@Feena I think you meant to say "almost never fixed" and nothing gameplay wise comes close to matching Witcher 3 thus far. As for Zelda, I'm just gutted it's Nintendo only, could be amazing, concentrating on new (to Zelda) gameplay and systems. Almost close to buying the console for that one game!
@Neolit yeah, I couldn't understand that one either at the time and was surprised how little fight Microsoft put up, was expecting a battle of the corporations. If your product is going to be on the same shelf, as it were, I get the need for protecting your trademark / copyright but both these disputes had tenuous links at best. Makes me wonder how the food packaging in lidl gets away with borrowing other brands designs with no arguments.
@Galvatron Agree that some text and even the mini map were pretty tricky to make out on my tv, 44in, but recent patches appear to have made some improvements. Might be worth taking another look assuming you haven't played in a while, or sit closer!
@charlesnarles Played the Doom demo and thought my PS4 was going to either take off or explode, the amount of noise coming from it. Similarly during Witcher 3 and occasionally Bloodborne but never on Netflix, unless you meant using remote play to use the Netflix app?
@Kage_88 I think Nintendo need to start building interest in the NX after disappointing sales of Wii U, whereas Sony don't need to dilute the PS4 brand or confuse potential buyers until they have to.
Sony hold most of the cards this generation, Nintendo just have their character cards left!
@Kamikaze_Krunch Drive Club is certainly a great example of the impact a disastrous launch can have on a games success and the closing of the company is the ultimate price, though I also think the poor handling of the PS Plus version had a small impact also.
So in terms of numbers sold you're probably right but if profits don't take a major hit the practice of patching unfinished or broken games post release will continue. I don't think Battlefield 4 had a good start but that franchise continues.
In short, I feel it's only fair for review scores to reflect the issues the reviewer experienced and a revised score if and when the game is fixed seems sensible.
@carlos82 Bought Bloodborne in the sale and absolutely loving it, even though my actual progress is tortuously slow. One of the only times buying a game as a download has had the positive effect of not being able to give up and trade in as soon as I realise I'm not good immediately! May approach DS3 the same way.
@Kamikaze_Krunch The fact that the practice of releasing half baked games and then patching then post release continues to happen would suggest it doesn't impact sales as much as you'd think.
@get2sammyb Please don't think I was criticising the review, well written as always (creep), more the concept of 10/10 games. I end up comparing A with B when that's not how it works, my addled mind!
Didn't read as a 10/10 but then that's why I don't agree with scores! Sounds like a good, fun game of its type but I'm not sure I'm willing to pay 40£ and will patiently wait for price to drop.
@aric201812 If you manually search for it or click on title from PlayStation blog it does appear as free (Switch Galaxy that is), but I was also a tad baffled by that Open Me and the fact it was 4.99! But then the PS Store is always a bit eccentric
I wonder what impact this will have on initial sales of the PS5, whenever that may / does happen? Will people be so quick to buy "day 1" or hang back a year or so and see what new, improved version may appear. The knowledge that your console purchase "future proofed" your gaming needs for 5+ years is a key factor for me and would make me think twice in the future.
Good review, not sure to wait and see if the season pass goes on sale. Are there any plans to improve the games performance that you're aware of? Frame rate is still patchy on my PS4 and loading times are ridiculous!
Having been both alive and playing games in the 80's onwards, I'm not totally sure Broforce would have been anymore than a title in the Mastertronic 199 or 299 range!
@hi_drnick They were probably meant to keep the information to themselves and so the refund has been rescinded! Not keen on multi-player games being included in IGC as it is little interest to us single player gamers.
Tried all three on PS4 and only Galak Z has survived an initial play. BroForce seemed pointless and didn't like controls (maybe better suited to a keyboard, I don't know) and Flame Over was just awful at everything. Possibly the worst month of PS+ in a long while.
@Boerewors Core gamers hated the Wii? How do you figure that? It was home to some excellent games, admittedly the majority first party, but it can hardly be blamed for the influx and increase in pricing for DLC and season passes. Many indie developed games are starting to increase in price, and I think that were it not for the DLC market, most AAA titles would be £60 or more. The additional content model is effectively subsidising the current £40 pricing point.
Hats off to Sony, no longer displaying pricing in their Store Update posts is an inspired way of avoiding the outcry over differences between currencies.
If your electric goes out for a day, yes you get compensated (spoilt food in freezer). Should Sony feel obligated? Probably not, but it makes sense from a customer service point of view and isn't going to cost a packet to give all subscribers an extra day for this outage.
Seems odd that it's often Western game developers that get accused of lacking originality or retreading the same tired ground whilst lists like this get such a positive reaction.
I'm sure I'll buy a couple of the games mentioned but style & genre wise it's hardly inspiring!
