Comments 3,820

Re: Frostpunk 2 Dev Recoups Entire Marketing, Production Budget in Three Days

thefourfoldroot1

@NEStalgia
Yes, that’s why I used the words “imagine” and “could”. We are talking about the future. Which is why I said “we need” in my first comment. Just like we are talking about the future when people talk about job loses en masse.

To repeat my first post to you:

“ We don’t need hardware to “go back three generations”, we need ai to speed up software development for AAA games.”

Re: Your Horizon Zero Dawn PS4 Progress Will Transition to PS5 Remaster

thefourfoldroot1

@Fiendish-Beaver
For offline games we always get the choice about carrying over save progress (just delete your save from the console). The question is whether it shares a trophy list, but someone pointed out to me that this never had a PS4 version (amazingly) which, if true, means this should be a different SKU with a new list. Fingers crossed anyway.

Re: Poll: What Did You Think of Sony's State of Play for September 2024?

thefourfoldroot1

Dragon age looks like turd, and I’m not really into more swordplay 3rd person stuff but those all look top quality anyway. Very happy with the Hitman trilogy in VR (£10 upgrade if you already have it flat), and metro is looking very good in VR too. Would have liked a few more games I’m personally excited about, but I can’t say it wasn’t an objectively good showing.

Re: Sony Appears to Leak Many Games from State of Play

thefourfoldroot1

@OldGamer999
Yeah, I’d normally be the demographic for the pro (have 2 PS5s, PSVR2, Portal etc), but they have given me no reason to get it, because there are no games that require it. Hell, most games still don’t even require the base PS5 and could get by quite well on PS4. Very happy with the amazing VR games (although Sony themselves could make more) and the great Portal flexibility, but Pro has nothing new.

Re: Frostpunk 2 Dev Recoups Entire Marketing, Production Budget in Three Days

thefourfoldroot1

@NEStalgia
Imagine if a dev could just speak their imagination and AI would create it. No need to actually code. Adaptations and alterations done on the fly, by voice, allowing many instances of a team’s imagination to be created and discarded or iterated upon.

The thing holding back more originality is the fact that there is a large time (and so financial) investment to creating and changing things, and that is a risk.

So, yeah, I don’t buy the whole “AI just re-uses what has been done before, output will be generic and boring” argument. AI is a tool, not a master.

Especially as this is what every human being does anyway, reinterpret and iterate from their experience.

Obviously there are lots of process things AI could take over too, but I’m concentrating on your originality concern, as I see it again and again.

Re: God of War Ragnarok PC Mod Removes PSN Login Requirement

thefourfoldroot1

@Deityjester
That’s a laughable response. Why would you think people care if PC players get to play it, the more successful a game is the more likely it is to get a sequel (I don’t like most Sony games, but that doesn’t mean I want them to fail and disappoint all those who like them).
I think you’re lumping me in with a group of people who, incidentally, barely exist.

Re: A Massive 75% of UK Game Sales Were Digital Last Month

thefourfoldroot1

Is this number of games, or value? I probably buy more games digitally these days, but spend more physically. £15 is my limit for a digital game, anything more and I know it’ll be cheaper to buy and trade back at CEX. From the title it seems volume. If you did this by value I suspect it would be a lot closer.

Re: God of War Ragnarok PC Review Bombed Over PSN Requirement

thefourfoldroot1

Pitiful people. Can’t believe there are so many. Many just buying the game to review bomb it then getting it refunded.

I don’t like the new God of Wars, I tried, but I just find them boring and generic, but I wouldn’t review bomb just because you have to connect to another account, any more than I have when I was made to connect to Ubisoft’s network. These people are just more fanboys who don’t do the same to other companies’ games that require exactly the same thing. If they did I’d respect them a bit more.

Whats more, I hear you don’t even need to connect to PSN to play it. It asks you to, but you can just skip it (I have no direct experience with this, just numerous indirect reports).

If I did get any Sony game on PC however, I wouldn’t even consider not connecting to PSN as I would lose all of the trophy challenges. I also like the fact Sony can boot someone’s account if they find them cheating in a single game, which would theoretically make any cross play much more console like rather than having to endure all of the PC cheaters…maybe that’s another reason these sad people review bomb thinking about it.

Re: Rumour: PS6 Could Span a Console and Handheld Device

thefourfoldroot1

@CVCubbington
I think we’ve hit the point where spending more to push games forward isn’t profitable. I don’t think it matters too much what the power of a system is, until AI progresses enough to take all of the grunt work out of game development we’ll be getting games that can be sold across multiple systems and not maxing the best.

