Comments 539

Re: Horizon Forbidden West Production Efforts Boosted as PC Patches Wind Down

Menchi

@Col_McCafferty Hard to say roughly €30 million revenue for quick port of an existing game is a waste. But I don't come to push square for logic.

@IonMagus 30% is only for the first $10 million, then it's 20%

Extra hot take: Sony should put all their games on PC so they're not limited by hardware, like PS4 and PS5 do to their games.

Re: Bethesda Teases Indiana Jones Game, But Will It Come to PS5?

Menchi

@get2sammyb I also wonder if it's like The Outer Worlds or Deathloop or Ghostwire. These contracrs are all inked BEFORE the acquisition is complete so are honoured separately already.

Also, I may be misremembering but isn't the MS/Bethesda deal the 2nd half of 2021? I can't remember for sure.

Edit: Yeah directly from Microsoft's press announcement. Microsoft fiscal year ends September 30th 2021

The transaction is subject to customary closing conditions and completion of regulatory review. Microsoft expects the acquisition to close in the second half of fiscal year 2021 and to have minimal impact to non-GAAP operating income in fiscal years 2021 and 2022. Non-GAAP excludes the expected impact of purchase accounting adjustments, as well as integration and transaction-related expenses.

Re: Bethesda Teases Indiana Jones Game, But Will It Come to PS5?

Menchi

It'll definitely be a multiplat (Xbox and PC) but would not surprise me if it went to PS5 after a year. But at the same time, I actually don't believe Microsoft would have the guts to keep it off PS5.

70% chance PC/Xbox/PS5 same day
30% chance PC/Xbox then PS5 down the line

Imo

Re: Lots of PS5 Games Given Release Windows, Including Solar Ash, Kena, and Stray

Menchi

@Gaming365247 I wasn't even referring to that, it was more that it is coming to PC on the same day as PS4/5, let alone possibly Xbox down the line.

This is why I hate why people dilute the "exclusive" meaning. Anything to try claim a win. I don't even count timed exclusives like FF7R. It's not like I'd never have been able to play it if I didn't get it on PS4.

Re: Feature: Push Square Readers' Top 10 PS4 First-Party Exclusives of the Generation

Menchi

@AK4tywill No. "Exclusive" has been stretched and played with fast and loose for years now, diluting more and more every time. On more than 1? Multiplatform. Exactly why there is the saying "Xbox has no games" because there is nothing you NEED to buy an Xbox for when you can get it elsewhere. "Console exclusive" "console launch exclusive" "timed exclusive", it's all a joke.

Edit: As illustrated by this thread and the original thread, now you see why people meme on the whole "GOTY 10/10 BECAUSE PLAYSTATION EXCLUSIVE!11!ELEVENTYONE!!1"

Re: Official Killzone Website Shut Down, Some Services Affected

Menchi

@kyleforrester87 Your memory has failed you. Go watch the "gameplay" trailer Sony showed of the beach intro (including no black screen blink transition to actual gameplay because the entire thing was CG rendered) then go play the demo or game itself. There is a brief black screen flash where it swaps to in game graphics which are considerably worse. The internet tore it to shreds because of the sheer gulf in quality. Pure CG to barely looking like an early PS3 game. It became one of Sony's legendary most egregious bullshots of the PS3 era.

That and the Uncharted 2 debacle.

@NEStalgia and people wonder why I say Sony are bad for at everything except games. I never forget.

Re: Poll: What Was the Best PS4 First-Party Exclusive of the Generation?

Menchi

@Kienda Sony themselves are agreeing that "console exclusive" isn't a thing. Do you need to buy a PS4/PS4 copy (since back compat) to play it? No? Not exclusive then.

Glad to see Sony putting this to rest and hoping the inconsistent and frequently inaccurate reporting of "exclusives" by PushSquare staff will be applied going forward.

Re: Epic Acquires Rad Game Tools, Creators of Oodle Compression Technology

Menchi

@Jimmer-jammer I will concede that thanks to the run up and launch of new consoles and fake gaming news, the incompetent shill media and fanboy frenzy that has accompanied them I've lost patience for many console people/places, or at least the ignorant and the fanboys. Which is typically why my points come across as blunt and harsh. @NEStalgia broke it down better so I thank him for that.

I am glad that someone actually had a brain and thought "hey maybe making Tencent the Disney of PC gaming tech is a bad thing" instead of the usual "A WIN FOR SONY WOOOOOO". It's not the kind of thing I expect from console sites.

Re: Push Square's PlayStation Quiz of the Year 2020

Menchi

19/30 got most of the 1st party stuff wrong since almost none of Sony 1st party appeals to me. Got a kick out of the HZD upset manbaby question though.

@Gaming365247 Mainly because neither answer of the 2 people know about is correct. Yet. Bids and deals are not finalised.

Re: Game of the Year: #8 - Persona 5 Royal

Menchi

@nessisonett The inevitable PC port will fix that. Just like P4G was improved so much by it, and that was a PS2/Vita game!

On topic, P5R was the joint best game I played released this year. It gets joint because it's "only" an enhanced version of my 2017 GOTY and the other game it tied with is the best version of an enhanced game I'd already played. PC version of P4G. That's why they both got a joint top spot.

If you remove straight re-releases (P4G PC) then P5R is the best "new" game.

Re: Death Stranding Adds Cyberpunk 2077 Content, Exclusive to PC for Now

Menchi

@Deadlyblack I always wonder where this claim comes from. It was announced for PC before the Sony publishing deal was announced. It was announced for PC before it was even shown or had a name.

When founding the studio it was announced so that he could make a PS4/PC game.

Sammy couldn't answer his claim (because there isn't anything to prove it that I'm aware of) when I called him out on it, can you?