Bought it but just couldn't get to grips with it, felt no desire to persevere and so back to the shop I went to shamefully trade it in. All these words of praise and endless accolades tempt me to try again but have a nagging feeling it's just not for me.
@Kidfried it's a news item, not an opinion piece and so is reported as such. If it isn't frame rate or 720 vs 1080, us gamers will always find some trivial matter to quibble over! All that really matters is Fun or Not Fun (although 4k is really the way to go!)
@john_c Do you mean Valve? Can't see that happening! I struggle to think of any developer who would benefit from the status and are making ground breaking games.
@TomKongPhooey I agree that PS Store pricing is not competitive with physical purchases, more so in Europe I think, so what made you go digital-only now?
@whizzkidd you're not alone, have never been able to find the appeal of this or the Souls games. It's not the difficulty that puts me off as much as the opaqueness of the whole experience. I keep trying to find what so many others find so special but just find it a joyless task and don't want to admit defeat by trading in, like I did with Dark Souls!
I'm amazed how the save game files are so small, with so much going on. No major bugs, crashed once whilst moving furniture, few frame rate drops but not much else (touch wood). Feel the game throws too many features at you in a short space of time and for once would have appreciated a few tutorials!
@RawShark Scores of 7 for such a high profile release don't exactly scream "must buy" and I get a sense from reading a few reviews that it is a bit of a let down.
It'd be nice if discounts and sale items had their own heading in the mobile browser store. Always have to open the desktop version of site, on Android anyhow.
I feel that if Ubisoft were serious about altering public perception of them as a company, they'd be allowing reviews of certain prominent releases to be up prior to release.
Don't drive! Can't afford a car and keeping up with all the games coming up or already out! But I'm sure that not all finance people are untrustworthy, just like not all coffee shop workers.
Comments 334
Re: New Final Fantasy XV Screenshots Prove It's a Preposterously Pretty PS4 Game
@Feena I think you meant to say "almost never fixed" and nothing gameplay wise comes close to matching Witcher 3 thus far. As for Zelda, I'm just gutted it's Nintendo only, could be amazing, concentrating on new (to Zelda) gameplay and systems. Almost close to buying the console for that one game!
Re: PS4 Firmware Update 3.55 Doesn't Appear to Do Much
@Bad-MuthaAdebisi Light drizzle and sleet but no fog.
Re: Hello Games Settles No Man's Sky Legal Dispute with Sky
@Neolit yeah, I couldn't understand that one either at the time and was surprised how little fight Microsoft put up, was expecting a battle of the corporations.
If your product is going to be on the same shelf, as it were, I get the need for protecting your trademark / copyright but both these disputes had tenuous links at best.
Makes me wonder how the food packaging in lidl gets away with borrowing other brands designs with no arguments.
Re: Hello Games Settles No Man's Sky Legal Dispute with Sky
@Neolit but another lawyer could surely counter by saying that there's a distinction between a space flight exploration game with infinite content and a broadcasting empire with a few new shows and endless adverts.
I had a call from sky ®© this morning asking why I'd decided to not renew my subscription, wish I'd thought of this as a reason like a previous commenter suggested....
Re: Hello Games Settles No Man's Sky Legal Dispute with Sky
@Neolit I can't see the precedent, one is a computer game and the other a broadcasting company. Lawyers gotta get paid I guess!
Re: The Witcher 3 PS4 Patch 1.22 Attempts to Fix Almost Every Remaining Bug
@Galvatron Agree that some text and even the mini map were pretty tricky to make out on my tv, 44in, but recent patches appear to have made some improvements. Might be worth taking another look assuming you haven't played in a while, or sit closer!
Re: E3 2016: Save Money on Old E3 Favourites with NA PlayStation Store Sale
@Riririn We got an EA sale, for a change...
Re: E3 2016: We Won't Dictate the Future of PS4 to Our Fans, Says Sony
@charlesnarles Played the Doom demo and thought my PS4 was going to either take off or explode, the amount of noise coming from it. Similarly during Witcher 3 and occasionally Bloodborne but never on Netflix, unless you meant using remote play to use the Netflix app?
Re: Sony Confirms 'High-End' PS4K Exists, Won't Be at E3
@Kage_88 I think Nintendo need to start building interest in the NX after disappointing sales of Wii U, whereas Sony don't need to dilute the PS4 brand or confuse potential buyers until they have to.
Sony hold most of the cards this generation, Nintendo just have their character cards left!
Re: Review: Oxenfree (PS4)
One to wait for on PS Plus then and that's not a dig at the game or the service!
