I think releasing so close to Rebirth didn’t do P3R any favor ether, but I am sure it will have legs. Congrats to Sony for having successfully launched two exclusives in a row.
@ShogunRok Just for the sake of conversation, (your reviews of these and more games were very informative and useful to limit my crazy JRPG spending):
Pacing problems aside, FF16 really lacks a third wind in terms of gameplay.
P3R, on the other hand, is a very subdued and understated "homework" remake that lacks the FF7 or RE remakes' impact, re-imagination and ambition. Consider Gekkoukan High in P3 and P3R, Kalm in FF7, and Rebirth afterwards—not exactly the same level of work 😅 the game maintains the same size as the original, doesn't truly utilize the power of the current generation, and doesn't even include all that might be included—the female MP and the answer are both missing.
And while these two games kind of tunneled me in different ways, FF Rebirth is the funniest game to play and the least dictatorial when it comes to telling me what to do and when to do it.
I have one hour tonight and I can do some Shinra Towers, unwind, do some hunting in Rebirth in a way that doesn't function well in the other two games. It’s just my taste though.
Good point about the install base@Porco I am not so sure about a ps4 version and honestly glad they just released it on ps5 - the visuals held better than from say FFXIII to XIII-2, it’s easier to make a linear game look very good but once you are out in very large areas …
But I am seriously surprised you scored FF16 and P3R higher than Rebirth. I am only on chapter 5 but so far this is clearly the best experience out of the three. I mean, they are all good games and there is no accounting for taste but this is the richer, grandest and most ambitious game out of the three. I am constantly waiting for Rebirth to terribly disappoint me since I am really loving it hahaha
@somnambulance same experience here!
I hope the fact that it is actually a part 2 doesn’t punish its sales too much. Honestly the best JRPG experience I had in a very long time - loving it.
I still find it nice looking and fluid and pretty impressive considering its open world-ish nature, especially coming from P3 Reload that feels like a switch game most of the time (don’t get me started on the dormitory)
But yeah I recently played right on front of my TV and found the fuzziness people were referring to, though I still prefer it to the variable frame rate of 16, but if it can be improved I am all for it!
I really enjoyed the small DLC (probably compiled in a month or two) they already put out - looking forward to Leviathan! One of the best FF combat systems ever
I am sure that is not the main selling point but I am here to point out that costume is horrible! Hopefully we can influence the costume choice like in the first one
@ShogunRok I wasn’t objecting to your review at all, just pointing out that many posters here are overly dramatic: I can think of many, many RPGs that did side quest worse than recent FF. SMT and Persona, for instance, have absolutely dire ones, yet that aren’t scrutinized for not being on the level of the Witcher 3 or BG3, a completely other vibe and form of game.
And while we’re at it: maybe we should start comparing FF16 or FF7R combat and boss fights with The Witcher 3’s (again, one of my faves) since it seems so natural to compare the side quest, let’s do the same with the combat …it is just my opinion but these comparisons are one sided, unfair and serve a ready-made narrative that it’s getting more and more tiresome.
All the people complaining dramatically about ff16 and Remake quests have been playing P3 Reload? Because bring me Pine Resin and Muscle drink were really compelling and moving side quests that redefined the genre 🙄
Thank you for the review!
It sounds more up my alley than 16 (which I liked!) was. Love mini-games and explorations and non-linear plots.
It has a striking 93 on MC for what it’s worth…I see the dry PS5 2024 continues after TLOU2, GBfabtasy Relink and Hell Divers 2: such a bleak, bleak year for PS.
I will surely get Hi-fi Rush and maybe put Pentiment on a wishlist.
That said, to have the podcast and not reveal the titles “to leve it to the developers” and then announce them all unceremoniously 1 week later …why? It really looks bad for them, don’t they realize it?
This game has plenty of room to become a better version of himself and was actually really suffering from severe hardware restrictions.
I still enjoyed it but would welcome an expanded PS5 port
Final Fantasy VII remake quick re-run and Tekken!
@Bentleyma I wish I had your stamina!
@ApostateMage I wish the female protagonist was in Reload, she is so cool! And the female perspective is nice for a change in these dating (kinda) heavy games
It helps PlayStation move hardware and expand/reinforce their brand.
It helps the dev to optimize the game and ship it sooner. It’s one less platform to worry about…
What about acquiring entire studios that had games in development for PS, who did it help, Phil?
And I thought Sony’s communication was weak…
This was a master class on how NOT to squash internet rumors.
