In this sixth part of our Silent Hill 2 Walkthrough, which presents a step-by-step guide to completing the entire game on PS5, including Collectibles, we'll be covering Toluca Prison. James finds himself down here after jumping down a hole in the Historical Society.
This Walkthrough is intended for a playthrough where the Combat Challenge and Puzzles Challenge are both set to the Standard option. For more information covering Combat and Puzzles difficulty options, click the link. This page offers a full guide through the location, from when you drop down from above until reach the Labyrinth. Also included is the Witness Room Generator solution and the Gallows puzzle solution in the Yard.
Silent Hill 2: Toluca Prison Walkthrough - All Collectibles: Memos, Glimpses of the Past, Strange Photos
After using the Spiral-writing Key up on the big grate in the Historical Society, you'll drop down into Toluca Prison, more specifically its Canteen. There's a Health Drink behind where you land, then you can approach the lit-up corpse to find Eddie, who appears to be losing it. Before you do, from the position you started in, go to the end of one of the wooden tables on the right for a Glimpse of the Past.
Glimpses of the Past #1
As soon as you drop down into the Canteen, before talking to Eddie, go to one of the wooden tables on the right to find a wooden slab you can interact with for the Glimpse of the Past.
When you regain control after speaking to Eddie, head through the double doors and enter the door directly ahead to find a save point, the Toluca Prison Map, Handgun Ammo, Rifle Rounds, and a Memo. You'll also spot the Rifle locked away in a cabinet, so we'll need to acquire that via solving a puzzle later on.
Memo #1: Gun Cabinet Notice
After speaking to Eddie in the cutscene at the start of Toluca Prison, go through the double doors and enter the room directly ahead to find the Gun Cabinet Notice next to the locked cabinet with the Rifle inside.
Back out in the hallway, go into the Chapel and approach the altar to find The Heaviest Weight, then in the Vestry next to it is a book extract to read. With this section explored, the only path open to you is the one into Block A and Block B. In here, at the beginning and end of each cell block row, are levers you can pull that'll turn the lights on for a short amount of time. The mechanic isn't essential because you can simply pull the cell doors open, but they do make seeing a little easier. In A3, you'll find Rifle Rounds and a Glimpse of the Past.
Glimpses of the Past #2
In Cell A3 of Block A on floor 1F, interact with the shrine in the back corner.
In Cell A5 there's Handgun Ammo, then in Cell B1 you'll find a Health Drink. Enter Cell B3 and break down the wall leading into Cell A8, which holds Shotgun Shells. With the cells searched, head east into the Yard. As you walk in, you'll hear something running around in the dark. Approach the Scales in front and place The Heaviest Weight on it. While you were searching the two Blocks of cells, you likely noticed the sculptures of an Eyeless Boar, a Hornless Ox, a Headless Serpent, and a Wingless Dove. By placing the two weights on the Scales correctly, we can open the doors they've been engraved into. The first one you can open is the Headless Serpent, which is done by placing the heavy weight on the right and the lighter one on the left.
Return to where James marked it on your map, allowing you access to Death Row / 1F Serpent Section. Cut through the Guardroom and work your way through the next cell block, searching E4 for a Memo of a Family Photo. Every other cell is locked, so head through the door in the northwest leading to the Witness Room.
Memo #2: Family Photo
Search Cell E4 on the Death Row / 1F Serpection Section floor to find this Memo.
Feel free to save your game, then interact with the Generator next to the locked door. For the solution to power up the Witness Room Generator, click the following link: