We've spent around 20 hours with Mass Effect: Andromeda, and within that time, our belief that the internet can make things seem much, much worse than they actually are has been greatly reinforced. BioWare's latest intergalactic tale is nowhere near perfect, but from what we've played so far, we reckon that the series' spacefaring soul is still alive and well.
As you may have already realised, Mass Effect: Andromeda makes for a very easy target. For about a week now, the web has been swamped in gifs and videos of the game's cock-ups - dire character animations make for a seemingly endless supply of embarrassment. And these laughable scenarios really do exist, by the way - we've been playing a fully patched version of the final release and it's rough to say the least.
If we had to write a full review now, it's safe to say that we'd be rather torn. There are aspects of Andromeda that we really enjoy - the combat is a genuine step forward, for example - but at the same time, there are issues that we simply can't ignore. The aforementioned animations immediately spring to mind; human faces in general look painfully awkward, to the point where you won't be able to concentrate on the current conversation because you're trying to work out how the monstrosity that stands before you ever came to be. The lack of quality is baffling, especially when you consider how much better Dragon Age: Inquisition's cast looked back in 2014 - and even they weren't great.
We don't want to rant on about facial animations, but the bottom line is that little details like this can pull you out of the experience. On that note, it's worth mentioning that we've encountered a number of bugs during our time with the game - the kind of bugs that end up in YouTube highlight reels. From squadmates assuming t-poses for the duration of whole conversations to both allies and enemies dropping their animations entirely and skating across the battlefield, there's an overbearing feeling that Andromeda has been rushed to market. And when you consider how long it's been in development - not to mention the fact that it was delayed - it really makes you wonder what happened behind the scenes.
Performance isn't great on a standard PlayStation 4, either. The frame rate sees some noticeable drops in busy areas or during large firefights, and environmental pop-in is prevalent when you're driving across a planet's surface. All of these negatives, no matter how minor, begin to add up.
We question whether they're enough to outright ruin the game, though. Andromeda manages to capture an enthusiastic sense of adventure as you and your buddies hop from planet to planet, discovering ancient alien technology and putting bullets in the local wildlife. When you're done gallivanting around alien worlds, you return to the Tempest - a sleek looking ship that acts as your hub during your travels. It's a lot cosier than the Normandy - the vessel that starred in previous titles - and watching our squad transform it into their home has been one of the game's highlights so far.
Indeed, there's a warm camaraderie at the core of Andromeda. Unlike Commander Shepard, Ryder - whether male or female - is very much an explorer, not an elite soldier. He or she is here to help find humanity a home in a brand new galaxy, and as such, Ryder comes across as a more lighthearted protagonist. So far, it's an approach that's worked quite well, as we've found ourselves enjoying role-playing as Ryder - a likeable rookie who's just about as clueless as we are.
That brings us neatly to the writing, which, as mentioned, is surprisingly hit and miss. BioWare partially built its name on creating well realised characters that we could connect with, and although Andromeda has already offered up several seriously interesting personalities, we've found ourselves cringing at some of the dialogue. There are a few one-liners here that would make even the cheesiest of action movies blush, and after squadmate Liam came out with "Hah, I think I really p*ssed that one off... Maybe because I shot him in the face" during combat, we decided there and then that he would never be coming on another mission.
It's the kind of cheap and dirty dialogue that we really don't expect from a studio such as BioWare, but much like the other issues that we outlined earlier, it's not quite enough to kill the fun. There's clear evidence of a great Mass Effect title here: the much improved punchy combat, the intriguing alien worlds, the addictive process of unlocking cool new abilities for Ryder, and, of course, the tension that comes with making tough story decisions. Right now, we just need to see all of this good stuff shine through the game's disappointing exterior.
Are you looking forward to Mass Effect: Andromeda? We'll have our full review ready soon, but until then, jet off to another galaxy in the comments section below.
Comments 53
I haven't played all of the game yet - we got review code late - but if anyone has any questions, I'll do my best to answer them.
Cancelled my preorder for this. I don't recall ever having done that before. Glad to read it's not all bad, will likely pick it up in a sale when they start fixing it.
This was a day one purchase originally but in all my years of gaming I've never seen a game go from AAA excitement to an internet meme/joke so quickly. Okay maybe UbiSoft games come close but I love the ME series and I see this as a situation where so many things went wrong over many years - to the point where I believe anyone who spoke up about it's potential issues was either let go or too afraid to say anything. I can't wait for the reporter who really gets the full scoop in the next couple months hopefully.
Early returns have been mixed and I can't say I'm surprised. For the love it got, I didn't exactly think Dragon Age: Inquisition was all that either and it's not like there's a shortage of good action RPGs. Just the last few weeks saw Horizon: Zero Dawn, The Legend of Zelda; Breath of the Wild and NieR: Automata. It's also a post-Witcher 3 world as I've said plenty of times, and RPG at this point needs to be really good to compete and unfortunately this isn't the old school Bioware. Still picking the game up as I did like the first 3 games (didn't like how 3 ended but it is what it is).
Even IGN gave it a 7.7..
@ShogunRok
I've heard that only the salarians, krogan, asari and turians made it...
So no Drell, Quarians, Hanar, Geth, Elcor, Volus, Rachni...I could go on...Is this so?
The majority of early reports agree that the combat is the best part and everything else is really quite average. Good combat isn't why I fell in love with Mass Effect.
This is definitely a wait till its patched and buy when its under £20 game
Oh no 😞
Star Boy come back all is forgiven.
It does sound a fairly poor game from such a usually good developer. The animations are usually the tip of the iceberg but steal all the limelight.
Much like Fallout 4, graphical issues from a 'big' developer are usually the hint that something isn't quite right with the game and its development.
Combat, im sure will be fine.. just like Fallout 4 however when the dialogue and possibly the story is poor to the developers usual standards coupled with the animation issues then I know it'll be a struggle for me to enjoy the rest of the game.
Especially, given the recent RPG releases I have just completed one after the other (final fantasy xv and Horizon) which have been very good examples on how to do RPG's I'll be giving this a miss I think.
Looks like I'll save my money and play through Baldur's Gate again. 😀
According to the reviews I read, the game will be quite good once patched. Problems with UI or menus and glitches can be patched as The Witcher 3 showed last year. Let's see what EA and BioWare are going to do in the next months...
Because of all the negative previews so far, I cancelled my preorder and bought horizon instead last week. I think mass effect will be one to pick up once it has been patched (and is on sale) in a few months time. Mass Effect games shouldnt have any of the issues listed above.
cancelled my pre order wait till its alot cheaper
Made a decision to get 2Dark Limited Edition and Little Nightmare Six Edition for PS4 instead.
the most important question, how many monster/alien jump scares!
@HarrisonMode I have it was called Skyrim.
Just wait until its patched obviously i gave them to much credit to Bioware as developers, but thinking about it Bioware only hit it big with ME. Thay are at the same standard as Betheada Game Studio, otherwise not really that good as developers go.
After those reviews, I am glad I cancelled my pre-order and went with NieR.
Yeah no thanks. Shame as I hoped we'd have a great scifi RPG, but with the likes of Horizon and Nier (and BOTW if you've a Wii U/Switch) why opt for this?
Will get it down the line, Dragon Age has been £10-£12 in sales lately.
Bottom line, the bar has been raised in 2017 and anything that comes out now has to live up to the standard that has been set or people will spend their money elsewhere.
@Mega-Gazz exactly, I called this last year too prior to uncharted 4.
The dodgy 20fps frame rates 900p and weak presentations were put down to the hardware. That's been clearly proven wrong since U4s release with the multitude of optimized games such as Horizon. Its the developers at fault.
@themcnoisy Time to get Horizon instead?
