Comments 586

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 525

breakneck

FF7 Rebirth: in Nibelheim now. This game is really quite weak compared to Remake that had a lot more forward momentum. The biggest issue to me is the game literally did not move forward plot wise since you leave Junon until Cosmo Canyon. Then you have sequences like Dyne's which are unintentionally comedic and it is just a disappointment. I'm hoping the last few chapters are good and save my overall feeling of "MEH" towards the game. The open world stuff absolutely sucks and falls far more into Ubisoft territory than Horizon or Witcher territory. The mini-games are awful for the most part and mandatory often enough to make you actively hate them. 6-7/10 so far.

Nier Replicant: A fascinating game that does the Found Family dynamics a million times better than Rebirth, is funnier, more emotional and much shorter. Also less minigames and you don't need to waste time on side quests. 8.5/10 so far.

BG3: This game will never end!!! Just reached the lower city and there is so much to do! But it is consistently fun and high quality though there is a big pacing drop in Act 3. 9/10 so far.

Hoping Stellar Blade gets positive reviews so I can pre-order it but given the recent Kotaku and Inverse articles and the way certain journalists online are behaving I do not expect it. Just bad discourse from every side.

Re: Huge PS Plus Clearout Confirmed for May, 25 Games Leaving

breakneck

Not a big loss wrt FF. They've been on the service for nearly two years which is more than enough time for those who seriously wanted to play to play it. Also, most of those games are on every alternate sale at dirt cheap prices.
I played FF7 Remake when it came on Plus same for Artful Escape. They've been on there for a long time.

Re: Final Fantasy 16 Successfully Expanded the Series to New, Younger Players, Says Square Enix

breakneck

Sounds like XVI did exactly what it should've done that too on a single console and with the majority of RPG/FF gamers wanting it too fail.
The problem with FF7 Remake is it isn't really great for newcomers and caters towards those who grew up with FF7.

I liked the game a lot when it was not focused on the politics of the world (such a poor job tackling complex topics) and I loved Clive and Joshua as protagonists (that whole thrid act was amazing and the ending had me in tears as a older brother). I hope the DLC does Jill well since she was quite poorly handled.

Re: Whoa! Crash Bandicoot 4: It's About Time Has Sold More Than 5 Million Copies

breakneck

The discounts have been pretty massive so I am not too surprised. Do PS+ Downloads count or is it just sales? Because some companies consider those sales as well.

Personally? I disliked it quite a lot after the initial wow factor. Levels were too long, the reverse levels sucked, too many hidden crates, the relics were irritating, Polar was a mess to control with horrible hit boxes. I liked the mask abilities, the music and the graphics though.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 524

breakneck

FF7 Rebirth: I feel like the story has just started in Gongaga after basically going MIA since the boat trip. Chapters 5 to 8 have really killed the pacing and IMO didn't need to be as long as they were. The characters are still a joy though I think Aerith has been given the short end of the stick and has almost no character moments so far. I can see why this game undersold.
It is TOO MUCH and the burn out feels very real. The mini games are TOO MUCH.
The weird way the women over emote in cutscenes to be Kawaii is TOO MUCH (not seen this level of weird women animations since Catwoman in AK).
This game oscillates between a 5 to 10/10 so quickly.

Nier Replicant: A very very good story. Unsure if I'll grind out everything for ending C and D though. I've cried at least twice so far. The emotional moments in this hit a lot harder than Rebirth and it is weird to see a game so much more focused on its characters while retaining a semi similar open world structure. I think this game is proof that AAA open worlds are way too big for no reason.

BG3: in Act 3... Overwhelming but my god this game is so consistently excellent in a way people claimed Elden Ring was. The combat is my only major issue with the game because of how many people are on screen in some fights now. Turns are way too long lol. The story also feels a little disjointed after Moonrise Towers but I'm hoping it picks up soon.

