Comments 203

Re: Vast Majority of Gamers Say Elden Ring DLC Should Never Have Been Nominated for Game of the Year

QiaraIris

I can't believe people are actually dumb enough to use Blood and Wine winning best RPG as a comparison.

Expansions and DLCs are always eligible for best game design, best narrative, best audio, etc, those are not the issues.

The issue specifically here is adding a DLC into GAME OF THE YEAR category where historically they are not eligible to be included. Until they changed it this year - at the 11th hour to boot - just to include SotE. That's what scummy about it.

And no, you shouldn't be cheering this practice so that it "raise the bar of future DLCs and expansions". Game of the Year award should always be reserved for a new complete game that raise the bar for that particular year. Not an expansion of the game released in another year. That's like saying "it's ok your initial game is a broken mess as long as you churn out 9/10 DLC to be considered in GOTY nomination". If they want to celebrate expansions, make a separate category.

I don't think I can't simplify this even further.

Re: The Game Awards Under Heavy Criticism for Elden Ring DLC's Game of the Year Nomination

QiaraIris

If DLC and Expansions has always been able to be nominated for GOTY just from Critics choice, Blood and Wine ( a 92 meta score and 9.3 user score) should have been nominated as GOTY too back then.

That fact that Erdtree stole another potential GOTY award from a full-game like Infinite Wealth shouldn't give this guy a pass.

Changing the rule at the 11th hour just to include Erdtree is really disingenuous and highly biased. Stop watching it and stop engaging it, stop giving this clown a platform.

Re: All The Game Awards 2024 Nominees Revealed, Astro Bot Up for 7 Awards

QiaraIris

Erdtree shouldn't be nominated at all for GOTY, but what else can you expect from this joke of a person and his show.

Definitely just gonna be skipping it this year and watch the trailers on YouTube after; not even gonna bother giving this guy an engagement. The quality and integrity of this "award" keeps deteriorating each year.

Re: Final Fantasy 7 Remake's Third Entry 'Won't Cheat' with the Airship

QiaraIris

"Are you looking forward to the third part of Final Fantasy 7 Remake’s trilogy? "

After how Rebirth ends, no. Imagine being told over and over again that you're going to change history and destiny only to have the exact same ***** happens on the 11th hours. Only this time in 4k and a ***** PhD to understand what's going on.

Not everything needs to be a ***** Kingdom Hearts.

Re: Assassin's Creed Boss Says Series Is Inherently Diverse, Just Like History

QiaraIris

They're free to do whatever they want with their games, as much as we're free not to purchase it as a consumer.

Personally, I won't be touching this mess of a title after all the annoying drama surrounding it and now that they delayed it to February 2025, that decision is a lot easier with a slew of great titles coming out that month. I found both camps of people attacking and defending Yasuke are equally as aggravating and obnoxious as neither of them seems to realize that this discord is a well-crafted experience by Ubisoft's team to create more buzz on the game for free. So carry on virtue signaling for both your camps while the rest of us just sit here looking forward to Yakuza: Black Flag and Monster Hunter: Wilds. We also already have AC in Japan, it's called Ghost of Tsushima which was arguably far more superior experience than any previous AC titles. Ghost of Yotei is also coming out next year which is a death warrant signed for Shadows.

Ubisoft's demise is long overdue and I'll be the first one cheering when they announce their bankruptcy or buyout.

Re: Dragon Age: The Veilguard (PS5) - The Best BioWare Game Since Mass Effect 3

QiaraIris

@ShogunRok I can't believe no one asked these yet:

  • How are the romance handled? can you romance everyone or you're locked into one or two companion like previous Dragon Age? (Lelliana or Morrigan, you can't have both)
  • Is there a reset skill point like previous games?
  • How are the craftings handled?
  • The review seems to contradict itself at some point, does Rook actually have choices and consequences in the game (so like a proper RPG), or it's the illusion of choices where every response pretty much ended up with the same result just told in a different flavour?

Thanks!