Re: Expect a Fallout 4: Far Harbor Performance Improving Patch Next Week on PS4
@Kamikaze_Krunch Drive Club is certainly a great example of the impact a disastrous launch can have on a games success and the closing of the company is the ultimate price, though I also think the poor handling of the PS Plus version had a small impact also.
So in terms of numbers sold you're probably right but if profits don't take a major hit the practice of patching unfinished or broken games post release will continue. I don't think Battlefield 4 had a good start but that franchise continues.
In short, I feel it's only fair for review scores to reflect the issues the reviewer experienced and a revised score if and when the game is fixed seems sensible.
Re: Your June PlayStation Plus Games Have Been Revealed
@carlos82 Bought Bloodborne in the sale and absolutely loving it, even though my actual progress is tortuously slow. One of the only times buying a game as a download has had the positive effect of not being able to give up and trade in as soon as I realise I'm not good immediately! May approach DS3 the same way.
Re: Expect a Fallout 4: Far Harbor Performance Improving Patch Next Week on PS4
@Kamikaze_Krunch The fact that the practice of releasing half baked games and then patching then post release continues to happen would suggest it doesn't impact sales as much as you'd think.
Re: The Witcher Dev's Cyberpunk 2077 Won't Be at E3 2016
This may be what you're referring to @Gamer83?
https://mobile.twitter.com/ChineseRoom/status/725958220284465153
Re: Review: Uncharted 4: A Thief's End (PS4)
@get2sammyb Please don't think I was criticising the review, well written as always (creep), more the concept of 10/10 games. I end up comparing A with B when that's not how it works, my addled mind!
Re: Review: Uncharted 4: A Thief's End (PS4)
Didn't read as a 10/10 but then that's why I don't agree with scores! Sounds like a good, fun game of its type but I'm not sure I'm willing to pay 40£ and will patiently wait for price to drop.
Re: Your Free PlayStation Plus Games for May Are Available Now
@aric201812 If you manually search for it or click on title from PlayStation blog it does appear as free (Switch Galaxy that is), but I was also a tad baffled by that Open Me and the fact it was 4.99! But then the PS Store is always a bit eccentric
Re: Live: Watch Uncovered: Final Fantasy XV Live Right Here
Really trivial reveals so far, it's like pulling teeth
Re: Evidence for Supercharged PS4.5 Console Mounts
I wonder what impact this will have on initial sales of the PS5, whenever that may / does happen? Will people be so quick to buy "day 1" or hang back a year or so and see what new, improved version may appear.
The knowledge that your console purchase "future proofed" your gaming needs for 5+ years is a key factor for me and would make me think twice in the future.
Re: Review: Just Cause 3: Sky Fortress (PS4)
Good review, not sure to wait and see if the season pass goes on sale. Are there any plans to improve the games performance that you're aware of? Frame rate is still patchy on my PS4 and loading times are ridiculous!
Re: Store Update: 15th March 2016 (Europe)
Enjoying Salt & Sanctuary, even though I'm not making much progress (I'm rubbish), but definitely worth a try!
Re: Soapbox: Why Action Henk and Broforce Have Me Hooked
Having been both alive and playing games in the 80's onwards, I'm not totally sure Broforce would have been anymore than a title in the Mastertronic 199 or 299 range!
Re: One of Your Free April PlayStation Plus Games Has Already Been Revealed
@hi_drnick They were probably meant to keep the information to themselves and so the refund has been rescinded!
Not keen on multi-player games being included in IGC as it is little interest to us single player gamers.
Re: You Won't Be Reading Any The Division Reviews on Launch Day
@SonyInfinity Because gaming journalism is a new thing and product reviews are a recent development?
Re: You Won't Be Reading Any The Division Reviews on Launch Day
@Neolit I agree with you on that, hold off on purchases for first couple of weeks and this culture of review embargoes will swiftly disappear.
Re: Your Free PlayStation Plus Games Are Available Now
Tried all three on PS4 and only Galak Z has survived an initial play. BroForce seemed pointless and didn't like controls (maybe better suited to a keyboard, I don't know) and Flame Over was just awful at everything. Possibly the worst month of PS+ in a long while.
Re: Vote for Your Free PS4 PlayStation Plus Game Now
Feels like the General Election all over again, none of the three appeals so think I'll abstain!
Re: Review: Call of Duty: Black Ops III - Awakening (PS4)
@Boerewors Core gamers hated the Wii? How do you figure that? It was home to some excellent games, admittedly the majority first party, but it can hardly be blamed for the influx and increase in pricing for DLC and season passes.
Many indie developed games are starting to increase in price, and I think that were it not for the DLC market, most AAA titles would be £60 or more. The additional content model is effectively subsidising the current £40 pricing point.