Re: PS Store Sales Charts: Helldivers 2 Dominates Once Again, Dragon's Dogma 2 in Third

breakneck

Final Fantasy has a problem where it doesn't seem to be getting new, younger players into the franchise. Square (and most game companies) in general are struggling with it. Octopath, FF all have been disappointments. People are saying going multiplat will solve it but I don't see it happening.
FF7 Remake with PC barely crossed 7 million (during a pandemic). I don't think Rebirth would've been able to cross those figures.
Also, we have to remember the PS4 had double the units in the market when Remake released. Remake was also very divisive and Rebirth is the same. I've seen people who loved Remake not like the ending of Rebirth.

Re: Stellar Blade's Demo Had Way More Daily Active Players Than Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth's

breakneck

Rebirth was the sequel to a very divisive first game. Those who were out were never coming back. Stellar Blade got a lot of interest due to controversies online, positive word of mouth and overall interest due to the promotions from Sony who are treating it like a proper first party title. Both Ronin and Stellar Blade are getting insane promotion in Asia especially.
Also, the demo was great. I've probably fought the Stalker 5-6 times because the combat feels so good.

Re: Japan Sales Charts: Rise of the Ronin Rides Again, Refuses to Leave Top 3

breakneck

@mrbone They keep doing it in every article. Not surprising since gamers have been more positive overall towards ROTR and their 6/10 was stupidly harsh considering the high praise they gave DD2 despite also having performance flaws and failing to do anything new in the 10 years since Dark Arisen. Every negative DD2 article (about MTs etc) also has them praising the game.

Ronin is not perfect but as Stephanie Sterling's review put it: it actually likes its players unlike DD2.

Re: Confusion as Duelling Reports Confirm/Deny Existence of Dead Space 2 Remake

breakneck

I think Grubb may have misunderstood his sources more likely. Because everyone has confirmed DS2 ain't happening. The question is did it ever enter the concept stage as Grubb states or was it never even discussed as per IGN.

We all know Dead Space Remake wasn't successful commercially at least not to the levels EA would've wanted and while critically well received it was completely overshadowed by RE4 Remake. So they just probably don't see any need to make a sequel/remake-quel

Re: Bungie Might Be Making Destiny 3, Its Fanbase Speculates

breakneck

It would be odd to have two live services with Marathon also coming out. But I do feel with Sony playing the tough guy and reining in some of Bungies excess but giving Bungie all the creative control they need. They could learn from their mistakes and make a consistently good live service rather than the up and down cycle they seem stuck in.

I wish them well, they've been through a lot in the last year.

Re: Talking Point: What's Your Favourite PS5 Game of 2024 So Far?

breakneck

Probably Rebirth for me. 2024 has been disappointing with too many REALLY LONG games and all overstay their welcome by at least 7-10 hours.

Otherwise from that list in general the Last of Us II still holds up as a 10/10 and Pentiment when I played it on Xbox was imo the ONLY EXCELLENT Xbox game of the last 12 years

Re: $70 Games Are Just a Phase, Believes Saber Interactive CEO

breakneck

Looking at how many pre-orders are usually for deluxe editions I think 80USD is the maximum limit they can go for a long time for base editions. I do think the future is in re-finding that balance of 2 70USD games and 3-4 50USD a year for console manufacturers and big publishers.

Re: Dragon's Dogma 2 PS5 Patch 1.060 Isn't the Update You're Waiting For

breakneck

@Michael2008ish Yeah I was saying that the fact that Weiss and Nier joke about it just nails how much people hated backtracking even at the time that it was played for a joke. The beauty of Nier is the world is so small and you run so fast that you can be anywhere on the map in 2-3 minutes and massacre most enemies in the area.

Re: Dragon's Dogma 2 PS5 Patch 1.060 Isn't the Update You're Waiting For

breakneck

@B0udoir Wouldn't say it sold well... yet (it has started well but if ROTR is expecting to sell 5 mil units, DD2 probably aims for 8-12 mil being on three systems). The drop-off in the PS store has been quite quick and in Asian markets is already almost out of the top 10-12 games. A game with this level of marketing/advertising would've wanted to have more staying power.