I was definitely going to buy it within the first month or so, but now I will probably wait for a price drop. I will definitely get it, though.
@themcnoisy It seems that all those in-house developer issues have affected the overall quality of this. So many people leaving and being replaced. Its not the same 'Bioware' studio that created the original trilogy - this is Bioware Montreal as opposed to Bioware Edmonton (if that makes a difference) - maybe the change to Frostbite was more of an issue as the developers were not familiar with it - the originals were on Unreal 3.
Maybe I am making excuses a bit for the lack of polish - maybe EA themselves were pressuring Bioware to release instead of polishing etc.
The Difference between games like Uncharted and Horizon is that they were built specifically for the Playstation 4. That means that every aspect is tailor made to the exact specifications and specific attributes of that hardware. Its no different in essence from Xbox games like Forza, Gears of War etc from also running perfectly well at 1080p on the XB1 yet multi-platform games often fail to run at locked frame rates or even as high a resolution. It was no different last gen either with games like Uncharted and Last of us being some of the best looking and running games on the PS3 (andarguably better than any console game) yet struggled to Multi-platform games as well as the Xbox 360 at times - the RAM was split into 2 separate blocks of 256MB and couldn't be 'shared' where as the Xbox had a block of 512MB and gave developers the ability to allocate RAM specifically - so if Graphics required 300MB, they had to compress that on PS3 to 256MB. What I am trying to say though is that a game built to the System is a lot easier to design around its strengths and weaknesses than trying to port a game to these. Frostbite games on PS4 don't tend to run at 1080p anyway - Mirrors Edge, Star Wars: BF, Battlefield 4, Hardline etc all run at 900p - Battlefield 1 uses Dynamic Scaling so can hit 1080p on occasion but generally these are 900p games.
As I said, the same argument was levelled at the PS3 - why is it that PS3 exclusives can look and run as well as they do but multi-platform releases often didn't run as well as the XB360 versions.
This article seems to contradict with most of reviews...
Cancelled my preorder too.. good I have more time to finish up Zelda and Horizon
@Godsent Not sure how it contradicts? Reception seems very mixed.
@CountFunkula78 Yeah, I've only seen Turians, Asari, Salarians, and Krogan so far.
@Godsent Seems right in line with the reviews I've read so far TBH.
Clearly a behind the scenes story on this one. It went for ages without having anything confirmed to have a very quick release window. I've got too much on the backlog to opt for this but a rushed game never pays full dividends.
@ShogunRok
Thanks for the reply, I thought your article was well balanced and seemed fair.
It was bad enough that you can't choose a race for your character (I was looking forward to playing as a Krogan or Drell), but most of them aren't even in it....
I didn't think Thane got enough screen time in ME 2 (same goes for the Geth character), no Drell or Krogan squad mate in me3, and now they drop most of the races altogether! I got the impression that Thane was really popular...Maybe it's just me.
I think they have totally focused on the wrong things, but I hope the game finds its audience. This might be it for me & Bioware now, too many bland games that demand too much time.
The more I think about this the more frustrating it seems. Why send the Salarians (with their notably short lifespan) to populate far off galaxies? You'd choose races with a higher chance of survival.
I know that they are a high tech 'scientist' race, if only there was some other race with an affinity for tech, but that perhaps needed to find a new homeworld because they were living in a flotilla after losing their planet.....Anything like that in the existing fiction?
Cancelled my preorder due to all the reviews... They were not what I expected! Gonna order horizon zero dawn instead..!
I'll wait till a price drops.
I'm glad my instincts on this one were on the money, even before we heard about the facial animation issues. I don't know that this brand is necessarily toast, but I think EA does not to take some steps to make sure something like this never happens again.
With critically acclaimed hits like BotW, Nier, Horizon, etc. all still in the rearview mirror, I can't imagine someone opting for this instead. If they do, it's on the popularity of the brand alone.
I might get it when it goes significantly on sale for the Narm appeal, though!
