Comments 418

Re: PlayStation Studios Boss Suggests God of War Ragnarok, Gran Turismo 7 Are Also Coming to PS4

ThomasHL

This sucks. It absolutely will hold God of War back, even if it's as simple as 'Can we put 12 enemies in this arena? No the PS4 CPU can't handle it, let's do 10'

And it's not because people can't buy a PS5. The PS5 has sold more than any Sony console. More people have a PS5 than any past launch console of theirs and it never stopped them before.

Sony seem to be transitioning into not selling their consoles based on exclusives, and that's going to backfire for them. Especially as Microsoft are going to have a deluge of exclusives in a couple of years

Re: Anime Streaming App Funimation Overhauled on PS5, PS4

ThomasHL

On the one hand the Funimation trial has introduced me to a bunch of dubbed (I'm basic) anime that I now love. My Hero Academia, and Love is War are just as good as people said.

On the other hand, the Funimation app has barely functioned on any decide I use, console, phone or PC. There have been multiple days where I've just had to give up because nothing will play.

Re: Tales of Arise Drops Multiplayer for Bigger Focus on Characters, Story

ThomasHL

JRPGs are just about the worst kind of game for co-op. Long and story driven. Battle systems that are more about strategy than the moment to moment game feel. And a big part of the engagement is the long term growth and levelling up.

Lord of the Rings The Third Age had a co-op mode when the second player couldn't even do anything until the battle started. It was probably more fun to just sit next to someone and suggest what they say should do next than actually play the co-op mode.

Re: March 2021 NPD: PS5 Is Still the Fastest-Selling Console in US History

ThomasHL

@ShogunRok It would definitely still sell out if there weren't scalpers! The only reason scalpers exist is plenty of people are prepared to pay $800 for a PS5. That's how much demand outstrips production

Those same people would happily buy a PS5 for $500 if it was in stock at a shop.

When people are sayings they're in the hands of scalpers, are they imagining scalpers with hundreds of PS5s just sitting on their living room floor somewhere? No, scalpers sell them on almost immediately

Re: Sony Bend Was, At One Point, Working on a New Uncharted

ThomasHL

I wouldn't play another Uncharted game with Drake. His story ended with Uncharted 4. I'm not interested in a reboot either. I'd probably play an Uncharted game with Chloe and Nadine, or a new character, but the developer needs to be on their A game. Uncharted is all about the details.

Re: Reaction: Sony Said Xbox Game Pass Isn't Sustainable, Then Released One of Its Tentpole Titles into the Service Anyway

ThomasHL

@everynowandben I'm very skeptical about that article. For example: "When certain people try to call Game Pass the Netflix of, or the Spotify of," Spencer says, "there is a fundamental difference... that these games are all for sale."

That's just wrong. Films that eventually go onto Netflix are for sale. Music used to be for sale until streaming and piracy made that impossible. They're trying to suggest that development budgets won't be impacted by Gamepass by suggesting sales won't be affected by Gamepass - and yet the article thinks that Gamepass is aiming for a scale of 50 million users to be profitable - of course that will impact the number of people buying games.

They also admit that Gamepass isn't profitable at the moment 'It's in an acquisition phrase' - and that once customers are acquired Microsoft believes they'll stay even if the service is no longer as good. They argue that prices wouldn't have to increase because costs go down with scale - and yes development costs go down with scale, but bandwidth costs do not and games are a magnitude bigger than films on that front.

They keep trying to argue that this isn't Netflix - but I don't see how that argument is real. Development costs for Netflix obey the same scale law. Netflix is also trying to widen it's consumer base - and achieved a scale much greater than gamepass will. Netflix has the same infrastructure costs - and what we've seen is that Netflix has continually raised it's price, whilst at the same time offering a smaller fraction of the 'must-see' content.

But more than that - they acting like Microsoft will keep the price down out of the goodness of their heart. And that won't happen. The article essential outlines the idea that Microsoft achieves a subscription monopoly - at which point Microsoft is free to raise prices as it wishes. On the other hand if other subscription services arise (like we're seeing with film streaming), then Microsoft won't have a monopoly, but they'll also find it much harder to license such a rich category of exclusives because they're competing with everyone else. Either way the quality drops.

The article lists a long list of tech services of similar ambition, each one of which started off great and got a little bit more expensive and a little bit worse as they reached closer to profitability. The article claims Gamepass is the Unicorn that will be different from everything else, whilst at the same time listing a huge amount of precedent for why it won't.

Re: Reaction: Sony Said Xbox Game Pass Isn't Sustainable, Then Released One of Its Tentpole Titles into the Service Anyway

ThomasHL

I totally agree that is a very feel bad moment for playstation owners, and should have been resisted by Sony.

