Still find it a minor inconvencience when all this can be circumvented by a 2 min sign up though. Sorry, dont have strong feelings about all these proprietary things at all. I once had to sign up for playing a Ubisoft game on Playstation. While a minor inconvenience, took me no less than 2 mins.
It isn't about the time it takes to sign up. On PC, it is something you need to deal with every time you launch the game.
@LogicStrikesAgain Yes. The situation on PC is different. The issue for me is not that I need an account. I already have a PSN account. I don't care that much about that.
The issue on PC is that every time you run the game, you have to have that account validated. So once the servers that do that validation go offline, the game becomes unplayable. Again, for an online game, I think that is fair. But for an offline single player game, it destroys long-term game preservation. Also, I hope you weren't planning to play the game offline, like an on airplane.... Preservation is my primary concern.
For other people, there is also a privacy concern. They don't need/want Sony knowing when and how they play their offline games.
@Athrum Even if you make a copy of the physical disc, in most cases it won't be very useful in the long run. What is on the disc for most modern is games is a prerelease copy of the code which is typically in a pretty poor state. There are exceptions but most console game discs do little for preservation.
PC is the only real legal preservation platform these days.
@Athrum Consoles don't last forever. We are already starting to see availability issues on the used market with some of the older consoles. Also, you are assuming those consoles will even still function in the future without their online component. Since the physical drives themselves require online activation, trusting that you will still be able to read those discs in the future is flawed to begin with.
PC is only platform where you have real game preservation so it is critical we push back on these online requirements for offline single player games.
@get2sammyb I think blowing this off as "a storm in a teacup" deeply minimizes the real issue here.
For offline single player games, forcing an online connection and login is a huge blow to long-term game preservation. That means those games become unplayable if those servers ever go away.
For online multiplayer games, it is what it is. There is a cost to maintaining that infrastructure so the expectation should be that those games won't stay around forever.
For offline single player games, that should never be the case. They are hamstringing the future of those games so they can harvest data from their userbase.
I still play games from 20-30 years ago on PC. If those games had online logins, many of them would no longer be playable.
The lack of a physical drive is the primary reason I did not get one. From a preservation perspective, that is a real problem given the need for online activation.
I am hardcore enthusiast. I buy basically every console. I am the sucker that buys the console at release and the upgraded model every time. switch/oled, ps4/ps4 pro, xone/xonex. I bought at least 5 different 3DS handhelds.
I am squarely in the target demographic for this machine and I was prepared to buy it even though I don't use my PS5 enough to make it worth it.
However, I can't buy this and feel OK about it. A $200 price increase over the base model plus an extra $100 for the accessories. It just doesn't make sense to spend that much on a console unless $800 is an irrelevant amount of money for you.
At what point does it make more sense just to buy a gaming PC?
Even if the PC cost a bit more than $800, you wouldn't have to pay for online gaming and you would have access to a bigger library of games. If you wait for a sale, you can get a gaming PC that will outperform the PS5 Pro in the $900-$1000 range.
The only other game that even looked interesting was Infinity Nikki even though I am probably outside the target demographic for that game. Seems to have strangely high production values for that type of game. I am curious to see what it is actually like when it launches.
Honestly it looks pretty good to me after watching the video.
A locked 60fps isn't super important in a turn-based game. I would play it in quality mode at a mostly locked 30 fps with no tearing and better visuals personally. Seems like the only area it falls below that is in the city in act 3 where it was expected to be a problem.
@Vega37 GPU includes PC gaming and a better cloud service.
I don't think that comparison is very relevant. That being said, I think the biggest problem is at the bottom where essential is now $20 higher than Microsoft.
I am glad I converted all plus and still have almost 9 years left.
This seems like a pretty steep increase to me. Especially for essential. It is 33-35% at all tiers. Extra and premium are being brought in-line with the GP price increases so I can kind of understand those.
It seems like people who don't care about online will drop essential altogether.
If you happen to have a need for the limited ways this can be used, the next concern is performance.
Historically, Remote Play has not been very good even on a local network. If that is the same system being used with the portal, I think people are going to be disappointed unless their expectations are suitably low.
I definitely wouldn't recommend pre-ordering this until there is solid information on real world performance.
As for the performance, don't forget one of the big reasons for the low internal resolutions on the PS5/XSX was due to the fact that it had baked in RT. Hopefully they will make it at least playable.
On the PS4, that obviously won't be there so that should help with getting it to run on the lesser hardware. It also probably be a fixed 30fps.