Re: Store Update: 19th January 2016 (Europe)
Hats off to Sony, no longer displaying pricing in their Store Update posts is an inspired way of avoiding the outcry over differences between currencies.
Re: Free PlayStation Plus Extension Details to Roll Out This Week
If your electric goes out for a day, yes you get compensated (spoilt food in freezer).
Should Sony feel obligated? Probably not, but it makes sense from a customer service point of view and isn't going to cost a packet to give all subscribers an extra day for this outage.
Re: Feature: 20 Japanese PS4 Games to Watch in 2016
Seems odd that it's often Western game developers that get accused of lacking originality or retreading the same tired ground whilst lists like this get such a positive reaction.
I'm sure I'll buy a couple of the games mentioned but style & genre wise it's hardly inspiring!
Re: Your January PlayStation Plus Games Are Available to Download Now
Has anyone else noticed that in the small print / blurb for Dragon Age: Origins it mentions the game is playable on PS4?
Re: PSN Down Just Days into 2016
@SegaBlueSky The only compensation I can see being offered is if PSN is down for say 6+ hours, you get an additional days subscription?
Re: Game of the Year: #1 - Bloodborne (PS4)
Bought it but just couldn't get to grips with it, felt no desire to persevere and so back to the shop I went to shamefully trade it in. All these words of praise and endless accolades tempt me to try again but have a nagging feeling it's just not for me.
Re: Tons More Classic PS2 Games Rated for PS4
@Boerewors I'm just glad you understood I was (mostly) joking. Forgot the smiley face!
Re: Tons More Classic PS2 Games Rated for PS4
@Boerewors It would be crowd funded & unfinished?
Re: Destiny Launches Pricey Level Boosters for PS4, PS3
I think a symbol should be tagged to your character to identify who has paid for instant level 25. Might help when choosing your team?
Re: Sony: Our First-Party PS4 Lineup Looks Incredible Next Year
@Kidfried it's a news item, not an opinion piece and so is reported as such.
If it isn't frame rate or 720 vs 1080, us gamers will always find some trivial matter to quibble over! All that really matters is Fun or Not Fun (although 4k is really the way to go!)
Re: Sony's Open to Acquiring Additional First-Party Studios
@john_c Do you mean Valve? Can't see that happening!
I struggle to think of any developer who would benefit from the status and are making ground breaking games.
Re: PSX 2015: You Can Buy Final Fantasy VII PS4 Right Now on PSN
Or 8.99 GBP. Someone buy Sony a new calculator for Christmas!
Re: Guide: UK Black Friday 2015 Deals - Every PS4, PS3, and PlayStation Vita Sale
@TomKongPhooey I agree that PS Store pricing is not competitive with physical purchases, more so in Europe I think, so what made you go digital-only now?
Re: Review: Bloodborne: The Old Hunters (PS4)
@whizzkidd you're not alone, have never been able to find the appeal of this or the Souls games. It's not the difficulty that puts me off as much as the opaqueness of the whole experience. I keep trying to find what so many others find so special but just find it a joyless task and don't want to admit defeat by trading in, like I did with Dark Souls!
Re: Poll: How Well Is Fallout 4 Running on Your PS4?
I'm amazed how the save game files are so small, with so much going on. No major bugs, crashed once whilst moving furniture, few frame rate drops but not much else (touch wood).
Feel the game throws too many features at you in a short space of time and for once would have appreciated a few tutorials!
Re: Star Wars Battlefront's PS4 Launch Didn't Quite Go to Plan
@RawShark Scores of 7 for such a high profile release don't exactly scream "must buy" and I get a sense from reading a few reviews that it is a bit of a let down.
Re: Paris Games Week 2015: Shadow of the Beast's New Trailer Rips PS4 a New One
@Jocinetu Predator rip-off? How so? I don't remember the original much, apart from its difficulty but can't recall any similarity to Predator?
Re: The PlayStation Store Seems to Be Getting a Wishlist
It'd be nice if discounts and sale items had their own heading in the mobile browser store. Always have to open the desktop version of site, on Android anyhow.
Re: UK Sales Charts: PS4 JRPGs Infiltrate Best Sellers List
@Matroska I bet you're a barrel of laughs at a party.
Re: The Reaction to Ubisoft's New Club Hasn't Been Great
I feel that if Ubisoft were serious about altering public perception of them as a company, they'd be allowing reviews of certain prominent releases to be up prior to release.
Re: Feature: The PS4 Game That's Being Built in a Hotel Lobby
Don't drive! Can't afford a car and keeping up with all the games coming up or already out! But I'm sure that not all finance people are untrustworthy, just like not all coffee shop workers.
Re: Feature: The PS4 Game That's Being Built in a Hotel Lobby
@themcnoisy I don't trust anyone that sells finance products.