It basically indirectly confirmed that anything could be coming to PlayStation and Switch.
What a terrible show!
These are excellent games, I prefer SF6 if you put a gun to my head but it’s just more my vibe! Anyway we are eating good, now back to some Tekken matches and trying to finish my quick Remake rerun
C’mon even FF16 was rated M and the sexuality played out like some bizarrely puritan version of GOT. I don’t think she will be flashing us! At least I hope so. What did I pre-order 😂
Err…people seriously had no idea of how this looked after roughly 200 hours of trailers? The characters models are incredible, the art direction is solid and it runs at a very stable frame rate in performance!
The demo convinced me 100% and to think this kind of graphic impact will be applied to huge open worldish areas is just …wow!
@lacerz I mean, this is on their own proprietary hardware alone, it’s actually pretty shocking how high this is. Xbox would sure love to pull similar numbers on their consoles but they have changed their strategy and will change it again because it couldn’t pull this (among other things) off
@sanderson72 lol @ lackluster release schedule? Are we living in the same start of 2024? I can’t literally find time to play half of what I strictly consider must play on ps5
Wow it sounds and looks like an amazing re-release! I think my standard for re-releases/remasters is Crisis Core atm. Not my favorite game but they really delivered on that one!
Comments 2,908
Re: Sony Patches Mistakenly Released Stellar Blade PS5 Demo to Stop People From Playing It
Noooo I missed it! I would have happily tried it
State of Stellar Balde incoming?
Re: PS5's Stellar Blade, Rise of the Ronin Headline New Montage Trailer
The Final Fantasy XV energy is strong with this trailer. Killer year for Japanese games
Re: PS Store Sales Charts: Helldivers 2 Is Unstoppable, Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth Settles for Second
I think releasing so close to Rebirth didn’t do P3R any favor ether, but I am sure it will have legs. Congrats to Sony for having successfully launched two exclusives in a row.
Re: Poll: Are You Playing Unicorn Overlord?
Saving it for after FFVIIR, but the demo completely sold me on this
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth's 'Creepy' Moogles Are Giving Players the Ick
I love this 🤣 and yeah they look creepy
Re: Japan Sales Charts: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth Tops, But Doesn't Even Come Close to Remake
Different spin: It’s the second highest PS5 game launch ever in Japan, behind just FF16 😅
Re: Full Price Remake Persona 3 Reload Will Be 'Complete' with Episode Aigis DLC, Says Producer
^Yeah, The only way they could make me spend more money on this is adding the female lead and her arc
Re: Some Promising PS5 Games Are Getting Big Updates This Week
Jet set radio? I can dream
Re: UK Sales Charts: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth Debuts at the Top, Helldivers 2 Holds Firm
@ShogunRok Just for the sake of conversation, (your reviews of these and more games were very informative and useful to limit my crazy JRPG spending):
Pacing problems aside, FF16 really lacks a third wind in terms of gameplay.
P3R, on the other hand, is a very subdued and understated "homework" remake that lacks the FF7 or RE remakes' impact, re-imagination and ambition. Consider Gekkoukan High in P3 and P3R, Kalm in FF7, and Rebirth afterwards—not exactly the same level of work 😅 the game maintains the same size as the original, doesn't truly utilize the power of the current generation, and doesn't even include all that might be included—the female MP and the answer are both missing.
And while these two games kind of tunneled me in different ways, FF Rebirth is the funniest game to play and the least dictatorial when it comes to telling me what to do and when to do it.
I have one hour tonight and I can do some Shinra Towers, unwind, do some hunting in Rebirth in a way that doesn't function well in the other two games. It’s just my taste though.
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth Falls Short of Remake's Launch Sales in UK
Good point about the install base@Porco I am not so sure about a ps4 version and honestly glad they just released it on ps5 - the visuals held better than from say FFXIII to XIII-2, it’s easier to make a linear game look very good but once you are out in very large areas …
Re: UK Sales Charts: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth Debuts at the Top, Helldivers 2 Holds Firm
@ShogunRok the skinner meme is on point hahah.
But I am seriously surprised you scored FF16 and P3R higher than Rebirth. I am only on chapter 5 but so far this is clearly the best experience out of the three. I mean, they are all good games and there is no accounting for taste but this is the richer, grandest and most ambitious game out of the three. I am constantly waiting for Rebirth to terribly disappoint me since I am really loving it hahaha
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth Falls Short of Remake's Launch Sales in UK
@somnambulance same experience here!