@get2sammyb A name brand quality tablet with an OLED screen costs about $200 by itself. When you attach a Sony controller to it plus add in some Sony tax you can easily be at $300 or more.
I think the biggest change is that it will put Sony and Microsoft on a more even footing in the console space. If that is good or bad will depend on perspective.
The days of all the good exclusives being on PS are probably over but this is hardly the first time in the history of consoles where that has been the case.
Personally, I don't think this will result in any drastic changes. My hope is it will force Sony into a spot where it feels pressured to start making more consumer-friendly decisions to compete.
What is my previously held belief that I am confirming with my reading of the available data?
I think the idea is that you went in believing that "they seem to want to only discount the really expensive versions of games while the normal version remains full price."
If you verified this by checking some games and seeing this to be the case, that could be confirmation bias depending on the method used.
To be clear, I am not claiming that is what happened in this case because I have no idea how you verified it. I do think that confirmation bias is possible in this situation though.
@Ashina Yes, I wasn't a fan when it initially launched but coming back to it later after some of the bug fixing and on stronger hardware, I thought it was a great game.
@DualWielding Unity still holds up much better than Black Flag. The assets are much higher quality and they did so many amazing things with it. Honestly, the overshot the hardware at the time and it needs a current-gen console to run it well. It is pretty amazing on a PC at 1440p/4k.
but what Microsoft has done, games that were planned for multi play release and then they lock that away...yeah, that's just morally wrong.
You and a few others have stated this but I don't really follow this logic.
If a company uses money to buy exclusivity it makes no practical difference when they do so. Ultimately, it is all the same. The difference is purely an emotional one.
@number1024 I don't really understand this line of thinking.
Both companies pay for both timed and permanent exclusives.
Both companies buy studios to gain exclusivity.
Both companies have their own self interests in mind when doing these things.
Other people have stated this above multiple times but neither of these companies are angels acting on behalf of the community.
Speaking logically, exclusivity is bad. It is anti-consumer behavior no matter how you look at it. People are splitting hairs based on the mechanism to achieve it but it all comes down to the same thing. Without exclusives, all that would matter is who could put together the most compelling hardware solution at the best cost. It would also create competition between the stores. All things that benefit consumers.
Thinking emotionally, I like the idea of exclusives. It makes the platform and the hardware matter and makes the market a more interesting place. It also brings back fond memories of the days when a much greater percentage of the games were exclusive. Of course, as with most emotional arguments, it is logically flawed.
@Ristar24 Yeah. I wonder how much that contributed to Sony's dominance in the last generation. It wasn't the only factor but it definitely didn't help XB.
@Cutmastavictory Unfortunately, one of the flaws with this platform is I don't know which of my comments you are responding to.
If you are referring to the original one at the top, it was a joke.
If you are referring to the one about competition, I think it is better for the exclusives to be spread more evenly between the big 3 competitors than to be heavily focused on just two of them as has recently been the case.
@PCPS4XB It makes literally no difference to me, as I said above my original statement was intended to be a joke and the conversation got carried away from there.
@thefourfoldroot1 I suppose one reason would be that after years of being locked out of great games they would finally have some decent exclusives coming their way.
Personally, I am a multi-platform gamer so I have no stake in the console wars but even as someone who is console agnostic, it is clear that Sony in recent years has been killing Microsoft on the exclusives front. Things were bound to equalize eventually.
We are now moving towards a situation where all 3 major platforms have numerous exclusives and I think that actually helps competition overall.
Comments 196
Re: Sony Boss Says It's 'Learned a Lot' from PC Player Pushback
@LogicStrikesAgain
It isn't about the time it takes to sign up. On PC, it is something you need to deal with every time you launch the game.
Re: Sony Boss Says It's 'Learned a Lot' from PC Player Pushback
@LogicStrikesAgain Yes. The situation on PC is different. The issue for me is not that I need an account. I already have a PSN account. I don't care that much about that.
The issue on PC is that every time you run the game, you have to have that account validated. So once the servers that do that validation go offline, the game becomes unplayable. Again, for an online game, I think that is fair. But for an offline single player game, it destroys long-term game preservation. Also, I hope you weren't planning to play the game offline, like an on airplane.... Preservation is my primary concern.
For other people, there is also a privacy concern. They don't need/want Sony knowing when and how they play their offline games.
Re: Sony Boss Says It's 'Learned a Lot' from PC Player Pushback
@Paramahansa It isn't about being too lazy to make an account. It is about the implications that come with it.