In the practical sense though, I still agree that Gamepass is unsustainable in it's current form. I'm sure Microsoft know it is too. Netflix has never been profitable, they've always gone into debt for the sake of growth, and Gamepass is in a similar position.

The deal seems too good to be real because it is. Microsoft are losing money to gain subscribers and achieve a dominant position, and when they have enough they will jack up the price and reduce the service.

Re: As Stock Increases, PS5 Is Doing Much Better in Japan

ThomasHL

@Max_the_German Spiderman is big in Japan. Spiderman films are some of the only superhero films that do consistently well in the Japanese box office, and there have been a lot of Japanese specific spiderman media.

Spiderman is Hideo Kojima's favourite superhero, and he says it's because Peter Parker has relatable fears and worries, similar to Japanese superheroes.

Re: Poll: Which Bethesda Franchise Will PS5 Miss the Most?

ThomasHL

Fallout: New Vegas was one of my favourite all time games but Bethesda didn't make that one, and most of the writers behind it at Obsidian have left too, so it doesn't leave me with much to miss.

I've never played an Elder Scrolls game, but I'm open to starting one day. And I've never played an Arkane game but I appreciate how quirky they are - so probably one of those.

Re: Future Bethesda Games Will Ship 'Where Game Pass Exists'

ThomasHL

@Salt_AU Still heroically not admitting defeat I see!

Platform holders don't make money from selling their own games. Sony is quite happy for it's studios to operate at a loss if they produce great games. Platform holders make money from the 30% commission they get on every game sold on their platform by other publishers.

Therefore, if having some of the most popular games in the world makes even 1% more people buy an Xbox, Microsoft will make money on every game that person buys on an Xbox for the course of it's life - that could be 20+ games. Making money from 20 games is a lot more valuable than making money off their own exclusives.

Even more than that, Microsoft are trying to be the Netflix of games. And they see that as a market which could be worth hundreds of billions of dollars in the long-run. Microsoft bought Bethesda for what is pocket change to Microsoft - they could throw away $10 billion every 3 months and it wouldn't scratch Microsofts accounting book - as an investment towards to that goal of being the Netflix of games.

Now you might not think this makes sense, but this is what I told you earlier this week when I said Microsoft would make their games exclusive, and it turns out they have.

This is the economics. The money isn't in being the guy who sells games, it's being the guy who makes money from everyone else selling games on their platform.

Re: Bethesda Says 'Some' Future Games Won't Launch on PS5, PS4

ThomasHL

@Salt_AU Yes, they're expecting people who would buy a Playstation to buy an Xbox instead. Is that so surprising? That's why Sony buys studios.

There's a big difference from pulling games already released and available on platforms, with legal agreements that were signed between various platform holders, and pissing off a bunch of fans, and telling people that the new games you are now funding are only going to be available on the platforms that make you money.

Again, I'm not saying it's impossible - Minecraft is one hope, but people are just going to get hurt if they convince themselves that Microsoft wants to help Sony sell consoles. Microsoft has a crazy bank, and buying Bethesda was a power move to help their long term strategic goals - selling subscriptions and selling Xboxes. They will do whatever they think helps them get to those goals, and I imagine telling people 'DOOM is only available on our stuff in the future' is a good way of doing that.

Re: Bethesda Says 'Some' Future Games Won't Launch on PS5, PS4

ThomasHL

I think it's still best to assume that the next Elder Scrolls and Starfield aren't coming to playstation.

It's definitely not out of the realm of possibility that they will, but because we all want that to happen it's easy to talk ourselves into the idea that it makes good business sense for Microsoft. But the truth of the matter is they didn't buy Bethesda just to make money selling Bethesda games. They bought Bethesda because they want to sell Xboxes and subscription services.

With the PS5 already taking a sales lead it's going to be awfully tempting for Microsoft to put some massive exclusives down on the Xbox side.

Re: Last Year, the UK's Gaming Purchases Were 85 Per Cent Digital

ThomasHL

I want physical games to exist because they keep the playstation store a bit more honest and help drive down the digital price of old games.

But personally I'd prefer to buy a game digitally than on a disc. It's less of a pain to store and use, and I pay a little more for a digital version than I would for a disc.

I never sell on games, so I don't benefit from that part of physical discs.

Re: PS Plus March 2021 PS5, PS4 Games Announced

ThomasHL

Wow, I apologise, I totally didn't believe this could be happening.

I'm a little unsure what to do, I only want to play FFVII Remake once, but if the PS5 version has more content, perhaps I should hang on for that?