I loved the trilogy, especially Mass Effect 2. I'll wait for a price drop.
Look at the bright side: everyone will have time to really get into Persona 5 now
@Ralizah
EA doesn't care. EA will survive whatever happens. If Bioware becomes unprofitable, they'll close the studio and buy another one to run into a creative grave, meanwhile keeping the ip for remasters, f2p mobile games and a reboot in 10 years time
Sounds like a real mixed bag, which is a disappointment. But I'm going to get the game and judge for myself regardless, think my pre-order is only for about £38. I'd be a bit worried if I was spending £50 or more though.
@ShogunRok speaking of the Krogan, why is one of them really camp? They're a race which is basically walking testosterone. It's just odd. I've no problem with gay characters, I mean, I'm in favour of fair and diverse representation of characters. Inclusion is a good thing, and im not so dumb that i assume a man with effeminate mannerisms is automatically gay....
It just seems a bit odd. Does he have a back story which explains it or something?
"we decided there and then that he would never be coming on another mission."
I decided he was going to stay with the bomb if that came around again. Played the trial on EA access, gameplay is decent but the story kinda blows and the voice acting feels wrong for most aliens if you've played prior titles.
@THRILLHOU I haven't come across a camp Krogan - I think you might mean Kesh? She's actually a female Krogan!
@ShogunRok that's enough internet for me today then.
I honestly thought it was a male voice.
Despite the game's issues, it seems like one I'd enjoy thanks to the characters.
Definitely looking forward to picking this up for $30 on a PSN sale down the line.
@GraveLordXD Yeah, well, this is what you get with EA behind the franchise. They're getting worse and worse as time goes on. Bleed the franchise, get the games out as soon as possible, we'll fix them later.
Well, that's disappointing for fans of the franchise. Truth be told, game franchises which surpass the trilogy mark will eventually release a mediocre or just plain bad entry (Resident Evil is especially guilty of that).
Right now Mass Effect Andromeda sounds just about right for a $20 game with all DLC included. I can wait.
Struggling with this. Have it on preorder, but even with the bad reviews, I just can't seem to cancel it.
What to do, what to do....
@Fandabidozi Great! Now I want to play those again, thanks for that! The dialogue in those games was a riot sometimes. What did those random ogres used to say? "You mess with him, you mess with you." Or something nonsensical like that. It's been a while.
@Gamer83 Good points. Rented Horizon pleasantly surprised definitely on my list. Nier P5, GR2, and so much more coming fun 😀.
Canceled my pre order and bought Horizon, to me this is a sad day. I love mass effect but I really can't put my money in this game.
Bioware is just a shadow since ME3.
Mess Effect.
@Frank90 if you're buying Horizon then you won't be sad for long. Now that game deserves the praise.
@banacheck BioWare are great visionaries with great ideas.
They just never seem to be able to fully realise those ideas, to their fullest at least.
Personally Ill still buy, looking forward to cruising the Galaxy again.
Im not sure how I feel about Nier and Horizon is of zero interest so this will be my first foray back into the Sci-Fi RPG arena in a while.
@FaultyDroid A 7.7 is not so bad the game needed a few more months polish thx EA and shareholders.
Please, put your torches and forks down to read this, but I never thought Mass Effect was a brilliant series. I mean, they had many problems, be it in bugs, combat, RPG elements, dialogue, depth of some characters, etc. They were still really fun and addictive games, making your own choices, evolving abilities, meeting different characters... They had some great gameplay and they had a good share of problems too. I never expected this to be perfect, but I'm sure it'll still be really fun and addictive. Also, since English is not my first language, I don't really notice that the dialogues are weird; and I tried hard to find the 'awfulness' in the animation (that walking was weird, but acceptable, and the faces are fine too, at least by what I've seen, maybe these things simply don't bother me).
You can pick up your torches now, haha. =)
Have there even been that many bad reviews? worst I've seen is a 6.5, which to me that isn't that bad
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...