I hope the fact that it is actually a part 2 doesn’t punish its sales too much. Honestly the best JRPG experience I had in a very long time - loving it.
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth Is Getting Another Patch to Improve Performance Mode
I still find it nice looking and fluid and pretty impressive considering its open world-ish nature, especially coming from P3 Reload that feels like a switch game most of the time (don’t get me started on the dormitory)
But yeah I recently played right on front of my TV and found the fuzziness people were referring to, though I still prefer it to the variable frame rate of 16, but if it can be improved I am all for it!
Re: Ori Dev's Action RPG No Rest for the Wicked Gets a Huge Update, Gameplay Looks Amazing
I will surely keep my eyes on this
Re: If Anything Was Going to Get You Back to Tower of Fantasy, It's Probably Evangelion
The quality of the illustrations is crazy for a F2P game event trailer
Re: Brush Up on RPG Unicorn Overlord's Complex Battle System on PS5, PS4
Wow Sakimoto’s soundtrack is immediately recognizable, he’s so underrated!
Re: Mega, Man! Street Fighter 6's PS5, PS4 Fighter Pass Focuses on the Blue Bomber
Oh Power Battle is gonna be mine
Re: Poll: Are You Playing Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth?
I am currently unavailable due to very important personal matters 🌸
My mantra for the next weeks
Re: EA Cuts Roughly 700 Jobs in Another Round of Industry Layoffs
This is getting more and more concerning …are we moving away from AAA development for good?
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth's PS5 Disc Labels Are Wrong in Japan, Asia
In all honesty, this would annoy me quite a bit. I like things to be in the right place
Re: Surprise Final Fantasy 7 Remake Patch Changes the Ending
She says something like that when you first meet her at the slums church
Re: 900 PlayStation Employees Laid Off, London Studio Closed
Devastating news! I hope everyone affected lands on his feet and manages to get a better position/job as soon as possible
Re: Second Final Fantasy 16 DLC Set to Be Revealed Next Month
I really enjoyed the small DLC (probably compiled in a month or two) they already put out - looking forward to Leviathan! One of the best FF combat systems ever
Re: Random: Our Twitter Timeline Is All Tifa from Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth on PS5 Right Now
I am sure that is not the main selling point but I am here to point out that costume is horrible! Hopefully we can influence the costume choice like in the first one
Re: Hands On: Unicorn Overlord Has the Potential to Be One of 2024's Best RPGs
Yeah I am hooked! 🥵 Japanese game fatigue
Re: Unicorn Overlord's Gorgeous PS5, PS4 Demo Is Available Now
Tried on switch, will play on PS5 - Too many great games! 🥵
Re: Final Fantasy VII Rebirth (PS5) - Strong Sequel Seeks a New Direction
@Cloud39472 preach it!
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth Becomes the Second Highest-Rated Final Fantasy Game of All Time
The poor visuals statements are hitting my faith in humanity hard. Those are some of the best character models I have ever seen in any videogame.
Re: Final Fantasy VII Rebirth (PS5) - Strong Sequel Seeks a New Direction
@ShogunRok I wasn’t objecting to your review at all, just pointing out that many posters here are overly dramatic: I can think of many, many RPGs that did side quest worse than recent FF. SMT and Persona, for instance, have absolutely dire ones, yet that aren’t scrutinized for not being on the level of the Witcher 3 or BG3, a completely other vibe and form of game.
And while we’re at it: maybe we should start comparing FF16 or FF7R combat and boss fights with The Witcher 3’s (again, one of my faves) since it seems so natural to compare the side quest, let’s do the same with the combat …it is just my opinion but these comparisons are one sided, unfair and serve a ready-made narrative that it’s getting more and more tiresome.
Re: Final Fantasy VII Rebirth (PS5) - Strong Sequel Seeks a New Direction
All the people complaining dramatically about ff16 and Remake quests have been playing P3 Reload? Because bring me Pine Resin and Muscle drink were really compelling and moving side quests that redefined the genre 🙄
Re: Final Fantasy VII Rebirth (PS5) - Strong Sequel Seeks a New Direction
Thank you for the review!
It sounds more up my alley than 16 (which I liked!) was. Love mini-games and explorations and non-linear plots.
It has a striking 93 on MC for what it’s worth…I see the dry PS5 2024 continues after TLOU2, GBfabtasy Relink and Hell Divers 2: such a bleak, bleak year for PS.