Re: Rumour: PS6 Could Span a Console and Handheld Device

thefourfoldroot1

@TruestoryYep
I wasn’t even thinking they would try to get a PS6 game on a handheld with its inevitable computing and thermal restrictions. Sony are not turning into Nintendo when they are doing perfectly well in the higher end console space, and this story doesn’t suggest they are. I saw this as a separate handheld market device if it exists. Obviously with some PS4 back compat, some crossover IP and perhaps even cross connection of games on both devices in some fashion, but not a Switch compromise. They’d be foolish to take on Nintendo at their own game.

Re: Rumour: PS6 Could Span a Console and Handheld Device

thefourfoldroot1

@Toot1st
Yes, it is. But MS require next gen games on their system be held back through their parity requirement. This then means it will be on PS for multiplatform games. It’s a bit different as it means it’s inevitable, whereas staying on last gen isn’t depending on sales numbers and such, and is likely to reduce as a problem over time whereas the Series S type problem is locked in till next gen. Nobody wants that.

Re: PS5's Commanding Console Position Is Seemingly Insurmountable

thefourfoldroot1

@RoomWithaMoose
In fairness, nobody knew MS would not prioritise its own platform above others (in fact, they still could in theory). History actually indicated the opposite in fact. MS could have destroyed the PlayStation platform by strangling it of much of the largest third party content, they just decided not to. For now anyway.

Re: PS5's Commanding Console Position Is Seemingly Insurmountable

thefourfoldroot1

What’s crazy is that this would be even worse for MS if it wasn’t for Sonys stock shortages early on.

As you say, it’s obvious why MS are giving up on the Xbox as exclusive platform for selling its content. With PlayStation consumers having a significant library of games already, people are not just going to walk away from the ecosystem.

What I wish MS would do, rather than the subscription rubbish, is push Nintendo. Release a handheld hybrid instead, with more grunt, and price it as a secondary console. With MS’s collection of publishers they might actually get Ninty to do more than release more copies of its same old franchises.

Re: Vince Zampella Defends PS5 Pro Price, Says 'It's Actually Not That Bad'

thefourfoldroot1

@NEStalgia
There are so many…I just…I don’t know where to start with that

“objectively poor value propositions”

No. Not objective at all, especially when we haven’t seen what it can do. The closest you can get is “objectively expensive compared to old consoles, unless adjusted for inflation”.

“ They're a CONSOLE vendor. By definition their obligation is to cater to the masses.”

Which they do with the PS5. This is an enthusiasts upgrade. That’s all. It doesn’t damage relationships.

“ They released the PS5 about 2 years too early in terms of the tech it needed to have to be a genuine generational leap. ”

Ignoring that the time to move to next gen is mainly dictated by chip manufacturers, also that “genuine generational leap” is subjective (for me just the reduction in loading times is a big deal, more than a few more res’s certainly) sure, Sony could have waited 2 years (or 5 or 10) but they would have given MS too big a lead had they done so. Ironically perhaps a case of MS being too much competition lol.

Re: Vince Zampella Defends PS5 Pro Price, Says 'It's Actually Not That Bad'

thefourfoldroot1

@NEStalgia

You say:

“ If they could not build a machine that represents a significant upgrade where the price represents obvious value, they should not have built the console at all. ”

You really are thinking too much into this, and are actually at risk of descending into hyperbole. Also, what does it hurt you if others can afford to get a more powerful system and think it’s good value to them? You are a PC gamer, you should be used to that 🤷‍♂️

I’ll refer you to my first comment:

“ The reason this is £700 is because people will pay it. If they wouldn’t, it would either be marginally cheaper or it just wouldn’t exist.”

Costs have gone up so the price goes up, if Sony didn’t think people would pay the price they wouldn’t make it. It’s not complicated.

They are under no obligation to cater to the masses, they can release a niche device if they want and it causes no harm. The fact top end PC GPUs exist doesn’t mean the lower level market is destroyed, just like releasing this doesn’t mean the base PS5 market will not be catered to. It will still be the biggest market. Let’s just let people enjoy what they want without saying it shouldn’t be made.

Also, the PS5 is not a “terrible console” going purely by capability at release benchmarked against high end PCs, it is actually better than the PS4 at release by quite a significant margin. The problem is the economy has meant people didn’t switch and devs had to maintain support for PS4.