Comments 1,318

Re: PS5 Exclusives Final Fantasy 16, Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth Failed to Meet Expectations

Grumblevolcano

Considering even Tomb Raider 2013 failed to reach Square Enix's expectations, I'm pretty sure the real problem is Square Enix's expectations. Multiplatform will probably lead to more sales but Square Enix's expectations would also be higher which cancels out the gains from multiplatform.

I also think Jim Ryan is to blame. Naturally the actions of a platform holder affects 3rd party exclusives and Jim Ryan did a lot of damage to the Playstation brand.

Re: Horizon Zero Dawn's PS5, PC Remaster Is Very Much the Real Deal

Grumblevolcano

The existence of this remaster is concerning.

No console except the original $599 PS3 has full backwards compatibility for more than 1 previous generation (Xbox's backwards compatibility approach for original Xbox and Xbox 360 games on XB1/Series X|S are only partial with lots of games lost in the process). Is this remaster perhaps an indication that while PS6 will be able to play PS5 games, it won't be able to play PS4 games? Push Square did report about PS6 decisions happening in 2022 which is when rumours of the remaster started appearing.

Re: State of Play Rumoured for This Month As Sony Looks Set to Skip PS Showcase in 2024

Grumblevolcano

Is this maybe about the Game Awards? 10th anniversary is a big milestone and Sony supports Geoff a lot. Considering GotY will probably be Rebirth or Astro Bot, I could see Sony wanting to take advantage of that with some PS Studios single player announcements.

Kind of like how Nintendo made a bunch of announcements at Game Awards 2017 when they knew it was likely that either BotW or Mario Odyssey was going to win.

Re: Lack of Competition from Xbox Partly Why PS5 Pro Is $700, Says Analyst

Grumblevolcano

@NEStalgia Multiplatform does seem to be the more immediate thing, I mean look at the Gamescom saga. They chose to make Indiana Jones on PS5 be the "one more thing" announcement and then warn people that change is coming.

To me that sounds like a future where you can play PS exclusives on Xbox because Xbox hardware has become Xbox branded PCs (and hence has stores like Steam) meanwhile Xbox has an aggressive PS/Nintendo porting strategy.

The Nintendo side of things is the big unknown. I don't see Nintendo porting to other systems unless Switch 2 went the way of Wii U. Also it's hard to tell whether Sony seeing Lego Horizon Adventures on Switch (a decision seemingly forced by Lego) being a success would tempt an aggressive porting PS exclusives to Switch 2 strategy.

Re: Astro Bot (PS5) - One of the Greatest PlayStation Platformers of All Time

Grumblevolcano

@get2sammyb At least there's been the classics line but you have situations like the only remasters/remakes greenlighted by Jim Ryan being 2013 games onwards and the only new games for legacy IP being from franchises that got PS4 entries.

Hopefully Astro Bot does well enough to convince Hiroki Totoki and Hermen Hulst that Sony has a gold mine of IP to pick from.

Re: Reaction: PlayStation Needs to Take a Long, Hard Look at Itself

Grumblevolcano

@AdamNovice Nintendo have some franchises that showcase well that just because there's been a long gap between entries doesn't mean there isn't an opportunity for a comeback to work out.

A good example of this is Pikmin which has had franchise gaps as long as 10 years yet the franchise has grown such that the newest entry (2023's Pikmin 4) turned out to be the best selling game in the franchise.

Remasters/remakes would be a good way to bring pre-PS4 franchises into the spotlight.

Re: Failing Manufacturers Are Pushing the Narrative That Consoles Are Dying, Says Ex-Xbox Exec

Grumblevolcano

I think the fate of consoles lies solely in the hands of Nintendo at this point. If Switch 2 is reasonably priced, has a strong exclusives lineup and backwards compatibility then I think consoles will be very safe. Xbox just won't be a part of it.

But if Nintendo started releasing their 1st party exclusives on PC like Sony did in 2020, I think consoles would die out as the message sent would be that PC is the place to own everything.

Re: Rumour: PS5 Pro Design Seemingly Leaked

Grumblevolcano

Sounds like PS5 Pro and the rumoured State of Play are 2 separate announcements. I hope this means PS5 Pro is part of a bigger event rather than it just being a blogpost announcement.

In any case, no disc drive is concerning. All digital future is extremely bad.

Re: Reaction: It's Time for Xbox to Tell Us Which Games It's Bringing to PS5, and Which Games It Isn't

Grumblevolcano

I think they'll use other platform holder events to announce legacy ports meanwhile their own events and Geoff's events to announce ports for upcoming releases. So like Starfield being announced at the PS5 Pro reveal (maybe due to the power of PS5 Pro the game can run at 4K 60fps), FH5 announced at the Switch 2 reveal, Avowed announced at the Game Awards (the game releases on Xbox in February), etc.

Re: Reaction: It's Time for Xbox to Tell Us Which Games It's Bringing to PS5, and Which Games It Isn't

Grumblevolcano

@NEStalgia XB1 had a Wii U situation in a different way, it took too long for the system sellers to arrive. For example with Wii U you had Skyward Sword release on Wii the year before meanwhile with XB1 you had Halo 4 release on 360 the year before which meant it took longer for the new systems to get entries.

Granted, Halo 4 being a XB1 launch title and Gears being a Fall/Holiday 2014 release wouldn't have helped much given how much damage Don Mattrick caused with the console reveal.

Re: Rumour: Xbox to Announce a 'Big' Game Coming to PS5 at Gamescom

Grumblevolcano

The biggest thing that makes me question FH5 for PS5 happening at Gamescom is that it would overshadow the new Indiana Jones trailer already confirmed for Opening Night Live as Forza is one of the Xbox big 3 (Halo, Gears, Forza).

I think Indiana Jones and Starfield are most likely to be the PS5 port. Leaning towards Indiana Jones as it has the biggest chance to give the game more attention rather than just devolve into arguments over whether Xbox console is dead.

Re: It Took PS5 Longer Than PS4 to Pass 4 Million Units Milestone in the UK, But There's Context

Grumblevolcano

I think it's that PS5 never really had an equivalent to Holiday 2016 (161 weeks after PS4 released was December 30th 2016). Push Square reported on crazy sales during that time period and the stuff which happened back then was stuff like PS4 Pro, PSVR (both sold out fast during Holiday 2016), crazy discounts (e.g. PS4 + Uncharted 4 + FIFA 17 for £200), big multiplatform games ditching last gen (e.g. Infinite Warfare was the first CoD not to release on PS3/360 which released on PS4/XB1), etc.

Re: Talking Point: Is It Finally the Right Time to Buy PSVR2?

Grumblevolcano

This article did make me wonder whether PS5 Pro will require a new adapter for PSVR2 to function (like the one used for PC). For context, I'm reminded back to 2016/2017 when Microsoft released XB1 revisions (XB1S and XB1X) and you needed a special Kinect adapter to be able to use the device with those consoles.

By the way PS Direct says the PSVR2 sale ends on August 5th.