Re: Sony Boss Says It's 'Learned a Lot' from PC Player Pushback
@Athrum Even if you make a copy of the physical disc, in most cases it won't be very useful in the long run. What is on the disc for most modern is games is a prerelease copy of the code which is typically in a pretty poor state. There are exceptions but most console game discs do little for preservation.
PC is the only real legal preservation platform these days.
Re: Sony Boss Says It's 'Learned a Lot' from PC Player Pushback
@Athrum Consoles don't last forever. We are already starting to see availability issues on the used market with some of the older consoles. Also, you are assuming those consoles will even still function in the future without their online component. Since the physical drives themselves require online activation, trusting that you will still be able to read those discs in the future is flawed to begin with.
PC is only platform where you have real game preservation so it is critical we push back on these online requirements for offline single player games.
Re: Sony Boss Says It's 'Learned a Lot' from PC Player Pushback
@get2sammyb I think blowing this off as "a storm in a teacup" deeply minimizes the real issue here.
For offline single player games, forcing an online connection and login is a huge blow to long-term game preservation. That means those games become unplayable if those servers ever go away.
For online multiplayer games, it is what it is. There is a cost to maintaining that infrastructure so the expectation should be that those games won't stay around forever.
For offline single player games, that should never be the case. They are hamstringing the future of those games so they can harvest data from their userbase.
I still play games from 20-30 years ago on PC. If those games had online logins, many of them would no longer be playable.
Re: Poll: Did You Buy a PS5 Pro?
@Voltan Out of curiosity, can you transfer the SSD over and have it work or do you need to redownload the games?
Re: Poll: Did You Buy a PS5 Pro?
The lack of a physical drive is the primary reason I did not get one. From a preservation perspective, that is a real problem given the need for online activation.
Re: Microsoft Is Investigating Why Devs Are Prioritising PS5 Over Xbox
I am pretty sure they already know the reasons without doing any research.
Re: Talking Point: Is PS5 Pro Way Too Expensive?
I am hardcore enthusiast. I buy basically every console. I am the sucker that buys the console at release and the upgraded model every time. switch/oled, ps4/ps4 pro, xone/xonex. I bought at least 5 different 3DS handhelds.
I am squarely in the target demographic for this machine and I was prepared to buy it even though I don't use my PS5 enough to make it worth it.
However, I can't buy this and feel OK about it. A $200 price increase over the base model plus an extra $100 for the accessories. It just doesn't make sense to spend that much on a console unless $800 is an irrelevant amount of money for you.
At what point does it make more sense just to buy a gaming PC?
Even if the PC cost a bit more than $800, you wouldn't have to pay for online gaming and you would have access to a bigger library of games. If you wait for a sale, you can get a gaming PC that will outperform the PS5 Pro in the $900-$1000 range.
Re: DualSense Edge Fully Customisable on PC with New App
Did they get the adaptive triggers working wirelessly on the PC yet? That is the primary blocker with me on PC.
Re: PS Plus Essential Games for August 2024 Announced
This selection looks good to me. Much better than most months.
Re: Poll: What Was Your Favourite Game from State of Play?
Astrobot for me as well.
The only other game that even looked interesting was Infinity Nikki even though I am probably outside the target demographic for that game. Seems to have strangely high production values for that type of game. I am curious to see what it is actually like when it launches.
Re: Remastered LucasArts Adventure Games Looking Likely for Release on PS5
I am curious to see how these will be better than the PS4 versions.
These games don't seem like that would benefit much from a native version.
Re: Game of the Year: Best PS5, PS4 RPG of 2023
I am not sure that I would consider Lies of P an RPG though....
Re: PS Plus Essential Games for January 2024 Announced
Looks like a pretty good month to me.
Re: Turns Out You Won't Lose Access to Those Discovery TV Shows on PlayStation After All
Well...it is covered for another 2.5 years. After that, you could lose the content you purchased.
Purchased digital content is broken across almost all media. I am not a fan of regulation but this is a space that needs attention from lawmakers.
Re: GTA 6 Skips Last-Gen PS4 Version for PS5, Xbox Series X|S
Seems like that was a foregone conclusion given they are hoping for a 2025 release date.
Re: PS Plus Essential Games for December 2023 Announced
These seem OK but is it my imagination or has the quality of monthly games dropped since the price increase was announced.
Re: Existence of Unannounced Gearbox Games Revealed via LinkedIn
The thing that strikes me most is that are still developing their new games in UE4....