Re: Interview: Falcom President Talks All Things Trails, Daybreak 2, and Kai in Our Biggest Interview Ever

QiaraIris

As a FALCOM fan, this is a really good read. I especially like the insight he gave on both the differences and similarities between western and japanese JRPG players. It is especially true that the older I get, the more I resonated with Vaan's story being the "older person" of the group.

I also love the fact that he's staying true to his visions that Trails will always remain the primary turn-based title of their IPs.

Also this snippet right here:

"The first thing I felt was... boy it's difficult to end a series! We got so good at thinking about how to continue the series that we never kind of had a chance to stop and think about "okay, how are we supposed to end this thing?"

I specifically told the team, "okay guys, we really need to come up with an ending!"

I want to come up with an ending that will satisfy us, as the developers, and also, it's obviously incredibly important to come up with an ending that's going to satisfy the players as well. Particularly those players who stayed with the series for 20 years, and have waited a long time to see how the series is going to end."

This made me really happy as I've been following this series from the beginning and I can't wait to see how they wrap it up.

Damn, it's been 20 years.

Re: UK Sales Charts: Silent Hill 2, Dragon Ball's Physical Copies Topple Metaphor in Massive Week

QiaraIris

How are people so bad at reading the article?

This is just a PHYSICAL sales in UK Market.

See this paragraph:
"As is always the case with the UK charts, we must underline this only represents a small portion of the market. Recently, it was reported that an enormous 75% of British game sales are now sold digitally, so you’re looking at roughly 25% of the market here."

So it doesn't really paint a picture on how a title is performing.

Re: Poll: Are You Playing Metaphor: ReFantazio?

QiaraIris

Absolutely. For their first foray into a fantasy sword and sorcery settings, ATLUS absolutely killed it with Metaphor.

The archetype system is really fun to mess around with as I'm a sucker of mixing and matching abilities to make the perfect class of my party. And the charming and relatable characters are surprisingly still present albeit being a fantasy settings. The demo doesn't do it justice as just like every other ATLUS titles before, Metaphor doesn't really shine well till you finished the first dungeon and actually get out of the first city. The new exploration and travel mechanic was such a joy to experience.

I have to say it's also the darkest ATLUS story yet, especially for a JRPG standard. Some of the bond stories and dialogues absolutely made me ugly cried.

And you bet I will get the enhanced or whatever definitive edition they'll be releasing to follow up this game. Hopefully Metaphor will be one of their permanent IPs next to SMT and Persona, because they truly have a gem here.

Re: Atlus Fans Don't Think Xbox's Marketing Is Doing Metaphor: ReFantazio Justice

QiaraIris

@Shad361 you really can't see the difference between XBOX marketing a well established IP like Yakuza and Persona compared to a brand new game like this one?

Yakuza and Persona were born and grew with PlayStation, no JRPG players in the right mind would think that that these two titles would ever be an XBOX "Exclusive".

It can't be said the same with Metaphor which is a completely brand new IP.

Re: Atlus Fans Don't Think Xbox's Marketing Is Doing Metaphor: ReFantazio Justice

QiaraIris

I said it in other articles covering this that the marketing rights with XBOX was probably the stupidest thing ATLUS has done. It's amazing how short their reach is for JRPGs that even my close circle of friends who are actually always look forward to ATLUS games felt blindsided on how unaware they are about this game.

When majority of Japanese players also still think that this is an XBOX "exclusive" due to your poor marketing, that's on you.

Hopefully they'll learn their lesson after this. XBOX is where JRPG goes to die, so good thing it's a multiplatform release.

Re: Microsoft Is Investigating Why Devs Are Prioritising PS5 Over Xbox

QiaraIris

Simple, games just don't sell on XBOX. Their market shares keep getting smaller and smaller since they simply couldn't even penetrate the Asian market for years, no matter what they do.

Becoming a publisher like SEGA did would be the right move, when your leader himself even admitted that XBOX already lost the console wars and couldn't recover.