed To a T and loved its world but I’m not shocked it didn’t do well commercially. More games are released per day than the average gamer buys in a year, the rare successes tend to have long tails (which is good for them and their fans, bad for other games) and there are more clicks to be had hating or hyping stuff everybody knows than trying to sell people on unknowns. Such is the industry.

I hope Mr. Takahasi continues to work in the industry (it seems he is looking for a publisher) and create original content but I get he has a family to support and no matter the choice he makes I wish him well.

Re: All The Game Awards 2025 Winners

Carnage

I don’t watch the show for the awards but giving the best strategy game award to a FFT remaster over The Alters or Two Point Museum (I didn’t play the other nominees) indicates to me there weren’t many strategy game fans among the voters.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 611

Carnage

Spent the weekend playing Roboquest VR (hectic and tough but fun first person roguelike), Sektori (hectic and tough 2D roguelike in the vein of Geometry Wars), Two Point Museum (whose zoo expansion has some cool twists including animal rescue) and of course Helldivers 2 (been practicing with the backpack nuclear bomb and friendly casualties have been minimal and enemy casualties have been massive).

I also watched that Johnny Cage animated movie Cage Match. It was even more of a comedy than I was expecting but it’s fast moving, dumb fun. The visuals are great, very reminiscent of Miami Vice.

Re: Poll: How Would You Rate The Game Awards 2025?

Carnage

I dozed off a few times towards the end but I watched most of the pre-show and the show. Neither of my predictions (a Media Molecule reveal and a Helldivers 2 new phase announcement) happened but I enjoyed the show. Ontos, Phantom Blade Zero and Saros were my highlights.

Re: New and Returning Killzone Content in Helldivers 2 Warbond Next Week

Carnage

I own all the old KZ stuff already but it’s nice it’s coming around again.

The guns are solid (though like all guest stuff they can’t be upgraded/modified like normal guns) but the best thing about the pack is the armor, whose multi element resistance (acclimated, which provides 50% resistance to gas, fire and electricity) was once unusual but which has now been almost equaled by the Dust Devils warbond (only 40% elemental resistance but also a 20% throwing range bonus). The only advantage Dust Devils armor has (IMHO) is it offers a heavy variant.

It’s also worth noting the Helghast armor looks very cool, especially the glowing red eyes of the helmets.

Re: Netflix Says Warner Bros Games Doesn't Hold 'Any Value' in $82 Billion Acquisition

Carnage

WB’s game division management has been awful of late but Netflix’s is even worse. Netflix recognizing that they lack the skills/temperament/incentive to manage a profitable game division strikes me as reasonable. It’s a damn tough business. Along those lines the ‘Netflix for gaming’ model hasn’t demonstrated that it is commercially viable yet. Games aren’t like tv shows or movies where many fans demand a constant stream of stuff, a few games a year satisfy the vast majority of gamers just fine. .

Re: 'The Development Speed Is Amazing': Shuhei Yoshida Says Japanese Studios Can't Keep Pace with China

Carnage

@PuppetMaster Don’t know about the quality (haven’t played any of the big Chinese made games) but the Chinese pop culture market is huge and like a lot of markets, values stuff which speaks to it. To not invest in China is to leave a lot of money on the table.

It’s incredible that Ne Za 2 is the biggest animated movie ever and made almost all its money in China. On the flipside lots of markets are cool with stuff shaped by cultures and myths they don’t know much about (Black Myth Wukong made most of its money in China but did well among Soulslike fans everywhere).

Re: Key Square Enix Shareholder Publicly Criticises Weak Game Sales, Company Management

Carnage

I think breaking FF7 into three big, separate parts (seen as the safest of safe bets) was a mistake. The first two are fine games but the fact Squenix is pouring more resources into FF7 remakes than they are into modern FFs (thus far just FF16 though I guess we might get 17 before the generation ends in a few years).

I’ll also note Squenix’s competition has gotten stronger (nods towards Clair Obscure and the modern Personas) and fans are more willing to look elsewhere. I thought the Shadow Hearts series (especially the second) was a great series on par with Square’s work but it never built up much of a fanbase.

Re: PS5 Survival Gem The Alters Gets Big Free Content Update Today

Carnage

Nice. The Alters is an excellent character based strategy game with lots of hard choices and branching paths I didn’t fully explore but I did play it several times (I saw one good(ish) ending in which most survived, but many bad ones).

My dance card is kinda full at the moment but I will jump back into it soon to check out the new content.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 610

Carnage

Thus far I’ve been playing Sektori (a twin stick shooter I suck at but the few minutes it takes to kill me are glorious), Luminees Arise (wonderfully trippy), GT7 (haven’t messed much with the new content because I am working on winning 1st on an older track), Helldivers 2 (which got a new warbond with an insane new shotgun as well as the long requested mini gun but also got new lava worlds which introduced new mission types including an incredibly brutal new extraction mission), Roboquest VR (gorgeous cell shaded roguelike fps with some crazy weapons and a ton of enemy variety), Demon School (which has a pixelart style and is kind of a fusion of Persona and a squad based tactics game and has become my game of choice when playing on Portal) and a bit of V Racer Hoverbike (I am having trouble with this one time challenge, missing the mark by .007 seconds at one point).

I would like to check out Path of Exile 2 (which just got a major update) and start on Ghost Town (VR puzzle/adventure game) but time will tell. I normally don’t get in this much gaming time but there are upsides to having a cold 😁.

Re: Someone Made Banjo-Kazooie in Dreams on PS5, PS4, and You've Got to See It

Carnage

It’s been months since I played Dreams but there are a lot of talented creators there and the engine is both easy to use and incredibly flexible.

As I noted in a long post I once made on Dreams I think what hurt it was the lack of any form of multiplayer at launch (offline co-op hit months after launch) and the fact the campaign was pretty simple (more a demo of the things the engine was capable of than a proper game).

Re: Poll: Five Years of PS5 - How Would You Rate Sony's Console?

Carnage

No complaints here. I’m perfectly happy with my PS5 Pro (and my Portal and my PSVR2). The hardware is nice and the library is wide and deep.

I’m currently playing Roboquest VR (lots of weird guns and for my money the best VR fps since Synapse), Sektori (a gorgeous twin stick shooter from an ex-Housemarque developer very in line with their 2D games and of course Geometry Wars), Helldivers 2 (whose intense co-op action reminds me of arcade classics like Smash TV) and Luminees Arise (I admittedly suck at it but I love the audiovisuals).

Re: New Weapons, Stratagems Take Helldivers 2 to the Jungle in Latest Premium Warbond

Carnage

The mini gun has medium penetration (light penetration was a possibility since a lot of fully automatic weapons fall into that category) and like other guns with backpacks one ammo pickup will only partially refill it.

Based on chatter among randoms this morning between dives I expect it to be phenemonenally popular (among people who play Helldivers anyway 😋) once it hits.

Also the chainsaw sword sounds like it will be hands down the best melee weapon (aka the tallest midget). It starts off medium penetration but kind of like the dual sickle damage increases over time so it can eventually cut through even heavy armor.

Re: New Weapons, Stratagems Take Helldivers 2 to the Jungle in Latest Premium Warbond

Carnage

I’m glad the content drought is over. In my experience (I am gaming on a Pro though I crossplay with all sorts of randoms) the crashing was resolved weeks ago so I have been using the new content pause to play with some of the weirder weapons.

The mini gun and the assault rifle with grenade launcher under barrel look very useful but I think like the arc drone the fire drone will result in a lot of friendly fire deaths.

The chainsaw sword looks fun. I’m not a big melee guy but it’ll be nice to see people running around with the chainsaw rather than the one true flag.