Also, this person clearly violated their NDA.
Re: Baldur's Gate 3 Dominates Golden Joystick Awards, Wins Game of the Year
Is anyone else surprised that RE4 is the PS GOTY?
Re: Poll: Are You Happy with Your PS Plus Essential Games for November 2023?
There are often months where there is nothing for me. However, this month just looks objectively poor.
It seems like the quality of games is dropping as the price of the service is increasing.
Re: Video: Spider-Man 2's Striking PS5 Console and DualSense Controller Unboxed
I can't decide if I like the controller or not.
I guess need to open the box and look inside.
Re: Baldur's Gate 3 PS5 Is Comparable to Ultra Settings on PC, But There's Room for Improvement
@Sakai keep in mind that it is only in one area of the game. The rest of the game doesn't see those issues.
Re: Baldur's Gate 3 PS5 Is Comparable to Ultra Settings on PC, But There's Room for Improvement
Honestly it looks pretty good to me after watching the video.
A locked 60fps isn't super important in a turn-based game. I would play it in quality mode at a mostly locked 30 fps with no tearing and better visuals personally. Seems like the only area it falls below that is in the city in act 3 where it was expected to be a problem.
Re: PS Plus Essential, Extra, Premium Price Increases Announced by Sony
@Vega37 GPU includes PC gaming and a better cloud service.
I don't think that comparison is very relevant. That being said, I think the biggest problem is at the bottom where essential is now $20 higher than Microsoft.
Re: PS Plus Essential, Extra, Premium Price Increases Announced by Sony
I am glad I converted all plus and still have almost 9 years left.
This seems like a pretty steep increase to me. Especially for essential. It is 33-35% at all tiers. Extra and premium are being brought in-line with the GP price increases so I can kind of understand those.
It seems like people who don't care about online will drop essential altogether.
Re: PS5 Fans Divided on PlayStation Portal Handheld
If you happen to have a need for the limited ways this can be used, the next concern is performance.
Historically, Remote Play has not been very good even on a local network. If that is the same system being used with the portal, I think people are going to be disappointed unless their expectations are suitably low.
I definitely wouldn't recommend pre-ordering this until there is solid information on real world performance.
Re: PlayStation Portal Is Sony's PS5 Remote Play Handheld, Priced at $200 / £200
The price seems reasonable given it is a first party product. Certainly cheaper than I expected.
However, it has a pretty limited market I think.
I can see some use cases:
That being said, since I don't have any of those needs, I will probably pass.
Re: Assassin's Creed Mirage Returns to Series Roots, But Won't Ditch Cosmetic Microtransactions
I find it hard to believe that Ubisoft would offer microtransactions......oh wait.
Seriously, anyone who thought this game wouldn't have some form of microtransactions hasn't been paying attention or was enjoying a lovely dream.
Re: Poll: Will You Be Buying Red Dead Redemption on PS4?
A straight PS4 port of an X360 game from 2010 in 2023 for $49.
Not a remaster, not a remake. A straight port.
That would be a hard no.
Re: Star Wars Jedi: Survivor Is Being Ported Backwards to Decade-Old PS4
@haoie It did sell well actually.
As for the performance, don't forget one of the big reasons for the low internal resolutions on the PS5/XSX was due to the fact that it had baked in RT. Hopefully they will make it at least playable.
On the PS4, that obviously won't be there so that should help with getting it to run on the lesser hardware. It also probably be a fixed 30fps.
Re: PS5's Remote Play Portable Appears to Leak Online
@get2sammyb A name brand quality tablet with an OLED screen costs about $200 by itself. When you attach a Sony controller to it plus add in some Sony tax you can easily be at $300 or more.
Re: PS5's Remote Play Portable Appears to Leak Online
@get2sammyb
I think that is highly unlikely. I would be be shocked if they list this thing for less than the $249-$349 range.
Re: Reaction: What Happens to PlayStation if Microsoft Buys Activision Blizzard?
@Total_Weirdo
Hahahahaha. Yeah, their negotiating position just got a lot weaker.
Re: Reaction: What Happens to PlayStation if Microsoft Buys Activision Blizzard?
I think the biggest change is that it will put Sony and Microsoft on a more even footing in the console space. If that is good or bad will depend on perspective.
The days of all the good exclusives being on PS are probably over but this is hardly the first time in the history of consoles where that has been the case.
Personally, I don't think this will result in any drastic changes. My hope is it will force Sony into a spot where it feels pressured to start making more consumer-friendly decisions to compete.