I do find the disparity between gamers and critics with this game to be surprisingly different. Maybe proof that there are too many critics cut from the same cloth/tastes and not enough who have unique voices/tastes?

Re: Despite Flagging Physical Software Sales, PS5's Retail Presence Is Still Strong in Japan

breakneck

So lets look at the two games mentioned: FF7 Remake had a more mixed reception among japanese gamers for the changes to the story and the heavy action oriented jrpg combat system, so I'm not surprised people are more apprehensive about Rebirth. DD2 has generally been poorly received in Japan with Ronin getting far better word of mouth.

The Nintendo domination is not surprising especially with the handheld nature of the Switch and the strong association to many of the IP. A native handheld console like a Ps4.5 or ps5.5 could do huge there.

Re: Helldivers 2 Is Selling at a Faster Rate Than Spider-Man 2 in the UK

breakneck

@CrackmanNL Again Jim Ryan is a lot smarter than people want to give him credit for. He saw the issues with profitability coming and looked into recurrent revenue streams and based on how many of those games have been cancelled in development it is obvious he and his team saw the strength of HD2.
These cancellations mean his team still cares about the overall quality of output with the PS Brand. His only mistake which may yet work out in his favor is Bungie (the new update has been well received and people seem to again be enjoying the game).
He was also ridiculed for calling GamePass unprofitable and disliked by many studios despite being proven right two years later.

Re: Most PS5 Players Say 60fps Is a Must

breakneck

Some games like Spider-Man 2 and God of War absolutely require 60fps. Others like Alan Wake 2 and FF7 Rebirth don't need it. I think first party and action/platform oriented games should absolutely require 60fps to showcase the strength of the console. I also think this gen we've been caught in between a shift of technological prowess (too expensive to invest in optimisation or engine overhauls).
We are seeing games that are too technical to run well and games that look so outdated that run well. I think the Sony first party games are the only ones this gen that don't sacrifice either graphical fidelity or performance to heavily in either of their modes.

Re: Stellar Blade Director Recommends Players Wear Clothes, Where Possible

breakneck

The clothes are cool but the way people on Twitter are reacting and the weird ass horny posting is already creating discourse of the negative variety.
Generally stupid discourse from the left (who are okay with Leon being modded nude or in BDSM clothes but complain about this) and the right (horny posting and saying gaming will be saved from Woke because of this).

Re: Another Capcom Success as Dragon's Dogma 2 Sells 2.5 Million Copies

breakneck

@Brydontk It also isn't surprising, their reviews have always hated backtracking for little gain. Hence their negative impressions for Death Stranding when it released. They also had issues with how laborious certain aspects of RDR 2 were again especially with back tracking and irritating fast travel.

They are consistent with these critiques.

Re: Hands On: Dragon's Dogma 2 Update Improves Frame Rate on PS5 at the Cost of Ray Tracing

breakneck

I keep saying this but the time has come for these "small" Japanese companies to be held to the same standards as their Western competitors in every regard. This was Capcom being overconfident because gamers and Game Journos have let them get overconfident.

These issues have been there since Monster Hunter world with the stupid uncapped framerates but we could overlook them due to the age of the hardware.

Re: Game Pass Woes for Indie Devs as Microsoft, Epic Funding Reportedly Drying Up

breakneck

Not surprising. Playstation always knew how expensive these were. We saw in the leaks just how much research they do before they implement something. Epic and Xbox true to American capitalism threw money in the hopes of disruption that affected no one but their own businesses.

Even for first party day one: Playstation saw the damage it did to HFW sales when that came out on Plus a year later. Microsoft are losing so much money in their subscription business if you look at how well Starfield would've sold in the initial launch period.