Comments 538

Re: Microsoft Commits to Next Call of Duty Game on Xbox Game Pass, New Report Says

IamJT

Well it sells more on PS5 and PC anyways. But that’s still walking away from a lot of revenue if true. It’s so hard to get accurate game pass subscription data we will likely not even know if it was a success. It’s a huge gamble either way but I think it’s probably smarter to launch day and date than walk back the entire game pass model.

Re: Ghost of Tsushima on PC Attracts 57K Player Peak on Launch Day

IamJT

I don’t see how this is not a good strategy other than the lack of PSN in certain areas. Releasing a four year old game on PC not only garners sales, but also puts Tsushima back in the discussion before they announce the second game. Good move all around and the length of time between release does not hurt PS5 marketability. Now please can we get Sons of the Forest on PS5 already.

Re: PS5 Sales Reach 59.3 Million as Sony Falls Just Short of Fiscal Year Forecast

IamJT

@Titntin Yea the thing this gen has made clear is that exclusive games are not why people are choosing one console over another. Most people play 1 or 2 games a year and they are multiplat or free-to-play games. The whole “Xbox/playstation has no games!” Does not even enter the majority of consumers minds. The value proposition of each console is tied to many many factors. At the beginning of the generation I thought Xbox was going to be on pace with PS and maybe even overtake it due to gamepass day and date promise, but that doesn’t even appeal to most people as they would never play those games anyways. Gamepass wasn’t a system seller, and ended up devaluing the platform because people just generally don’t consume games like this.

As for the “no games” argument people must be playing as a full time job because I can not keep up.

Re: Hermen Hulst, Hideaki Nishino Replace Jim Ryan As PlayStation CEOs

IamJT

“Go ahead, name a country that doesn't have two presidents. A boat that sets sail without two captains. Where would Catholicism be without the popes.”

Also no surprise people are scapegoating California politics in the comments even the California is super politically diverse. Also, California is the fifth largest economy in the world with a huge talent pool in tech so it’s not like it doesn’t make sense to base operations there.

Re: Alan Wake 2's Haunting Soundtrack Out Tomorrow, Includes 35 Tracks

IamJT

@WolfyTn probably. There is no doubt they left some money on the table not releasing physical. Although I think the game’s sales were weakened more by Epic exclusivity on PC rather than a lack of physical at launch. Regardless I hope they release physical so more people get to experience it! Same reason I hope it finds its way to steam!

Re: There's a 'Real Hunger' for AI to Make Game Dev More Efficient, Says EA Boss

IamJT

AI and copyright needs to get sorted before this is rolled out in any significant way. For example, if you use AI to generate art assets, you have no copyright protection in that asset currently, potentially leading to profitability concerns. Using AI to “clean up” assets is probably okay while still being able to protect the content, but it’s a fine line and nothing is settled.

Re: Poll: How Do You Feel About All of the Xbox Multiplatform Rumours?

IamJT

@HotGoomba I’m not sure avowed is a system seller. Even Stafield didn’t move enough systems to matter. Honestly I am still blown away Xbox isn’t selling more. They have the lowest point of entry and have the cheapest way to access a large amount of games and even have been publishing new releases day and date. At the start of this generation I thought it was gonna be 1:1 but apparently I know nothing.

Re: Third-Person View Makes Helldivers 2 More Immersive, Better Game Feel

IamJT

@theSpectre They were in a tough spot with the characters from that perspective, one because some of them are dead like Elliott, and two because the actors are so identifiable with the characters. Like it would be weird to redesign the characters, and it also looks kinda weird to just copy the actors exact appearance. Maybe if they had gone for a more stylized less realistic look of the actors it wouldn't have that uncanny valley feel. Another thing is Harrison Ford has a very specific movement set. It's something I noticed when watching the new movie, the cgi running Ford just doesnt look anything like how he runs which has almost a goofy, unsure gait. I dunno long story short I dont know if there was a better way to do it. If its good I am borrowing my brother's xbox and getting gamepass for a month to play it though!

Re: Hogwarts Legacy Beats Modern Warfare 3, Spider-Man 2 as Most Downloaded PS5 Game of 2023

IamJT

@KundaliniRising333 I think a flaw in your "argument" is that most people only buy/play a few games a year. So a "pretty stale" game like Spider-Man 2 doesn't seem that way outside of the small enthusiast market. If Sony corrected their course based on your feedback it would be disastrous for them. Realistically, there is room in the market for both styles of games. Something like Alan Wake II will have great appeal for the enthusiast crowd, which is extremely small in comparison to the entire gaming market, while something like Spider-Man 2 will appeal to casual gamers.

As an aside I liked both games. Spider-Man 2 wasn't terribly innovative, but it was great comfort food with a compelling story and satisfying gameplay loop.

Re: The Last of Us Part 2 Remastered (PS5) - A Near Perfect Package for New and Returning Fans

IamJT

@Bez87 One of the reasons it's controversial is because people thought a certain person was a "good" character and they wanted to play as them again. I dunno though the entire first game shows you they are the bad guy, especially the very last scene. The "okay" says it all. Fans took a weird ownership over the story instead of just wanting to be told a story that the creator wanted to tell. I loved it and was very lucky to go in with no spoilers.

Re: GTA 5 Michael Voice Actor Calls Out 'Garbage' AI Chatbot Using His Voice

IamJT

@Northern_munkey The added layer is that he doesn't own the copyright to his voice recordings used in the training of the AI, Rockstar does. So really they need Rockstar's permission and not his. That's assuming they need permission at all though. If the AI is used to make a noninfringing output.. it is likely fair use anyways.

Re: Remedy and Rockstar's Logos Both Use an 'R', and Take-Two Can't Tell the Difference

IamJT

Everyone getting mad at Rockstar but from a legal standpoint this makes perfect sense. Trademark is only protectable as long as you are willing to protect it. It is likely that Rockstar doesn't even care about the outcome of this case. Trademark law is deceptively complicated but when you are a company worth as much as Rockstar... yea you try and have no one in a related business with even a remotely similar trademark.

Re: Game of the Year: #2 - Baldur's Gate 3

IamJT

Baldur’s Gate good, Spider-Man 2 good, doesn’t matter which one got first place. Honestly, Alan Wake 2 is my personal favorite and another persons ranking is interesting and doesnt change my rating at all.

On another note, BG3 is an incredible game but just too darn big!