Re: New PS Store Essential Picks Sale Has 1,400 PS5, PS4 Game Discounts
@Wheatly
I think the idea is that you went in believing that "they seem to want to only discount the really expensive versions of games while the normal version remains full price."
If you verified this by checking some games and seeing this to be the case, that could be confirmation bias depending on the method used.
To be clear, I am not claiming that is what happened in this case because I have no idea how you verified it. I do think that confirmation bias is possible in this situation though.
Re: Assassin's Creed 4: Black Flag Remake Reportedly in Early Development
@Ashina Yes, I wasn't a fan when it initially launched but coming back to it later after some of the bug fixing and on stronger hardware, I thought it was a great game.
Re: Assassin's Creed 4: Black Flag Remake Reportedly in Early Development
@DualWielding Unity still holds up much better than Black Flag. The assets are much higher quality and they did so many amazing things with it. Honestly, the overshot the hardware at the time and it needs a current-gen console to run it well. It is pretty amazing on a PC at 1440p/4k.
Re: Assassin's Creed 4: Black Flag Remake Reportedly in Early Development
If this ever sees the light of day, I will be thrilled.
Re: Indiana Jones Game Deal Amended to Exclude PS5, PS4
@number1024
You and a few others have stated this but I don't really follow this logic.
If a company uses money to buy exclusivity it makes no practical difference when they do so. Ultimately, it is all the same. The difference is purely an emotional one.
Re: Indiana Jones Game Deal Amended to Exclude PS5, PS4
@number1024 I don't really understand this line of thinking.
Both companies pay for both timed and permanent exclusives.
Both companies buy studios to gain exclusivity.
Both companies have their own self interests in mind when doing these things.
Other people have stated this above multiple times but neither of these companies are angels acting on behalf of the community.
Speaking logically, exclusivity is bad. It is anti-consumer behavior no matter how you look at it. People are splitting hairs based on the mechanism to achieve it but it all comes down to the same thing. Without exclusives, all that would matter is who could put together the most compelling hardware solution at the best cost. It would also create competition between the stores. All things that benefit consumers.
Thinking emotionally, I like the idea of exclusives. It makes the platform and the hardware matter and makes the market a more interesting place. It also brings back fond memories of the days when a much greater percentage of the games were exclusive. Of course, as with most emotional arguments, it is logically flawed.
Re: Indiana Jones Game Deal Amended to Exclude PS5, PS4
@Ristar24 Yeah. I wonder how much that contributed to Sony's dominance in the last generation. It wasn't the only factor but it definitely didn't help XB.
Re: Indiana Jones Game Deal Amended to Exclude PS5, PS4
@UltimateOtaku91 While that is probably true, Sony does the same thing on a regular basis.
Re: Indiana Jones Game Deal Amended to Exclude PS5, PS4
@NotSoCryptic
Umm.....millions of them?
Re: Indiana Jones Game Deal Amended to Exclude PS5, PS4
@Cutmastavictory Unfortunately, one of the flaws with this platform is I don't know which of my comments you are responding to.
If you are referring to the original one at the top, it was a joke.
If you are referring to the one about competition, I think it is better for the exclusives to be spread more evenly between the big 3 competitors than to be heavily focused on just two of them as has recently been the case.
Re: Indiana Jones Game Deal Amended to Exclude PS5, PS4
@PCPS4XB It makes literally no difference to me, as I said above my original statement was intended to be a joke and the conversation got carried away from there.
Re: Indiana Jones Game Deal Amended to Exclude PS5, PS4
@thefourfoldroot1 FWIW, my original comment was intended to be a joke about my XB collecting dust not spark a huge debate.
Re: Indiana Jones Game Deal Amended to Exclude PS5, PS4
@thefourfoldroot1 I suppose one reason would be that after years of being locked out of great games they would finally have some decent exclusives coming their way.
Personally, I am a multi-platform gamer so I have no stake in the console wars but even as someone who is console agnostic, it is clear that Sony in recent years has been killing Microsoft on the exclusives front. Things were bound to equalize eventually.
We are now moving towards a situation where all 3 major platforms have numerous exclusives and I think that actually helps competition overall.
Re: Indiana Jones Game Deal Amended to Exclude PS5, PS4
@Kevw2006 I think MS would allow PS Plus on their store if Sony allowed GP on theirs.
That being said, I have lost the thread of this conversation so I am not sure that is even relevant to the discussion.