Re: Xbox Games Hi-Fi Rush, Sea of Thieves, Pentiment, Grounded All Confirmed for PS5, PS4
I will surely get Hi-fi Rush and maybe put Pentiment on a wishlist.
That said, to have the podcast and not reveal the titles “to leve it to the developers” and then announce them all unceremoniously 1 week later …why?
It really looks bad for them, don’t they realize it?
Re: Could SMT 5: Vengeance Be the Long-Awaited PS5, PS4 Port?
This game has plenty of room to become a better version of himself and was actually really suffering from severe hardware restrictions.
I still enjoyed it but would welcome an expanded PS5 port
Re: PS5 Exclusive Stellar Blade Will Feature a Trio of Graphics Options
Balanced sounds good! Really looking forward to this one
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 516
Final Fantasy VII remake quick re-run and Tekken!
@Bentleyma I wish I had your stamina!
@ApostateMage I wish the female protagonist was in Reload, she is so cool! And the female perspective is nice for a change in these dating (kinda) heavy games
Re: Xbox's 'Everywhere' Future Outlined in Company Memo from Phil Spencer
“We couldn’t sell consoles and subs and our parent company is tired of losing money and forced us to publish games on other platforms”.
Re: Microsoft Exec on Helldivers 2: I'm Not Sure Who It Helps By Not Being on Xbox
It helps PlayStation move hardware and expand/reinforce their brand.
It helps the dev to optimize the game and ship it sooner. It’s one less platform to worry about…
What about acquiring entire studios that had games in development for PS, who did it help, Phil?
Re: Rumour: Xbox Has Considered Microsoft Flight Simulator, Gears of War, and DOOM for PS5
@Korgon Yes! The voice of reason
Re: Xbox Is Bringing Four Exclusives to PS5, But It Won't Say Which
And I thought Sony’s communication was weak…
This was a master class on how NOT to squash internet rumors.
It basically indirectly confirmed that anything could be coming to PlayStation and Switch.
What a terrible show!
Re: Rumour: Astro Bot Will Return for Another PS5 Rescue Mission This Year
A big Astrobot game would be HUGE for me! Please make it real
Re: Tekken 8 Exceeds Bandai Namco's Expectations, Tops 2 Million Sales
It’s selling faster than SF6, isn’t?
These are excellent games, I prefer SF6 if you put a gun to my head but it’s just more my vibe! Anyway we are eating good, now back to some Tekken matches and trying to finish my quick Remake rerun
Re: Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet Could Be a Brand New IP from Sony
Not the most inventive title to be honest. But colour me interested in a PlayStation Studios RPG!
Re: PS5 Exclusive Stellar Blade Gets Adults-Only Rating for Nudity, Violence in Korea
C’mon even FF16 was rated M and the sexuality played out like some bizarrely puritan version of GOT. I don’t think she will be flashing us! At least I hope so. What did I pre-order 😂
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth PS5 Demo Update Will Improve Performance Mode Next Week
@MrMagic and then complain about AAA development times after driving development teams insane with some insanely high standards
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth PS5 Demo Update Will Improve Performance Mode Next Week
Err…people seriously had no idea of how this looked after roughly 200 hours of trailers? The characters models are incredible, the art direction is solid and it runs at a very stable frame rate in performance!
The demo convinced me 100% and to think this kind of graphic impact will be applied to huge open worldish areas is just …wow!
Re: PS5, PS4 Pull in an Incredible 123 Million Monthly Active Users
@lacerz I mean, this is on their own proprietary hardware alone, it’s actually pretty shocking how high this is. Xbox would sure love to pull similar numbers on their consoles but they have changed their strategy and will change it again because it couldn’t pull this (among other things) off
Re: Sony Slashes PS5 Forecast to 21 Million for Fiscal Year
@sanderson72 lol @ lackluster release schedule? Are we living in the same start of 2024? I can’t literally find time to play half of what I strictly consider must play on ps5
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth PS5 Demo Update Will Improve Performance Mode Next Week
Nice to know but it looked fabulous to my eyes!
Re: Tomb Raider 1-3 Remastered Starring Lara Croft (PS5) - The New Standard for PS1 Re-Releases
Wow it sounds and looks like an amazing re-release!
I think my standard for re-releases/remasters is Crisis Core atm. Not my favorite game but they really delivered on that one!
Re: Granblue Fantasy: Relink Sells Over 1 Million Copies in a Super Busy Release Schedule
Happy for them!
Wasn’t the best time to come out